High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/493/2004dismissed

State Of Haryana v. Bala & ORS.

2026-02-17Mr. Justice N.S. Shekhawat12 pages

P a g e | 778 9 :9 778 9 :9 778 9 :9 778 9 :9 9 ; 9 ; 9 ; 9 ; 78 78 78 78 '

( 9% (/ +00 '/( 020++0+6 ()"##( 3C0++0+6 //( 0C0 +0+6 State of Harya Bala Devi and Dalbir The State of H ana Vs.

d others Vs.

Haryana

...Petitioner(s)

...Respondent(s)

...Petitioner(s)

...Respondent(s)

< = 97 < = 97 < = 97 < = 97 < = 97 < = 97 < = 97 < = 97 8= 8= 8= 8=

$(/-$ 8 *

*/% /'(" $#"--#)(%(/ (

$.;/'

/'( :(.%(/ ("

! 1.

* 5* () . # >-/1$ $ 5 . /#%( ()) 5( ( "#$# %% % # () () () () ) +00 +00 ) +00 +00# /D()* D()* D()* D()* & & & &

'# '# '# '# / (. / (. / (. / (.? / 60 0

+00 +00 +00 # / D ,# ,# ,# ,# & & & & () () () () * * * *? ? ? ? + &#/ . #$%-1/ >-/1$ / (/ // 0@3++00

,# %% #60 +00!5 5"('#"/)("($$##1. ())" %- #., -/ "#( 077 / 5 "/ ( -/1( ( #1((- #$ $%#($ )( %#(/ () 0 02 * / ( %* )# ( ) 30 0004

(15#./)- #%- #( 5. .""-/ $ * *

'# ((%/ $A.5 (//(,"B-#/ ,# #

P a g e | 2 )# /60 +00/%*/)(.#"B-# 5..() *.)# /.%%% 5#.%*("('#" .)(- ""-/4%(/ -/ "#( 0+4 7 #" ,(. . %% #(-()."($$(#$%-1/>-/1$/(/ .$,#1 /#%(/())#$- (- * .:7E4+#.%"51#/(.,# () . $ $/ ,* &#(/ -$ ( () $ #1.

/ . 'E"().:7.,%(/-"/, (5

! "# $

()&)))*+ ! "# #

& ),--.))-

! $&

! "# %

-/) ! & %

& "# ! $ % %

! 0 "#

% 1

P a g e | 3

! "#

# # 0

& ' #

# #

2 ##

& '

3 # 00

!4 &'

3 &

1 *+5 6 '3$!00 7 ).1##(().:7 ,(..#>-/5/$#/ (#'# (%# .>>(5' .155"##" *#>-// 5 )/ ( 87 (.A - $ '##/ . %( / %%/ . (-1. # % 3+33+003 .15 E%#/ # . .(%# /.())"-/"#( 0+75///.%($($ ( . // ,(/* () .15 5 1( "(/-"/ / . %( 5 .//('(.%( #" ++33+003 ,# ((%/ $A.

%(/ 5/#.%"/A#("-(/*,*. %( #" 7 %--" () .# /#" (- $ ,# 1( "('/ #((/ 5.((%1("('/0 #%--"().#/#" (- $ $A.""-/ ($/.#/#" (-$/1( 0 "('/ )($ .# .(- % )($ . ( 3 33+003 '# %(/4""-/ 5 ( / / 1( "('/ ) "($% #(()"*#'#1#( .5%/1# .)(-%(/#.(-() 1#)."($$# %("/#1 ."5A-%,*.# (-/'#/(//

P a g e | 4 ".1 . // +0+00+ . ".1 -/ "#( 0+4 +42064 75)$/1#.%(/4""-//.*% //(1-# * /" #$/(,#/ 2 -#1 . "(- () # . %("-#( E$#/ 3 -#/.# 5.(./$/#"( 1 *E$#/&#(/-$(() $#1.

"($% #/)(-/.)( (5#1#>-# - "

8-9:9 #

. "

8(9:- # ### #

& 2 # / "

899:9:9 #

$# # ;+

( "

8 /9 :9 :9 & # 2

# &# %.#$ .#>-*(+5/" /#$% /#>-# (3 /5A%-/(,'#(

.$/* .$/#"( 1 *E$#/ .15( ()$#1./)(-/.)( (5#1#>-# - " # #

. "

8 /9:/9 2 #

## # $ # ;+

/ "

8.:9 #

& : $ # ;'

%.#$ .#>-#5A%-/(,'#(/. %#5)/(87 (.A)()-.$

0C03+003# ) ../$/#"( 1 *E$#/> 5#)() ,# ""-//)( (5#1#>-#5)(-/(.%( -"

8-):)9 2 #

## #

P a g e | 5 # ;+

8-9:)9 #

# $ # ;+

8<9:)9 & # $ # .#>-#(3/+5A%-/(,'#(5. .#>-*( 5/" /#$% #-

.$/* . ($/#"( 1 *E$#/ ,#( ()A.//)(-/.)( (5#1#>-# -"

8-:9:9 # :

$ # ;+

89:9 #

: $ # ;+

# =>#

. - () #>-* ( 5 A% -/ (,'#( . #>-#(3( (.%(() .155%(. ) #/().#,(/*/-".*%()#>-*() .15"(- /,%(#, /-() (./#1- -)"/.#>-#(.%(()&#(/ 5(#1.#/().#,(/*7>-#(3 +/"(- /,%(#, ,* #1 ) 6 .%("-#()-.E$#/+..#1. 5.( #$(* 5 )($ # - . %("-#( )-. E$#/ &#(/-$ "($% # 5.(-%%(/."().%("-#(7 .#"(E$##( ./../#/($$,./ 5.. $(*5/'"/,* .15(((%"(- /($#(' .$(.(*.$(*5/'"/)($.". *#1../

P a g e | 6 ( /.# /.%("-#()-.E$#/-> . #5.( %" 5"('/)($ '# ""-/#%--"(). /#" (- $ . %("-#( )-. E$#/ 2 .$ 5.( ./ "(/-"/ . %($($ E$##( ( . //,(/*() .15(()$#1.)(-/)( (5

-,<

# 3 # 0

? - @ # /(

-):A #

. . : B &

: ## 0 // :/ &

7 7$*(%##(./"//#/()*"(%)( (5/,*./ #>-* 7>-# 5 $($ # - / -))#"# ( "- /. /-#1- "(-()' C .%("-#()-.E$#/67#) (.$$/ 7 5.(/ #'/.%"# %((. 1# / .#$(*()C #./ (, 5)($ #-./ .%%/" /#% E.%("-#()-.E$#/ @7 $A.7 5.(./"(//.)($ :7E4+7 .#%" 5"('/)($ '#.%("-#()-. E$#/ -$ 5.(5.7 #.%" ./1(. =() .15/&#(/%%/ (1("(// .$()."($% # (/.""-/#.%

P a g e | 7 "/$/"('#/"(/-"/.#'#1#(.%(7.# "(E$##( . /$#/ . ,# / '# ""-/ 5 .'#1 #>-# ( .# ,(/# .* (,#/ .# $/#" E$##( / (%(/.$(.%( #".%(5 (/1/,* ,# #.%( #"#( 5.#".5"(//,*.#$)-./.( "(1#F, ())"5$/(-)($. =(.((A("#(( .(%("/#1.%("-#()-.E$#/30$#1. ).()./"/-%%(/.#$(*() &#(/-$ 7.#"(E$##( ./..$(*5/'"/.* %#((.(""-"(5' ./#/($$,.$(.(*() ."#(.$(*51#'( $A./((%,*.#( .#.(-,-.5(%.)-./$#/.% (()

'# 5/>" (.#'"% ( '## . 5#)().# ,(.G(.% (() '#/ ,###-/)($% ( .(""-"./A% ")42$(.75#" %,-( ( ./ -/ -% /-#1 . (""-" E"% A. .15 #>-/ ./,"($-"("#(-/$#/-"("#(-.(-1.(-/ ../#/.%("-#()-.E$#/33# 7 5.( 5 (%().### #'#1#( @ )." (-().%("-#('#/" .#"#$##1 '#/"5%-)(5/( .%(/4""-//.*% // .#) #$% #"#(75/..*./'(,#/* ( )($ .15 / . ( 5 A )($ . * 8$#

A)(%-".#1"(( 30 3@/(02."$,+003 .* ( / 5* .# / )( $A#1 %*$ () . ,A .* # 1/( . /( .15 ,-.5(/*(%*.)- %#"(.*( /. /(.#./' #/().A /

P a g e | 8 /-(.# .155(*/5-%"#1.#5 ,# 5.(1(.# /( /((.//-(.$#* ./.#,(. &#(/"A/ ,#/.#5#) '#/"-/.$#>-# ' ((% / $ A. % // . .* 5 ( % . % "().(""-" 7/)" %(/4""-/./E$#/. -$ 3 5.( / . ( 0C33+003 . 5 1(#1 (5/.# )# / )($.#.(-,(-343 0%$.5%#1"(.#

() .'# 1 .5.."(( *() ,#5%A/(#

/ . / .# 5#) '# 5 - (/#1 "(% () . . 5 ./ */#"()30%")($#

../.&#(//

.155E.(#1/5,-#1 ,#(5.*../( /. /(($(.%(/((.$. .15"$ .( * 5.# ,#5- (/#1."(%)($.( */ '#5/#1(.1(-/ .15 %%/ '#/. 1', (55#. (../() '#/ (.$ '#%-./ .15/ ,# (>-$%/)($.( *&#(/ 1', (55#. (.#.//(.#$5. '#%-./

.15) (-,5 1#5.#".5 *#1. '# "./. () .15/1'($ , (5(&#(/# )/)"(). )/..-,/ ,#1'(, (5(*,(/*# .(""-"((%/ $A.

,(..""-/5(% .(.*-/-%.(-1.(-.(""-".(""-" / )(334+40+$#-/(%(/.##1.5 (%. . ""-/ ( E$#/ ($,# 1##( A () .# ))#"

.>>+ 5.(,(-1.."(/%##1( //(+C32 //3302+003 5.,* ((%#1." ./( /. /#)'(-()

P a g e | 9 .#. / ' -$ . // 5 E.#,#/ E # $ A 8$# A ..-".A5 5E$#/ 5.(./ ,(-1.."(/%##1(.""(-()A./ (()./1# $ ((% #1. / $ A. . ,A ./ /'"/ ( () + 0004#)'(-()A.//.#5((((%#1./

$A.)(.%-".()"(( *( 3023@.)# %*$ 1# . ( 5 $/ ,* . ""-/ # . ,A ( 3023 / .* 1# %#/ +0 0004 ( +0. - * +000 / . $##1$(-5#.# )- /)# %*$5$/(2. ('$,+003%('/("(/."("/"#)#/"(%*() .#(). /1E 30 =/ "(- '.$ * 1-/ . # . % " .5-))#"#'#/"("(/(%('."($% #"#*() . %(/ # . "#$ 7 )" . $ 5 %($% * 1#/ 5#. . %( #" / . 5 ). '#/" ( .(5 . . )(- %(/./"-/#>-#(&#(/-$ #>-// .

15 #" /"/ ' # %--" () .# %"#' /#" (- $ .5%(()())"5"('/)($.$/.*./ "-/ #>-# (,(..#>-/ % )($ . .%"() '# %(/(35/$#/,*./)"# ).% "(). (""-"/..,5(1 *E(/,*.

. (. ./ / "(- %%#1 ( ,. ) () ,# %% #60 +00!

-,$#/..# (-) # ( 5.# "('#"#1 .#$ 7 )" . %("-#( ./ "(" / . ())" () . (""-" / )# / ( E% # . #>-# -))/ ,* ,# 5 $ '# ' . # (- ./ "(// )#/#1..1#().(""-"5(" /.%%

P a g e | 10 5"('#"/( *(.,#()5.#$/ (.)". .15 ./ E%#/ # . % " # )-. . %("-#( "(- / ( E% # . / * # 1##( () . :7 / . # (- ./ ( %%"#/.'#/"#."("%%"#' 3+ .'./. /"(- )(.%#/%-/ ."(/")- * 3 7.%" .%("-#(5 /)"./#/ (-%.#(5"/ ( /'#/"5#.1/(.$ # 5.#"..(""-"./A% ".%("-#( 1/. . )(- ""-/ "$ ( . .(- () .15 / &#(/ / "-/ #>-#(.$5.(.(../ .""-/ 1/.( ( 5 A ,* . ""-/ )($ .15 . .

""-/ # 5/( .# /#)'(-() .15#" ./#/(()) %(% %#" .* ( / . / # )'(- () /#)) %( ( 3302+003#" .155-%"#1. ,#5#-$ #1#1. /( /#)'(-()(.%( .5##$#" (5/ .$/(0C33+003 . (15#..#,(../"A/ ,#/ .#5#) '# .15./ %%/ '#/ (1', (5 5#. ..//.//#.# )/)" ,#"-/ #>-#(.#$/&#(/ 3 7.%" 5 (15#..)#/#1"(//,* .# (-..5%(#,# #*..""-/./(,#/ ( )($./"/7)" .*./(,#/ (()+ 0004)($. ,A)(.%-".

()"(( *( 30 3@(5' #5 %%)($."(/.*() 00045% *$/ / # 5 %(#, . . #/ $(- $#1. .

.15 ( . ""-/ # . % " # )-. 5 .' (

P a g e | 11 ((, #'.5(""-/ $ * ((%/ $A.5 ( %.% "()(""-"7)" #., 1/,* .%("-#(.,(.().$5/- *$/5#.0 &.(5' /#/ ("-*#>-*(*().#>-/#.%"(B- * ##-, #', .,(.().$5%.% "()(""-" /.*./,#1. *"B-#/,*.# (- 32 ()."() ,#/$ '##"("/ .*5/$#/ *%.% "()(""-"7.%" ,(.().$./-))/#$% #>-#(.#%(/.#>-# 5(-,>"/(H*E$##(.""-/.'#/(-% " . .* ./ "-/ #>-# # .# ) /)" 7 5 )-. -,$#/.

#"."($% #4#>-/./ %%//"-/#>-# ( '# #%('(A/ ,#/../"-/#>-## )/)" (5' ## (%%.#" .15/&#(/./"-/ #$% #>-#( '# ,#"(- /.'"-/#$% .-. $(#. )/)"(5' .1', (55#.#((/(../ () .15/.55 5().)"..E"//.##1. () )/)"/ (./.A(5 /1.,*"-#1-".#>-* ."(- /"-./.() .15(B- * .# (-5 >-#)#/ # "('#"#1 ,# -/ "#( 0 77 7 . ./ . A(5 /1..#>-#"-/,*.#$5 #A *("-./.

.15'(.5# 5.'")- *%-/.>-/1$() "('#"#(/(/()""(//,*.# (-/)#/.. # (-./"(" *%%"#/.'#/"#. #1.(). / "(() 5' . /"(- )(.%#"(- /(%(#(- *# 1 #*(#)#$#*(%'#*#.#$%-1/>-/1$/(/ %/,*.# (-/5)#/(((/'#)($.$

P a g e | 12 36 -%.((),('/#"-#( 5)#/($##,(.. %% /.$(//(,/#$#/"(B-" . #$%-1/ >-/1$ / (/ // 0@3++00 %/ ,* . (- () //##( ##"/#( -/1 /.("!

.>>-%. / 3C ,# . %% 4""-/ # 60 () +00 # /#"/ ( -/ 5#.# 32 /* )($ (/* )# #1 5.#".

"("/ . #- ( ,# , 5 1# . % %% 4""-//. "($$#.#$("-(/*('.$##1 "()#$%#($ 3@ %/#1%% #"#( #)* /#%(/()) ""(/#1 * 3 ."%(%* #)* $*,/ 5#.%.- +0 "(/().(-, (5,,"A +3 %.(("(%* () .# >-/1$ , ( % "/ ( . )# () "("/"

! 98

8=!

98 3C0++0+6 3C0++0+6 3C0++0+6 3C0++0+6 $# ..(/4%A#1

;4( ..%(,

;4(