High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3027/1986disposed of

M/S Ansal Properties v. Chandgi Ram

2015-07-20Mr. Justice Rajiv Narain Raina4 pages

"#$%#& '

(!) * %+,,-"."#/

!"#$"%$&'%"$!(%)% ##$ % *$"'

+,-%+"',++)%+$"

$#$% / 01 '

2,.,#+/ ""+./(0%$ "%+$##$ % $#$% -$ 1 !"$-2+"$+1-) #$" "$#"$$%$31"%"/(0%$ "'+",,"4 /(0%$

""$#$% %

4) 1*

%+$" "$5'$% $"$0'$ "%+$#"%$/ "% /

/4+0+% %$ "%1/%6$'# "

+$", !

7+## 0%'$" "$"

' $"$4%+$0% !+3$$ $3$+ ## 0%"%4+"$#$% (

"#$"-%0-#"-$3$+ -""$#$% -$ 1 '-% -!"6+ &%+3$$-$%$%+$## 0%%+%"$"% "$ ($$%% $%+$#'%$-03 1/%+$) # %

+,-+($ ""($%0-#"-$' 1,$31##$ % $ $%

) % "$#$% # %

+, - 0$ $0$$ $ %+$ ) "$#$% -$ 1 '-% 8"$#$% 9-"4+3$,"$#"$$%$%+"',++-%+$"-% "%/4++%'" ,'"+$+,%%$"$%($"$%%+$ %$"$% -" %+$ "$#$% 4+ "$ #"%1 % %+ 0-#"-$0 ',-"+($3$$0-#$%$$5'%$ 1:1 41 %+0-#"-$/ ,#"%"0%$ %,%0-,%$ '$ ' #'"#$4' 3$$"($% 310%',%+$#"0$$, %%##$ /0$%+$-%%$"#'%$+3$$$%% $-03 1 3$%4$$%+$#"%$7+## 0%'##"%$31' 14"

(% -%"%8"$#$% ( 944 -!"6+/%+$-%+$"

%'" ,'" -""$#$%'-%8"$#$% 9 7+'"%% $%+%%+0-#"-$% ($"$%%+$%$"$% %+$-"'-%4+"$#$% %+$%$"$% ;'%0$/%+%00$#%$%+$## 0%

"$#$% ( "% #$"-%%$ % 0-#"-$ %+$ -%%$" 3$+ -"'-%4+"$#$% %#$ 00", 1

7+## 0%'$" "$" ' $ "$ 4%+$0%!+3$$ $31%+$0'$ "%+$##$ % "

$0,%+$-##$ 3$%4$$%+$#"%$%+$3 0-#"-$ &% + 3$$ -$%$ %+$ ## 0% %+% %+$ 3($ #$,3$ "$%+'"%,%%+$;',-$% $0"$$%$#$31%+$'"% $"$% <%"0%

.',$/='",($4+0+%+$##$ 4 4$<'",%+$#$$01 %+$##$ /%+$#"%$%%+$##$ +($$%% $%+$-%%$"3141

0-#"-$$#"%$4"%%$0-#"-$$$"$%%$%+($3$$ $>$0'%$3$%4$$%+$##$ %%+$ $, +$" 0%$%,# %

"$#$% $#$% %%$ % 3$ #" "- "$#$%&% 14"%%$0-#"-$%$ $>'"$

4$>$0'%$3$%4$$%+$##$ % $ $%"$#$% % $-2+"$/'-% -"

/"%44 - !"6+ +"

<$( 44 +, - 0#1 %+ 0-#"-$ 4 3"',+% "$0" %+ ##$ , 4%+

7+$$#"%$4"%%$$$ 0-#"-$%$

$>'"$ + 3$$ $>$0'%$ 3$%4$$ %+$ ##$ %

$ $%%+$"$-,) $0$$+,--$ 1 !"$-2+"$8"$#$% 9+1-) 8"$#$% 9

(% !"$-2+"$+1-) "$ $>$4%+ %+%+$"$31-%%,%+0-#"-$4%'3-%%$%+% %+$#"%$%%+$ +($0-#"-$ %+$#'%$##$ %+$"$'"((,#'%$#$, %$"%+$$>$0'% %+$ 0-#"-$ $$ $>'"$

$>'"$ #$" %+ 0-#"-$/%+$ #'%$4 "$-4%+($$$##$ % 4+$ ('" $ $$ %$ 4 $>$0'%$ &% '"%+$"

'3-%%$ %+% %+ ##$ 3$ $0$ %+$ 3 3($ 0-#"-$

& +($ ,$ %+"',+ %+$ "$0" 3($ 0-#"-$$>'"$ $>'"$ %+##$ #$ '$"?

%+%%+$##$ 4$@

%+% %+$ -#',$ ;',-$% $0"$$ %$ #$31%+$ $"$% <%"0% .',$/='",$%$@

%+%'% %+$# %

"$#$%"$"$% 3$-$4%+"4@

%+%#"$ $-#%-$1$#%$%+0$/ 1/ "$"$%3$"$ '$%%+$",+% ' 0 -%

7+$ %$"- 0% %+$ 3($ 0-#"-$$>'"$

3$%"$%$#"% $0"$$ <$0"$$ +$$%/ 1/3$"400", 1 7+$

4$ %+$-

%#$ 00", 1 0$ %+$ - ##$ + 3$$ #$ / %+$ -0$ $'## 0%/ 1/ %'%-%0 1#$

+(,3$$"$$"$ "'0%'' 0#1 %+"$"3$$%%%+$5'"%$"00$"$

"0-# 0$

)

* 2"5