← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1139/2001disposed of

Ramesh Kumar v. State Of Pb.

2021-11-16Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan23 pages



!"

!#$"

% & ' 

& 

&  ( )*++ +

,!-./

010  +++22

 3   ($4 5 +++ 2  +

6,!-./ 0 %7 8

+++22

 3

   (7  +++ 2  +

*,!-./ 47947  +++22

 3

   (7  +++ 2 

 :+

,!-./ ;7 +++22

 3

   (7  +++ 2  <+

:6,!-./ "47    +++22

 3   ($4 5 +++ 2  *+

<,!-./

1     +++22

 3

   (7  +++ 2  =+

<,!-./ 07 +++22

 3

   (7  +++ 2 



!

.) !

>?.

%"  3 &

 @

 

       

  

 



 !!""#$! !%&&"'

     



 !!""(%! !%&&"'

   ) 



 !!""$*! !%&&"'







 !!"%"&! !%&&"'

 + , -) 

  .

 



 !!"%/(! !%&&"'

 0  1 

 '

 !!"%2% "%2#! !%&&"'

 .   

 ).

) 

 !

 0)     666666 3 &

 @ A%+ +  .. ).  ,. 

  ,   )   

. ).  &* &$ %&&"

   )

4 5,   7

 



  ).

   &* &$ %&&"    

  .



5



  "%&!

4   

 849'

   /%& /*: /*( /:" /::! 4 

:

%'





 "$/:

 8 9'

 ; ) <5 )   =  >;

) . = .  0  

  "%&!

4   /%& 4

 .

 )

  "%&!

4    /%& /:"

4  



     

 

)



.

. !

 - -.

  ?





 

"

"%&!

4   /%& 4

&"

7



 "&&&@!

4   



)

% . /%& 4

&# 7



 %&&&@!

4   



)

/ . /*:

4

&% 7



 "2&&@!

4   



)

# . /*( 4

&% 7



 "2&&@!

4   



)

# . /:"

4

&% 7



 "2&&@!

4   



)

# . /::! 4

&# 7



 %&&&@!

4   



)

/ .

%'



&# 7



 %&&&@!

4   



)

/ . % 5



"%&!

4   /%& 4

&$ .



 2&&@!

4   



)

"

. /%& 4

&% 7



 "2&&@!

4   



)

# .

< /*:

4

&"

7



 "&&&@!

4   



)

% . /*( 4

&"

7



 "&&&@!

4   



)

% . /:"

4

&"

7



 "&&&@!

4   



)

% . /::! 4

&% 7



 "2&&@!

4   



)

# .

%'



&% 7



 "2&&@!

4   



)

# . # ; "%&!

4   /%& 4

&# .



 2&&@!

4   



)

"

. /%& 4

* .



 "&&&@!

4   



)

% . / .

 ) "%&!

4   /%& 4

&$ .



 2&&@!

4   



)

"

. /%& 4

&% 7



 "2&&@!

4   



)

# . <5 "%&!

4   /%& 4

&# .



 2&&@!

4   



)

"

. /%& 4

* .



 "&&&@!

4   



)

% . *   = "%&!

4   /%& 4

&# .



 2&&@!

4   



)

"

. /%& 4

* .



 "&&&@!

4   



)

% .

* :

>;

"%&!

4   /%& 4

* .



 "&&&@!

4   



)

% . /%& 4

&"

7



 "2&&@!

4   



)

# . ( . = . "%&!

4   /%& 4

* .



 "&&&@!

4   



)

% . /%& 4

"A 7



 %&&&@!

4   



)

% . $  0   "%&!

4   /%& 4

# .



 2&&@!

4   



)

"

. /%& 4

&* .



 "&&&@!

4   



)

% .











 )

      7 "$(*!"$((

5





;!

.! 



,



  

 ; ) .

 ) <5 )   )   =  >;

) ?.

; 

. = .   

.

.

 0     ,;

 ,;

4





 ;





- "&$&



;

%* &# "$(:

&( &: "$(: 



,

 #2$@!

>





":

,

 

.

&: &$ "$(:

%( &# "$(( 

 

=   , 

 

 )  , !

 - B - 

B 

7. .

"

#2%(#& &: &$ (:

"&&&&& && % #2%(#:

"" &$ (:

"&&&& && # #2%(#( ": &$ (:

22&&& && / #2%(#$ %" &$ (:

"&&&&& && #2%(/& %$ &$ (:

%&&&&& && * #2%(/"

#& &$ (:

"&&&&& && :

#2%(// &( "& (:

2&&&& && ( #2%(/2 "& "& (:

2&&&& && $ #2%(/* %% "& (:

"&&&& &&

"% "& (:'

"& #2%(/:

%% "& (:

#&&&& &&

"% "& (:'

""

#22:(% %& " (( %&&&&& && "% #22:&# %2 " (( %&&&&& && "# #22:&* * % (( %&&&&& && "/ #22:&:

%2 % (( %&&&&& && "2 #22:&$ $ # (( %&&&&& && "* #22:"& "* # (( %&&&&& && ":

#22:""

%( # (( %&&&&& &&  ":



  7

 .

7. 7  ) .

   ) ;@



,;

)

7. -    

) 

.

@   C)  D;

,

 

  ,



.    - " # :

(

 5



) .    - " # / 2 * ( $ "& 

6 , 

; ,; 5



 )  

   

   > .

7.

 E .    - %  CE.



   . ) 

 

   )@ ) 

5



;

 5





E 

.

.

 !

 - B - 



.

7. .

"

#2%(#( 2 $ (:

: $ (:

% #2%(#$ "$ $ (:

%" $ (:

# #2%(/* "& "& (:

"% "& (:

/ #2%(/:

"& "& (:

"% "& (:

#22:&# %/ " (( %2 " (( * #22:"& "/ # (( "* # ((

 5



E  

.





.

- #2%(//  

 )  )

 5



; )   

;



 %"&2&&&@!

4

 )  %2 "" "$(* .

 )   

7



.

 - :%:2*%  %2 "" (*

 "(&&&&@!

 ? 

;

.. ., 

 - "&*%





 - = . .  

7 



 )  ?

- %#/  %2 "" (*

 $22@!

  ..

 ,



 ":$&/2@!

  

- "&*%

- = . 



 - = .

 - *:*%:(  %2 ""(*

 "(&&&&@!



7.  



7.

 ,   .

 )  CE.



   . ) 

 

)  ,;

, 

.

 )

;



7

)   ,



7.

. %2 "" (* , 

.

,  %/ "" (* B - :%:2*%    .

 ) ,

,

  

E  

.

.

 ) - = .

? 

;

.. .,   

, ) 

 .

 

7 .

 )  ,;



 "(&&&&@!

<5    

.

@ > -

 1    - $"(  %& ( (2

  

.

 . )    ,



  ,

 ":*""" /:

#& $ (* ?  7



 



7



 

 &2  %%2&&&@!  %%//2&@!

 

- $"(  )  22&@!

..





     

  &:



  

 )   , !

 - B - 

B .

"

"&*#&$ %* $ (* $*/&&@!

% "&*#"& %* $ (* /2(*&@!

# "&*#""

%* $ (* **:&&@!

/ "&*#"% %* $ (* /&&&&@!

"&*#"# %* $ (* 2&&&&@!

* "&*#"2 %* $ (* %%2&&@!

:

"&*#":

%* $ (* :2&&&@!





 #& $ "$(*   B 

 &:

 

&*

7,     - 

 &:



 

.    )7

 &:

 

 

 !

 -  - . -.

7



 

  7,   "

&"%%:2@"$@(* #& $ (* /2(*& && ,

 , >  $*/&& && % &"%%:*@"$@(* #& $ (* /2(*& && !!

# &"%%::@%&@(* #& $ (* **:&& && !!

/ &"%%:(@%"@(* #& $ (* :2&&& && !!

&"%%:$@%%@(* #& $ (* 2&&&& && !!

* &"%%(&@%#@(* #& $ (* /&2&& && !!

:

&"%%("@%/@(* #& $ (* %%2&& && ,

>!

;  )

  - 

 CE.



   . ) 

 

 

 )  

  .   



.

  .

 

7  ,;

? %( &: (:

)

  ,  

 %&&%&&@!

  .

. ? ,;

 ,    

 ) 

 

 )  - $"(

7     %( : ((

 



 7 7

)  )    7  "**& #2

 

  



  =

 

 % 

7,  >  ,

    - %::/:(@"@(:

 %( : (:

  ,;

 CE.



   . ) 

 

 

 ) 

 ,    



7   )    ,;



 %  <5 .   ,;

- #"("

- 

 

  

 2$ &2 

 , "% ( (* >

   , - 2*:(// 2*:(/2  "% ( (*



 "



.

 7 >





7



 "% ( (*

 2&&&&@!

 .  

- 











 $$/&&@!

) 

- $"(

@ > -

 1

 *&&@!

; ,;

..

 )   

 ,

 """ (% "% ( (*

,  

 $$/&&@!

<5

  - 2&(2$/  %$ : (* 7 )  .



 2&&&&@!

 )   

   - 2&(2$"

 "% ( (*



 2&&&&@!

.

   <5

 



 CE.



   . ) 

 

 

 )@ ) 

<5    , - 2*:(// 2*:(/2   ,        ,;

 

   <5



;

   7    



7 <5   ) 7

 7 ) 

- $"(    ,;

 

  7

   #&&&&@!

 *$&&&@!

 

7



 #& $ (* 7



 .

  $(:2&@!

 )  %2&@!

..

   

 - $"$

@ 7 .

7    = 



@ 7 .

7  

 - 2"*(:*  %* $ (*

 ($&&&@!

)

  



<G . ,;

    )   =  - ("%%:/@":@(*  #& $ (*

 

 ($&&&@!

7,   , >   CE.



    . ) 

 

 

) 

  =   )@ ) 

7



  )

   



7   =   )  ,;



 ($&&&@!

    ,   - "&:%:*  %$ "% (*

 #%/&&&@!

  .

, 4

   .



    , 

   

4

   )   )

 %$ "% (*

7 ,;

 1)

;

    

 5   

 

 %%2&&&@!

 $$&&&@!

  #%/&&&@!

.

)



@ .

.

7   - "&%&

"# * (* ? . 7 .

,.

 - :&($/"

 "# * (*

 (&&&&@!

7.  





     ,

? %& * (* .

,.

  - :&&$/2  "$ * (*

 %&&&&&@!  



  7 , )  

   

 %(&&&&@!

.

  ,;   .

   "$(:

: >;

)

 

@ =  C)    - *$* ( / ("

>;

 - #2%/:*  - 

 %2&&&@!

%& % (:

  )

7. >;

) ,  ,

)   7 , ,

 2#22: #%   



5



 .

; ,;

  H7   



 5,  CE.



   . ) 

 

) 

>;

 



7 5



  >;

7

  H7

 "%

  ,

 >;

)

 

@ =  C)  )

7. !

 - B -  .

 "

&#:22& "/ % (:

/&&&& && % #2%/::

* * (:

2&&&& && # #2%%::

" : (:

%$:&& && / "&*$:# " : (:

2&&&& && #2%/:( %( $ (:

"&&&& && * #2%/(& # "& (:

#&&& && :

#2%/(% %: "& (:

*&&&& && ( #2%/(* 2 " (( /%&&& && $ #2*((/ %2 " (( *2&&& && "& #2*((* " % (( %"2&&& && ""

#2%%:$ %: % (( /"2&& && "% #*:""2 "* 2 (( /&&&& && .    - " % # / :



< 5





 

; ,;

  H7 ,

 7  .; , 7

) 

- *$(

7   

  E

%( $ (:

 .  )   - "

%  

 "/ % (:

* * (:



)  %( : (:

 )

"#2 7 %# 7   7  CE.



   . ) 

 

 

) 

 ,   

 5

    ,;

 - #2%/(#  "& "% (:

 2&&&&&@!

  ,

 >;

)

 

@ =  C)  )   - *$* ,  .; 7 , 7



 )7 .   "& "% (:



"& "" (:

 2&&&&&@!

 ,   >;

,

  - #(%*&"

 

 2&&&&&@!



"& "" (:

.

@ 7   .

7 0)

  

.

- 7 .

)  - *$*   #:

7 

7  

 2&&&&&@!

   - :$&2$%@"@(:

 "* "% (:

  -

;

4  0)    

 )  ": "% (:



7



*  2&&&&&@!

7  

.

@ =  C)  ,  7  .

) 

  @ 7   .

7

#:

7

  H7   .    ,;





 "&&&&@!

E .7 ?

 - = .

 

@ - = . .

7   - "&*% "" "" (*

 . ) 

 - = . , 7 





? . 7

"" "" (*

)

 

 /%#2&&@!

) 

   ,  ?

 

7 ,;

,;

 "" "" (* 

 - = .

 - *:*%:*  "" "" (*

 %2&&&&@!

B  ,;



 .   





.    

      .    "

  " 2& 

   ) ..



 %2&@!

 #&&@!

? .  - #(%2&&@2$@(*

 "



 



.

 )  

; 

  - #(%/$$@(%@(*

 " 2& 

 



@ 0

=   )) .

7,  

, ) 

 - = .

  - *:*%::

 ":2&&&@!



7.



7. )   ,;

 

 /%2&&&@!

= ?.

;  . = .



@

)

     - "&(*

%2 % (:

 ) 

 

7

 .

 

 7 ,    ": # (:

 "&&&&&&@!

    , 



 2 &&   ) 

 $$*2&@!

 - "&(*

@

)

    )  #2&&@!

..

 ?.

;  . = .





.

  - #2%2/&  ": # (*



": # (:'

 : && 



,;



    )7 ,;

     - %:://*@:$@(:

 2 &&  - %:://:@(&@(:

 % &&  ": # (:

   CE  E ..

   

7,   

    .  



? 

     CE  E ..

    )

7.  ) 

.

    ?.

; . = .



 - #2%2/"

 ": # (*



": # (:'

 # && 



7.   ?.

; 

  

 

 "& && 

 

  ..



 #2&&@!'

)  

7 ": # (: ,   4

   "# / (:

,

  

   . ,  .; 7 7

4

   ) 

6 - #2%2/2  #& # (:

 / && 

 ?.

; . = .



@

)

    ) 7  , ,

 #(&( :&

 - "&(*  



7.   ?.

; ,  7

 .

) 

.

? "/ / (( - #*:"%*  #" # ((

 # 2& 



C )  

,;

 )  .



7. ,  7 .  .

) 

) 

- "&(*

7

) ?.

; . = .



@

)

    

 .

 

7 ?.

; . = .   

 ": 2&  ,;

B  ) 

  0     ,;

- (/:%

 

%2 / (*   ,

 "%#&&&@!

 %$ 2 (*  0   

    *  

 %2&&&@!



.

 0   

)



 0   + ; 

 0   -



 0    ) .

7

  0   . =

 

   ,





 " &&  

 - (/:%

 0  

 2&&&&@!

   ,;

- (2:#    %$ 2 (*

.

     

  %$ 2 (*



 % 2&   " && 

.

 

   

.

 )

7, 

!":  )

    7

 H  0  



   .

  )  0   ,.

  , - **#%:"

 " " ((

 2"&&&@!

**:""&  " " ((

 2&&&@!

  7

5 )  



 

7



 ( % (( 

- (/:%

 0   ? $ % ((  0   ,.

 

.

 " &&   



,    " " ((  

7.  7

5   ,;

  

- "&:#*

 0   ,

 ; 7   H

.

7 ,  ,7

 %$ # ((

  .

?

) 

 .    0    

   ,;



 " && 

 .

 

7  0   4 , ) 

5



 .

 

7       

 ,





, 

 .

 

5



)  



? .



 )   !

  , 

  

 ?



   .. .

 , 

 .  )

  %&:

 

  .

G.

 

.  

.

 

  "%&!

4   /%& 4 . )     

   /*: /*( 4  . )   

5





  /:"

4 . )      ) .

 ) 5



  

  /::! 4 

"'



,

 

%'

 "$/:

 . )   

5



)  )7

.

    

)   E     

.

 ) )  

  )

7  .  

 



 E.

 **  

.

  .7  

 )





1   

 . = .   



    )

)     .   ,.

  7 

 ) 7

 .

    

 

  

  , )

:& 7

 

  "$(*!(( 



  %&&"

4

)  ,

  .

 ) , :( 7 5 ) ) , (% 7  ) .

  "%&!

4   /%& 4

 

%'



   

 7 1     

 

 %'

 "$/: ,.

 7

,   ..

  .

 .

   ,

,

.

.

.     ,   &"

7 , .7 E  7   ,  ,

7



    .7

7    

 )

.

 

.

.

  &"

7 4

 ,.

 

 5 7  

;



 )

;

 ,  7  , )7



 .

1  

  0    )   ) ) 



 

     .

 7

 2&&&&@!

     4

 ,.

 



) , $:

7

,!  , 

 )  .



 

,.

, ;    .7 , 

, 1  

 ;  )  



;

  .

? 

  7  

.

 ,



;

)   "$/$ .7 ,   ,  ?

  7   , )7  )

7

  )



 ) ,       

 )   .

4

 )  



7 ) , (& 7



 )  

,.

7

 

 1  

 <5 >;

,.

  7   H  , )

:& 7 7    ?

  7   

;

1   

 !

      



 

 4

,.

 

  .



5



, ,;

.

7



7   

)7 ) .

?

  7 



      ,  4

 ,.

 



 

,  

..



      

 

 ) 

 "$(*!"$((

.7 )   ) 

  .



5



  , 7

   H  7 ) ? 

  7   

     



    

 

 



 ) 4

 

   

 



  7 ,   



 

.  ## 7 7    .

   7 



7 ,B  G4

  %'

 "$/: 

       &"

7 4  

,    

  

  .

)  .  7

 ) 7   , 

,

)  

  /

,

?

 

   !

'

7  .

,

 

 7

,'

7  , ,5



, ?

 ,5    

,

?

  

    )7 B 3 &

 @ C "* "" %&%"

%"&  D ;

)@ I@- D  , I@-