← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/1806/2023disposed of

M/S Fermina Developers Pvt Ltd And ANR. v. Indiabulls Housing Finance Ltd

2023-02-23Mr. Justice Tejinder Singh Dhindsa,Mr. Justice Sanjiv Berry19 pages

    

 

 

  

 !

"#

!$%&%"'( ) ) 



 

        



       (  * + ) ,   ,

 ,)  * + ) , ,-

 )  !

"  #$!

# ! %

& #$!

# $ ' $ #!

# $ 

'$  #!

# ! &$

#!

# (  ) #!

#   & ) #!



*

'+#!

,     -  #$!

# !' .-

#$!

/  !$0 / #!

# ! &$

 / .#!

# 

.

$  #!

# $

%

#!

# $

$  #!

,

 11111   ,

 ,.

)

" 

 



    

   232243445!

6 78 .   

      /.   .   $ 90$      323:43425!

6 48



 

 

 2:244344  $ 2;548, $   <

 ,

!

= ,  ,$  . 

!

#43345

,, 4334!

8 !/ ,

          

              .  90$ 323:43425!

6 48





. 



    > . '   

  .

 

   ,  , 

 ")/0/ 

1& - %2

'!

'3% !4 5 )+ 3) '3 '" 6!7 5&) '3%89::& ";;!7$%:

7!3% + 3)) $     /       

  ,    

. 

        

, .  90$ 323:4342  .     

 

       $     

    ,  

.

, " 2?32434;

/  

  ,  4;34434;#       /   

  ,   '

.





 



 0 ,  $5"8@2?AA,434;

 2?32434; .  "

$/  ,  ;332434;  ,/

 

    

 



  



 

 

    !

  "  ! #  #  

$



 % & '(

   )*   )

 #



 +   

  #

     

 , -





  -

   ) 

 

# #



  * #

.

&

'(

       )

  - /& ' -

    0



    

-

#1

  )) . &

'        ,-





 -

   ) 2 , * 3  !

 + 

+  # 

      4 5  # ) /+  

   #   * 

       )*   )

  #   6  

2 / 7 2-# * +

  



  

 + 

  % 8,-9

8- 0 -1 & ',

  



* 

#      

"   !

 . &

'  1  *       *       - 0 -1  +   

*         

    - /&:' + +

  



 

 *  

2 :2 2 $7 -

* +

  





   

+ 

  *   +                       ) *   )

&

6 ;/'   

    ,-  +

  +   

*  

2/  +



  +       ) 

<

4*   )

2 <2= 

*

    *        

    #



    

  ,-+7 2-# *  

  ,-

  

  -

   )  > 

#

 

)2?  +  



   2  

 

 #  

#      / 5  # ) /21 

6 +

     * 





  /2: 

   !



 +

     % 8/2:,       *+ #       

 1

  

 #

   # 

       

  "      

  2  

 1

* +     #   + 6    #          

2

*





+  

     # "  

 2 # 

  

   $ 

  #

   

#     #29  1       ** 



    

 #



#

  @2 ,!

 +

 

 

 

/  45  # ) /+   

+   +   > #

     

#

  



 

*

      *  - 0 -1

2   



+    !

         



  / 0  #  ) /+

"   

   

$

  * 

      ) *   )

2 , 

     !

  / 0  # ) /2! + !

  >     

     # 



    "      *       #   

    

# 

     % & ',

  

* 

#



 

 . &

'!*

       ;5 3   



     

  



  

     #  - @ *  2 ?2 ,!

      " 

           6      

+     / 0  # ) /21 !

     





+    +

   

  *    +



          





2 ) ,   !





 #



  

   

 /0  # ) /   #      !

  ,-  A*

  

 *

 2 





 +  #+  2  ,

   .!6"/

  ,    , 



         

  

  .  ,    

    



  .    /   

 ! 44B,"    ,   

/



. $ 27,4334!

 

'

/   ,$" 

     

 !

"

   $      ,                      @ 

'

 

       5@-"8     

 -

', !

2:;C

  /  .     , -!

    

    $ CA 2!, -!

/ 

  /'



                 

              , @



-

'!

2:?7 -. ,    $ 4: !#    

     ,$ 42,-

'

  !

  2:C:#           .  /        . -,    

        / 

 

 ,  ,

#. , "    

,

323C4344 .  -

',    <           

 ,

    

     

,

      

 /   #    , 

 

#  .



'

, -   

 "   

  / 

/ &  , " ! 

,

           #$%&& '%(  )*   " +,#  -

../0       , , 



*-

'

 



' 

/ &   ! 44B, "    ,  

  

 & 

"

12%**3  "" 4   ( 3  " 

. / 5/  / /





     ,     ,

  $   ,   

  .

  &  ,!6" 

%6    

   ,



 /

  

  .  

 

  

%6 / /



 ./ 

/ &  , " 

  .  

,

     

 / 

     

!  "

.

 /  

/ & 

!6"  '    &  /  ./  /     



 

 . ,  .,   6  

 

D  .&

  

 

 &    ,

  



%6 /  , 



 ,@ 227 

  

. .  

  

             "      .    $!

!=$  

      / 

   # 



  



   

    

   .   $   / 



/   

 

  . 



 .&  

/    .            



/ , # ,

.#/     

,

 

,,  

%6  "  

 /      $    ,   & 



%6 /       

' .    /  $ 2;5C8,4334 !

 



./

 $ 27,4334 !

,   

      $ 2;548,4334!



     '

 $ 2;5C8

    

,,

.

    

 "./ .,, 

/      ! 44B,"    ,  

 

=  



  -

, "   7("8 7   

 & 95/  

 

'   

      /   & 

 ,      ,



.

 $ 27,4334!

#/ 

 

, 

,  $ 2;548 

  

  -

 ;7%2 ,%'>6*& $&!

&9?7#  ' / &  

%6  /



 



!  "

./

    



'

   

/ /   /   .     

.

'

     @ 

'



     

!  "

.    $   

 /    



     ,

, 





  .   

/  &  , "0,

 

  .

.







   .     /

    . 

 ,

 .

.



 

 &  

%6    /   

 

,

    !

" !  44B ,  "     ,  

 



   $ 2;,4334!

/ 

 

   

  E$"&  ) &7"

( : 

- /

9--/     /    / 





    

    ,  ..

 ! , ,

  .,/   

 

  .#     

     ,    



. 

 $ 2;5;

!8,4334!

   $ 2;548,4334 !

  

   

  $ 2;548 ,4334!

#  &  .,  $ 2;

5; !8

/          

, 

,       ,  

  

   $ 2;548, !

./ ., /    /  .  

 .

    ,   

  

  &  ,!6" 8 #6 " 7,#  /!

9 "

>  

        ,       

     

   0 

/       .  

   .

 , 

,    .      ,      .    90$       323:4342 5!

6 480  

 ' 

  .

. ,  .  .  /58/

 

   ,90$



/58   

# ,  .  '

 . ,  . #   

  

   $ 

/  , 

, 



  232243445!

6 78

 >   



      

      23224344./ .,

'

! 44B,"    , #       /    /

      . .  

 / /,  .   0       ,   ,       /    @ -

'

 

       .    ,     .

         ,  -

', !

2:;C# @



-

'!

2:?7

  .  -

',  / ,

 ,

  

 / &  , "F 0  

   

 

2

 

  , ) &  7  %6    E  $  "  

   /   

  

'           .    -

'

 !

2:C:  

. ,

 G H;;1  * +

*  # #

   $



  $+

   

   # #

  #  #     #2

*  #    #    

"   #  

#   #   #     #  # 

  

     



* 



2= 



  

   

*  # #

    *

# $

27 #    # *     *

#   #

*    $

 

+    #

  #    # 



  #       

  



 

=  &  ) &71*%6 /    

', 

.  .

 / 



 /  " 1*%6  / ' ) &71 *%6      

     .



$ +     ./# #. ,# /  ,

.       

. 

  /  . ,   , /   ! 44B,"    ,  $    //  ' 

%6

       2?9

    

   

 + 3 $C 

 #       

              *

#    3 $C 

       

   

      #  6            #    -  

222229  ,

,

  .





,  .  90$ 323:43425!

6  48 0 /  .    /



  

.,    @-" 

.     .  -

', /

 

     .    90$     323:4342 5!

6 48

  ,  . 

 0  E$"

,#: &  "

","" // 5

/     , 





  

          

   . 

/ # ,

 ,

 .  90$ 323:4342 5!

6   48            ,

  , 

.   .



  @-"0 .  90$      323:4342  5!

6   48  /    .  /      

 

   / 

  

,

, 



. > .    @-" 







./   .&  

,  > '     /    ,  

  

  &      ,  ,     58      

.

    

 

,$  @-", ', 

  , , 

 .,$   



   .  , / 



  -   .# @-"/





    , / 

, 

 ,$ 

  ,    #     

             

 

 



  -

', !

   , 

    

0

   ,,

.

<

 

  @-" 

.



.

,

  /,    

 

'

/  / .$" ) &7%6 "  %6



%6 /

  



   @-"/  

/ &  ,  " ! 44B,"    , 0



.     &  #$%&&'%()*%6

 

 0 

  

/  

  2C3;4343/.!  ,*-

'  # , - .$ '=6

5-$=8  

@

$ '=6

  

   ,/ 

,,#!  

0 2  -  ! /  ! 44B ,  "     ,  /  







'     



  . , 

 D  / /

 . 

0,

,

   . 

  

   .  90$ 323:43425!

6  48     

 /  , 





 ,

,

. .

  ,   

  

 .      

 

-

&  , "   7(1*%6 

 



'  "--

'   

/ &  #  /,,      

,"       ! 2C2  / .$"  

  /   ., /  ,

/  "D    ,    ,$ "     , "

  .$"!,

  

 .

 &  ,$" %(% ;%

"<(

 %6  %  !

"

=  /  /    '

/    

 /     / 

  ,&  

%6 "    #  " 1 2%*  *  

         ,

   ,  

6  7 "  9

 ,,   . /#  ,! 432;#

 ,//

 ,  @ ,

!5@!8.

'!/ , 

  .



'#   323B432; $ 2;548,4334!

/     , 432C#@!

 ,//     ,

  

./ 

.-

' ,

,

  * 2A 2  

 !  

 "

.   

  



 #/ 



6 /  D,  

 . ,

 !,



4734432A/ 6 /   /./

'

/ 

    . .  

 $

/

 ,   . ,

#  

6           2;3?432A   

  /     

     

  ,  $  2;  548      323B432;

D 6   ,,



 

 4734432A#/

,  .



  

6 / 

 '  ,

   ,6 .,2A .0  

  ,,

 ,    $  "  /        

   2;3?432A

   $ 2;5C8,4334 !

!

6  ,  $ 2;548/  

. 432;

 ,



 4734432A#

 ,  /  # 6!

"

 / '  . /  //',

/ , 

  $ 2;5C8,4334!

/  

  

,  6!

"/  2;3?432A 

/  . 

   /       ,  

      

 /  

 

   6!"'%4 

&9?7   $  "          1 

 

   - 0 -1

 C  #     $     

  

*  #   #            

* $C  $C +    *   #   - 0 -1        

       C  

  C 

 29  8 #6%6  /      , 

       $  2;  548    .    

'  



    

 /   .$

% 

  .., '



 

0   $ 2;5; !8,4334!



  -

,  "     



  E $" /   



 .

.,    ,

 

, ,  "  ! 

# /   ' , ,



   /  .  , @-"

 

  232243445!

6 78    

  

#,

  ., 

 $ 2;5; !8,4334!

 $   ,    

 ,





    , ,

   

 ,  / 

%6  8 #61*%6 # /      

 

 !

           /   /      "  / 

 ,       



     ,           $  :  ,    ! 

"

!

2::B,   " 



  ., 

  23224344 . $     /     &   2:2443445!

6 228

, 

,/

,

  6

      



   +



 

 #

 

- /"  2   

 + 

     #

         

    

 *        ,- #

 * - /- 0 -12,

    



        "  

           

2,  

   

 

           "    

        #           

 2   ,

     * 

  # 

   

#   ## 

  - @ - 0 -12 ,     

 

  

  >      

#  

   #      

2,     #

  



   #   - / - 0 -121    

+  

        



#>

     

 21

 #

$  > "  

#      6 *#

 # ,2,   #



 # - 

 &&$72,>

     8 #  

  #

           #



 9   > #



- /2 ,           #  "     # # 

  - @ 4 - 0 -12 

 $  

   #               

    

=         #     "  

  

 

 # * 



2   *        +

          - /

- 0 -1 

 #  

 + 

 

 *   # 6

   

     

       

      - /+@ 4 - 0 -12 "

.&   2:2443445!

6 228  .   "   .    

      

  0  ,

          /   

.,   / $ , 4334!

 ,  /,     #   , ,

/ 

 6 ,/ ! 44B,"    ,   >      ,    ,  /

 6    

/ ,   58 '    .

   ., ,  

      ,

 ,

 

,-



 

) ) 

 > '

  F *@ > F *@