High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/474/2004dismissed

State Of Haryana v. Diwan Singh

2026-04-1616 pages

P a g e | 1

!"#$ $

# %&' ! "$ "$

# ()'' !

$ $

# * %+ ,(()) -$ . * /0 '0% ,( ' 1! 2 31$* $*$*45 2 31$* $*$53 % ! 1%$6 &* '078*%$8%+ $ 1%$%(* /0 ))8'& 9:

77% ;

1%$1 60 <0%8'& ' 1%$1 6* /08'& 8 %0%( ' $

$*$*458 $ "$ 0 * %+ 0 (% %%' 0 (% (() / 0 :(7/ '67'/: ''""$ =$

>('?+07%

) %

'* 7'/9'0 ;066%8.0%?+0 %( ' .%%'%'? @7 ' 0 0%/$

$ 0 A$B 0(% .%/ %' 0 ? 0: :'?+/'&* /0 0 ( '0 %)& A% 0 0? %(%'7 '?).!

P a g e | 2

!"#$!% $

! %

$ & ! "% '

#( ! )

! !

* %

$ ! %

$ ' # " !#

$ ! !

* +,-..--. / ) / 0 * 0

' / & ' ' ! ! #

( !& #

( !'%! $ !$ !&

+1-02 $/ ) / 0

' / & ' ' ! !

!# !! #"$!% $

! #3 !

/' 4 %

$ ' '#

( !! #

' &

* 6 % ' ! ! '

&* $ # !48$!% $

+--9.--.

$:8 ! "0"

$' 3 $! 3 ! .;< !

' 3= >9> ! & ! %

$ & ! $!

$ !

! !

# & % ! $!% $

! !

& #0""

4?"

1-.,9.!

1, "3 !.9 0#0 #!

$ ' $ & $

4?"

3= >9>"

#&& #!$

P a g e | 3 "

2$ ! $ &

"0"

$' # ! 3 ! #

& # &

% $

0 !(

$ & !

!48 $0"

+--9.--. ;--02 0

:8 & %' $4?"

! !

% $& $ !3&

!' & $ "

3= 9<<3

! $ ' $ & $ &* 0"

$ # $

& % $

%! +.+9 # !482"3 +-9.--.!48$! 3 !2 3@

8?7C!> :8 :() /'&* /0. / /)

* 8 % .

00 ?& :() 8?70:*

6* /0?7 ' & ))/7?)'0 =$

: '0' 0 : A$0()

%%/ % 0 0 (% $ % '

/0.% /A$0()

6* /0 '0%()

). 0( 0& ))/

:( '?+0 :() ' ( '0 $(0/%(0% .%% /' '(0/%(0 0''?'+.% )

<'$* 6 * /0(%(%'0 @7%(%A$.))0%7/0 ()

P a g e | 4 A$.

0 %% :%/ ) $0%:(+ %% '/ '.

%'?7)) %:0(.%< ( & '% &%+ ::A$ $0?)' '%( 0 '?)' '

%0.%)(

<' '.%< ( & '% &%+ ::A$$0''?'+. & )( )8066% % (:%:A:

0%7/0/'

0$ >$ 7% /0 7% & / 80). 0 :%/ +.%' 00( ).0% ?)0%:?

%.)+ / ':

'8 ' %0.' )%'

:<: ?+0 ' %8 0 : . ) % %'' ?+ 0 ()

$ ?) 0%:?

%)(%'7 ' :

' %% '/ ' :(+ %% '/8 '0.%)< ( ')'$0 & /

%0'%%'))00%%( ' 0(% $0 :

7'4% 0 7)' ?%%' ')% 0.%(%' ?''$ $ % :() & / 8

.(% '

? %0%1/ % ' (

.%7(() '0 %( ' ?+0%1/ %$ % ::

: 80% ) 7%

7 ' #8 7 '%* =8>

8> %'.

0 * > ' 0+ .% 0%/0'

/)+$ 0 %( ' ()''00+0'? ))+ :()

' 0(%

' ) :'?% '?+0% ) 7%$ 7((% 0 0%/8 0(% A:

'">.

P a g e | 5 D$ 0(% A:

'/'&5"8.0':

0 0

) :() A$8.0

0 %:'0?

%/ % 0 A$B 0(% $ 0 % A:

80'000 :) 0'/ 0?7 ' '

0 ''&%0 :() A$? %0()

%$0 ''

&%A$* 6* /0$

7 80 7)' : 0.( .0

00 ) .%0& / '

& '7))+$ 0% 7%.)) 0 07 00 /0 "

'0% / 0 7%.))$ . % /?7 7)' ?07(%(%)+ ' :())+$0' 0 () (%(%'?+0()

' . %% 0($0/7 : . /.%'0/ '$ 0/7 0/7 : . 0 0 '0 : ' .)+ / ?+0 '$0+.% / 0 0.<:)+ % 0/ '.% / 0 % $ .) / .0 0 .0$0

7' : %:0 ' .

'%/8.0

0.0 : /$0/))%+ ) '.

00: /$ 7 '%

:0 %070 :

7%% $7 : )

%'0 ) '% %0:$0

%:'?+/7 : 0'0 $ 0 ) (' %:0:: /$ ):(% ) % .

000%(% $7% /0

7%% 80/7 : 7)'

%0 ) $4% 0 ' ).%0' )).0 ) ( /$ 7)'04% 0 .0& /%&)&%8.0 ) ).0& / 7 %+:'( )$

P a g e | 6 #$ 0 (% 7%0% A:

' 5 ?) 0%:?

%.07((%'0 : + 5"/'&$'0

0: 0 1+

80.('/7%'007

/'&$?7"!> $:$ 0 /0 %& /=B"

01+

80 .(% 0 7%+%' 007 /'& '.'% < / .%$0 :8 . 80 .

4 ?84% 0 ' ) %'

007 /'&$*: 0:/& *00+.7)' ? (%'$.0.%

%'8

%00'0 - % '%8.0 )0 0%

%00'0 0 :$0

%0.

%'0 :$0 ) 0 % .+.%'0.% ' '0)% %0: % :'

$.&%80 ) :'/'0 % ($)

%'0 ) .0 0+.%%7 /.+8?70+ ('

7 07%$ 0 %A:

80'0 )+4% 0 .0& / %&)&%8.0 )00%0%.%:(+0 ''$ 0 0.<

- % '%80 0%/'& ' :0 '%.% / 0 %

8 .0 ) 0 . '

/ % 0 ( 0% .%8 .0 0 ) %'007$0 ) ('0%7/00: / %:.0

00+0' %'007$ )8& 8 '4 ? % .%'0%.0 4% 0 (' %:0.% '$

%.:'?+0 :.0 0. )) 0 7%+%'8.0 )00%

%.:'?+0 :.0 0. %0/ /%/$0:

/ 0 7%+%' 7)'?07(%(%)+.

0 /)$0/. ( '?+- % '%.0 0 ))'0 7 )E'$7')(

& * %007 :() $) 0'%( '.

P a g e | 7

/ 0 0 :

7%% $0

7%% <() %BD:

7$0% %8 - % '% 7' ))0 7 )): ' )+ : ')($E'.) ))'?+0: %/ & /

:( +0 :00'<(. 0&%007'7% / /0$ +0 :0) 0& ))/80()

)%% &' 0& ))/ '

00%'00% ()

)$ %"D:

78&%)(% 0& ))/0' :007 /'&$) 007

/'& %?7 D:

7 0

7%% '0.< % 0( )$ %% /0( )80 :/0()

%/%'

7%% $0:/./ & ?7>!>

1$0' %%'0 : '? '/.(() '0 .7 '$0 ' %% %%'0 :0: /0 1*80<?71$ 0()

% %''0 : 1*0< 0 A '+$ $ 0(% 7%0%A:

'5> ?

%* /08.0 0' '

'0''?'+ - % '% 00( )0 :

(:%:A:

$/'

0.A:

'5$ 0

/0 %& / =B"

0 1+

86* /0* '*+. ?).%)(% 0(%)) /(%+$6* /0* % &'

%: %/%'

7%% 007 /'&?7

$:$80+))%70'.%'0& ))/ ()

6( '

% 0'0()

7%% $ % /0: / 0078 0+ .0 '' ?'+ - % '% )+ / $ 0% :(+

%% '/ '.

%'?7)).%< ( ?+0()

P a g e | 8 & ?)' '%0.(

<' %:0(? '8:?)'

'%( %:0 $0''?'+. & )( )8 066% %(:%:A:

$0(% 7%0%A:

5# 0 '8.0(%(%'0 ) () A$$5+ 0 '0'') &%'0(

)%(%$5C6:%* /08* 80'

(%(%'0

%% %'

/ : ' %.%''0 :07%$% * /0* .A:

'5= '00') (%)+ & /'0:%$5"

00 '%8' ?)8 . .%< / 1 0 ()

' 0

% :

/ & ' .'( '.

00 : 1)<0 $ 6?

%95"";0'

'0''?'+ - % '% /'&* /0 ':

0 '%.A:

'5"

8.0'00 %.:%% '

0/'&$0' '- % '% 0 /'&$.&%80

% 7'7((%0 0(% ''0

7%% <() 0 (% % ?'+0- % '% 0

(% $'

' < . +0 /?70

7%% $0' :' +: 0()

$.' )%'0 ) '.

%A:

' ?+ 0 (7?)

(% 7%$ 0 (% 7%0% A:

' 6 * /0 * 5">8 .0 0' '7 ' 0

)

& / 0(% $ C$ % )7% 0(% & ' 80:

))0

7'.%% %''7 '% >">%$$$ '0 %

% :

/& ' .(70:$.&%80+()'' )

:()

''00+.7)')'0& ' ' $

P a g e | 9 .&%8 .

.A:

'?+ + 0

7' 0(%

$ =$ 3% ' 7 ) %0* 7 6?&0: )+%/7'

0 0(% 0%.7

% :

/& ' / 0%( ' +0+0'? .% /)+ @7 '?+0% ) 7%$ 8 0(% 80%:?

%5 . 67%'

'0' 0

7%% $. +.

0 . 0'.

00' '/7 : '0' % ))+

&)& + (% $& 80 (% 7)' ?'7?' 00 :) . 67%'?+/7 0 67%+

%'?+4% 0 F4)8 .00''

''7% /0% )$0%:?

%5 )

%' ) ' '0 (% 0( 7)' 0&? '

?) &'$0780 %( ' 0&? .% /)+ @7 '?+0% )7%$1%&%8 5"/'& 0% 0' ' '0'% ?(% 0() 0

7%% $& 80% )7%.% /)+0)'00 (% 5"/'&.'7? 7)0() 0

7%% $

8 ?0 0 .

0' .

' 0

7%% ' 0 % : .%) ?)??) &'?+0% )7%$ "

$ 00%0 '8)% ' 7 ) %0%( ' .)))% ':

7 7% 0&(('07?:

:'?+ )% '* 7 ) '7?:

'00(% 5"/'& ' 5 0%:?

% . '7?

7) 0 () 0

7%% $ 1%&%85"

:0 '%8. )%) & 0' '8 ))00' 7((%'0 0(% $(% %:08

P a g e | 10 0

7%% 0'< () ?7

$> $:$ '0()

::'

)+% 0'0() 0

7%% $.&%80%(% .)'/' =$> $:$ A'+ '0(

)%(%. "

$> $:$0')+ ) )7' 7(

0 % (% $ ""$ 50&0%')% ' 7 ) %0(% '(%7'

0% %' % 7))+.

00 %?) $ "

$ 0(% 80(% A:

' :() /'&5"$'0 =$ D$

80 '0 ?%0% ).

:0 '%0' :& ))/7?)'0 '.%+ /0

07$?7 "$> $:$ 0 /0 =B"

01+

80+.% (% 0 %07 ' 0: :84% 0

%'.0 - % '%$ :

'0 : '00%00 0 :0 0$ )

%'0 :?70 (' '%70'0 %: %< /0

%&)&%$/.% :() A$%/%'

7%% '/& 0()

: 8.0 0.(% 0?7 '

0 %& ))/$':

')+8A$.7?:

'?+5"/'& ?7 =$

$:$ "

$ D$

$ .8 .7)'?((%(% % % 0 : + 5/'

08.0'00. (%)'7+ '7% /0 /0 =B"

01+

) /.

0()

) '0+ % &'

%: %/%'

7%% 007 /'& ?7

$:$0+ ::'

)+%70'0( '%% &'0 (

$> >$

$:$0+&

'% &% /0 %:0 ( ) $ @7 )+8 . )' 7 '% ' .0+ 0

P a g e | 11

:() . :'0()

0 :.0 0 %()

:0'&

'0 %07 '0%(%.)'/' =$

$:$0 A:% /$& 0(

)%(%% 0'01/ %"

($:$ @7 )+80%. 7 A() '')+ ?7""07%

)'/ /0 $(% %:08& 5 0%:?

%.)0

00( ).

0 ">:

7 0 < '& 0()

% 0'0()

7%% $0780')+ %/ % 0 7)' ?A() '?+0(% $ ">$ * )) 7%0%8 0 0 (% . (% :% )+ ?' 0 : 5"/'&85 0%:?

% :() '5"

:0 '% 0(% $& 07/0:0 '%

)%) & 5"/'& '- % '%8' '8?7 ))0'

7((%0 0(% '0''000' 0

7%% )) ' 0 /0'0(( ' 0 (% $ (% %:08.)

'00 : 5"/'&. ) 0 /0)+ 7(

7$ (% %: 08 7:7) & %'

: 5"/'& '5 0%:?

%.7)' )%)+0.0 0%.%% 7 %'

0: ?00.

'0%.( ?

) +00+.% (% 0() 0 ))/'

7%% $(%5 0%:?

%80.< /(

.%0 : 0

7%% 8.0%5"/'&'00 /7 : . / %0: / '0/7 .)+ /?+0 '$ * )) 7%0%80%.% 70%0)

- % '%' '

'5 0%:?

%. 0'/7 : .

00 :$.&%8&

P a g e | 12 7( / 7%(% % /007 0' ' '0 '7)+%:'80'

' %) ''

' &

% /)0 0:$* )) 7%0%80 7)' & 7 67%+ + 0

.0 )0+.% ) / %:0() 0

7%% $(% %:

08& 0 : +.))+ %%+0: 5"

/'& * /0$

/ 5 0%:?

%8 4% 0 % '

% .0%0%(% % 0%'

% $.&%8/'& 5"'04% 0 ' ).%0' 0:.0 )0+.% %7 /.+$& ) ):?+ )/ ' 7 ?) &?)0 5"/'& '5 0%:?

%8/7 : 8.0 ()

: 7)'

0& 7' + 67%+ )$ (% %: 08 & 0 (% %+ 0 /0)+ :(%??) '7 ?) &?)$(%5

0%:?

%8 - % '%8 ' '((%0 '' 0% 0 )

$ * ))8 - % '%8 ' ' . )) 0 7 ) E' * /0 %: : '

'& 0%:?

%5 '

' ?0%/.

00 :$& %%7% /0 078- % '%8' '8) 0'%(

$:$ '0+' 0/ 0 7%+%'$ 0%/'& 5" ':% )7 ):0 '%5"

.% / )) "!> $:$ & 8 7 ?) &?)0%7

& ))/% 0 (% 0 7 %+ .%.< / "$> $:$.

07 +% $0(% 0

7 '0(% E'* /00() 0

7%% $078 0 %(% %+ 0 /0)+7 ?) &?) ' ((%0 5"/'& '5 0%:?

%.% %'+.

0 (% $& 0%.

8.0&/ 0%7/00 :(7/ '

P a g e | 13 67'/: ''""$ =$

>('?+07% ''

) %

'* 7'/9'0 ;066% ' 7 ' ))/) +8 %%/7)% + '(%&% + 0:$ "$

0? 0)'?+0 2?)*7(%:7% 0 :% G 0<%% '0%-$* 10%0%H8

"C 9*7(%:7%;

"C9D;9% :

);

C )).! +,0

! $3

% $

% !

! # ! #

# ! $ &% ' # ' #% #

& $ "

$% !

$' ! * # !% '

A ! $ !0 %

&+;B>. 3 # 19:+;B>3 7;>,8 C $3

! !$#

$ % & !

!$ ! !

$ #

6. !6<'

%6 $3

! !

% !

! #

!!&

!$ 3

% !

' % '

!! ! !&3

% ! ! $

! $ !

P a g e | 14 !

$ ! # &!& #

&#!'

#!&

% ! % ! & # #

!!&3

' '

% &

& %!&

! !

! & & D!

%6'

% '

% ! !!

! !

* % ''

' !

% '* &3

% !

C "D$ "

% 5 +;;>1

3 # <.:+;;<3 7.B<> 3

&%!: C 3

# % '

* & 3

& $ # %! &

% !

% ! !

! ' !

$' % ! '

%!& ''

& 6 $ !$# %

! * '

' !

$ 3

& '

$ #

& "

'& %

P a g e | 15

$ % !

& ! &!C "#$ * )) 7%0% % :

)(() 9$;"

""B

"DJ&

*0%:-*9&% : $$$ )0 ; ' 0%K8'

""$ $

8 2?)0*7(%:7%00)'7 '%! % $ # ''

! *

1>B 3 ! 3 # !

E33F' ! !

& $3

' !6'

! * %

!$# 3

! !% / .-..33

3,;9

.96 !

$ &

% * $

1>B 330

!' 3

G% ' &#!

' % !

& D!

! 0

& %

% $ ! 3

! $ #

$'* !&

$ ! !

! & ! &!

! $

P a g e | 16 "$

& . 0?&'

'0).) ''. ?+ 0 L?)*7(%:7%8.

' :% 0(% (() '

0: %'%'?'

'$ "C$ @7 ?& '

8 0 :(7/ '

67'/: ''""$ =$

>('?+07% ''

) %

'* 7'/9'0 ;066%8 %'%'?7(0)'$ "=$ 0 7%% %' ((%

% 1%$%(* /0 ))8:

77% 8.00% '%'?) 07% ?0) 0%( ' $ '$

B8.0

00)) ?( '?+0* %%+8 /07%3/)*%&

$ )) ( '

/ (()

+8 % '

/)+$

"$ 0 (%(%+8

+8:+?').

0(%0 %7)$

$ %' 07%?).? ? <$ $*$*45;

9$*$53;

"#$ $

# 500%% 'B(< / !B :<B:

% 500%%(%?) !B