← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/593/1999allowed

Gora Singh Etc. v. State Of Haryana.

2016-05-25Mr. Justice Inderjit Singh14 pages

GURPREET KAUR 2016.06.06 12:37

   

     

 

        



  

     

!" #   !

 "#$     

    

  

      

!   "#"  

$ % &  " '    &  (' '!"   % )))))   % *  +   ,-      ./000

+" 

 1'    '  +"'     %    +

  

+ 3$4 +

    -    "

 .%  

 "'               '   - %   5 -67

 8   -  # ! -   - 9         :(

   % 

&     "      "+   %

 5 -6  "  "  + 

 +"7 + 8' 67-% % 8'1 + 6;%

  75 8 -    -+" %

+  -  '5 -6 

*  - " 

  +"

 -     %

 5 -  6               +   -"'

5 -6 

< +

  - '=3#5 0>000?    %    *  @-  - "  

*       @-   A%        (  -'  A% (- 6 A%2# 6-  #   <      

'       4       % '  -"'

 ;  ; 

 7+ 8' 6 7-% % 8     1 +   6  ;    7 % %  75 88      

+        2/%  3$4                 -     "    .%    ,- ./000

+"

1'   *  ,-      

+  +" +" "    : 

 +-  ,-     +        + * %   "

/0>% 3$4    3$4+"+ B 

    

+        /0>%  3$4  :   

  

+-    - ' -+"     +   @-  

'  +  " % "   5 "  

  

   

            

+             + +

 " @- $

$A% $A%     $A%

"@-     



 + - - *  +"- + -     

 3  -  



 - " +    + B  /0>% 3$4'   -  3$4 - '  +     23$4< "+   -  

 -   +"     % '   '    -   - -: 

  +-      5 -6 +

= %5 -6 @-  $A%?,       : 

 +-  

-

+'

@- ! '% %   '   "+5 -6'  % %

'

 --  - 

    -   

 $A% ! ' 



'

   + -   5 -6 +   -  + *   

  "   

+ 

 *# %     

 "



+  +" '  + 

   C    -              " -: 

 +-    +  -              

    % 5 -  6         -         -     

       +  

-  - + - +

+"  44- %   -  "+"     ,  -  %

5 -63  

- - * -+" 

  + -  

 :   

                ,- ! D+ @4  ( )*+(, -  ./

- -  0 * &123 4&'%$ * ( # ./ - -  0 * &1'232)5)* 3464%(   5./ - -  7*8 9&12:3

'&   8)*;< 7./ - -  7*8 9&12&3 :&

-  : 

  % +-   ,-        4           +            !-  

                      

-  +   4



- "'     %          

+ 3$4 "   +"  4     ,-     000  *  =3#'      ' 

  +

 -+"- %   

/0>% 2/% 3$4+ %  B   /0>% 3$4    3$4*,-          +            

      +  +      "     

     + 

   " 3  -  

   

- " +   % + B  

+ /0>% 3$4+"  "+    3$4=    34'

 +     (             

    + " +" 

3 + 

  

"

' 

3$4

+= 

+ 3$4'

"

   " " + B +   3$4  "'     % E2/ # 78A

-  +" "+

+ " ,"  

  - -

 " -   

   +        +,   "

+" +  " 

:

 + '

  ' "-  "'  +E "F'

 +   +-     

 =          +%   '

E "F  --

    "$ +   '07 >08 8A--   " +



 - -    +

   "  +     -"  @    -  F =    ' -   + '

 '

   

78 -  +"+

+ "

,"      

       -  -  7+8(  "  -  78* - +,"

+" +     78    "    

   '   

  ' "-  " 78"

+ 



  3$4' -

- +  +"+

+ " ,"

 

- - -  

" - *     - - +

+,"

+" + +" "   + +"

- +

  - "  '      +  +

      

    "        +

 E "F  ( - ' +     +- *@

E/

*9 ; -(F   3$4   2%  C     

"  "    2%

C       - +

'  '    " -  +'

     - "

'

 -    2% C    

2% C      % E2  /75-) * /- ;

=0; -(GA

B     --   " -  



+  -  + +,+"

      "    

  '   

  ' "-  "'4   -    "F

   H;

=0; -(D   2/ 3$4    2% C   '  

" H/

*9 ; -(D' -  + +, "

  - "<    

  -   +'  -      2% C       "

*@

E/

*9 ; -(F   3$4

>-) * -(.);*>>-

+"! D+ @ 4   ) # ./ - -2 .-  3()%&1123 2)5)* 3613 0  ,- '  + 

  % E0    ,          2%     C      3$4

- +-   +  -

+,"

*

 

+  "   

  +     E   

 - - F*@

+F "    2%   C           2/%  3$4    

  

 * +   +   "

  "

  -   C     ++" E +F   -      -     ,(- + 



    

           +    3 +9    " @  ' +   - @ - " +   "   

 -  2% C 

*@

E +F 

+      3$4    2%   C      @ - " 5    +   @

D

+D             @

 E

+F   /3   78C 

  3"



4-" - -  

 E  '      (

 -    +   '   

          

F*-           

- -E +F +-  +"4 '    -    ' '  @

+F  -" -"  

+-+    "

 B   *- +@  @ -  % (+  "+   "-    3

  " -  -  +- 

   +- B  + - -

 '  + 

B F -

  ,- ! D+ @4

  < 5/( *8)0  ) /< 5/( *8)0 ./ - - )(  &112&3 66'      % E*  @

 H  +D   "  

  2% C     

3$4

  $ + 

 +  " 

  "   -    C    ++" H

+D  -       -    ,(-

+ 

  

  

+ 3 +9    " @ ' +   -  @ - " +   "

  

 - 

2% C   *@

H + D        +       2/%  3$4     2% C       @ - " F  -   ( ,- ! D+

@4 ( ?? * (  *; -(/./ - - )( &11'23  '6'    % E*+

 4 

 @ - "  - +-  E

+F - +," 

E

   "F*

- @ @ -  (+ 

"+   "-     -E +F  -

 %,(- + 

 @  " -% -  *-       - 

1 -E +F +- +" 4               -    F *     4'                '

B   %   

+ 

/0>% 3$4  

- "  3

+ -   ,-  4 

  - " +

   ' 



 %5 -  6  +"          "  +  +"   

B -       +"  

*      "-

 -    

       - "'        -   -+" % +  

+ -         - -  %5 - 6  +      - # ' 5 -6  @-        + B "@-  $A%?

      ,              *      @-  ! '% %   '  "

+5 -6'   %

 

     5 -  6  -    -      -      +  

   % 3 

+" - +" 5 -6

-( -   3     +" !  "  (  

  - 5 -6+"

 

 -  +  +    *  %5 -6    

 

+    + 

 "



-   -     -+"     +  C   =3#+"- %  '  -     # *   @-  $ - ,      *  (    "+"   ++   

 =   3$4' + - "  - +

 " - 3 +  "- "' 

+

   3$41 -(    3$4' -  +  + - -  +

   " -  - - +

+,"

'

  ' "-  " +        '        "   -      %  + 

 -      "     

      +       %  + B  

+ /0>%

3$4C   + 

"

+ =  3$4'- + - -   +' - +, "

*   - @  @ -  (+  "+   "-   -A E/

*9 ; -(F  -

&  ,(- + 

 @  " - -    '  - "  "



   +      

   

  

*   +

'- "  +   C   -    5 -6- - *  - "! '-    '

+    +                -  3

      

-   '  -    

+-  # ' 

@- +"

+

  "- -+" - "  -      3 -   

 

-    ++"- (  

" +   B + 

 (  - 3   "     %     "  -   + +," 

+" +       '- " 



+   % + B  *   2% 3   C      3   $ 4'    -- "

 G(+          -  " - 3 E

F

+     "-

    "B 

  +

  +4  

"

   + +

     $ * ( # @/  7 8'    

/0>% 2/% 3$4+ 4       /0>% 3$4*,-        B   - +   -+"! I+ @4

  = *- )*+( *; * -(./ - -  7*8 9&11'243 4&''

   % * 





4"

@ - " 3 +  



 4E/

*9 F

@

 -     "'  @ - "  + (    

 -  * -  @ @ -  (+   "+   "-     -F   ,-  '       "

-+" * 

-   " + 



 +       

    -      " *  % 

/0>% 2/% 3$4+  4      /0>% 3$4 ! I+ @4   ,-     - +"  

  +

  -   "*,-  4 +" 4! I+  @4  ,-  4   4  B  3$4

'

   ' 

- "



 + +" 4  %  B 3         +" 4'   % +    

+ 3$4     



" 

+ 3$4  -  23   C   ' +

         %  

  +       

 

       *             +"  +++   '    - " 

  4  (   

     -  

             %  

+ 3$4          

+'

      ,-     

./000

+"

1'    * % B 

2/% 3$4 * %  +    

    "*+ .

"+ 

 +" %     7 J 4!

K!

#J8

    1KC