← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/10374/1995allowed

Urban Improvement. Co. Pvt. Ltd. v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2016-02-11Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal,Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih12 pages



        !"# $$%& '( )#*+ ,

- - .

/) 010 01) 2  34 

  5+6+ 78)#)2) )) 47+ 

+1 4 +  

    

  

 



 

      

!

  " # !



 $ % &  '   " # !



 $ ()#* +  ,,,,      

        

       

         





 

       ! "  



#   



      

    

$%    

     

   & ! '!                

   ( 

   #  

 

 !) '!!$*+ & ,

-  (  

 

    &  .$*  / 

    

#

        ! 0    1!'    /     2 &   3

 

5    1!    4

 6

 /#   .  

- 746/.85   1! 9  : 3 4

.

  

  1! ,!& !;

< =  ! ! "   $* $   

  

  9        >1)?  &  @   /  - 9   # 



  !     

     

  

   

   #   

 

            #      

     >1)? &  @! 

  #   A  # 

  B

 (

#    !              +   3 ?

 <  0  & 



    

 /#  .$*7   



>$*.@8#    ! ! "   $*< 3 ?

      (    <   3 ?

  <   4

!          #              1!'   /   &  3

 4

  # 

  !) $$!!$**/   2&  3

 

 #



   





>9   :  &  @     :



!            

 #       

 

                3 ?

< 0 & 

.

  

/#  0 $*7   



>$* 0 @8!     A          >C(

/#  &  @7C/&8!

! 3

           #     !"

       



 #    +!  4

 0    7/#    0

   &   8.$*+$7   



>$*+$.@8

   $!$$!$*+$!0   1!'

      

            $*+$.!  3  @

      

    

  

 

   !!$*+!4 # $*+$.

    /#  -   &   

          

 



!

!  # ? 

     <  & ! ! D

 = !;

       

     

  A      

    

    $$!!$**      

   #   

   !D 

  $$!!$**     @

 

     

      #  

         

  ! *! 4

/#   0

 6

.

. $*+7   



>$*+.@8

    $*+! < ' 

   

  



  

  



    

  

         



  



     



 



 





  

"

$!7.8        '!'!$*$ 

 (    '$*+.! 7-8  &

   <    9#   4

   &   3

  /        !!$*'   (  

 

   '$*+.

     (       

    ?   

     ! 3





'78  7#8   



   !" 

 #      $%&$%'()*  $+,     

  

 

  

#      -+  

        #   



 !

!" 









       

                      

    .

/  0  1

 



 

 

"





      

   1 

 -

  



             #     

)     2-()       $%            1 

 "

    3  

 /   3       



    

 ! 7&8 3





    #     

  

   

    $'!!$*'! &

 

  F3 



5)"







  

        

                      

    .

  /   0  1

  



  

  

 "

% 





    

  1 

 $$! "    

  #          !!$*'  

 

  $'!!$*'! $'! )  '!*!$*+    

      

    B  

$!7.8 -     '!!$* 

     

   1!'    C/&

   #       #    B

     

 (      $*+ .   0 

     A    C/&  #   

   

B! 

      (          #  



          

       

  C/&  # 

                1!'     #  # 

B   

  #   

 

 ! 7-8 0   1!'   '*!!$** 

 <  9 

34/&  &  "  1 / 

                    <  9#               A C/&

  # # 

  

# C/& 

$$  

  !

      #     

            $$   !  C/& 

     

+ $!     &# D 3 1!'$**$ A

      '!!$*! /         



.

    1!' 

  +!$!$**'       1!'

 



!- 

    

 

       C/&  

   !

 

!3



 '7 8

  6 !"



  

            !          

       

  

  

    "   

      3   

 /01 7 

 0" 3    

  1 

"

 83  4

  )    -+  

      



 

 

     



5) ! %,          913

#

2-:& 

       

! -+



    ! ; <%,   

   

   

  

 

  =$&, 



  

   



     

#

  >-:& 

  !                

       = -, 

      

 "   







 

 ! ?

%, #        913 

#      -:&  

     

         

 $! ./#  -    &    ?   "# $%& % 

 '

(      )'!(

) * +

,$ '

-#(

).

A

       '!!$* +!$!$**'

       $!*!$**'    

!

 

A   (     

   



     



  !/#   - 

A

 

  $!!$**

  



#     $*+.!/#  - 



        

 B   

#

         $!        &# D 3 1!'  $**$           &  C/&     ''*  



  $$' ! 3

? /#  -  &  

  



! $+!           <

, # .

  1!*$$**!< & 



      $+!$!$**E 6" 

 @ $7(0  

 3  A

 

)B2%$:

                   913  

 : C   $''D     

    

   "         

 



-+ $''D " 

)B 

                  

 

 #

  "            

  

*     

         

 E

    

  

     "  



   

     

       " 

 

         

   

 

    913   #  

  

       

      



  

                2%$: 

       -+   $''D     

         

   

 < C  $''

  "      $&   

 "

B

  F

 

 # 

             2%$:

    " 

  @ -                      

  $ $! <

, #3 



   

? < &  !$!$** 

  6   

  

           

     3   D $<+$$''D   *      

 @ $)0  

 3  4A A

     

  

    



   A

     



  @ $          

  @ $    *         3     

    

   

 

     913   #  

  

      

  

 B  C 



     

  

  

 

 

       

 *     #    

    





       

   

   #  



 



/



  *     

  

  

   

   $<+$$''D   

     



  @ $   #     

*    

 @ $        

 @ $     

    

E     

 

  

" 

$ " B  A  

     



 $*! :

      <  &    !$!$**  

           

  

     ? /#  -  &

     

  A

 

       '!!$* +!$!$**'!.  < &      # 

               !      $+!$!$** 

 !$!$**

  < & 

      

 ?  '! " "# /  &% 

 '

(      )'!(

)  7 

8      '!!$*+  &  ,

 -    (  

 

   &  .$*

 / 

    

#

               !  /#   -    

                

 

>   

@ 

 



      &  ,

 -      

 (          

  

( 



         '$*+.!       ! '$! .

  = !;

 #  

    

   & ,

-  #    - / 

     (  

 

    '  $*+.

    

 (          



 !D 



 '7#8 (  

 !"  A           !     

    



   

               

        & ,

 - !  

                 

    !D # 

 (      #         !3



 

A                      

  

 !   

 

   

 

         ! ''! = !;

         

     



   !"          

  #  

        # # 

  

'! .

   = !;

          

B   #    (      !!$*'!              '!!$*  +!$!$**'

  



      #



!    

 

   &# 3 1!'$**$!

 A

  ?  &  !!$** "# /  &% 

 '

( 

    )'!(

)

'

&(    

            ?    <  &    !$!$**!D   

!1

      



  !

'! .

 #     < &   $+!$!$** 

 !$!$**   

    ?        !              

  

   !"   #      

  ?    = !;

    

   

    



 #            ! '! = !;



 A C/& !4        A       

        !4          1!' <   9 

 34/ & 

  &   "    

                 < 9#     A #        #    

       C/&  #  



 ''  

   

 

 '  

!4    ?  #       $!'!$** &C   46/.

   1!'

/     &   3

  4

 

 

    (

 (

 



'!*

$!$*

 # !   #       (      #  

    

 

#

!

  

!  ,     

      C/&



      

'! "    

   

         

 

    

 

                     ! "        

-    

                

   

  !  

  

     

 

     

 ! '+! "  

 # 

   !        #         

     ! = #  #    #  # 



 

   $'% !                   

      !    

       

! '!     

                  $'%      

     

      <  &    $+!$!$** 

     

B   ! 

   $!!'$!   

 #  



     

  !:  #    # 

# 

   

 

 

       $'% ! 7<!G!H.I":/.08 .&"19&4"C:G6<"&C $$!'!'$  7.0613.,,"8 >

#  @ G6/9C /#471  √+