High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/287/1986dismissed

Ranjit Singh v. M/S Baba Ram Ashok Kumar

2019-02-01Mr. Justice K.Kannan7 pages

##$$ %& '

( )*'+ ",-'+&

&& ".&*",&/0 &"##$$ &% 1"&+/0 &"&

! "#$$% ##$ &*& ! ! &&$!$"& ##$$ !"3"##$ &$+ !"#&#&1 "* 4$$ 5

3" ##$ *1$& '

$ &" *1 !"0 #&"4$$/##$ ! &!" "#&#&1 /"+&" * ''# +& '

$" * #&+&!'/"& &/" ##$ ,# !" &

'# ! &'()&*+ ##$$ "!'$& ##$!

" '!+ #

*1"$& 6& ##$$7'&&0& !" '!+ "&$7'& !& !& & # #& &+ "!&+

$"'!"/& ) "" $$:"##$0

8/":0&/&0:##$ $ "

+; <*$='!"

' 3"& &/&0:##$

& #& ' ##$ & & & : $ +

##$: $* &; <*$"'#&+7'& 0 && / ;!" 7'& : & "& " &0:

##$ +& 3"& &/&0:##$ "& 0 &&8

/: ""##$ &>'&*& "& +& *'

"&: # '$&&& " '!+ "<

":" ##$" +'# & $ $ ?

&0: " 7'&/">'

$::""

& '

4""& #'&" &* &@' &!

" $ $&+"#&#&1:"" '* +& $$ &+"&#&1A 4""& & + (@

+ &@' &!

$+'

0 " & /"& &/ &! $!&+ &>'&*#& &+A + :'$*&>'&* 3$&:"": '* +& $$

>'&1& "'

5 8(5 '*"B/.$#& #&#&1 : +&!! :" " ?

"& !" "&'!" "& #& +&!! 9

/ 8

$ +&!!+ 1 /9(3"& &/ ##$$ !& $$ && 8 >'&1& 0'& "#$

& 0 !&+

/ &$ $

5/(

8 &0 !& + 1 /("&'!"* ,& 3"&!

&@' &! $: @:""!&+ "#&

?: !&""#

:'$* $0&"+ &! $

/ "& !&+ : @' "#$

"# "& '+ /( " ?: """ $&1&0 /(0 + &

"" &0 '&"&#1+

/( 3"'

/ +, ! $ #1+ /( 3" & &! $: @

3" "$$ $0&"#

"#$

&:1

!&+

3"& "&!&+ *: "#& 89

:"& &# #&0'

#1+ /(: , :$!:"$ && !"#&0'

/":0&/ : &@' &! $: @8

3"& &/#$

#'&" +&!!&!" &+?

"& !"+&!! "#&#&1*1 #1 !"+&!!

"#&#&1 :"": #

"+&!!3"#1+ " * #&0

#& &# C@. & "0 ! >'& , :$! " &+# "+&!! $0&1 #

0'& #$

:"& #"#&#&1:"": '* +& +&!!/

$ ' & '

& & !)*'+/#& & "#$

&+ &+ & ! "#

/#$

! &0

$$ !'# " +#& * &"

'* ! && @'" $ &# *$ $

5 9( & '

!"& + 1#/(D+&!! +'

/9( 8

"&! &@' &! $ #&"!&+ $$89

/ *""#& &""

"'*! &&.$

&" "

'*! &&

+0 ##$ * &" '*! &&# !'"" " +#& ;:

,:.$

" # $$1 " ##$ """

*&'!""*$ $

+#& "

'*! &&5 .:" " & + : +*1"

$ "

'*! &&"*""#& &#& *' "& $3"& &/#$

$ $ ' &#&+ '

& & !" &+ & & ! " #

>' "#&#&1:"": '

&+&!!3"'

/: ' :&# !:"

"#& & $+

*1*" "+ :"": &&""&: #&0'

$$ && ""'$ $0&"#

":'$ $0&"#

1 &@' ":& ! :"" " $:'$$ *@' &! &/":0&/

+ &:& & !"#$

$"#& ' & # #& &+ "!&+ $$ E& &$7'& +

" ' "!&'

"" #$

" $1*&'!" 8/( &#1+ 8

:"&

&+ !*$ +'

#1*$: /(;:0&/$& 6& ##$$7'& & !""#$

"*'!""+&!! &!" /"$" $1 9(: #1*$ & !$1#$

9 "0 !"+ 1 " @ "!&+ $$ ":

&1 :$$ !#& &+" #& " & 3" 7'&" "&"$& '

$ &"#& $ !" :""&*$

! "&'!"" '!+ #

*1 *""7'& *$: "&& E& '

$##& ! &"##$$ " '*+" "!&+

#$3" & #&0'

"0$ * + "!&+

'* >' !&+

/"& &/#&0'

$$ & & &>'&* #& &+ &+ "?

7 &/

3" #$

&1 :$$ !#& &+" #& " &; &&" + B'&, & !"/! &17$&, &* B'& !":"" ##& 0 ; " '*+" "#$

" &!"&+"+&!!* &@' &! $ /"& &/&$ # #& &+

"!&+ $$ "'$ *!& ""&" /$& '

$ &"& "

'*+"" '!+ #

*1"6& ##$$7'&

##& 0 "& &&& "+#'!

'!+ 3" $"0* "#&0'

#& '!+ /"& &/ &# &!& " '*+

" $& '

$ " " !&+

" * #$/+1* "" !&+

# !&+ &"&

' & !&+ :"" "0 * :"$

! " / "& &/ $ '& " !&+

"#$ !

:'$ / "

&0: " 7'&/ +#&0" " !&+

& + :""& & #&0'

" "

'!"+$0&"#

: #& " & :&+ :& $?

'"&'+ / '"!&+

$$ " "?

7 &?

" /

'& !&+ :"" "0 * @' & " '

&! $ & '"/ $$ " '&!&+ & $1

' ""&*'$ #& +&

3"& &/

"& "& : 1 &>'&+ #$ !

& +'

'* ' &$& "#&0'

&!& &!'+ "$& '

$""#$

: &1 :$$ ! 8

/+1* "" : $0&#

3"&

& #& " "" &1$0&#

6'&"&/#$

&&1 ! 8/(

"1/:"& *$ #1+ #1*$: 9( "&

'&"& !&+

/ 8

&$0 ?

1 / #&0"" +"

'*! &&"+:"

+: ! !*0&/ $&$1 ":

"" 0& @'" $ $0&#

; /&!'+ $& '

$"#$

&+ : &1 :$$ !/ '

:"' '* @ &!'+ $& '

$/ $"'!" ##& *

&0 & *$'

"*' #&

'* 3"#$

&+"#'&" "+&!!&!" 6&+

## " " +&!! " #$

&+ *+ +&!!/: $ '

"#1+ '

&"+&!! & " + :" "+ $0 ?

'" &'+ / " 6& ##$$7'&" &&$1"$" $1+'

9(: ' #1*$" :"": & 8

C$*& &!'+ "0 * + :" & & 999* " 3&

& .&#&1/ 8 "# $

83" & #&0

$" #'&" &+#$ "0 &!"$ (#&#&1'

'+*&* &@'

$&#'&" & $& "+'

&:"""#&#&1 '

'+*&3"'

/*""#

&0$*$:"" #'&" &

* " + "!&'

"":'$ !"#&#&1'

'+*& &@' $? " " """$ !&+ ?

0:"& /"& !&'

& & !'$& ##$ +

$: &+&$&&

:& 0'&

"##$$ $$"# !+ $$ '

##$

/ 1/& / 0: "*0 '!+ $ $##$ ,

-.+/.+0*1+&2'(340+&* (+5!

+*4

-.+/.+00+1 0/&67+!

+*4