← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/683/2014dismissed

Sanjeev Khosla & ORS v. A.P. Super Market & ANR

2016-07-11Mr. Justice Arun Monga7 pages

  

       

!"##$%&%'()*+, -!'.##/01&*! "1#2&  #"%"%'#2& 3#2&)&  -)4#2!25#", !'$15)*! !'"1#2  #&4'6#'"&  

  !" #$%&'" '& ( !)#$*+"

 71#"1#2 #42"#2&*$!*4!4#2&8!+9#!**:#6"&##"1#.)6;8#'"<  9#2##22#6""1# #42"#2&2'"<  71#"1#2"1#.)6;8#'"&1)*69#2#42"#6%'"1#%;#&"<

2#&#'"( 2%"%'0)8!2,6/$!"#, 2"1#4#"%"%'#2& 291%'##"!'#.!,6/$!"#, 2"1#2#&4'6#'"& =====

'& ( !)# ,- > 2!'&*!"#6$4+"1#$2&&>#?!8%'!"%'"1#4#"%"%'#2%& "!5#''2#$26 &"!'6&6%&4&#6  

#"%"%'#2>*!'6*26>6#$2##  1*6#2&  !2#  !;;2%#/#6    "1#

  %84);'#6  26#2,  :1#2#9+  "1#  9.#$"%'&  %*#6  '  9#1!*    "1# 2#&4'6#'">.)6;8#'"  6#9"2&  1!/#  9##'  !**:#6  !'6  "1#  #?#$)"%' 4#"%"%'%*#69+"1#4#"%"%'#2&&##5%';#?#$)"%'"1#.)6;8#'"!'6 6#$2##6!"#6@,1!&9##'6%&8%&&#6 2%"%'0)8!2,*#!2'#6$)'&#*2"1#4#"%"%'#2>6#$2## 1*6#2&&)98%"&"1!"%'!&)%"&##5%';4&&#&&%'9+:!+#.#$"8#'" "1#2#&4'6#'"&,"1#**:%';6#$2##:!&4!&&#6(> A3!*)#2"1#&)%"2"1#4)24&#$)2"## &B,@BC> 3!*)#  2  "1#  &)%"  2  "1#  4)24&#    .)2%&6%$"%'

&,D,BBC>  - '"1#)2"-12%!%9%2-%';1,66%"%'!*%/%*)6;#

-2%/%&%' , !'$15)*! %/%*-)%"@ !"#'&"%")"%'(@@CB  !"##$%&%'(@ -1-!'.##/01&*!&'2 001&*!, -1-!'.##/01&*!

"12);1%"&0!2"!-1-!'.##/ 01&*! -8"*4'!01&*!:%#-1-!'.##/01&*!, **2#&%6#'"&)&#@@D,-#$"2>, !'$15)*!  *!%'"%& 3#2&)& C& -)4#2!25#""12);1%"&4242%#"2-1 !:!'

  0)8!2  &'    *!"#  -1E!*  1!'6,  #'!'"  2)'6  *2

#?$*)6%';  9!$5&%6#  $)2"+!26 ,  -   ,  -#$"2>,

!'$15)*! -1 !:!'0)8!2&'E!"#-1E!*1!'6 242%#"2 C& -)4#2!25#",2#&%6#'")&#B,-#$"2> B, !'$155)*! ##'6!'" -)%"  2  !  6#$2##  2  4&&#&&%'  9+  #.#$"8#'"    "1# 6##'6!'"&%'2#&4#$"2)'6 *2 #?$*)6%';!$5&%6# $)2"+!26 ,-  ,-#$"2>, !'$15)*!!'62"1# 2#$/#2+ &,@BC>'!$$)'"2#'"2"1#8'"1 /#89#2,@'"1#9!&%&2!*!&:#**!&6$)8#'"!2+ #/%6#'$#>4*!%'")'6#226#2D )*# 

*!%'"42#&#'"#6'(@@ 1%&&)%"$8%';"6!+2%'!*6%&4&!*9#2#8#

!%9%2  -%';1,  66%"%'!*  %/%*  )6;#  -#'%2  %/%&%' ,

!'$15)*!%'"1#42#&#'$#-12%303#28!,6/$!"#2 "1#  4*!%'"%&  !'6  -12%  01!)1!',  6/$!"#  2  "1# 6##'6!'"& "%&26#2#6"1!""1#&)%""1#4*!%'"%&&)$$##6&!'6 %" 1#2#9+ 6#$2##6  !*';:%"1  $&"&  1#  6##'6!'"&  !2# 6%2#$"#6"1!'6/#2"1#/!$!'"4&&#&&%'"1#;2)'6 *2 #?$*)6%';9!$5&%6#$)2"+!26-  ,-#$"2>,

!'$15)*!""1#4*!%'"%&:%"1%'!4#2%6":8'"1& 1#6##'6!'"&!2#!*&6%2#$"#6"8!5#"1#4!+8#'""1# 2#'"!8)'"2"1#8'"1/#89#2@F &@BC>, "1#2#!"#2,!"#2"#28%'!"%'"1#%2"#'!'$+,"1#6##'6!'"& !2#!*&26#2#6"8!5#"1#4!+8#'"8#&'#42%"&

 

&B,C> 4#28'"1"%**"1#6!"#  1!'6%'; /#2"1# /!$!'"4&&#&&%'"%&$*!2%%#6"1!"%"1#/!$!'"4&&#&&%' %&'"1!'6#6/#29+"1#6##'6!'"&""1#4*!%'"%:%"1%'! 4#2%6":8'"1&,"1#'"1#+&1!**9#*%!9*#"8!5#"1# 4!+8#'"8#&'#42%"&F &B,C>4#28'"1%'&"#!6  &B,C>    --

*!%'"%& ##'6!'"&  -"!8424*!%'"

B,@B> >  -"!8424:#2 > >  *#!6#2G&## BB> BB>

 -)92:%"'#&&#& B> > B %&$ > >  2$#&&## B>> D -"!842#?1%9%"& >>  E,BD>BB> %/#')'6#28+1!'6 &#!*"1#)2"'"1%&&"6!+ -#4"#89#2,  !%9%2-%';1   66*%/%*)6;# -2%/%&%' ,

!'$15)*!

"#(1%&6#$2##&1##"$'"!%'&":4!;#&!'6 9"1"1#4!;#&1!/#9##'$1#$5#6!'6&%;'#69+ 8#   !%9%2-%';1 66*%/%*)6;# -2%/%&%' ,  !'$15)*!H

 . $$26%';""1#6#$2##,"1#2#&4'6#'">.)6;8#'"6#9"2& :#2#"1!'6/#2"1#4&&#&&%':%"1%'":8'"1&,!%*%';:1%$1"1#+ :#2#"4!+"1#8#&'#42%"&!&#'/%&!;#6%'"1#6#$2##  1#&"2+ $%'#69+"1#2#&4'6#'"&1!'6%';/#2"1#4&&#&&%''D 1!6'"9##'42/#6 '"1#$'"2!2+,!*#;!*'"%$#''#?)2# 6!"#6 :!&&#2/#6%'"%8!"%';!9)"1!'6%';/#2"1#4&&#&&%' ''#?)2#& !'6

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

2+,  *#!&#  6##6  6!"#6    1!&  9##' 426)$#6'2#$26 "&1:"1!" "1#2#&4'6#'"&1!6"!5#'!'#: 42#8%&#&1# &"!"#8#'"&"1#!2#8#'"%'#6:%"'#&&#&1!/#;'# )'%84#!$1#6,2!"1#2&"2+&1:&"1!""1#2#&4'6#'">"#'!'"&1!6!$")!**+ 1!'6#6/#2"1#4&&#&&%'""1#*!'6*26&,:11!69##')''#$#&&!2%*+ !&5%';  2  8#&'#  42%"&  9+  %'/5%';  4#'!*"+  $*!)&#  1#  #'"%2# 6$)8#'"!2+#/%6#'$#92);1"'2#$269+"1#4!2"%#&1!&9##''"%$#6 9+"1#"2%!*)2" !8"1#/%#:"1!""1#"2%!*)2",!"#2#?!8%'%';"1#2!

 / !'66$)8#'"!2+#/%6#'$#,1!&2%;1"*+!$$#4"#6"1#9.#$"%'&6'" %'6 !'+%**#;!*%"+!'64#2/#2&%"+%' "1# 26#2)'6#2$1!**#';#1# 9.#$"%'&1!/#2%;1"*+9##'!$$#4"#6;2)'62%'"#2#2#'$#%& 8!6#)"

#/%&%'4#"%"%'&"!'6&6%&8%&&#6 #01)   '& ( ! ,-23 #$*+"