High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/1084/2009allowed

Pritpal Singh @ Titi & ANR v. State Of Punjab

2017-03-10Registrar-Judicial,Mr. Justice Surinder Singh Grewal22 pages

!" "#$%$ &'()( *

' + ,( --(-(- + ,( ---

!" "$

" $ " !" %%%%&''( ! ) ""*

+ %, -$

- + &,) . " !" " " /'& 0 1 %23'+4014* , " ! !) .) " $ $ . 5'''6*"

.$ $ $ )$ "

& 7 " ! !

&5%%&''3 "$ ) "! " 8! 9& : $

1!; : <*%'* 0

1! ; :

" " " $ $ 0

! 1! ; &=%%&''3 $

) "$ $ $ >?<%'6>) " ) .)! .)

@ $.$

)."; #

;

!.?; A

) " ! . ) !

) . ! " ) " . ) "!

.) ) "! @ &5%%&''5 ) $ )) $ ) $

) ""* -$

) + ;

) ) .

$ /5*/3.). -$

-) !

) !

$ ""$ .

$) !

4 4 "!.< "

/%5$ ""*

. $

" ""* -$

- ! 4)

; ! )) 4

!)) 4

)

! )) 4

$0 $ $ " !.

$ ! * )) $ " .

$ ! 8

) $8 )

!))

;"$ ! $)@

$. $

:$!

) $ $ #9 1 ."$ !

) "!) ).$ .

" ) "! " . ) $

; " . .

$ .)

$: #!

)

! " $ ; ) $ 1!; : ; ) " "" !" $" ". .). "

%& ==56* " " " $ "

. $ @ $ >?<%'6> $ .

. B0 $ >?<%'6#) " /&/ /&C) " /C01 ! / 0 !

@" " $ ""* -$

) )$

"1 ; : $ ) ) " 0 !

" " "" "

>?<%'6; C @ &2%&&''3 0)

+<*%%," ! ;""*

""$ %%'%&''= " " /'&01)""* -$

-) %C'%&''=.<*%&0 "

@ "$ >?<36-

" "!4$ "

4 >?<361) $) !$$>?<368

$ "@ "$ $ ! " %=/ 11$ " %(=/+4114* ,) 1 5 ")"$$ 1 . A" 0 1 : ! '5'C&''= 3 ""* )"

" " /'&01. A : ) ""* .

"$ = " " ?$ $ . )

" "$ 2 < ?$ " /%/11 ""*

" " $" .#!

. .

)

) "$$) ".

. )

""* -$

- ) $" !

. "

""* -$

- "$$ $" '='3&''3 "$ ; ) ) " - #!

)

.) ;

"."

)

$" $ " .."$ ) @

&5%%&''3 #!

$) 4 ) "$ $

. +<, ) . -$

- $$

;)" )" $@

$.-$

+ %,"$ ! $$ ""

"$ . . !" . .

( " ! " ""* ?$ $

8<*% ) "$$)

88!

8<*&;) ; :

&5%%&''3 $" . ?$

; ! : >?8<&6 $ )

>?8<&6- )

8<*/ ) " ") " $ "" " "! ")" %' @ "

! " " .

" ""* )

. " !" " " /'&01 . A +B"1, : !$

$ " !" %%%%&''( .) $ $ . 5'''6* "

.$ $ $ )$ "

"%%%%&''( %%

! ) $ " !" " . %& < ! !" " !" # !" " "$ !$".?$ " " %/

$ " " ""* ! .$" " ! )

." !". 1

" " /'&01;" .

" ! ! $ $"! " $" >?8<&6.8<*&88!

; :

. < $" >?<56.<*58 # "@" ;# A : ! ) ? ! $ $"

%C ; " ""*

)$ ) 4

+,- "

"! $ ""*

! ) "

"!) " " %5 ; " " " /'&01 $ ! . .! . " " . ) $;" ) ""* "

. .<*58# " ". ?" . 5 *! .0 . 5) !" ! ) )

; " "

) $ .$$ " $ . ."

! ". . "" "

." " ! )

. " !" . 1 " " /'&01 $"

" " /&301 "

".$/% -$&01.%(-! !" 2&3 45 6- 6( %3 @ !" # . !" " "$ " " $ $ $"

" !

. "" " . " *"!. 4

$ *

" ! ! " . " ! "$$ " %= . " ""* !

." !". 1 " " /'&01- ""* )$)

.) 4

4 4""*

$ 4

8"*

) .; $ . "

" B )) ) "

) .) ". ) ""* "

%2 . "

$ $ .$$

$ .$$ "$ . " .) ) " "

. ." "

. ;"! &5%%&''3 ." . .)

&2%%&''3) . .

" <*28A 9 .

1D; : " ". . ?". .$) " " .

; $" $.. .

$$" 0 >?<26-<*28 A " ".$ $" $" $..) " ") "$ ) $.$ . $$$0 $ . ! ) ; 4 "0 " &=(*%" $"

" $.. ." .

) $ .$$) " "

. $ ) " " ." .

. " !" " " /'&01 " .

" /$3 1271 & &8 !1"/%.%(-! !" (( 6* /$, 6 5&8 &8 !1"/%.%(-! !" 3 %!1 & 99/$, *5 -28"/%1 &:2; /.%(-! !" "<1$ *6/$, 9 : %1;$/$, < &8 !1"/%.%(-! !" 2&3 4

*-2=/";" 2/!) )

%( < !." " &' ""

) ; : ) $" . ?$ . 8<*& 8 8!

) $" >?8<&6 &% ) 1!; : ) $" .?$ .<*58#

"@" ;# A : $ <*58# ": >?<56 . "*

&& 0 )"."$

$ " $" " . $" $ $ " $ $ $" $."" " ! . "" " 0""$$ ) )! $ 0$. 8<*&88!

!$$ 8<*&88!

$" .?$

&5%%&''3'(C'$

. . %&/'$ ) 1!; : ) )$" .?$ .<*58# '/&'

$ <*5 8# " )

$" >?8<&6

$ )" $" ?$

; : 8"*

) " 1 7 . " $" >?8<&6 >E<56 " ! $ $ $ $" ?$

) " " . " " &/ 0 " ! ""*

)$)

" "*

) )-

)

).""*

) "

"!- $ "!.) "

" " " ; 4?1

"/$!2&3 > $%? %.%(/ & 4@:2!$ $%? % &8 & !1"/

((( /$;$& < ) * F/& , 71 & - A( -! !" $1 / &8 & !1"/5 B

((( /$;$& < '

- C

*"!. " "$ " " ) "! """ // -! !" 3 %!1 &A(/32&-$&01 &8!1"/%5 (( /$;$& < *' 6"#"&!="D 280;"&!% (( ( '

-65 1 ? $ * "!. " " " " ) " "

"! """:) "! "

"!. " ""

" "

"" " " ) $ $"

"! " $ ". $"! " * "!. ) " " "G &C "2/3 &!-$&01.%(-! !" 2&3 4 ) ; 4?1 ) ) $

$ *"!. ) " "" " " "

) ) ! " ! "

""! "! " "" " "$0 " "*

$ $ >?<*%'6><*%' 0

""$ "

) $ .

" " " . " $ $ <*&

<*/ ) $ ) "" " $" ! " 0 $ " >?<%'6> $ <*&*

$ <*/* )

$ " " ""

"".$ 0 ""$ " "!. 4

) "$ ""*

) ! !" !".

" " &5 ?7 ) "" ""$$. ""* ""* !

" !". A +B"1, : " " /'&01 "$$

0 "

$01 4"

$"4 4$4"$"

. 4" $"4 ""

""$" $" $

$ &3 " " " /'&

01 ""$$. " ) !) " /''01) $ " /''01 * /'' H>?" " ?" "

$"$ ".) " )

H + " .,H0 ) "

. .

)." ) $ $" H + .,H0 ) "

. . .

. . "" ." " H +B .,H0 "$$

" ) $$ .

$ . " "

. .." "$$"

") .?" "

. &= ! ) " " $"$ ".) " ) "

1" .) " ) "

. . ) ." ) $ $"1 .) " ) "

. . . . "" ." " 1 ."$

. "$$ $$ .

") $ ." " " " /'&01 ""$$. ""$ .

" " /''01$ ! &2 "" " " " &5%%&''3 '/%5$ $ <*58#

$" >?<56. "*

)

* % ") " %&"$?C"$ " $ )) )

$!)!?*. & :") %"$?%"$ "))

!?*. / 8 )

) $ ) " " 5"$?&"$ " !?*. C :") %"$?%"$ $

" ) )

) ) " 5 "$?/"$ !?*. 5 ") 55"$?%"$

)

" !>9 3 ") )

3"$?/"$

"$ !?*. = 1 %'"$?3"$ "

$ $) )

!?*. 2 ") C"$?&"$

)" ) I

) )

!?*.

) $ ( 8)

)

" $!$ ) ") !C"$?& "$ ) !?*. %' 8)

)

!?*. %% ") $ $!.

$C"$?3 "$?%&"$)

+ , )

) ) ) -)I

!?*. %& ") $ $!.

$C"$3 "$?%&"$) I

)

) ) !?*. %/ "3"$?5"$ " ) " $ <*=*8 # ?*.>?<561 "*

" J "

$*" "

J "

" "

! "; . 5

)

$ " ;)>9" - $ $ <*58# "$ >9") "! .)

" !$8# )" " !);

$" .?$ .<*58# %& "" " $"*

) " " !)

$$ .

?" . 5 ) *! ..$ ") >9" ) " . 5 "

)"! $" .)

) &( 8"*

)" &5%%&''3 /%5$ %%'%&''=C=. "" "<*C8 $

) 8# " " . .

. "

* F " " +%,$ .

+&, $ +/,8

"$ .) " "

." G

/' $" " "*

) . $ $ .$$

"$ . " !

""$ "

/% 8"*

$ $ <*2 8A ; ""6>?<26-B$ $ <*28A 9 . 8 1D ; : "$ " " . &2%%&''3 )!.) ) $ . 7 .;"! . %''%&''= %%'%&''='2/'$>?<26- 8 A "

. " 8 1D; : * F"

5=.$)$

. &5%%&''3; ! . .

; 8 1D; &=%%&''3'=&5

! $ /C25= 19 %'%5'& $ " " " " .

$.. 7." "!

$" ) " " ?$. % $ @ " " . ) 9 . '(%&&''3; ! " "$ ) )) " ;

! "$ )

);) ! .??8@ %%%&&''3 .

?. $!) %/'62' $$;

'2'' "" ) " "$ .$$ !) " )

"&= 9!$ &''32<;

& />";4 <$%; ##2//$&08$/"#!<> / ;/ #!2/"%? %<" %!<$7"<> !!1$%%! 0" $<<&"%% $& <8$ 0& %$%'* ;. ) $ " )

$" $..) " ") "$ ) $.$ . $$$G $ . 8 A ?

. ? ) "$$ $" $ $" $. ? . . " $ .

" .

. ) !$ $..$ .

$ $" 8A $; 4 " " %2 > &&(2 ) $ * F 0+" .0 .,$.". $ "$ "

$. $ "" $.$

. " . $""

$ "

$! $.

$ . $..$.$$""

$" "

!" " .

"$$$I

I"!.

?"!?" $

.* $ " $" + . $ ! . .$, $. + * " $" $$.,G /& B$ $"! " "$ " " ""*

!$" $.."

- . $"! " " ) . "*

!. ""!.)" " ." "" . " /''01 "

$ $$

$ .$$ $ "$ .

// 4 "A " ?" .&5

> 1 &( $" .

* FB" .

."$ )

$.""$ !) . " $ $$ "$

G /C - $$ "" ).

$$$$ .$$

. " E2<;

& /> ;4 <$%;+ " " 8" . & > .;1

K" $ ..."K B $ =2<;

& /> /!"/$"% ?.

.4 " "" "A "

K2<;

& />";4 <$%;" ) $$

) !" ! "

$). $

! $!. $ " $ " " $ ) $"" ! ) .

$0 "";4 <$%;$"

."" $$ "

$ !)

$ $.! $." $) " ""< "

" I $ " .

) ." =2<;

& /> " " =2<;

& /> . "$.

"" $ =2<;

& /> $ . $ $ ) " $

$ !).)

) =2<;

& />";4 <$%;7 ."8" !1 ) " ". !0 ! ! "

$"K

; 4 ? 1 " 18( %$ .%( -! !"

!!/ &#1 <

((( /$;$& < ) * F2<;

& />";4 <$%; ". "

"$.$ . . !

2<;

& />";4 <$%; ?$."$$

. "

"8" !1 0$. $ .) .0$."!

! "$$ .$ "! 0 .G /5 $"! " "*

. . .! . "

$ "<*58# ) $" .

?$ " " ". ) " " !)>?" . 5 ) ! .0 . 5)

$"! "

) .) !

9 " ) $" .?$ " ") " " $$?$ ! ! . . " ) !. ""!.

" " ." "

"$ .$$

" $ .) )" " .

" 0 >?<26- 8A 9

" ".$ $ .$$""

$"). <*28A "". $ .$$ " ". "41"4

" 4"$ .4 4"". 4 " "! $""

$ 0" 4"$ .

4 ! " " "+.".

! " ,) 7 "

" ! . "

" " ! "$ . )

.) " 0 . " "

". "*

)

"" /3 $ " +>?<%'6>, " )

! )) "4

"$ ! " $ ! $ " ."

" . *

)$)

) *-$

-)$) 4 "$ )$) ." ! " ! .

. " ) *

!) ) ! " /= 0"

!!C=.

< ) $

)" " !)$ ! . $) !.""!." " ." "

" " - $$) ! ."

) ) 4 4

$ ! ""

)." ""$$. " $"

0 " /'C01 "" $"- ;

&.%(-! !" :"/"< ((( /$;$& <

*) 2/& 81$ &8 & !1"/.%(-! !" /$%%

/$, 9*( /2 1 . " "$ 7

" " .

")" " ."

< $" .$

" /(

!)" ..) " !" .

$ $ " /'& 01 " /'C*0 01 ".

"" " ". " ) ""*

" "

. $ ) .

. . " ? . $ ) .

%(%&&'%3 $. ""* -$

- "".

$ ! . ; $

. .

" "? .

$ !

. %3'&&'%= !.

) ? " . . $ ".;)! . .$%""

5'''6*"

.$. 1

.$ .) $ $ ?$ "

@ I $&" "$ "*

-(-(-

%' &'%=

6 L69 < L69