High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/6860/2014dismissed

Kela Devi Alias Kanta Devi v. Seema Devi And ORS

2015-12-01Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih4 pages

" #$%&' ( ) " #$%&' ( ) " #$%&' ( ) " #$%&' ( ) "%*+,,,+,*,-' "%*+,,,+,*,-' "%*+,,,+,*,-' "%*+,,,+,*,-' ."/ ."/ ."/ ."/ 0 "

0 "

"%, "%, "%, "%, "

."/ "

."/ 1# 1# 1# 1# 231 " 231 " 231 " 231 "

'*# 1'%*,(4$,*( '*56**' 1' +",(4$,*( '*5'64* 75*5' 6'*' $, 86,6' %,9 & ,84**5:;4<%*="> &' ''4**5 6'*''*="> ?75*5' *5 :;4<%* 5;4 & '6'*4 *5 4<*=">

33(. ',/

33(. ',/ 04'4'&<,,4(4,*4 @ ) !('4'4 &9;4<.;'/(;'<,(,66$,*%4&9 *56,*

A'64*"%,4,;<5*' ,*+,', "<5(B<,%4%**56,*(5,4$&,84 5$$;'$'44&9*5*',$;'*(',4,*5;#A CD D D D 6';, *5 ,& %*4 <, 6';, *5 ,& %*4 <, 6';, *5 ,& %*4 <, 6';, *5 ,& %*4 <,

6'*$,'*5,*$;'*%,9,*,9*,<,8 6'*$,'*5,*$;'*%,9,*,9*,<,8 6'*$,'*5,*$;'*%,9,*,9*,<,8 6'*$,'*5,*$;'*%,9,*,9*,<,8 ,%4%* 6,4<**5'6,'*9 *5;* ,%4%* 6,4<**5'6,'*9 *5;* ,%4%* 6,4<**5'6,'*9 *5;* ,%4%* 6,4<**5'6,'*9 *5;* 8'*5$;'*5,**5,*;$5,%4%* 8'*5$;'*5,**5,*;$5,%4%* 8'*5$;'*5,**5,*;$5,%4%* 8'*5$;'*5,**5,*;$5,%4%* 5;4*$,;,96':;4$'$$* 5;4*$,;,96':;4$'$$* 5;4*$,;,96':;4$'$$* 5;4*$,;,96':;4$'$$* *5*5'6,'*9'<*5*5'6,'*9,;'6'< *5*5'6,'*9'<*5*5'6,'*9,;'6'< *5*5'6,'*9'<*5*5'6,'*9,;'6'< *5*5'6,'*9'<*5*5'6,'*9,;'6'< 5$B ;* *5 *', 5, $%%$4( 5$B ;* *5 *', 5, $%%$4( 5$B ;* *5 *', 5, $%%$4( 5$B ;* *5 *', 5, $%%$4( ,%4%* 5;4 & ,84 E$6* 85$5 ,%4%* 5;4 & ,84 E$6* 85$5 ,%4%* 5;4 & ,84 E$6* 85$5 ,%4%* 5;4 & ,84 E$6* 85$5 $$'4 6,'*9 $;4 * %,B , *' 4; $$'4 6,'*9 $;4 * %,B , *' 4; $$'4 6,'*9 $;4 * %,B , *' 4; $$'4 6,'*9 $;4 * %,B , *' 4; 4<$9*56'64,%4%*(*56,*

4<$9*56'64,%4%*(*56,*

8,**$'6',**5' 6,'** *5;* 8,**$'6',**5' 6,'** *5;* 8,**$'6',**5' 6,'** *5;* 8,**$'6',**5' 6,'** *5;* 6'6'*98*5%*,4&;4,48,**%6,4 6'6'*98*5%*,4&;4,48,**%6,4 6'6'*98*5%*,4&;4,48,**%6,4 6'6'*98*5%*,4&;4,48,**%6,4 16,,6,'*9*56'*;*56,*

16,,6,'*9*56'*;*56,*

'<,9 4*56'*;* '4$,',*8*5 '<,9 4*56'*;* '4$,',*8*5 '<,9 4*56'*;* '4$,',*8*5 '<,9 4*56'*;* '4$,',*8*5 $F;*,' 6'%,*:;$*,<,* $F;*,' 6'%,*:;$*,<,* $F;*,' 6'%,*:;$*,<,* $F;*,' 6'%,*:;$*,<,* *5 4 4,* 85 ,' 5' %*5' ,4 &'*5' *5 4 4,* 85 ,' 5' %*5' ,4 &'*5' *5 4 4,* 85 ,' 5' %*5' ,4 &'*5' *5 4 4,* 85 ,' 5' %*5' ,4 &'*5' 8'(,*'*56'*,66$,*8, 4* 8'(,*'*56'*,66$,*8, 4* 8'(,*'*56'*,66$,*8, 4* 8'(,*'*56'*,66$,*8, 4* $'6',**5' 6,'** *5;*6'6'*9 $'6',**5' 6,'** *5;*6'6'*9 $'6',**5' 6,'** *5;*6'6'*9 $'6',**5' 6,'** *5;*6'6'*9 ,4*$'6',*16,85*' 6,*

,4*$'6',*16,85*' 6,*

,4 , $A5,'' *5 ;* 6'6'*9 5 ,4 , $A5,'' *5 ;* 6'6'*9 5 ,4 , $A5,'' *5 ;* 6'6'*9 5 ,4 , $A5,'' *5 ;* 6'6'*9 5

>,66$,*5,;&%**4*5,*4;*,$B

<,,4$*5' 8,*'<,9;<5*5 <,,4$*5' 8,*'<,9;<5*5 <,,4$*5' 8,*'<,9;<5*5 <,,4$*5' 8,*'<,9;<5*5 $** ,66$,*>6,*

*;*,,& $** ,66$,*>6,*

*;*,,& *59 ,8,'96'6';%4*& *59 ,8,'96'6';%4*& *59 ,8,'96'6';%4*& *59 ,8,'96'6';%4*& ,8,' 5'<5*<',$ ,8E$; ,8,' 5'<5*<',$ ,8E$; ,8,' 5'<5*<',$ ,8E$; ,8,' 5'<5*<',$ ,8E$; 8'(B6<8*56'* '4' ; 8'(B6<8*56'* '4' ; 8'(B6<8*56'* '4' ; 8'(B6<8*56'* '4' ; D*5,*&*5,*85*5'*5,66$,* D*5,*&*5,*85*5'*5,66$,* D*5,*&*5,*85*5'*5,66$,* D*5,*&*5,*85*5'*5,66$,* $,'9 ' 6'6' ,4:;4$,* *5 $, ,4 $,'9 ' 6'6' ,4:;4$,* *5 $, ,4 $,'9 ' 6'6' ,4:;4$,* *5 $, ,4 $,'9 ' 6'6' ,4:;4$,* *5 $, ,4 ,4%;*6$*9 6'$4<'*5'<, ,4%;*6$*9 6'$4<'*5'<, ,4%;*6$*9 6'$4<'*5'<, ,4%;*6$*9 6'$4<'*5'<, ;* , ;* ' 4$,',* 8*5 6'%,* ;* , ;* ' 4$,',* 8*5 6'%,* ;* , ;* ' 4$,',* 8*5 6'%,* ;* , ;* ' 4$,',* 8*5 6'%,* :;$*$$'4<*6,*

(*56,'*,'$A :;$*$$'4<*6,*

(*56,'*,'$A 5,''*5;*6'6'*9,4*&;*,*;',*5,* 5,''*5;*6'6'*9,4*&;*,*;',*5,* 5,''*5;*6'6'*9,4*&;*,*;',*5,* 5,''*5;*6'6'*9,4*&;*,*;',*5,* ,;* '6,'**&9*5' *56,'*5,*& ,;* '6,'**&9*5' *56,'*5,*& ,;* '6,'**&9*5' *56,'*5,*& ,;* '6,'**&9*5' *56,'*5,*&

4$(*56'64' %,9&$'6',*4

4$(*56'64' %,9&$'6',*4 *5 6'* ;* * ,4 %;*6$*9

*5 6'* ;* * ,4 %;*6$*9

6'$4< 1''( *5 6'* $, 6'$4< 1''( *5 6'* $, 6'$4< 1''( *5 6'* $, 6'$4< 1''( *5 6'* $,

G4$5,*9**,'*4*$,*

&,4*5,**5;*,**5'9&,*4*,<5 &,4*5,**5;*,**5'9&,*4*,<5 &,4*5,**5;*,**5'9&,*4*,<5 &,4*5,**5;*,**5'9&,*4*,<5 *,< *5;*5,*&,$$'4<**5 *,< *5;*5,*&,$$'4<**5 *,< *5;*5,*&,$$'4<**5 *,< *5;*5,*&,$$'4<**5 6'$4<$4;$*4*5$,,4**5*% 6'$4<$4;$*4*5$,,4**5*% 6'$4<$4;$*4*5$,,4**5*% 6'$4<$4;$*4*5$,,4**5*% 6'41''(*56'64,%4%*8* 6'41''(*56'64,%4%*8* 6'41''(*56'64,%4%*8* 6'41''(*56'64,%4%*8* $,; 6':;4$ * *5 4 4,* 1''( * $,; 6':;4$ * *5 4 4,* 1''( * $,; 6':;4$ * *5 4 4,* 1''( * $,; 6':;4$ * *5 4 4,* 1''( * **46'6* ,8*5,*,9,66$,*';* **46'6* ,8*5,*,9,66$,*';* **46'6* ,8*5,*,9,66$,*';* **46'6* ,8*5,*,9,66$,*';* 5;4 &4$44 %'*,4 * *$5$, 5;4 &4$44 %'*,4 * *$5$, 5;4 &4$44 %'*,4 * *$5$, 5;4 &4$44 %'*,4 * *$5$, <';4 ;'*5'%'(*5,&,448&9*5 <';4 ;'*5'%'(*5,&,448&9*5 <';4 ;'*5'%'(*5,&,448&9*5 <';4 ;'*5'%'(*5,&,448&9*5 G& ";6'% ;'* , 8 , ,'; <5 G& ";6'% ;'* , 8 , ,'; <5 G& ";6'% ;'* , 8 , ,'; <5 G& ";6'% ;'* , 8 , ,'; <5 ;'* *5,* *5' 6&*9 *5, ,%4%* ;'* *5,* *5' 6&*9 *5, ,%4%* ;'* *5,* *5' 6&*9 *5, ,%4%* ;'* *5,* *5' 6&*9 *5, ,%4%* ,66$,*5;4&,84&',9E$6* * ,66$,*5;4&,84&',9E$6* * ,66$,*5;4&,84&',9E$6* * ,66$,*5;4&,84&',9E$6* * $,; 6':;4$ * *5 *5' 6,'*9 *5 $,; 6':;4$ * *5 *5' 6,'*9 *5 $,; 6':;4$ * *5 *5' 6,'*9 *5 $,; 6':;4$ * *5 *5' 6,'*9 *5 $$$,;4**566*6,'*9$,& $$$,;4**566*6,'*9$,& $$$,;4**566*6,'*9$,& $$$,;4**566*6,'*9$,& $%6,*4 *'% %9( *5 , $%6,*4 *'% %9( *5 , $%6,*4 *'% %9( *5 , $%6,*4 *'% %9( *5 , ,66$,* ' ,%4%* 5;4 & ,84 '

,66$,* ' ,%4%* 5;4 & ,84 '

*584',8;66'* '%*5,;*5'* ,:

+;%,';',8,',01> "+",',< ,4%6,9 +;%,';',8,',01> "+",',< ,4%6,9 +;%,';',8,',01> "+",',< ,4%6,9 +;%,';',8,',01> "+",',< ,4%6,9

*3*4,4,*5'

@. /

."/(",5&

*3*4,4,*5'

@. /

."/(",5&

*3*4,4,*5'

@. /

."/(",5&

*3*4,4,*5'

@. /

."/(",5& "<5 ,4 ,*5' 0 +;46 +;%,' ,4 *5' "<5 ,4 ,*5' 0 +;46 +;%,' ,4 *5' "<5 ,4 ,*5' 0 +;46 +;%,' ,4 *5' "<5 ,4 ,*5' 0 +;46 +;%,' ,4 *5'

. /! .

-/ *'$'6',*<*5'

. /! .

-/ *'$'6',*<*5'

. /! .

-/ *'$'6',*<*5'

. /! .

-/ *'$'6',*<*5'

6,'**(*$,'9*%6,416,, 6,'**(*$,'9*%6,416,, 6,'**(*$,'9*%6,416,, 6,'**(*$,'9*%6,416,, 6,'*9*56'*,;* '6,'**,*5$A 6,'*9*56'*,;* '6,'**,*5$A 6,'*9*56'*,;* '6,'**,*5$A 6,'*9*56'*,;* '6,'**,*5$A 5,'','$,'96,'* 5,'','$,'96,'* 5,'','$,'96,'* 5,'','$,'96,'*

*5,4$,',4$*4,;*5'*,4 *5,4$,',4$*4,;*5'*,4 *5,4$,',4$*4,;*5'*,4 *5,4$,',4$*4,;*5'*,4 <,6'(*5,66$,* ',%4%*,4 <,6'(*5,66$,* ',%4%*,4 <,6'(*5,66$,* ',%4%*,4 <,6'(*5,66$,* ',%4%*,4 %6,4%*(5'&9(,84;&:$**$*

%6,4%*(5'&9(,84;&:$**$*

>A;* 85$5

>A*&<**5

>A;* 85$5

>A*&<**5

>A;* 85$5

>A*&<**5

>A;* 85$5

>A*&<**5 66* 6,'*9 ,4

>A * & 46*4 66* 6,'*9 ,4

>A * & 46*4 3"(;'<,H 3"(;'<,H 3"(;'<,H 3"(;'<,H $449(,;* 4&9*56,*

A'64*( 5 6',94 ' , 4$,',* *5,* *5 :;4<%* ,4 4$' 4,*4 ?

)(6,4";*

!(8, 859 <,( 4 ,4 6',* ,<,* *5 '<5* *5

*546;*F;,*5*,* 5' ,*5',*

+,',"<5(8544!

?(6,*

,<8*5*5 4 4,*5,4;$$44**5*,* *54$,4**5 E** >)*55,',$51,<*5'&9('<,9(85,**5

6',94 '8,,4$' ':*6,4(4, 6'64,%4%*(55,6',94 '6,'** *5:* 6'6'*9 4 $;'(,"%*6,,5,664*& *54,;<5*' ,*+,',"<5(*,'',95',6,'*9 4 4,* EA ,$(6,*

4*<,,9*5<&94,9< *56'$4<,55' 5,**;*4*5;*4$ *5 6,*

9* * $%%$ , & ' *5 ,%4%* 6',94 ' 8, <',*4( *5;<5 *5 $;'* 5,4

',%4 ;( &;* 4$ *5 6,*

5,4 * 9* $%%$4 4;&*49( *5 ,%4%* *5,* 5, & <',*48;4,'*%;*6$*9 6'$4<,4,9 ;'*5'

$%6$,**5%,**' 5,* &< ( *'

'$ 8,'',*4 E'$ ', :;'4$* ;4' '*$ D *5 **;* 4, ** &< 44 %'* ( ,$$'4<9(4%4 1 ( ) 1 ( ) 1 ( ) 1 ( ) .

33/ .

33/ +,< +,< +,< +,<