← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/539/2004dismissed

Delhi Special Police Establishment, CBI v. Puran Chand And ANR.

2018-08-24Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan,Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri6 pages

   

       

 !"#$!%&'&"()*+*+ !,-&./!%&,",&%! ' 0,&'-1!( 2 !( 3,43!4"#(5!' &6 &"(2.

2

-($&63- ******//!,,( 7!3'4' 43( -($($(" -!3 *******!'/"($!( '

 )  89  * . **    89  * . :

9.  3!'!( )

3*.4;-$!!/.&(6-.($-42$5"% !2 #"3//!,,( *

3***.*!",2.!(&"3$5"% !2<& -2

3*=!'-9102$5"% !2 #"33!'/"($!( "** * >-! -!3 -!!/"3 !3'"#,"%,(!<'//!31?0!,,"<!$ " '!! -!=4$61!( @ * "0!3!#!33!$ " -!!/"3 !3"3(" * * >-! -!3 -!=4$61!( '-"4,$0!3!/"3 !$&( -!$&6!' @ * * :

9. 2* -&'&'(//!,6&(' =4$61!( $ !$**2/''!$0? ,!3(!$$$& &"(,.!''&"('4$6!210,25&$!<-&%-3!'/"($!( '43(

-($($;,.&(6-2<!3!%A4& !$"#%-36!'#31!$6&('  -!1 4($!3.!% &"( 3!$<& -.!% &"( * %"1!'"4  - $43&(6 -!/!($!(%?"#//!,243( -($3!'/"($!( "* $&!$*-!3!#"3!2 //!,A4-&1' ($'0 !$* -!/3"'!%4 &"(' "3?&(03&!#&' - <(:413$!%!'!$ <-" <'<"3;&(6'!"(&( 3&(63-3&13?63&%4, 43,9($ !5!,"/1!(  (;  9&1& !$2  '&(%!  *   !6-  =  .&(6-2  4(%,!  "# $!%!'!$2<'% &5!&( -!,"%,/",& &%'*!<'1!10!3"#5&,,6!

 /(%-? '&(%!B*!<' -&31("# -!,"%;.1& &($<','"

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

$ <'#"4($ ) 0? 435:413($!1( :4132 0" -3!'&$!( '"#.--C$/432"( -!-!/"#=3& 35!, <& -& '#%!

 $"<(<3$'* 43&(6 -!&(5!' &6 &"(2;,.&(6-<'33!' !$($-! '4##!3!$$&'%,"'43!'  !1!( &( -!/3!'!(%!"#&($!/!($!( <& (!''!' 1!'-9-""($** -4$-3?($$1& !$ - -!,"(6<& -43(

-($-$%"11& !$ -!143$!3"#<(:413<& - -!-!,/"#(&3"( 3"$ ;, "#/&((&(6<-!!,($-$ -3"<( -!'1!&(5&,,6!/"($*( /43'4(%!"#$&'%,"'43!'  !1!( "#%%4'!$;,.&(6-2&3"(3"$ ;, "# /&((&(6<-!!,<'3!%"5!3!$*-!5&$!"63/-?"#/,%!"#3!%"5!3?<' $"(!* %%4'!$43( -($<','"33!' !$* 43&(6&(5!' &6 &"(2-! $1& !$ - -!,"(6<& --&'%"%%4'!$;,.&(6--$%"11& !$ -! 143$!3"#<(:413<& - -!-!,/"#(&3"(3"$ ;, "#'/&((&(6 <-!!,($-$ -3"<( -!'1!&(5&,,6!/"($* " - -!%%4'!$<!3!%-36!'-!! !$4($!3.!% &"( 

3!$<& -.!% &"( 2 "<-&%- -!?/,!$!$(" 64&, ?* ('4//"3 "#& '%'!2/3"'!%4 &"(!D1&(!$'1(?'B <& (!''!'2<-!3!'>'"6&($!3.&(6-2:** -"4$-3?2 "-&($!3.&(6- (&<,2(&,:413.-312-&1.&(6-($;!-:413<!3!6&5!(4/ '4((!%!''3?* 43&(6  -!&3  '  !1!(  3!%"3$!$  4($!3  .!% &"(    3** *2 %%4'!$/,!$!$#,'!&1/,&% &"(*-!?'  !$ -  -!?-$("!(1& ? <& -  $!%!'!$*   -!  %"1/,&((  /3 ? <'  =/4 '2 <-!3!'  %%4'!$ 0!,"(6' ",1&;&%"114(& ?*   !6-=($-&' 3!, &5!' <( !$ "

#"3%&0,?  "%%4/?  -!&3  -"4'!*    <(  :413  -$  $&!$  '    3!'4,  "# %"('41/ &"("#!D%!''&5!,&A4"3($0?#,,&(6"(=3& 35!, * &'%'!

"#%%&$!( ,$! -2<-&%--'0!!(%"(5!3 !$&( "-"1&%&$,$! -* # !3-!3&(6 -!%%4'!$/3 ?2/3"'!%4 &"(($6"&(6 -3"46- -!!5&$!(%!2 -!,!3(!$$$& &"(,.!''&"('4$6!210,2#"4($ -!

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

&(6-'  !$ - 0"4 $?'# !3 -!"%%433!(%!2-!-$ ",$ !6-= -  -!%%4'!$ <!3!'!!(0?-&1<-&,! ;&(6<(:413&(5(*-!'&$'  !1!( ' -5!0!!($&'0!,&!5!$0? -!,!3(!$$$& &"(,.!''&"('4$6!210,* -'%"1!$43&(6&(5!' &6 &"( - <(:413<'-0& 4,%"('41!3"# ,&A4"3($-!4'!$ "5&'&  -!" !,"#"6&($!3.&(6-,1"' $&,?#"3 -&' /43/"'!*  (**23"4($E 2<(:413%1! "" !,"# "6&($!3.&(6-<-!3!-!1! ""/ -($2 $(($ 4;!'-2,,3!'&$!

"#.--C$/43($-!<'"##!3!$ !204 &(' !$"# -&'2<(:413 65!'*  ""6&($!3.&(6-#"303&(6&(6,&A4"3*  -! ,&A4"3<' %%"3$&(6,?  03"46- *   $-!?  .-?12  '-1  .&(6-  03" -!3  "#  <( :413 ($<(:413' 3 !$%"('41&(6,&A4"3 &,,+) ($ -!( '-1.&(6-,!#  -!/,%!*  -  &1!2"(!.43&($!3.&(6-23!, &5!"#

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

3&6- %-!!;* * 9%!3 !$<"4($"# -!'&C!"#FD F"( -!3&6- !?!03"< -"3&C"( ,,?/,%!$* *

4, &/,!%"( 4'&"(' "#53?&(6'&C!' "(  -!( !3&"31!$&, '/!% "#,!# ;(!!($,!#  -&6-1!$&,'/!% * *

4, &/,!  '4/!3#&%&,  03'&"('  "#  53?&(6  '&C!'  "(  -!  ,!# 1,,!",4'($,!# #"" * E* .4/!3#&%&,03'&"("# -!'&C!"#FDF"( -!/"' !3&"3'/!% "#3&6- !,0"<($4//!331* B*

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

:

9. 

 

 

 *+*+ '=;'

>-! -!3'/!;&(6 3!'"(!$ ) !' "

>-! -!3!/"3 0,!

) !' "