← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/5182/2022dismissed

Jatinder Kumar Arora v. State Of Punjab

2024-01-29Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu10 pages





        

   !""#$%$&'(  )

  

     

 '  *+  , ,, 

 !"!#

$%& 

  '"%(%

  ))))  ,, - 

  

!

 *+,

-  -!   %.,/+ 

01 !

1 ! 23 4/  +555%      .% %  # , 

 4  61    7      %.,8 

    *9/% *98%*/.#.5 $

3 !- %.895   % 1 !  % !!%6  $!

 &  23 "   1  

     

   &   +555   5, +5  7

!  7 

 :&

 1  ; :&7 <   1 = &  1  ; $ < 4 

 1 %     6&=  & 1  ; 

 < (

-1-

1 %<- "! =$!" 1 ;400 <( 1 %< $0  1 &%<- 00%& "  

% &   0

= 11   1  > !

 #        

  

!71

   '!!

"!% !! 7 &!!1 

  "  &!&   !0  & ! !!

!!

"

1?

- 1 1  4$

..

@ ./55"  !  !!'"

7 !0 !7  

!7

   !!'" 7  3  % !!

  !1"  '

 " 

  !

  !

%

& 23"  1 

.    7!

 - !

  "    

23=

 

   !   7

  A  $   ;    &    %

    

  ! 11   ! 7=  %     1   !   



   &1&!!   7



  71

-    =

 1 % & 

 % "

   1 

 !! = 

!  !

!7 1

  ! 

   !!

  & 7=  %

        &   2

  

      7  5/55

  .55   "

=

 % ! !0 !7  0   !1  

) B

 

 % !

    - !% " !

 

 1

7 % 

  

!7&!&  

!7!!

1!1  & " 

  =  %   ! 7 "

!!

 

-2-

 !   !!

  110



  1 & 7 > !

# !

  1 7   "

!!   > -     . 1 0  !   > !

 2

  

  & 7%! 

 "   7

  

!  71  .5!

 "

!  & 

 %"   "  11!!

 !!

1!  &  2

   !!

 .   &  

  1  

46  "

!! 3- 1

!

# !! " !

  1

 1 

   



!!7  1        # , 

 46     "

!!     *9/%*98%*/.#.5 $3-: !7    1  

 23%

     &!&   

    1 23 4+** .+5/55%   %#,

4 61    7        %.,8=  /%.+ 

  &   -

    %5.8=  *9%*9/%*98%*/.#.5 $

3 !- %.895%!  - 7$!%6  $!

 :

  - !  !  

!

 7- 1



 ..55%1 1 1 . 

 %

 !  - "    0   0CDE

/ !

 - !

 



0

0 '

     

  "      

 23= 

   

   

      !     7   A $  ;  & -3-

   & !  1  F 7    "   & 

?

-+555 61&

1 %  

 "

!   &!& 

10

 !

 & 7  

    B 9555%   G!0 ! ; G! "           

,555% & 7.%555 !

 -!&!'!A7 !

"     :  % &  G!0 !  !

     

   $

%1!%

1 #2H



! % 1  "  & "    

,1  2"!3" ##4%"5

"#6"17 .  $

 .5%55 '!

  -!&! '!A7 !

  1! +  

1  555 '!

 -!&! '!A7 !

*  2H

 1  "   ?

 -%"    

 &  2

  !

1&

1 %  A  $  ;  &!   /%955 >  !

%0  !

> -I '! A7 ! % 67! A7 ! % - !

 !

#*5%555 >  !

%0 &   '! A7 ! % 67!  A7 ! % - !

 !

%6!  "

&  .5/55 -4-

 !!       5%555  > !

% 0 -!&!'!A7 !

 "

!! 1 7 8%555< "

& A $  ;  & B

   !   7& A $  ;   &%

 "     

5/55% & 7!!"1  !!

 & 

   

,1  !"

"#6"17 .  85/55 +*%,,  !

%  1 !

 '! A7 ! % 67!  A7 ! % - !

 !

  85/55 ./%5 !

%  1 !

 '! A7 ! %



 +  85/55 .8%555 !

%  1 !

 '! A7 ! *  85/55 .%/5 !

% 1 !

!

H!   55855 .%555 !  "   !  > !

%  1 !

'!A7 ! !1 " .5!

 '  %    %%  "1    !

 

  ! 11   ! 7

   7%.  & 

 1

   #,

46 !1"    !

  *9/% *98%*/.#.5 $3-  1!! 1  "

!!  !!   !

#   

  

   

2   %

!

&   1

 ..55  >   

    

      ! " #$%&  ' "(' !(!(")*  ) + )     !"#$ %&'"( #$

 " " !$( !$ "  $)*  ! ""(  %(++ -5-

! "",-.

/.01 2034!$ .

/  (  * /  ( '  !$

    ! '

 )' ,") ')( "'  ,") ')(  '    -' ( ''    ) ." /)'" 0   1  0 ) + '  +    " 1')    '   )

."".1))

)    .' 2

 +   ! 3  

/    

      ! " #$%&  ' "( ' !( !( " ) *  ) + )     !"#$

&'"(#$ " "!$(!$" $)* &"(

5( &",-678/9084!$ 678 +%( *. 

+( '  /*

    ! '

 )' ,") ')(     ( ''    ) ." /)'" 0   1  0 ) + '  +    " 1')    '   ) ." " .1 ) ) 

)       .'2

 +   ! 3  



4   

   ! "#$'& ' "(' !(!(")*  ) +  )        + &'"( #$  " " !$( !$ "  $)*  &"( 

( &" ,- 8 :. 4!$   80 +5(  * 9& ( '  ;

   ! '

)' ,") ')( ''    )."/)'"0 1 0 ) + '  +    "1')  '  ) ."".1) )

)    .'2

 +  

! 3  



    

      ! " #$%&  ' "( ' !( !( " ) *  ) + )   +&'"(#$ " "!$(!$" $)* &"( (5 &" ,-/780. 4!$ /78 + ( *!$ ('  9& %    ! '

 '3'( ''    ) ." -6-

/)'"0 1 0 ) + ' +   "1')  '  ) ."".1))

)     .'2

 +   ! 3 





1  

    " ) '  #455( ' !( !( " ) *  )   +  )       

( " #$ ! '! &"    ! '

 )' ,") ')( ''    ) ." /)'" 0   1  0 ) +

' +   "1') '  ) ."".1 ))

)    .'2

 +   ! 3  

      5

  ( " '' )    "    ' "+       ''

6 ! 7 .'  ) .""'') ) 

)    .' )  &   

!  ) "   .    ( %&4  ) +   " ! 3  

8

(   !  !

& 



&   +/ 

46 

   

.!%5 $1 ./!<

!"&!*=& >&&? %9 +   ) ! "

 !  )  ) ' )(%& 5:%& ;9(< :9 1"     .'  )     '' . ! 3.'= :.9    )        .'    )  %&  ;    )'   1'1 !'>  " ''.')  .'  + . ) '< :9 .'  . !1     "   '   '( ) -7-

:9+  .'  '  (

     )     .' ! )  .'1 !     !'

"   )     '6'"   " + ' .'

 :9 '    !  !.') ':.9 .$  :%9 ))    '    ) )  ')(%& 5:%& ;9 " '+ 

. !  !  !.'

8        

         !  --!1 *+,

"  % '%!7 " 

    &!&1 !F 7 !! !

 ! !

 -      

     !

 1    ! &1   1!

7     !0 !7  7   " !

! $

&    ! &  !

 & '

!"   "

!!

!

  F              +/ .

  :.)9 11

  1 1!

7    

    !

1   !  

   '

"

!  +/

46 "    7AE!

  -  6 0> -/" &@( + .  4 .#.+ 1 !

&  

?

  ' .) !    $.   '   5  

  ).$  :9 

  +  !  .'     )  1 ! 

)  ) 

    '".@   '   ) )  ;5& ) ' )(%& 5( '.@     ')." -8-

' :.9  .$    :%9     5   

 

   !1 !      "   .'     '   '(   +  )   13= :9             .' ! ).'1 !  )  !'

" ''!)  = ):9     '6'"   " + '  .'( 1 . )      )   ' 1  )   '

  1         ' ) !) !  ) . !   !'

"(   . .)   A .'! )A 

%    7 ? .'! )8   .  ) )    )   .      !      ! )       .  ' ..'   .'1 !   )    !'

"        !)+

  .'.' ' )   ( 

7     )    

'1 @ "     )  !'

"

''!) :1)B   )1  1  69  () !    .  (  ).1(  >  !  !.' ) 



8

               ! 7 >  

*5"

 +5J  & 

1&  

  !   

  1

  1 234+** .+5/55%   %#,

4  61  7      %.,8=  /%.+

 &  -

    %5.8=  *9%*9/%*98%*/.%.5 $

3  ! - % .895%  1    !    - 7 $!% 6  $!

.   

  & 7 !!

 1

     &7   !  =   ! 7

 1

=

 %  - -9-

  !  

"

      & 

 +/.

  :.)9

)  3 & " 

 & %

    

 >

   

   1 

  B 1!7

/  '

&  &  7      >     

 7 

0   1

!  %7% !!!     (!3 &4 17- )   ,,  (1   C  6 !2 ) D C  / .' D  -10-