(O&M)Chief General Manager, Telecom Departmen v. R.P. Garg
!" #$% &' ()$&* +, - .. /&$&&0/,(12&/'1',13&&#'./ ''/ 4/5
&/0 26'
! "#$%&!&%'
/') $/ 7.51&,6(&', /'.2''/ $/ &8.52'&,6(&', /'./26' 99999 &%' ("
.2/'/2''6/('6&0&''./6/6&'6 + ! ! '.66'&'/('560, &/6&3&6,:./3*'.&22& '. /26';2&' 56/ 7(' !< '. /3'/&' &6 (&'(', -- " /./', -- ('%,.&3&:6 .3/ &(' '.(&&/'.&'/26';('/&('/50.' '.&/3'/&'&0&''.2''/56/7('<"% '.6& 0/&2.('3* 0&&22(&'3 /'.5/', &/6&3&6 + ,'.1&''/:&/ //6''./3'/&'/'/&('/ 6(&1 2''(&10'/'=+>2/&51 /1! ? --?&6&&'
'.&1/&' /1'.6&' 2/'&' '.(&1'2&*1'. /3'/&'/,6&:&/66&'6 ? ! ,&:6(/'&(&1,35'66 '.(&1 './26' /'/': 53;(&5"% &5
'.&0/1'(&1 /'0&'@2:&616.
('/&('/ 50.' @(5' '. & /1'6 &:&/6 &6 & 15'&5* 6'.3A('B5&;0/&' '/'&6& 6 &&22(&'56/7('!
-- (''.260@(5' &22(&'(&10'/' /1'.6&' &:&/6'2&*1' '. &15'46/6/6&'6 ,'.3A(':/616&6 <
,@(5'&22(&':&6166 &5' '&0&' /6/6&'6 ,('/&('/ 6&&22&:.(..&//5* 3&:6&6'/'.&3&:&/66 $/ 7.51&, &/6 (5 / '. 2''/ 531''6'.&'&2/53;(&5"% &5 '.'/1 '.('/&('
5&13055*&66:'.&''/':5632&*&3'.&/' 1*/(5/'*&15'&*&15'2&*&3''.('/&('/56/ '.('/&(',35''.66'/('560 &6'/ /''.&1&6 /652(/'&(&&:: '.&''A5601'/6/63* C3'.752/15/'")*+),)- .)/ /0 ")/-+ 12- /3+./ +4+1%-+ 50+ 3 *6 / +* +)/ & 0) /0
% 3/-+ 12-/3+./ +( 7 +8 ( :./'.'/ 2/5(&&::'./0&/6''.2&*1' '/'/6/6 -)+)/
)5!./+.) 6/04+19 8 :;)8 6/0( $ <=( 68.) /+1./ 4+1# & 0)( <>$ &6 $/)/ #//)+?+)0-4+1 )+--) 0+)) 0 6*) 5( 777 $ .& 3 (6/6 &6 ' .& 3 .6 '.&' '. & /1'6:.&3/6/6:.(6/0&'.(&&: 2/'&0'0/&' '/''.2&*1' '.'/'2'&:&/6.& 3 6(6 . 2/ 7(' ! "<% -- (', 5(.
(/(51'&(,:56'&22*&'6'36'.2&/'
/('/&,$/ &8.52'&,&/6(5/2/'0'. /26'531''6'.&': '.&:&66:3*C3'. 752/15/') .1 ?+ 01./ 6/04+1)
)/1+)9) +* +)/ 6/0( =7$ ('.2:/ '. /3'/&'/'&:&/626'''/'.&3.6'3&6,'.50.' :&&(&2/'&0'&625'&/ /1 -+ (' @ 50+ 1/ 2#A /0 4+19 + +($/)/ ++)%-+ 12--!
2 +( $=7(@2/D51E &:&/66(563(566&2/(2&&15'&65(.'/'&'. /3'/&/35&61 '@2/D51E56&5"3% 7(' !
"<%'3('/56'(&//*'/'= ?> /'.2'&:&/62/6 $/)/ )+5) ) ) 0 + 4+1 $
+ +) ) 6*) 5( & $1*+6 1+/ ( '. 5/' '(0 '. 2/ 7('!
"<%.6'.&''.(2 &:&/602/;&:&/6 '/'&:&*53A('''/1 '.('/&(',35' /2'&:&/6'. ('/&('.&&22(&'./35&.&6(/''2( *'./&' &6'.&3( '.&1,/&' ?>:56&22*$/52'&.&& ('6'.A5601'# & 0)4+1$)+)B)/%+)0 22 .5 ) 0 + (& $$1**=7
.&.&/6&/6(5 /2&/'&6&22/&6'.2&2/ 38 ':563&2''/2/65(53;(&5"% &5 '. ('/&(':.(./&6'.5);
D
/1'.2&&612&05&0 '.'/1 '.('/&(',
> '/&6'.&''.('/&('/.&'3''6''/''. &/'1*/(5/'*&6&:&&*'./&15'2&*&3'.1 . &(',&'(6&3,,'.61&6/&63 /'. /3'/&'/,2&0 &:&/6&6&((2'&( '.(&1&/'625' .B5''326/6:.'./: '.@2/63&/ ; ''1' '/'&'./3'/&/35&6/6'2:/'&:&/6 '.2'&:&/6'/': '.&:&66: @ $
+ +) ) 0 6*) .) 1*+) . C3 752/1 5/' :. ('/50'.2/ (&5"3% 7('! "<% '. -- (', .6'.&''./3'/&/35&(&2&('&'6 /1&:&/60'/',, 2'&:&/6 00 './50. '. &(' &6 (/(51'&( '. & /1'6(&,'/&6'.&''./:&5(.(&5'. ('/&('63&//02&*1' '.('/&('/.'./A5601'/6 52 3* $/ 52'& 2/'&6 ' 1 2/2' (560 50+ 1/ 2 #A /0 1*+), 35' & B5' &/ ")*+),)- .)/ /0
.)1*+)(:./3*&22*0'./5 C3 '. 752/1 5/' 56 '.&' ( '. '/1 '. ('/&('2/.3''.''1' '/','.&1(&'3&:&/66' :563&2''/2/65(&5 &6
'.('/&('00/'& 625');
! "!
#
" ! '/'./&.05' '.'/(&&:, &/& <, ?, - &6,':&((566&56/);
#$% & ! ' (
!)
# *
#+#,#+# *)'- ) !
.
#/
"
' #0%
!1
2 3 4
)'-
5 6& " )'-! 37. % #8
) '-! 37 % "
*! 94 ) '-! 37 % "
!
'
' #0, & : ;
. &
5 6#$)
. <2 ! ' = >7#000%#.8?@ # 0 )
57. 8$ 0% # 0 A
*!
*! 9 BB"
! ) " C ; 57. 8$ # % # & " *! *! BB
< 9 B B" !)
D !E
*! ! *! !
*!) "
! ! *! ( ;
!
7
% #/ ' >7#000%#.8?@ ! # 0 '! ! "
)
*! F
*! #0G *# 0
!
=
BB BB " !) *# 0 ' >7#000%#.8?@
++%) ' )
.(515&'/&60 '.& /1'6/&'&6/*0 52(6' '.('/&('.&6360 (''.2&/',:.(. (&'3&6'3;@'((& '.625','./6/ '. F:/22&'5/'&:&/60'/'2'&:&/6:.* &&(5 &60&.&1./3*';&6
2'''&6&:6 )5>( 7 &%' +)6- "#39!
'-/-+*), 2@+) 0 C@
'-/-+* +/)8
C@