← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/66/2004allowed

Vishnu & ANR. v. State Of Haryana

2019-05-10Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu9 pages

 

      



  ! "## 

 $#%&  !% ''(( ! & )%*! ! + ,     '!

 !" #$%&' ()*+,' -+./0 !

 #$%&' ()*+,' +#1'/+#20/+10( -!

 '#*#.%/" !/  ''(( !   *%&0% *#.%/#!# (" !1 (/+ ,  

-+./0 ! 3 4 )%'! '' (##!#!&! . #!!%2&.3! !

4 

4  !  

4/0,( #!# ( *#  5&./  *' !/  #  *#           4/  0, ''(( !$#%& % *#.% )% ''(( !6"% .6#!%  !# !%

"'&#% 0(&*"!#4  6#!%*"!#47- ''(( !$#%&6 "#"! !"&*"!#4 7-! &.(# #3'#3! !' , # /8/ # &(!

' ,3! #/!&. &!%#.&#3'#3!  '#

  ,   ''(( !  %   *#.%  6   "#"!    !"  & *"!#4777-!&.#.&#3'#3!  '#  ,  !' , #  /8/ # &(! ' ,3! #/! &. &!%#.&#3'#3!  '# #93!%  ''(( !% *#.%#&#.!%'", !% '' (  !%"!# #" !6 3   #( 0("

 '' (:& ''(( !% *#.%!#3#  0 !

)%"  !%'"&!## &!%((#!% !"3'( # ! ; 6 *#.%#%#! !3!/<9 -/'!% !%6 #!

#(( .- "%#5 !  +6  .#"&(!&#!0,' # )%%' %= ;&3  !% 3#(( .6 #!& ! !%#%& %=;&3 6  #.!%0&# ;#,  

 ! 0&! -  /%# 6 '!#!%%' %=;&3  * !#% )  % 6  ('!6#!%!%3 !% !#.%!#!!&! %#%& %!%&.%!!% !%#3#.%!% .!(' 6#!%%=;&3  4

/#!%3#./%6!!%=;&3  :&# 0&!%# +!(%#3!% !#!%#.%! ! 0&!   -  /$#%& % *#.%/#! !% 3#(( ./" 3 !%#%' !=6#!%%#3!%'!9!!% !%6 % #. 36=6#!%%#3 ( !!%%'  ""3' #$#%&  !% 3 , ! 0&!   /%" 3!=6 0&! 0, %# (,#.#!%3 #!# (%&  3;   )%% (.6#!%3#% 0#! ! !%#(( .6!!!%%&  3;  / 6%% 6!% ! 0, %#6 (,#.!% (

!%3 )%6#2&,3 =!% 0, $#%& %  *#.%#! !% 3#(( .6 % #.&'#"#&'%# !% !%6 % #.#((#"#!( !#6#!%!% &.%! %#&"(  3;   +6#!%!%%(' %# !%% *#.%% "33#!!!% 3& %#0," ((#.%#3#!%%& %#&"( 3 ;   )%" 6 .#! )% 0,6 ! '!3!3 9 3# !# )%#!#. !#6 " #&! % ((  6 '&!&' ! "3'(!#  ((!%" ( 3 (#!#

4  )%'"&!#9 3# &30 6#!#&''!

!%"  )%! !3! !% ""&6 ("&*"!# 44 -  )%,#!%"  !%'"&!# )%,'&"> ;#! 0*#.%# " )%,6 "#"! !"/ !#" %# 0 +"/!%'! '' ( ? "&( '' #.0% (  ''(( ! $#%& %3!(, .&!% !!%'"&!#%  #(!'#!"  ?  "&( '' #. !%*! !%3!(, .&!% !!%'"&!#%  '#!" 0,  0(&0! &''!!%2&.3!   !%( &!0(6 >% % ( "&( !%' !# .!%&.% !%2&.3! ","  &((, -> 72#!'!% !@

/%6 '! +  ! 0( !-(#"*! !#/1  & !% ! ,/ ""&$#%&3  #"(&! !3!!% !%% "" ( !%'  '#! !%  #%# 

+#! !3!#<9 -< @ -> 5 #; 6 '!% !@

/!%'(#"' !, 0&.%! ""&$#%&!%##(( . +(!%'(#"!%#%& +.! " 3%#%& 7!6 ! =#'#  ->  $ % % "&"!!%'!3!39 3# !# !#"!% ((6#.#2&#!%0, !%"  ( " !6& #A "39"36  '!!%#.%!' #! (.# !%=&(( 7!6 (.#!&# ((,'( " 9'( !#/ !%&(,#.06  &  "!&  '#.!%=&((!%3#.#!# 0 #6 

&( " ! 

 )%  6  3&(!#'(  "!&#    !% !## "%!  03# (6 ((  !%&''' ! !%#.%!# %#' )% "!&#3 =6 0&! !@"39

"3 0(&#%06#"(& '#.!%"%!

6 ((/!%63&(!#'(( " !#'!# 0!%  !%  (&.  )%  6  !%  ( " !# 3 =!%#.%!(0 (# 0&!!

"3#(.!% )%'#! (" #!,6  &((

0(  )%6!6'! !#.6&'! !%#.%!(. #A9 "3  )%6  '! !#.6& #A"3# # 3!'!!%3#( (.( !  )%" &  !%6 &!9!#% 3% . %"=&! #2&#!#! (. #  0 #/(&. (# )%#2&#6 ! 3!3# !& 6&

#"#!!" & !%#3 ("& (#   ->@; 6 *#.%#!% !% "  + !!# #!% !

/%#6 #!!#.#!%%' +# !!&!!%%&#!%#. +!%&.%!!% !#3#.%!%  .!0#!%%' +:&# 0&!%# 3%=;&3 # !%3#. %=;&3 !(%#3!% !#% .6#!%$#%&  %% 36=6#!%%#3 )%#(( .!(%#3!% ! 0, %# 6 (,#.#!%3  3;   )% !/% (.6#!%%#

3#(,330 "% !!%%&  3;    &!%  0, #(,#.#%#%& + (!#"#2&#!%( !

%  0 "=!% 0, %# 7%#"9 3# !#/%%  3#!!!% !!%%& (6 6 #!& !#!% !' ! !% #(( . )%%&  3;  6 #!& !#!%&!%' ! !%

#(( . !#!%6!' ! +%  ( 3#!!!% !%&  3 ;   %   0 "!&"! #!%'(! ((!! !%#3   #!# ( '&'&#."(# !# %(#. + ( 3#!!!% !!%%&   3;  6  2 "!!!%#(( .' +% =6(.!% ! %##% #((#"#!( !#6#!%!% &.%!  3;   0,!(%#3!% !%#% #((#"#!( !#6#!%!% &.%!  3 ;   $#%&!(%#3!% !%#% #((#"#!( !#6#!%!%  &.%!  3;   + ( 3#!!#%#"9 3# !#!% ! ( !#0!6 3;   % *#.%6! # !%( !

, 0" & #((6#(( + ( 3#!!!% ! 0, %# #6 (,#.#!%%&  3;   + ( 3#!!!% !

$#%& % *#.%6 3!%0 # &'#"#   ->%=;&3 '!% !

 ! 0&!  -  /%6 '! !%#%'6#!%# * !#% ! 0&! 

-  /$#%&" 3 !=6#!%%#30, ,#.!% !%% 3 6=6#!%%#3 7!%3#./%! (=!; 6 *#.% !(%#3!% ! #% . 3%#%'6#!%$#%& 7%#"9 3# !#/% 3#!!!% !%&!"(%#%' ! -  #!%6#!   0!6 ! -  #&33  +#%&6 #!& ! ! #! " ,  3%#%' )%,6 #! # 0&!B %& !% !/!%,6!!!%#%& +#!.## 3 !# !!% 3#(,330 #!% !%% .6#!%$#%& ! 

-  

->* !#%'!% !

%6 '! !!% %' %=;&3 6#!%%= # ! -  /$#%&  "%!% % ""!#!% !%% 30&#6#!%%#3

  !%  #  6!  6 , 6#!%  %#3  7  %#  "9 3# !#/  % 3#!!!% !%# !%C#!.26 3 #! (6 #!

#(( .5 &(#/#!#"!*' !  4 -> (6 *#.%#"#! C,6#!C +'!% ! 

 ! 0&! 8 4-  /%% (3!# % .! !% #(#!& !##(( .- "%#5 !! ! %#3( >%% "%  !%%&  3;  /%% !%# C    + 6% *#.%%(#.#0,%#%  $#%&6 .##. 0(6!%#36#!%   !!% !%6!!!% #( 7%#" 9 3# !#/% 3#!!!% !#! "0!6%#%&  3;  C %&6  0&!=#(3! )%6 ' !%#%& +# !!(( ,#(( .!% !%% % *#.% $#%&.##.0(6 !##!%%&  3;   +#! # ( 36%% 6 $#%&.##.0(6 +#!!((!%'(#"

#"6%" %#! !3!!% !%''#!%3  3;  !%&.%!% #!!#.

. ' !% +#!3 = , !!3'!!"&#&!   +#!#"(!%# "!! , +#%&6 #!& !#!%!% #"!###(( .- "%#5 !  )%%&  3;  6 #!& ! !% !# !%#(( .- "%#5 !    ->4*##- ('!% !@

/% (.6#!%5 # ; 6 6!!#(( .- "%#5 ! 6#!%'(#" $#%&(!%3  '(#"' !,!%#%& .!" (,#.!%

->  5 .#%  - %   6   !%  7!#. !#.  

#"  + "#!%# 3 !# +3 3!/<9 - +(# !0( ! # !% ' "=#!#  (' "( +!=#!'#    '#((6 %#! !%" (,#. !!%'( " "#3 +

'' #A&33/<9 -+ +9 3#!% 0, # (,#. !!%'( " "#3 '' !%#:&!'!/<9 -D + 3  ''(#" !#/<9 -D8 '!3!39 3# !# + ! ""&$#%&

 ""&$#%&3 #"(&! !3! .!" (,#.!% %# 

7%#" 9 3# !#/% 3#!!!% !% & 0(#63 / .#(  0&!

, (/  !%.#( ,   .#!%%&  3;   + #!3 =:&## 3!%63  !%.#( &#!%%&

 3;   +#!"!%#! !3! 

)%3!# !!#0&!!!% ''(( !#!% !" # %   #((#"#!  ( !#  6#!%  !%   &.%!     3 ;    +6/  ->@ ; 6   *#.%/  !%    "   /  #  %#  "9 3# !# 3#!!!% !%% =6(.!% !%##% #((#"#!( !# 6#!%!% &.%!  3;   0,% !(%#3!% !%#%  #((#"#!( !#6#!%!% &.%!  3;   + ( 3#!!!% !% %  6(,'&3'!# 

)%  "     !%  '"&!#  #  (  !% !  #"  "  #% #((#"#!( !# 6#!%!% &.%!  3;  /#!6  02"!!0,!% ''(( !$#%& %# !% ->@; 6 *#.%%  " !.#" ((,! ! #%#"9 3# !#!% !( !#0!6 3 ;   % *#.%6! # !%( !, 0" & #(( 6#(( *#"!%( !#6! #0!6% *#.%  3 ;  /!%6 "" # $#%& % *#.%!=#((# @ )%'"&!#%  ((#&'!%!!#3, -> %=  ;&3     ->  * !#%  !  &0! !# !  !%  '(    C( !   !.!%C ->%=;&3 #!%%'=' ""#.!%#3/

@

 ! 0&! -  /%6 '! !%#%'6#!%#  * !#% ! 0&!  -  /$#%&" 3 !=6#!%%#3 !%'!9!!% !%% 36=6#!%%#3 )%&!" ! =2&#"# ( !#" !% "!!% !##(( ./%' "(# #(, !@ 8  -  ->%  ('!% !%6 #! # 0&!B%& !% !/% * !#%6!!!%#%& 7 !% !6 /%%&( % # 3!% 3#(,330 !%"   ->* !#%'!% !

%6 '! !!% %' %=;&3 6#!%%= # ! -  /$#%&  "%!% %!= 6 ,#6#!%%#30, ,#.!% !%%  30&#6#!%%#3 7%#"9 3# !#/% 3#!!!% !%#

!%C#!.26 3 #! (6 #! #(( .5 &(#/ #!#"!*' ! 

 )%'"&!#%  ((#&'!%!!#3, C, 6#!C  -> (6   *#.%  +  '  !% !   

  !  0&!

 8 4-  /%% (3!# %% .!!% #( #!& !##(( .- "%#5 !! ! %#3( >%% "% !% %&  3;  /%% !%"# C    +(= #!!%%&  6!% !% *#.%6 %(#.#0,%#%  $#%&6 .##.0(6!%#36#!% 

)%%& ->

(6 *#.%##!& !#!%!%#"!###(( .- "%#5 !  + % "" #!.!6 !%%&  3;  ! %#3( )% #! "0!6!%%&  3;   !%%& -> (6  *#.%6 3!% =#(3! -> (6 *#.%%#3(  3#!!# %#"9 3# !#!% !%#%&6 #!& !#!%!%#"!#  !%%&  3;  6 #!& !!% !# !%#(( .

 - "%#5 !  +#! !3!!#'#" #" 7 %% !% ''(( ! % *#.%.##.0 !#.!" #/%6&( % # 3!%#(( .

)%E*?'!#<9 -* 0(6 !"!9%#0#!  !%&.%0(6  &9%#0#!  %#! '#((6

)%  '"&!#  %   !  '  !%  3!#  !!#0&!  ! ''(( !$#%&!=#((# >%  ( ,! =! !% "!

!% !!%( !#0!6 3;   % *#.%6! # )%&/ !%6 "" # !% ''(( !!=#((#! !%'!#.   3;   %# 3#(, )%'"&!#% #!%9 3# 3 ;   ,330 %# 3#(, )%7!#. !#.

#"5 .#% - % %  3#!!6%#( '' #. ->!% !%% !" ! !3!  , !%63  !%.#( &#!%%&  3 ;   

)%  '"&!#  %   #(  !  '  !%  "   . #!  !% ''(( !0,  0(&0! ""#.(,/!% '' (# ((6 )% ''(( !# ":&#!!  ((!%"% .  3 . #!%#3    2#*% 3  5&. 

  + #*#.%*#%&   5&. >%!%' =#.8  F8  >%!%'! 0( F8