High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/1098/2009disposed of

Sunena Devi And ANR. v. State Of Haryana

2015-03-06Mr. Justice Satpal,Mr. Justice S.S. Saron11 pages

! "

#$ %& ' (()) *+& %+,

(

-+ .&/ ))0' +.(()) -+ *'1% 00+, "

+ (().2 (+++2,%& '

34&/+5 3&&2/(&6 6.3&6/ ++ "7 #

8 " #

8 +('), ( 2, . )+ ) % &690 .: :.+2, ., .' 2

' + . (& .2) & + % "

;"8 . ++&6 ,.+(%&2 <+.+= % =>0#8?$ & +6+6+&/(+ / +) 2(, #0

;9 &).+& +6 /()/(+ / +@/ .

+& : / +6+ #!##8 #

? % :+6+ ./

%0/+.0 A8 :+')2,./..) 6:..+ ()):(+ ()+/ 7 +'+2+6+):, 0.: #? #

?2&$ B$( / +.1 6 + B$#84 @(+ .,:+)1 6:. 22+ % 6. -& . /:. .+ ++'()+/ 7 ),.) 6:.).26:.+( .++6.. :

)6. 6+/ )/(+/ + %. +:)1 6:+./+ 66<1> &( .:(( & +% $ %:+' &( .+ @(+ 6 &( . . : ++, 6 / +2 .26.)2,.+ ..+6. 6.+ 26+.2,%/+.+ ,.+C ++ -6+ %.+').+ /2%& 'D(()) #:4. '+ )&/;.&&. : %

: + : <

> %. ( + +. 2+ C + E& ),0 / : ', A$0 % .+ %

6. 0 %

%0 + F, 2) - ' #"

! : ) )) . ( (&, %&(+ )<% > .+% 6.++' .( 2&? #$( / +. +& 0(()) %& :+ 2+.2,- ' %+..26: &2, %/+. .+:+(( ,)):():+((+: & (+ .26:. +. :/()#

6+/ . :+ (+ +/ . +'+ +2 . +/ 6 +2 :(&21 ./260:..:.

# :6.:& 2B16?

6+/ .(()) &) (+& , ) + (+/ + ++, 6 . +2 %(+(+):+(+(+ &),)2,%/+.

:)) % .+ %

6. )) . (+) :+ 1

( '//@ 0:..:&),6 2,.% :))..+) &1@ : . )%

.+&6. /'+++6+ . +/) : +6+ (+(+,:(:.- ) 0

.: #8 #

? (+(+,0& : :+ (+& 2, % /+ . 2+ % %() %

#8 #

? % %())@.)=

= .. (+) (+(+,) 6:..&:+)(+ 2+.-0.: '(() @ 4 ' +,+(+ :+2,-0.: '@ 4;# .6+(.. &D%& 0@ B:+1 .(+ .2' +) 6:..(+(+, )&+/ 0G :&+2,(()) %& "# #

? . . . . 2 . +2 +/ 3&D(()) "0:.:+ .+ +2 :2)'+ ((&5%&+ + +% 6.:..&.&)( & %.+') .(()) "D 3&&6'.+#0

;9()&+ @( (++(+++, 6 +2 +/.+-.)

+.:

$ .++0(()) " 9 3 4&/+ 5 3& : ((+. " #

? #!" #8 #

)&+/ @ :&+2, 34&/+ . ...6'#16.+. 6.2&+ + '0 &1/ %& <(+ (()) >.+'))6 / 6++&((), 6.& (&5%&+ +%

6. +')...1( )H16.+:..+)' - (&++6' 6 ((& . 6./+'+ :'+0 &.+'+,: 34&/+5 3&: ++ .(+ 7 #

?2,%/+.

/() '6 0+(+& +% #!7 + : (+(+ 2, % 0

+ & ((& 5 %&+ +:)+(+)/ + !

" "

8 .+6 & +% "

"8 %6 2..&: +/ "B " "

8 &() 6&), )/+) / , : :+ @/ 2, . (+& &2 & :.) , +/ 6 ' (& ./ ()

) /() .+/ & +% 7#7+ F+ +) &+ ((+ . ' )& . . (+& . (+' 2, + 2) &2 6 . & .+2, ' 6 6./)2' F+ & ) + . (()) . './ ), +6&..(()) .'2 )),/() .

% .+ ' ++3&,. ' . & &2/..))6 ( : 22+ % 6.: @/ 2,.(+& .+2, 6&2 .))6+'+, &+.++6&..+),

6./()0.++0.(2),/(+ 6:.. /

2+&)& '+,: #? #

? ./(): "B #

? .+ @() +. & :++ ), F 1' .2/ 6 ) .(()) E&) +6&..+ @() + ), (+& 6.(+(+, 2+.% : (+&2+./? 7 / #8 #

?:.)+'+,: #? #

? 2& ? 7 ( / .+ ) @() :.,.)&2,%/+.: . '+ ( : (2 6(+ 2&%

/-.+))6&.2') % 0 .+ % 6.+ .)+&0.++0(2),/(+ 6

+&)& &+6.2 ./+).+/ 6 .&)0.&0+&.& +6+(()) "9 34&/+5 3&&20 './ ),&+6..+ .+' ++ &)(./ .// ))6 )

)&+/ @ &+2,(()) # @ &+2,(()) " #!".'2 :+ 6),+) &( '.(()) &) .'2 '

& .2)&+/ &+2,.9& + 2, ./ (&+& :.. : : '+ .++0(+,../(&6 3&6/ ++2 F+ & )+.%:.)+& 6.2' +6&/ &2/..+/() & ' ++0:..3&. ' /(&(

.(()) A.'.+)+ & )+.(+ 6 .+&6..++ (+' ++.(()) #9%& ' : ((+. 2, . () +):, 0 .:

#? #

? %.:& ++, 6).26 .+. %. :(( &( ++, 6/ +2 : 6' ( 2 +. 2+ C + + -6+ %. ( + . +. 2 & 2+ C + .+% 6.0% 0

%+0 A$:)) + +..( .(+ .+:6. 6$16: +'++/.).26++2,(()) #9%& ' : /() :+ (+0 ) '+ (+ (+) +&) . ++ +') . . + (+:++& + :./ +,(+' . % .+ /+)++6&)+,+))6),.+ &6.2(+3

) 2.) %& ' . .+

/() / +,(+' % $ . %

(2). +2 : +'++/(+ ) +. . & 2& +/ 260 :.. : .) 2, .+ .++0% $ . %:&) 2(()2)

..&6. ..+&/() %

$ %:)) '+,. +2 $16.+ :&),+/.( (()) D%& '

. (+ % .+ %

6. +& &), &((+2,)).(+& : +6&/ 2.) . (()) . ), ( : : /),22+% 6. . : : ) @/ 2, . (+& .+2, ) 6.(()) E&)' ,/+ 22+ % 6.:6' &(2,.(+& .' 62 : '+2, .& ,..+)' & + . /+ . ( : .&) .' 2

)+),& 2) )( ):. ' .2 ( : 0/ ,. ): + +& +&:+., )2)2 + .& ) ),2&236++ +& , & 6 & 0 ' 22 .+

. 2 .) 2, . =2) %&(+/ &+

()*)+,)- ./0( 12*343 5)52 !4/6)7

$ *.+./)-% $ ./+2 ( : )

:&) '.(+ 6& ) & ).:

. ' ++& +)2) & +&:+., .+ . ++.:..): .) ,6+&6+)):)) +. @6+ 6 .(())

&+.+/+0+')+/+(+. + % F2++,@ ..) .(+)+' :+ )):..(/ )(+ +:+ &.+,=)+ A7-%&.)4&/+. +.'0 @ .: . . (+(+, : ( :. ./ .++/():+ %F+.+/ "

2 6.),0.,:+(21:../ "

) .,:+ 6 %F0-.&2 "# #

?2& +&+ 21:..23 .) ./() :+ (2)

A!0- %...&. 0 )')&60% + ' 9&/9&) -6+ + )0 .: . . (() @ F&2/ "" #

?2,.()+ (& 6 1/(+ ./():+32,.+ (()

& +% $"9 %.2 /'2+.+

#8 #

? + + ' +, @ 4 ) 6:. (+(+, %..+./<@ 4;#> .++0.+

. 6 ++0:..&)( ++&( +6+ /(+ 6.(+(+,+./() E& %/)+),0 (+ 6+ ' .2,),@,

6./() +./()2 6(

"B #

?:. + % F2++,0-.&2 .2

&), & ),@() (+3&.2 &. (()) &.), 4( 6 ':.0 2'0&

+' ,2 +/./ A0.&0 /+ .+6&/ + 2.).(()) 9 %& ' :'+0.+/+ .+6&/ + 2.) (()) "D 34&/+5 3& /( . . ), ' &6. 2 & 6 (()) " )&+/ @ &+2,(()) #:)) .:

)&+/ @ .+ #!" F+ & )+.%&) ( & , .+' ++6 (()) " . . )&+ / %& '

2 & +/ (()) " +&

),.& 6 (()) " .)&+/ . 9& %& ) . )&+

2 +.)')&2 '' +/.2. ' (()) " 2&)2+) )

&+ +++2+ .+' ')2) ++

+ .+( 6 &)),2/3&6/ . =2)%&(+/&+ .8()*5(12*343 5)52.()*

%$% /),.+ .+' ++6 (()) " .)+ %& ).%

.' :&)/..(+&

.& & 2) .2 ,++2+ 0. /+ ( . +) . (+&

)&+/ (()) "<@ >. .+

E&)),/() /( . +'+, : (&+& @ '+,. +2 . )+, 2 +/ (()) # /&. (++ ((+. (()) " (()) ":))6), ((+. 2, A % - (.) %

6. " #

? (+ @ .)&+/ /2,(()) " . (()) ".'2 ++ +/.+ .+ : 2, ,(+ ' (()) # .& 0:&) 2+), &( .)&+/ @ % "!.' :..(+/./2),.(+ / .&:..)'+, 0.&0 2 (+ +'2,.(+& ' ++ 3&, ' (()) ":. ). 2 &2 E& ),0(()( 2.)(()) "D 34&/+5 3&&20:.E&..+6 6 ./@ 62 &2 .60)+ & )+(()) #&2/ . +6+& /(+ / + ) /( &(

(()) #@+/),.+. :.

6+', 01( 6 ':. (()) # %.),0.' 6.)+ )1+0.++0.(+,+ +& . /(&( .+ A .0 . (&)+ +&/ .0:&)2 . +3&+&. +6+&/(+ / + ) /( &( (()) # 2 +& . +6+&/(+ / +#",+ /(&( .+.)) +/ ./ #0

;9 &)(,/ .:&)& +6/()/(+ / +(++@/ . E& ),0 . (+ (() )): E& (()) "0 :. + 2 +) +.:. +E&+ ,.+ (()E&(()) #/ :..2'/ . /(&( .+ 2+)/5 4,5) .3) .-- 4802 4802

! "

#$ +