← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/696/2004dismissed

State Of Hy. v. Samshu Etc.

2024-08-02Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma11 pages

  

      



  !

"#"

 $ ! "%"

 

     

    &

#%&

'()*+,   

     

      '-

 

  

    

  

)+!)./01+"23&4 1&31&5463 )./01+&"23&4 1&3114&+ 



   !  "!

 # $%&%'('%&)%**+,

& - "./  # $%%01%)%**,   # $%&%'('%&)%**+  $%+%**+,

& . 2"./ 

  "./  # $%+%**+, 3333

  &31&546372"

  /44.# , / 

. # ,  / . /"4 

  52/

" /6 . # ,  4  / . /4 2        6 .  # ,      /  2    2 . /" +**"  /4 278   +*1**"  4    

        52"  ! 2 "

  2 / / 2 2 //9  /  4 *06+ :

$"4 8  /"

 52/

" / /   2 / ./ 2  %/ ./    / 4  +  / + :

$:   

 52/

"/9//  / 2 2     / 4 *0  / + :

$"4 8  / . " 2    / 2  8**"

 52/

"

  / %/ ./  ; /

        

          

   ! "          "

 #     $ "

  % &   '( )  "



*!&

 

 

"  "! +   /4//%/ ./4/22 .  4. . / / ./ "4"4/22 .  / 9    /#,    " "   4/

 " "4 

/ ./ 2$ /

"   /  2 / 4 27$%% 01%)%**"4  $  +  

 / %   / 4 27$%&%'('%&)%**+ / 

. 4 27$%+%**+" /. " 2 /      2   / ./  9  / ./%//"        4 *0  / + :

$"4   / 4 8  /"    /#,   /   / ./  



8 2   / /4/4 =:" />; )62 

 /

 >; )6 " (**    " :?

 /.    2-       4  4

      2 "7 &?

":?

 /  2   4 2    /   " /      / (**    2 /     - /  /   2.  4 @       "  $- 

.  2    / 

2

?

 2  2 "  - "  4  & /    2//     .2  /A  /   4   4/ "" < 

- /   2  2 //  2 $ //  B/   

   "   "  2.  4 ?

4. / *06+ :

$  8  /"  2  / 2 /

    .2 //  /   

 $      ! "

##!

$ '  /  / 4 *0 :

$"

;/.  44 $   ""

/ $   /

"   2    /        **"    //// / 4  $   % ! "

##!

$ 0 

 52/

"  /. 2/ 

" 4</.    / 

 "/ 4   " /  / 22 //" 

/    / 4 *06+ :

$"

4 8  /   / 2   //" /  2 " "/  1 :

   /" / ;   "

"        

  4/ 

/  /

"  /    / . /  /   / . /"

 52/

"   / 2"  $ $"

4 "//

/ /" "/ /

 . " /       /. /

& ' !$$!

$

( )# #

#  $# (

)# **# $$# ( 

/   22 ./ ./% . 24  $ "42 . / / ./ " "

/ 9      /" 9    /  4.4  2  "4 2   / " " % /  . /2  / 2 ' !$$!

$

( )# #

# #  $# 

*!

  * ?

  "

/  24  $ ". / / ./ " "/ 9    /#, # ,"4/ / ./% "   "

"  9 

   /"4 2 4 $  ; /     < /     "  2 "  

4 / ./% "4=   "

 2/ ./% 4/ ./    / 4 *0  / +  :

$"

4    / 4 8  /"    /   /   / ./ 8      9        :      $$

$  :

9$ 899 : ;5 5'

 )       # ,"     /.    "    /      /.  ;  % %/ "

/. / 4/ ./% " / 

"

/  "  9  / ./    2   2     / 

    /2 "   / 2         "  " /%//44 2./  2 . 2 /  4    :.    2   4.  "

 4 "       #, / ./%   "    /// %;   4   # ,"22 2"  / ./%    

4   

  .  

 4/"4    # ,   "     / "4  $ .%%.   / ./  /

"    .          

 .     /     4 2  "                / "   $ 4/ 2

. 

.2  ) "  /.    2       //

/ C,4    2   . 2  4 

 . /    2"4,4 . / / . .   /2   .  4 =:"/,4 .

 / // .%% ./ .  /4  

  

     / /    "   4           //     4/

4 .%%./ . "  42  /. 

.2 "  4  / 4 4 /2 4/ 2 2 // !  # !$ $ # $# # 

(

+!  $) ,-." + & 2/   .2 "4 2  =:"/ ./% "2  /  " />; &2 2  /  "4

//. 4; /

                      &  "   

!   !

","  

       ")     ,  " &        ) !      -   ")   "

       $ "( !

 "        

           

 $     + 8   /      # ,"  /

       2  " / .//

:

2  /  # ,"/ ./ "/ 2  / 2      " /  #,4   /.       2 9  2" "/ / 2 / 

     /"     . " 2  /    24 4 2  4/   2   2" "

.  / /.

  / 

  "

 .2 2 / /

" /  2" "

 2 ' 2  / " /  4 4

4 

2  //  >; =   4 4  .  . " / 4 44  24. /422. /.

 / .

.    "/ /4 2 . 

 / 0 2  /  / 2 2   /  "4 / ./ .2 2 / /

"

 / .//

" 2 /.

>; =6"/

/.

      / .2 2 / /

 $ 9 "   /.

 224

/2 . /4  /.

 " /  " . /.

4 2.%%. / 

     /"  4  / ./"   .2 2 /  /

 :

9" 2 .2  /  "4 / ./  /

"  4            /    .

/.

      / 

       /"    4    / ./ /

" .2 2 / /

"4   /

4    4 / 4   // # ," 4/    .%%.    /   //

/"    4    /

 # ,

 

<<$8 $ 1

@%&  )/ ;      /2   /        "   / . 4/ 2   "    / 4 //D>; E4/2  .  

/4 @% 4    ; / " /   D. 4; / / 0 !#$

)# *# $

( !

0 # !

#

!

) .  *  "     &      &   %"     "

" !!!  !

 !   

  " )!     

  &!/!!0 !

 ! - !!$  $      1 '

!   " " +

 ( !.          / 4  /  //   4    # ,".%%./ . " 4   / //  / . /// "4     2  /           / 9      /.

"    4/  /      /    "    4/  2      . 

 / " 42  / /  //  42 // #*



( !$! ,-*#  * . "      "    =D/

"  / /.    "4/    ;  4/; " / /"

   .      4" /4/  "

4  /      

2/   :

9 " $ 2 2/  / / #,"  /         //

/"   "           "   4/; "   9  / 2"4/ " /

))D2 "4/ /.  2 /.

>; =6"  / //$ 9 "/ 2 2 //4/ /4/ . /4  . 4 ; 9   2 / ./ 4/ / 4



 $ /

 =.0)1



  '-

  

 ./% 4/ 22 .    2 /9".%%./ ./%  .%%./ 2 2     / 4

  *0 :

$"4 8  /"

  6 . # ,.4 4  $ 

 . "    42  4 .        4           2  4   6 .     /C :,  ; 2     %52

 2"4// >; E"4//

2  .    4   "44//

2      22 ::, :

 9"   4     //     "

    / 4 

    2 2

:::,  /.      /  24

2     /    /            )/  ;     "          /  4/     

/. 2 "4/    .    4   "  4 $ / /      2 2

: "         /4 //  24

 2     2/ 2  44 " " /4/   4 /

.   4   "   "  4

 / 2 .44    2 4

2  :, :

9"// "

/

   2 2

   //  4

 4/ ./    / 4 *0

 / + :

$

&

#%&

'

 :

/ 9 /"2 . / / ./ " "   / 9             /"    4/  /.

/ " ""  %/ ./4 

  52/

"   

2  .  " 4   % / " " % /  . / / :

/ 9 /"    " ":

   4"  4      /   2    

     52  /

"         / 

2 //  $  " 

"4  //  /  "4   ;

        2   + / 4      8 / / #," 

"6 "   (&31&5463,  23>1 (&3114&+, 23>1

 7

 8 5 9? @   !

A@.

5  9

8 !

A@.