Thana Singh & ANR v. Financial Commissioner (Appeals) Pb & ORS
!"#"$% &'(&)
* $ +"$,* $ $ * - "
"$ -# .# "$ $!"
/00"##"$ -122 /#345$6 7 $ * -# #2$ $ # (
'
/7"-+"$,* $ $ * - "
"$ -# .# "$ $!"
/00"##"$ -122 /#345$6 7 $ * -# #2$ $ # 8% 9:8+8++8:;
8++8:;4
! "
# " # # "
( % " &! "$ # "" '
()*+, (**, -
. -"0 0 /"# ## # 1"$ " (* 23 (**, -"0 $
"# "" "# ! # $ !$ ! 4# % #
560 $
7 88 (8 (**, ' " "
( , ! " " 9:
#5
+
# " # 2; (( (**+
7
! < & " 9 5+0
!
" '
()*+, (**, -
. -"0 0
""$ 7"
#5 '
()*,3 (**,
7"
#5
" () 2; (*3( 5()0
""$ 5
" 8+ 2) (*38 5(60 =
#5 9: # 2; 2; 82(+
),)2 82(+ &
! (; 2( (*;;
5(0 &! !
! # # 5,0 ""#""$
9 ! 1 ""$
""#""$ 5,0
# ! # $ / # 4!
5,0 ! ""# !$ "
" "
"
8+ 23 (*3;
5+0
""$ ""
"! (* 23 (**, #
9 "
# "$
"$ 4 " " ""!#
#
!
"
# $ %
&' & (
)& * "
+ ,! - )* ... /0 '
1- 2(3 .( 4#3 "
)* 5%%6 7 % ! .# &0 /
)/ 56 7 % ! .# ' . 3 +
8 1 "33 9 & 56 7 % ! .# *0 ) - :3 0 5
! 5;6 /
& $ # ""!#
"
!
"
$ "
&# " " "# "
"
## # "
"
4# !
" ""!
"$ ""#"
"" ""!# = #
! $ "
&
>
" (, 2, (*6,
"
! " $ " " () 2; (*3( 5()0 8+ 2) (*38 5(60
= ""$ "!
(; 2( (*;;
5(0 ! #
"
!
# /<
) 5,0 # "# !
"$ #
!
" : '! : : !
!#"$ # #
# # ! ! #"# ""#"$
# 5,0 !
"
! #"$ #
""$ ! 4 !
5,0 4 "
# !
? 5,0 # 15 "
"# "
# ! % "$ "$ # ""
1 5, 5+ 56 "$ ""#"
= " # "
!
= ""$ 8+ 23 (*3;
5+0 # ,) 4 (* 23 (**,
< # +* 4
? !
#
"# 5,0
#5#"
! ""$ (; 2( (*;;
%
$ (*3( (*38 ! " &!
# ""#"$ #
5,0
#"# ""#"$ "$ # ""#"$ ! ""
""
/ " !
#
5 ,0 4 # "# !
""#"$ ""#"$ ! # ?
'
$ ! "" " !""$ ""
# # " " ! !
$ # " ! #"$ ""
5, 5+ $
: ""$ ! ""! ! ! =8++8:;> ,( 23 82(6 ' 4#@ A@ ' " A@