High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/4013/2026allowed

Satnam Singh v. State Of Punjab

2026-04-22Mr. Justice Surya Partap Singh9 pages

!"#"

$% &&

'( &) ) )

"#$%!& '! *! Mr. I.P.S. Sabharwal, DAG, Punjab.

+++++ ) )

* &

(*) *!'!,*-* ('* ) *!#'*-$,. *! $& *!/01!'2 (( *.3*44((* #516 (* ) *!(,'*-$7* (3$ !&**3! !' !

55$ $ 5/'! (&!

**!!'!''&)*(,-$& *!9&:;<;

0=!'&!

*&3$ .&(!

!)*&, && #80=$& *!=;

=/;=8!' & #8=8>& *!?;#8;<;0=!' & #80=# & *!=/$=8!' & #& *!5##!'*&'

& $ & *!=!' *!& $$$- !@# !-*&

*! !3-#* *&

*'-.

*3 ('& 3*3'!

&!$ ( !'

(*&& * !,*3 (* &!', )& !%*$" # 7(! ($ )! $ ! 58 5/ 7( ( 7 ! ) !--*3 $ .

-!37* (!

()!-*&!''*&*-#&,*33* *!!

;5;A ;?55 7* &) $! (,*!'& *'!

*!# (,*&$ ),.

()!-*&) .

&&!$*3 !,!%; $)!-*&!''*& (!&&) !' &72 *3(69 *!(*:$2 *3(B"-6

(,!%; $)!-*&!''*&' ()! $ 7( (&(!' &7&*$! #/5=3 !'2 !*6-!37* ($!7&!%$

* (&!' ()!& *! ) !&!%.!'

,!%;

*!$&! ,$#C** '! -* *7* (3$ !*D$ -*3!'&! ,$#'*-*3!' $'! - !' (&&$7 &!

)- $#$ ('

#' (*% *! 4) /

(,&! $$,.-$&!-'! *! ) *!(-$.''$)!-!3$*&& *!'!,*3*& !$.

'!)*!$!' ! ( 7!.$! ! &&!$*3 !-$ &!-'! *! *-* 4*3)-& *-6)&#!

7 . ()!& *!!-.*E7* (% ,E *$!'$ **3% . !,E *$ (-!,&! $$,.

-$&!-'! *! - (!3( ( (!

(& )$*33* *!#, *-- (,!%;

*!$ (& !

(*37&!%$'!

()!*!!') *!$*-- (,!%;

*!$ (&# *!#7* )-*& $'

* ()

&#! (,*!'$*&-!

!'&!;&&$

(-$

&!-(&! !% $ (,!%;

*!$ 3 &&!$*3 !-$

&!-* () & (&!%.

!'&! ,$#'!

()!*!!' ) *!#&!

7* (* ,* &!

&*-C .$ ('!#7* (! *'.*3 (*3!!'& *!1?

!' & # *!&!

,-3$!,*- ?

(&!$(,)$&'--.

*& (C .!'&! ,$&!%$* () & &!

7* (* ( ,* !' &!

&*- C . ( )*&*)- - $ &!%.!'&!

&*-C .!'&! ,$$ & #-*$ $!7,. !6,-) * (&!'2!($ -* B * %

69A!'-(*:#51AAF*A1= -%

,!% *!$& !6,-) ((-$ 3 !',*-! &&! !'$$-.* *-&!

,*$ !,'

$$& *!;1?

!' ( & #3*% (* ) *%!'& *!/1<;7(*&(*))-*&,- !''&$ (&

(*3$* *-!-% *!( !6,- ) !' $** (&!'2 $-$!

G 3-6#)&*-F% *!9A* *-:!

0<=<!'51$&*$$! / 51$2,* 4(%

!'$*(6#51AA-*A58# E $$ (,'* !',*- (&&$#7(!($,*&& $'! )*!$!'- ! ;1.$ *-7-*4-. 4&!*$,-

(,!%;

*!$,'* (,3*%,.!,%*3 )!-!3$ *&& *!3--. *-*

3* ! )&*!'$ -*3(

3 $$ *&-;!' (A! *!#$*&(* *!# &! *!-)*&*)- !%*$ (

!. ,3!&! *$$

& *!;1?!' ( &

$$* *! !,!%#*& -.)!!&$%$*& * (& !' 2 !( 7

!' A((

*(3( H 6 A* *- ))- !

/001I5=# !6,-) !' $*!,%$ *3!!'

& *!1?!' & 7*--!

,,'!&!*$*3 (&!' &&$'!,*-* &!

7* (&!$* *! ()!& *!7!-$) '!-.&!

)- *!!' *- (,!%;

*!$& !6,- ) !' $*(-$ ))-- 7(!7,*3)!& $'! ,*3*)!*!!'&!

&*-C .!'&!

*&, &#7 -$ '!,*-*%*7!'(*&& *!'!)*!$!'8 ! (

* *--.*!

(&* * (&!'2 $" *- % A -!' % *!695:5AA=)!-!3$*&& *! $*!$* $-.33$

*!!' !6,-) $*#7(*&(&!*$$ (&!& ))!&( !7$,*-#7* ()& %-&

#*&-$*3& *!1? &

( !6,-) A! !' $* E)$ (!)**! & *! /1< !' ( A* *-

!&$A!$#8?1>7(*&(C** -* (&&$ !,-3$! ,*-*' *-*!

&!&-$$7* (*)&*'*$)*!$@7!-$))-.*&( &

(&!'2 *-"(B

!' (6 A* *-))-!

/8!'5= 7* (3$ !&!%.!'&!

&*- C .!'&!

*&, & !6,-) !' $*&&!$$

(,'* !',*- (&&$*%*7!')!-!3$*&& *!'! )*!$!'5.$50 ! (!' (&&$

(* *-,'* (, 4*!

())-* F

+ !

=<88;5= -$2,(* B ,(* "% (

!'G

3-6 $* (&!'2

(!% A($*3(6A* *- ))-!

/0?!'5=

(&!'2 H I(

!'G

3-6F 9A- :!

1!'51# (,'* !',*-(,&&!$$,.

!6,-) !' $* !&&$#7(!7'!$* )!*!!'=,!

-!')($.-#,.!,%*3

;

: *!7*& !$.'!)*!$!'!.$ (

! (J ,: (*% *!* &7&!

)- $&(3;( ($ ,'*-$#, &(37. !,' $J &: (&!&-*!!' *-7!-$ 4!

J$ $: *!($!&* *- &$

%*7 !' ,!% *!$ )%*-*3 '& !# * ( , !,%$,. !6,-) !' $* (*, *- &!

)-*&!'& *!;1?!' &

* *--.#* (&!'2$--!$-B,(.!$-I (

!'G 3-6F 9A-:!

?00I51# !6,-) A! !' $*''!$$ (,'* !',*- (&&$#7(!7'!$* )!*!!'5#555 -!'&!$*)(!)( #$7*& !$.'!)*!$ !'!$(-'.#,.&!*$*3 &!&-*!!' *-7!-$ 4-!3

If the facts and circumstances of the present case are analyzed in the light of above-mentioned principles of law, it transpires that:- *:

*!(-$.''$)!-!3$*&& *!'! ,*3*& !$.'!)*!$!' ! ( 7!.$!

! (J

**:

(*% *!* (*&*-$.&!

)- #$!

(*3 (,-'

!,&!%$'!

()!*!!') *!J ***:

*-*!

-*4-. !,&!&-$$*' #!

7 . ( )!& *! 7* # % . ! , E *$J *%:

*-*!

-*4-. !,&!&-$$*' J %:

($ *!!') *!* $*&*--!&4;)*!

-*4-. %.'-))!J %*:

(*!

(*3!&!$ !(!7 *'-$!,*-# ) *! .

) 7* ( ( %*$& ! *'-& 7* J %**:

(*!

(*3!&!$ !(!7 *'-$!,*-# ) *!7*--!

&!;!) I) *&*) * *-

() &# ()*&*)-!'-7-*$$!7,. !6,- ) !' $** (&!'2 %

$( $!

(6#950:1AA#-% #7(** (,!,%$

K '$ - )! - !' &* *- *)$&* ( ) ) *!!'

*!&&# *3 (,. )!*,-*%$ !,*!& *-'!$ 3*- .

!7%# (* &*!&* *--77(%! (,)-&$!&&$7* (3$ !!

)&*'*&!''&, * !

(

$$!!

$ & '!

('$ -)! - *)&

!'!

(!''& L !

(* )! '& !'!&* *- *)$&*

(3 !',*-* (3--$)

*3)!* *-!* )*!!*&!& *!(!

97(*&(%E)*!! .7*( !:* E&) *! '! -.#!

!' (,*&)*&*)-)) !(% ,-! *3( !'7* ( (- !$ !)!,*3 *&& $$'!-!3)*!$ (*$!!

$!.3!!$ !!&* *- *)$&! !!!&* .

(*!$!, (3 !$*-!'

, ,*-* *-. ($*& *!!' ( $3&!*$*3&, %!# E&*!' $*&*-$*& *!(,&*& &*,$,.-3 ,!'

$&**!$$,. (*A! $,.%. *3(A! * (&! .

L # !&&*!--. (*&* . !* !)& 7( ($.*3,*- ! &&$)!* (*3( (*3 !$!! ('& $* (&*& &!'

()*&*)--*$$!7,. !6,- () $** (&!'2 $" *- A -!' % *! $ !

(6 95: 5 AA =# -! -% * (* & ,!% *!$&#* (,!,%$ K ( !'&!%*& *!* &* *-&* $**,. --.-!7 )) ! (*'& !7*3( ! *$!' (A! 7(*-$&*$*3 (,*-))-*& *!*3 *% A! $ (*4 ()!*,*-* .!'&!%*& *!,*3 * .#,*-))-*& *!7*--(% !,$&*$$ *& -.#&! . !-3- )*&*)- G&!

*E)&!*$ *!!',*-))-*& *!#7(*&(*!

)* *%* 7* ( !')!*,-$ $*& *!,.7.!' *- &! .#-

&C*

-7* (&! *$& !$.7!-$,&!'3% * *&M

& -.# * ( & !' 2) " -*

A((

*3(6#5=AA-*A1# !6,-) !' $* (!,%$ K*'&&$* !3 '*-%$*& '

*&& *!!'

*E !%.* *-$ *-)*!# (#$'** -.#* &!-$, *$ (**3( !(%)$. *-$ *&-!' (A! *! (,*'*3$M (-!,!,%$,. !6,-)

!' $** (,!% *!$& K$-.,$'! (&&$$

- E -.,$'! (%*& #'! $*!&* .$'! (&$*,*-* .!'! *&. #7(*&(*%-$ $3 !' (*A! !!

(A* *- !&$A!$)!%*$ . !!-'! ($3 !* !$ ! &)!&$''*&* -.M

!-&*$ ' (# (*A! *&!&*!!' (,*&$ '$ -)*&*)-!'-7 *3( !)$. *-*) !'!,-# '*$ )!&$(*$$ *&-!' (A! *!!' $*

(*&! *!-*3( &!

,$*$ (&&$ $ $,.

!6,-)E&! *K-7*$*3(%

!' ,$!

(M# 5/AA-*A/1=/

' ( & - *% ''& !' -- ( ,!% *!$ '& !# *%!-%$* (* &#* 4* !&!*$ *!#* -$ !&!&-*!

*!* -$'! (,'* !',*-#$ () ) *! $% !,--!7$

&&!$*3-.#7* (! &!

*3.

(*3! * !' &# () ) *!*(,...

() *!*(,.!$$ ,-$!,*-!'*(*3)!-,!$$ .,!$9: *'& *!!'-$ *-A!

!7% (,!%*$&!&*!(--, , & !'!--!7*3&!$* *! ;

9*:

( ) *! (-- !

$*& -. ! *$*& -. 4 .

*$& # ( !)!

* !.)!&C* $7* ( '& !' (&#! !$*$(* !$*&-!&('& A! ! !.!

( (!* .

9**: *!(-- !'E& *!!',!$#'*(

($$ (A! &!&$$(--!

*'. (&(3* $$ *-A! # *-- ('*-$&**!!' *-J$

9***: *!(--!

-% $*7* (! )*!) **! !' *-A!

1) )

G( ()4*3I!$LI!

G( ()! ,- LI!