R.P. Mehra v. Dheeraj Dembla And ORS





    

 

  !"# $%&        !"#$%  '"

& ("! '")*+

'"

,

%'(  )*% + +
*
+
** &"

"

 ' -!*"$.

  "

"

/!

'!00"$.

  "",

 *
+
**  ,   2'  ,  '  +   ' 3 3  )!

3*

%   , 
 !

3 !

 " $&4 4)!

3*



5 , .

 "

3$.,, !

' " #$



" "$&4

6"  

  "#   "   )!

   '    " 

",

7

 , !

"/

8  '9"# :"+ 

"  

;

.

$%80 3

"

",





8" * * ,"* "

' ! ! &4 

,

+# '",

7

,!

4 "3 # 4

+# 

=4

4,!"

' '",

7

 "3 "     ,

7/#

0 ',"*

 3"*

   =

4> + 4 '," ! 4 "

=4

 /#

0 /0"  '" !3'   6"

'  3" '" ,"

2'' !4"

 !

# ","  

*

' 2',"

"4 " "" " */0"+!

'

!

"  * ,"*

 '*  " >,"# ,"



=4 , 4# 2'' ! ,!

4 '" +#' 
'

" ' $ 

" '

!3'

"? ?

4/*

.' 4 <

" ' @!'" 2'," ,"

#4   ",

7

   4,

4" """ "

 " "$",

 ">  ' 3 *""

'"@!"  "' 4

," +   ,

 * +" 3 *' !

",!"$&4 34 '' '"

/ ' !4

+ '  '" ",

 4!"

'",

",

' '" " 2'' ! 4

! 

 '

"*# =3

4" !,

+!

'#

'

 "

,   '"4 '"

,

A"

  *

 4    +'    /#

  6 0$ 3  4 '6"

' /0" 0 3

',"

"    ' 

  '   ,"*  

'# 4" # *,

2',"

" ," 4"

 *

4' 3   * "  ,"

!"   "@!" !

" ' 4" 

"

 " "$

4 * +," ,"

"' " !"

4 **"

+! 3 '" 6  ,"    #   '  

 4  ,!

 4'   3 

' "  ',"* @! 

,!"

' 

'," ,"

#, ! 

!" 4!"

'", ',"

" '"4

',"* ,!



%%

',"  , ,

7/#

0'

4 '

#  '"

,"* &" ! 4 "

=43

' "#3"  ,!

 '"?,

9 ! >



" '"34"$ '!$+ 3, +#'* .!*  * " 
8 0'4 ,

" ' ,"*

B!"

'"* "$

=4 ' !" ',"

" ' 4 ! *,  '* '>

 + !


80' !

'," 

.

'* *$ 4 

4 !

!  ,"  3 '  4 "', @! ',"* 

,!

$ ',"

"4 !

, '*

*  4,"#  "

B  4 3!4""* 



" "?

 A' '" "

 " "  "

"  

4 '"3"

'' !,"#  "C&&  A' '" '! "

*

 +C& A' '" +  "*) 

" !

"# ,"

C&  A' '" ',

'3  !

  ,"

! C& A' '"  ,, +#' 4

" * ',"

C&

A' '" "' ! 

 ,"

! C&   ;

4 +#+ ',"

 ="





" "

!

'3"*

4   

 >  + 4  

 =  4  

 /#

  6



'" !3'  3" '" 2'3"*

4

> +#  '" ',"  , #;

"" *

* ,"*  4  "

" '+   ' ,"  +  

 #    '  

 .,,    +#  '  ,"

 , "  4

* .,, .!

' " #$&4 )!

3*



5  .33" '"" *$,"

'+ 

="

 " "!+*  ',"*

@! 4"4 "



'#"%% !"

'"

!+*

  '!+@!

3"*

  4

"

+ 4 '," !

/#

0$ !



' !  ',"

"

'"

 " "$ '" 

?

*,

 /

88 9"# :"+ 

"  

;

.

$%8 B!"

'"* "$

 ,"  ' ," +   9'

+ 3   ," ,"

# 4' '' ' 4 "

,    2'

' *

' '+!  ," ,"

 $ '!$,"#

', + 4

="

 "",

4'"!

'+   "*

!+* 

!""



3 

'+ !"

+#+ !"

+ 4 ," ,",,"   

" $4'

 " #

""

+# '
!"

9"

$"

 " ',"



'3 '" !3'

'4 '"+

="

 " "'

" # +)

" ' 3 '

!* ",

+

 

,!

,"* ;> &. '3"*

    ,,"

' 3"*

'+ > + 4 

= 4

/#

0 '" !3'  3"  '" & "$  '"4' ,  3A ' " >* '

"*

'3"*

4> +#'* +'  '/#

/0"6"

'

'3 ;> &. , #  3" /#

6 0$ '" "$  ""

#

!

!"

+ 4

'3"*

4

> ',"

" '," 

, 2'!$  "4

," " '>  

' ;> &. ',"  , # 

+,"!*

',"

"' > ;> &. ',"  , "# + !;>  '"

*#'+ >

  %% "," '"#"$

+' '

!

+

' ,"* ',"  , # ,", ! #

 ">  ;> &.    +'  '/#

6 0 ' , #  3"

2'"4

"@!"*

 

" 3"'

   '," !

D

4

!4 "

',"  , 2'  ?

  "3"*

 '' !+#

=4  '," !

 ',"

"$4' ' !3'

 ," 

#*

" "4 ' #"3'

!

, 

 ."3!*

!"3 +#"

 " "

"@!"*

 /

88  '.

'

+ *, 4 '

/

8  '.

" !

"?

E8  .  

 *# ,,#  ' 

" "   "    "

"

,!

,  ?

  "

+! 3$$??

'"@!"  "' 4

!, $

!,#

'""

+! 3 '!"+ "

'

 !

'+! 34 ' !

! 

! "

**

*

'%%.

' !"+ "FG =

', ', !

"?

2'  " ' $ "3 *""

"@!" " "' 4

," +  "  '*4 ''4  ,"

*

'" ","

#" 3

*' ! !

",!" '$&4 2'

' ! 4 +#' '"

2'"" '" "  2' ' !

! 

 " '

"*#  2', "4

'," "

 34 ''4 '' !  "

" *



, 

'"* # '*# 2', "

' 3

'"' ! ',   " '+ """ ,!", 

'!"+ " &4

'

3  '"

!

'' ! " **

*

 %%.

2'!$ ",

"+ +

" *

,"  !

"/

88  '9"# :"+



"  

;

$.

$%8 ="

 " "'"3!

'  * # *

' '+!  ," ,"

 3+!

'

"   '"," ,"

#4' ''*#+ "  4!"

'" " ' ! '4 "

D'

 D



*

D'

3  D$ '" "$ '" +

 ,  , '

4' '! 

?!

2'"3!*

 "#  !$!

+$'

")

& 3  '",

7

*

,"   ,

","

+  

+" 0!

'

","

 " "



,," 3&A '  ;> &AH.,  # , 

' 

' #' ! '!

," &44' '

!'"@!"*

!"

'"*



* 3

 "

  '.

%%$''

 #!

',"* &A' " ' " >* ' 3 '' !

",!"  ' 34 '',"



4 9  '"">" * '' !4' "# '"" # 4 " * '3" !

 "

" * '"  "

9!"

'"  '

+  '3" !

 '," +   #+!

# "

' '

,  '"   ="

,, !

' " #' """ " !)!

3*

  '
!"

!

 

 , ' 3" 

 /

88+!

 



$

?, 3  ' 3" 

4 !

+  4""

*    ,,   "  )

*

 <    "

  "4"#*!

' '!

2'" !

'



, 3 

4"

""

" '4

!,  " ' 4 "  '"," ,"

# "'

  !

'  ," ,"

#$  4' '  4 !  +    3" !

  " 

?! 3 

&" +   # 

 !#," 

"

2' '" "  '",



' 3+ *""



"

" *'  !3'

+!"3

 # *""  " 34 '"",

, !H*4 ! + *



2'" "$ '" "* # ' 

3  !"

+ 4  <    "

  ' 9 D+  /!,"*
!"

 

-./0  /1.2  1310/  *2/-  1.  40501  +65

 # !

&7+8"

 4'>* ' , " )!"

" "  , 4"

* $,!"

3 

!



 ,""

 ,,  ' 

' !

+

"" 4 '

,  # +"
2'

 "  ">* '

+# 93' 
!"

   "   )!"

 !

"  '  .

  

  

 !

 

3   

  "  +#
!"

H.!

' " #+ 4

4



!"

" *   #  "" "    4  .  

3    

 "  +#
!"

H.!

' " #  + 4$    ,""  "  '  +  ""  

4 ' !

 " '* "

 "!

'

+ 

 "*" 3  '

 " 3" #""

 ! $ 4 

$ 4 ! "!

3" * ""3 )! $ , ""

+ ! 

" 

3

4 

$ 93'
!"

>"

  " )!"

!

" + 



" .

'+

   *,!3  "

"+

3 "," ,"

2'93'
!"



  #  ""

 "3 # "," ,"    " "

"*,!3 + " 

+ 

9 4"$  #  '"3!" #$ ""

$3 "," ," #  '*,!3   " ' "

"$ '93'

!"

'

>"

 , 4" ,, , 4"

",,"   ""? '

 " *  "





 , 4"

+@!

4 ', 4" "

 "  @!  



!"

 " ,,  ="

 " "!

+ , 

 !

3 #$   "* #  "  "" "    4   '  *,!3 )!

3*

%   , 
 !

3 !

 " $&4 4)!

3*



5 , .

 "

3$.,, !

' " #$



" "$&4$ 4'  "

%

""

 >"

 " )!"

+# '
!"

'""3!*

'+ "

 &"

$

3#$ *

#*0& !"#$%













.-6 A' '",0 3H" IH

A' '"", "

+ IH