← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/4195/2002allowed

Bajinder Singh v. State Of Haryana

2015-05-27Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal9 pages

 

    

 

  ! "#$ %&' () "* +, "-. "* +! /00 1! ,

 +% "+ /

!0"*  $#  23$  ,$$, 44 

#4 $+ +5 !.$ "6) '*7

 + ! $+ .

+% '' +% 44   0+   +!

( .

! 8

" 0+ ++ +* *8% **( !

6*-

" 0

7 * )6*-:

*

*6-6!

;' *

+: " "- :6"

:0

"0 % 8( + "*

"*  + ! : ( +(%  +6:!

* ( "* 9"

+! 9. . 9

*7 * "

"*

*$ +.';6"* +,

" 3 <6 !

" '='+!.+ >  2  ,

' 7 *  !

* "

 ( "* " "6

!1 (( ! - "'$ ( 5 -+ ?.

+  -+ ?.

+ 

 +068( 06+0!

  +* (0:

"*6 ( @

"( !+ ! *

(' "*6!

( "*::

(

+,

+'

" 0



+ "! *  8)

"! " +*  9 . ( 9' ,

7 +":

7 * !68!

<6 "

"6"* +,

"A  *

* $ +. '  *

 ( "* 9 ! "

* * + + 06+0!

  .

 3 "* <6 !

" ((

+ +* * :0

" +

 *   +

! + .

. '  "  "*  + $6:5 " " *  7 (( !((9!#4 ,  1 (( ? "*3

B0 C  - .

. 

!A''D4  $ ( 5 -+ ?.

+  .

. 

!''D4 " 

!;''D4 +$6:5 "

!'&'D4 ;

-+ ?.

+  .

. 

!''D4 " 

!;''D4 +$6:5 "

!'&'D4 ("-9 . +( "*9"

+!'* !!

! *9

+*  ( * 8)

"! 9. . 9   "

((% *  * * 8%  ** "

(  !

6*-

" 0

'7 * )6*-:

*

*6-6!

;'6"* +,

=  .

9

"*:0

" "*9

!&=D40 +!<% +*" ** :6"

!4( "*9"

+!9 (!.

(*

! !" 6"

!

0(

!.

!9 (! - 7 " 8   !(

6:

 +

  ;E ("-9 .  + !

+% !6"* +,

"!;B4C;BC "*=  

 . !

( ("-9 . 

(!  9"

+!  60 + "! *

"8 +  +* "

  ". . ! 6+  

) !.  "* (' 7 * +* +*

8+6 +%;' :

+5

!A0 +!<% +*!+ +* "- "*9 ((!

+%8 "

(  ! 9 (! * !0!

*  "  ( -.

)6*-:

 "

&&=' ()

, "-.1!,

 +%  +!'*  * *"

8+6 +%;' !  (  + 9 00(

" ( : "-

 "

6"

  8"

 *  : !

  * !0!

(  86".   "

8+6 +% ;' '  ( :  ! +  :0

" "

6"

! !

"* "- "  ( * 6(* "  8 

(% +!6 * .6-. ".

:0

"+ +* "-

!.

"( *" ! !

"+ 0+ F .

!

*+ 9

00(

"9 ((9 *7 * +* +*

*6(%' +* +*

8+6 +%;'9 !+

*8%+ + "-

(

!+ - "

("6:8 + 00(

"+"*"

"* %A=* %!9 (! ((9 * .

.

+*(

+"

*6"!

(+ "*6"!

(+

!0"* 6((%-"

.+6-. +* : 0 " "

+ 06+0!

*

+: "

":

+5

*'

! !7 *8% !!:

:

+5

  ( "* :

*  "

  &&=  4  ()

 , "-. 1! ,

 +% " +'*  * *"

8+6 +%;'.

:

+5



*( "*.

8 *

+: "

!A0 +!<% +*!9

((!

+%8 " ,   ( :  ! + ".

:0

"++6

F !

"-" "* !"

+"

*'

! .

 + * 60" + 0+  F  0+ * 8% ?

+ , "-.  (('  %  +

+' + 6(

*'  +%     .

 +6

! +  06+0!

  :0

! 0 + 8 !  0+ " 0( "*:

.*!( **9"8%+?G *.9  " 7 +":

068(

"  ,

   +% ' 0%  9. . .

! 8

" 0(

* " +* !F 4?

+, "-. ((.

!*

+: "

"* "-" "*+;A

!

.'A

!6 '

!

"*"

 :6".

"+ 0+

*! !((9!#4 H3 3   , 13     ,    ,' $,G  ,  $ 3 ,'133 ? B  C 

 !""# $% &'#( # ) *)( +, -#.!"

% B C

"!

!D4 B C %6

!D4 B C  -- "- "* (( "-0

!D4 B 7C

$ "6+

 * ! "0 !

!D4 B7C !

  0( !' 0( "- "(6* "-

!D4

"!0+

 3#

!D4 /  )"$.'+, ((0#** 1(

 B8C "4

6++ "-!

# B C

* "- "* "-

!D4 B C ++ -

!D4 B C $ "6+ ! I

( @ +! "(6* "-

!D4

"!0+

B 7C

+

!D4 B7C ! "$ 5 "-

!D4 B7 C ,60 +7 ! "

!D4  3#

!D4 !9 (( "+

+%%

+9 . "+

 "! @

!9 ((8 !D4 ! 1 "4+ 6++ "- F0 "*  J- +6

K F0 "*  0 %

+

!D4 J%

+! K !L !D4

!F;A L'D4

!FA L'D4

!F L'D4  :6"

!F 4D4  3

!'D4 ! 7 9 (( "+

9  "+

 " 7

"+6

!0 +:6( 0+ *8%,.+  +8 "! , "-.'F4:: !! "

+'+ 6( '7 +":

"* **9"8%

"0+ " 0( "*:

.*5.

!+ "

3 "

4

 $ )"$ * ,," + 7.(. ". & .* # 4   .' "!#. ,* .(

"!#. 1"# $ 1"# $ )"$

"!#.,"

" 4

"!#. 1"# $ ,* . *# *# 6#*- 8$ ,* .( ,* .( # 5"(   9    : +++:  ; ' 3     (2 

3<

 :!) 3  

 (2 

 ;"     < (2 =

 4!

 3 

( ==

&/&7%

3< +* "- +:6( **9"8%,.+  +8 "!, "-.'E

" !

 +6  8

! !  8  - 7  9"

+

6!

:6"

 !- 7 " "(6:0!6:' 6 "*  !!

00 *'

 " . ! :6"

+6 !' ((  

+! "

+ 86

 + *6

:6"

D . E!

:

!6"* +#4 A''&D4FMLA'&'D4 . !- +* " !"

 "*-*:

+5

+ +* "-

+:6( E0+ : 6:" 

(!

 !- 7 9"

+ E0+ : 6:" 

(!

LA''&FDL';'==D4 >7?7>& ::  +6   00+F 9 -.



(



(

0( 6 (0

-.

<6 "

( ":

!C !C

;A  ;A D4 ;A'D4

< A  A D4 AD4

   D4 D4  :6"    D4 'D4  3# ;='AD4 ;;/@&&/&79/; &/ //A / &B:  !!

!!:

I7

" +6

!# !A&D4  E0+ : 6:+6

!*6 # !;==D4

+"

!! :

+5

;

(7 +6 0(

+8

# !;=AD4  3 # !='='=D4 !0 +:6( 

(:

!6"* +#4 !  1 J B  + " "- F ":

 0 + F J (1 

+ "-%

+! M%

D4 JA''&F M J (1 D4 JA'&' J;=AD4 J;==BEC

!''&&=D4 ! "

 3 ! + % 9 .6!

"* !

" .6"*+ "* !

% -.

"(%CN .

-"

.+6-. 0+  ""

! 0+ " 0( "F .

3 "*<6 !

"((

+ 5 "

"! *



"* +6

+* * "(% !6:  ! ( :0

"+0(

"*+6

!8!

+7 "-

,.?

+, "-.  (( 8 "- +

* .+ 6(  .

* - 7 --

* + 0+   .

= ,

 6"!

(.

!"

8( !

!% . ! 6+  .9  + 0+ F  0+ * 8% ?

+ , "-.  (( ! "  " "!"

 9

+! ( * *9" +

"   +6

! 8%  7 +":

7 * 0( %F   .

 -"

.+6-.  !

G ?

+ , "-.  ((

"* . ! +!!4 : "

"   ! + * 8 ( % 6(* "  8  :0

* ,

G?

+, "-. (( !++8+

*8%!

G

:0 (, "-.' 9..

(!

8( !.

!.

0(

*+.

+* "*+6

!" "*9. ..

*8

* ,

.

*0+*6 * +

:' G'6" +"- "

+'+ 6( 9. ". !+!!4 : "

".

!!0 ((% *:

.

.

!- :+

 " 0( "*" +6 !8

! *:

.

*"  "- +* " "7 9 87 * !6!! "' : 0 " "

0+ F  !! "- +6

!

.'

"*  :6" * +7  8  8 * 8 "- " "!"

 9 "

"*-6 * ( "

! ,

.

.6!.

(*

:0

"+ +6

!" *(

!''&&=D4.

"

6+ *

+: " "-

:0

"+ +6

+ "-0(

! ! ! ".

!''&&=D4 " ** :6"

:0

!*

+: "

* "

&&='*  * *"

8+6 +%;' 

!AD40 +!<% +*!9 ((!

+%8 "



( ! ((9 *.

.

(*

O C :0

"+ *(

!AD4 +!<% +*!9 ((!

+%8 !6"* +,

"!; B4C';BC "*,

"=  P C " ** 87  !

* :0

"'

!9 ((8

:0

"  +6

!6"* +,

";BC!

"*(%

9. . ! !'&'=D4 $ %&' B$$,C !

") %