State Of Haryana v. Mehfuj Ali And ORS.
) $$$
#+"
,"
$)A;<A)A5334 /4$32$5354 "%&*1/2(5354 $$$$$$&& +#$
!" #$ B$$ #&"#
) @ 9
#%
$
$
$-
$
"& '# ($)$
&& $ $$
$$ * !("+, ,*& ! -!'*!.
) ' ("+, # !.
("+, #&"$/$ " 0 &#&& !#&"1 .!#
".* "" /2$34$5336 &##" 1 " ""!! ##!# ". 7"
,8(9 ( :
1 !,, #"!
$2(""3;$3<$5333( ( .!#" " ,!#634A?/53A "
"! "(/2<37# ( ( = =8 !, !9 & (:,> !"$ $:+(
#&" &#&& .!# ,, #"?#&"#*
!( * *9 " ' $
5$
$$
$:#,"" #* ,*& !A *"
" 71 " ,#"8# ! . ! ;$<$5333 *!.
!##!# # 7#!,",#"8'& ,:
:! ,, #" !1 6 6 C # &! &# ,, ,$ !
,! ": !, "!. #,( ( !".($-$(, (. "*#/3= #= ="#! +*#:!.
!.
. 1 '! . *:.!+! *!. $!##!#, ",,!+$ $
#1"
!(
#1"=##!##9 !" !"
#1"=# # #!##D
#1"# # 7"!#8 "
## " )!( A!A :
:
* 9 " * A!A : *$ ' E 9 (
#1"=# " 1 *! " !# :! !" #"
## !$$ # 7#!, ",#"8$ "1 #*#+ !*# #:
+# #",*
& * *$ . ! 7 8 " * A." 1"
!(
*"A,*& ! : *!*! # # 7#!, ",#"8 ! +! . " ! &# "
!A :# ## ",#"1 !
. * + " .!+* , ":! *!.$ #!
! ( #!" &## * #!" *!*! * ,! " ##!
!." !. & #!, "* 1!#!."*"
" *":$ ",#"=#
#1"=##!## 7)=8"
#1"=# # "1 =#:!
!7==8,! ""* *"!.. "1. #(:
!
#1"=# " 1 7==8 "
# #1"=# #!##=
#1"# '& "*"!. . " !.# *$ 1 " * # 1 !,!"( ", #"D#
#1" & *( #!. : " '
1,':
.+ !* "*,, $ = ,*& !=#* A." " ,.!'= =
+! . " ! " !" ,+!, , ,, #" " ! 7,*& !=# ,$8*'!.&*!#(1+! # .!+*A,, (1 :" * #&! ,, ," ,#"=#
#1"=# "1 *!"
#1"D##!#=#
#1""
##=#( "1 *!'
' ",#"
*!*! *$ ,*& !=# *! " ! " #!"
" "*" ,, #"$ 1 1 /FA/< "# &! ,, , ,*& & !=# * A."A 1"
! : +! . " !" *!. !#!#
!,, #"$ ( #!",, #"A& ## " !* # "'
' # 7#!,",#"81 *!. #1 "7=)8 " "" ##
#.!+1! , ! "( !"*"
" #1 ! ""
# !# " ,*& !
!=# * ." # # : # ",#"$ 7 ,*& !=# * ." !*"
,*& ! " !# *! 1 #! ! (" :#! "!#, ##!.
. *$ <(5333( "4%33&$*$ ("
###*##.+! & ,*& !=# # !.
1( #!. # =# ,"!! :# ,!!, " > #!. !.
1!* ,*& !=# ' ! *$ @<A *"A, *& !" !#*! **1 # .
1 *"
" .!. + !, ( ( !#&#( !# #1 .:! #* &## : +! . " !$ , !. ( #: "" 1" # 7#!, ",#"8 " "
#: " # "
" =G ="
!! =G- =$ !*( !=##!## ! "9!"#!
!""
##: #&# $:#+!" ,, #" ,#&! " . "( ! , ! & ( '! " ,*& !D##!# #"
*":"* *"#"1, # ",#"
"
",,!+"
"(":# +!.!## $
6$
.
.
#!A& & , ,, , , :# &&"$ > # & ""
"A1" # :#&&"
"$ #A** ""1" # :# # # . ,"
,"$ *& -!#, :# # '$ $ *#:! ###:,""$,, #":
:#"$ ,*& ! !+#!.!(, .!# ,, #"
!( *9 (*!"
"
!#:! !": #&&""& &! !! $
4$ !, ,& !# 1 " ,!634A"! "/2<3!#! 1 H, #!+ 1 ##!( ( ,#:# # ,**!" ##!! "
,, #"&##:"!,"
" &&1 "##!#
".$ F$ ,#:#,**!"(&!* *,!,# ",!634A "! "(/2<3:# ".!
!# #!" ,, #"$ :# 1#> , ." " !##,!( :
!, & "".
! ", !*"! $ <$ *"7,*& !8 &&"! :!##1H //$/5$5333""
"&#"1 *( * *!!.F,, #":""
" 1# **" && !,! &#,
! "#,!6/I!*!
,"
"( /I;6(1 "" $##! # ".9 +!""""
" 6/$/$533/$ ;$ 1#!#", *#, "&!*A,!,#& !# 1
"#,!634 4A"/53A +!.1 ".!# I,, #"( ( :, . " A "/<$/5$5335( :
!, & "".
! ", !*"! $
2$ &#, ! ! # && !# .!# H*!" @/ ! !.
" #1 ( @5 * # # #1 ( @6 * 9 * $$( (
@4 )$ '#
!"
( @F !# 9 * #1 @< *"
" ,*& !( @ @; 1"
!( @2 ! :! . !( @I "!& & !.
1#&, ,( @/3 *9 *)#* *" @//9 *$$A $$ $ I$ #*# ,, #"
" " ,! 6/6 " !*! ,"
(/I;6:,"":
1 1 ,, #" +"!" &#, ! .
.!# " + & "" ! !,,$
+ #" *$ # :#+ ##""
"! A"1 *": :#+"*"
""* $ # #1 """ !**"! *!. !" # 7",#"8. *# +##&"* !# # &# " 1
" 1 =# :!$ ##" ,, #" 9
)!("
##(
!"9! "!+ + *! *!*! ! # "
#1"$G# ( ,, #"# " #!, # " ,,!+" "
!.
. !!*(
#1" 7
!8 :" &* * #," *!. :
!, :# :" 1 !# !.!$ !#( , !*"( "
" # " &##"("# # 1#> , ,**!"# !,!"$ /3$ !. 1 &!# " '!. ! ,#!"! +!", ,"( "##!# ,> !" ,, #" , .#*".
.!# *$ //$ , , &#&& $
G ", # # 1*!## "
"%A !$ &#, ! # &+" !# ,# 1" # ": #1 " 1 .!# ,, #" * !( *9 " ' $ !! " *$ # 7#!, ",#"8 :# "
,!, * *#,#( :
!, :# # * ##* " ,, "* " ": #&,!!, !# " " &+" ," 6 C C * #&!"
:! #&,"*"* *,, $ !!! *$ # 7#!, ",# "8 "!" :! ! #+ # *!. " " ,!, *#,#( ( &# *&! " #,!//6A +!",,(/2;5!#. !# ,, #"&##"! "1 &# *&!( ,, #""!" H*!",:!## # *! ,"!,! ,* ! , ## H*!! @< *",*& ! ( @;1"
!( @2 !:! . !$ !+ ! &#,#( +!", , "1 &#, !!# ,"!1 "1 ! +1 $ +$ :#+!",," "*"":"/F"# # &! "
# 7#!, ",#"8$ $ :# #&,!!, &+" ," :
! ,, #" " # ! * ."A ( # !# 1 ""# "!", , ! ""#'"1"
! ' * !
! #$ +!$ #& #*,*& !
*"( ,, #"
" :&# * !* !,!"(1 !# !.," # : ,, , #"*"!" #+ ! # 7#!, ",#"8#!,
:&#! #$
+!!$ *$ # 7#!,",#"8 8"!" *!*! *( ( #&# *&!
"#,!//6A +!"
",,(/2;5 #1": .!# ,, # " +!!!$ ,, #""!" " +!",&+ !,## # "!"1
&# *&!! 1, ##H*!!&#, ! :!### 1 "!. ", +!",$ ( ,"# !."!#, ,!634A "! "(/2<3",!//6A +!", ,( /2;5 ! " ! & &# ,#$ &# &#&& 1 :"$ /6$
, ,( " , # &&!
!. #&"#?,, #"
" .
# ! # ".*", "# +!", "1 &#, ! # !.
1 &&,!" 1 " ! :
! ,> !!. ,, , #"( ( &# &#&& 1"!#*!##"$ /4$ @
+ " ", #
&!#"& #" :
," ,# $ /F$ " ! ,> !" ,, #"( +!" !*& ."
"
".*" +&! ".* "## "%A
!"# $
%
"
&'(
)
*!
#
+
%
,
-
.
,
$
%
/
&01#
"
&'3-
&01# "
&'4 ,
&01# # "
-
$
&01# "
$
&'(
$&'4 , & &'3 -
$
&0 1# "
%
!/&
78 !/& 56
%
)
&01#
"
"
"
&'4 , , &'3 -
$
9
7 / &'(
: !"#:$ &'4 ,
!"# &'3 -
!"# $
!"# $
%
%%
/
%%
7
-
.
.
%%
% % $
!"# !"#
9
& &
; 8
$
$ $
$ $
5
7 /
&'(
-
.
)
)
$
/
!
&'4
,
&'3-
.
5
& & $
&'4 ,
-
. ,
<-
. =
# #!8*#*
,
<-
. =
6>%6?
&'4
,
- -
. $
$
) ,
$
$
$
/
!
/
,
78 !/& 56
&'(
-
.
) ,
<
=
"
&'( (
$&'4 ,
&' -
-
.
"
%
&'4 ,
# +
-
.
2
@
,
$
-
.
$
-
.
$
&'
'4
*
&'4
-
.
)
6>%6?
&'4
3
-
.
)
3
-
.
$
"
9
-
.
%
$
&'3 -
,
(
$
&'(
&'4 ,
-
.
6>%6?
"
#
#!8* #*
% )
"
-
.
&'(
% /
)
$
&'3 - -
9
-
.
$
$
-
.
-
.
7
"
"
)
$ $
)
$
&'(
$&'4 , &'3-
- +
A !"#
*
# )
!"# 2
-
.
$
&'(
&'4 ,
% $
&'(
$
$
&'4
,
-
.
)
)
* $
&' -
-
.
% %
% %
&'4
,
*
&'4
&'4
/
% %
,
-
. "$
&'(
&'3 - $
% %
&'4
,
- -
.
6>%6?
B%?
#
$
$
< , =
%
6>% 6?
$
& &
)
.
%
&-8 !/&;
.
&-8
7 C !/
,
$
$
"
)
$
&'(
$ &'4 , , &'3-
)
8
,
- -
/
$ $
7 C
&'B 8 ) ,
/"
&'B8 ) ,
,
% ((>>> %
*
%
&'
'(
$&'4 , &'3-
( ((>>>
)
<,
=
*
D
7
$
$
$
( 66
7
%
>B%;
6>%;
"
1 9
9
% %
%
E
/<$ )$
'# !"
( "!, !, (+*#&! (9 :
! &&!. # @4 ! !#"&#!! # " 3;$3<$5333( .
. :! )$ '#
! ,"
,"&#A** H*!! ""1" *$ # 7#!
,",#"8:! !#!"" !9 !$ ",#"(+!", & # * &7H
8$ !.*!#:#&#! !*1# $ #**#!!.:#&# 1,'"!.
#!" ,$ :#, *!. #(# :# #&##"!# :$ :# !. "
,'$H *'!
:## 1"$ /;$
!# ,## H*!!( #"
" ! !# ,, 1. !#,!,!"# , * *!, * !# &&H ( "
#* # ! ,1* ,*& " !#, !,!"#$ !# ,, &##!1 1! ! ",#" #
+!. ,**!"
" # !,!" /5 <$<$53 333 1,# *!.1. !# " $!#, , &#,,**!#
!,!"1, #"&##!$ ,#! "" #,,!+( !!#, # "&##!! #,!$ /2$ #* ",:! #&,, #" !#+ , !!#"
,# *&!&!#!$ ,1*,*& ". & !#,!,!"#$ /I$ H
!# ,& *!, H H*! & " # & !# # &#: (!.
.+&#!!+#1*, ,*& ". &!#,!,!"#$ 53$ H
)!# ,&!> #& (:
!.!# , * J !#*' +! , ""1"K( (! #1:!#L !#
*' #!" "K$
.!# , *L:
*1:
:&!# *# , * *'#! !#+! , && + 1 ! !,"K( ! # 1 :
:! # L ##!1! ! "
#.
! ,'K$.!# , *L &&, #" K(! # # 1 *!" # L ##!1! ! "
#.
.
! ,'K$ .!# , *L# #!." +!.1, # "1+! ,&!# * # # , 1!. , #K( ! # 1 :! # L ##!1! ! "
#.
! ,'K 5/$ H
!# ,& .
#!& "#& !# .
#!& ( (
'LK!# & ,(:
!+" # # *9 ( ,
(""1" # " .
. !:! !(!# !.$ 55$ H
!# ,&!> # &"! !#&(.!# , *L !#*'#+! ,
""1"* +,!+"
" : "#1 !# ## : &#!! . "1 1" $%A!+"& $ , &!
,': ":! !.$ !+! . "!, !,!#H,& ""H*! "" 1" !#!*!# "1 ! "! :#,*& "H*!!K(! #1:!#L ' :! , " 1 " #!" "K$ .!# , * L&& , # " K( ! # 1 * !" # L ##!1! ! "
#.
! ,'K$ 56$ H
!# ,& # * * & " # & !# &( ( .!# , * *L*! !# "1 !,K(! #1*!"
" #L # # K$ 54$ ,*& !A *" :
:
! &&!. # @< ! !# # "&#!! ## " !##!#:#* *!" !1 6C C # #.$
".!+# !,!":!, #! *!.$, ! ":#
1* !:
:" ,'$!A :#*! * *1# #" ##"
,, "*"": #: # 1!. , ! "$ ,, #" "1 "*"!. . "1. # !"9!#: # !"" '!
$ "1*'!."* "#. "!.#"!D#$ $ #" !# # "* ."A
"+!#!" # ,, #" ! + +! .( # & &, ( " "+!#" * ## # # 7#!, "
",#"8 "*" " :8$1 6 * # &! " # 7#!,",#"8( !#1 ! : ! !##!# ! # 1!. $ " # : "' 1,'
'
##" !
!#.!+" , ! ":$ ( ( &!" !"#( !# "* ."A :
# ,, #"
" " " ,##! ##" $ ,, #"
" &" !"* *"" ,, , " !# ". ."A "
" * ."A ## "
" : " * ! "*" ! "
, #$ 5 C * # &!
" # 7#!, ",#"8( , ,, #"1 ! "**!+!#!" !
#"'
1,' !*!*! * *":
! +!. #( ( " " ! " !"*"
"$!#* ." "
" . +! . " ! ! " " * *!. 9!( #!#
!,, # "" #,, #"&# ##'" !*' !##!# ! ##!, # !#1 "" #
+* !"*"$ $ #"
" ,!+!.!*!( : #,, #"
" "( # : !##!#A # 7#!, ",#"8:# !."" ," :##: 1#!"#(# "
" !:# "! # :$ $ !*(
!( !(9!""
##: #&"
" *!!.,, # ": # $
5/$
@A ;71"
!8:
! &&!.
.!:!##1H"&#" # :#* !" !6C#. $ !,!":!, #: .!+! * !.$, ! ":#1* :" ,' !$ ,, #"# ""*"":!, #!$ "1. #
#1"D# # #!## " . " !.# !
#1"# * "
## " 9 !$ $ !*! . " !
!.# : # "*"" *!$ ! # !#"
" "*" " ,, :
# !* ,* + # 7#!,",#"8 & *$ :"# &!" # 7#!, ",#"8( " . " *!. #!# ! ! +! ." !$ " # ,, #"
&## " !*': # 7#!," ,#"8(## !#1"# !"*"": " 1*$ " # 7#!,",#"8 8 !."" # ,, #"&##$ ,':##: $ ,, , #"&## +, ,!+ '! " # ! ,,!:! "*"":
:$ 55$ , ##AH*!!( #&,!!, , > #! 1 ",( #" ! *!. +H" *!. #!# ,, #"A !( ,, #"&###'
'" !*' # 7#!, ",#"8:! !
!*1, ## :#, ! " ##!$ 1" *,, "
" 1.!+ *$ #"*"". "1. #". "!.# ",#"=#
#1 " "1 #" !:!+# #$ 56$ &'%3 3 <- = :
! &&!. ! :!## 1H #" *!. # # 7#!,",#"8:## * *!M"6C#.$ !,! ":!, # +1.!+$, ! ":#1 :" ,'$ *!. ,, #"&##"*"". "
"1. #". "!.#* * *$1 6C * #&!" #
7#!,",#"8( !
! ! #1!. $ " # : "'
1,' ## " ! !# .!+ " , ! ":$ $ ( &!" ! "#(
#1" " :
#,, #" " " ,##! ## $5* #&! " # 7#!,",#"8(,, #"1
!"* *!+!#!" ! #"' 1,'
!*!*! #":
! +!. ! # #( " # " ! !"*"$1 /F"# # &!" # 7#!,",#"8( !# ".+! ." !! ""
*!.9!( #!# !,, #"" # ,, #" &# ## #'" # ' # 7#!, ",#"8 # #!,# !#1 "" #: + * !"*"$ #" , ,!+!.!*!( : #,, #""( #: !
# #!# :# !. "" , , " ,' :# #: $ $ 54$
@AI I "!&!.
7!! 8:
:
! &&!.!:!##1H H #" ,"!. #* *"A,*& !( : & ,, ,, ,$ ""1":# !.! #,, #"! +" ,$ .
#!& :#&& "$!#&," & ,"
" &&"!> # &7H$ 8$. &# **,"
,"$ 5F$ !, & # ,"# :# # # 7#!,",#"8 8 "
#1"
"A ! : #!. #& * &# ,, #"A !( (: ,# #!""&!! ,!/53A "!
"(/2<3!#&& !,1 1 ! &#,#$!, &#&& !# ! ".!# ,> !
#&"*
!( *9 " ' , . "
",!#634A "!
"(/2<3 3(!: "1 +& "
, +&+!#!#
"! "
"(/2<3" +!",,( /2;5&&"
"!,! &#,#$
! ,
!*-"./#0(1<6='
.
.
$
$ $
:
:$
!/
7
%
$::
&
$6F(6<3 6F(6= <='
/
:
! 2 3!
!"#$ $%&'()*+0$(*/*-"./#0(1G'
9
.
$
$ $
1 1
4'50+0()*+ + % 7
$ :
:
>B%; & 1 <B? 63(>=H 5<$ (:!!#1"*!"
"1 !# ( :
!."!#, ,!634A "! "(/2<3( ! "! &#,##& +!",""
,"$ 5;$ #
#! ,+!,! ", ,!634A "! "(/2<3( :!.##! !."!# 1#1 !# "%A <=
.
@ @ <=
@ <=
.
@ <=
@ <=
:@ 52$ , ".* " # !$%
& ( 1D1 &* #" :! ": " ,#$ + &! #* &"
," # #
"%A IF "
/
>B%;$&1
D9 @ D9 @ @
;
$
# $
$
$
)
J 1 1 < =$ - + D @ @ 1 $ <>63= F 11 6$
,.
- )
+ .
$ >> 11 *C 1 B6H
.
$
)
$
>B%;$&1 6>
>B%;$ &1
) &
"
$
.
"
&
&
$ 6F(6
7
$
$
1 C < =
$6F3<
B( 6F3=
1
KK
&1$
BF3% 66 # $
$
$
"
)
C 1 F6 18 "
C 1 A
&1$ /
$
)
"
G I6$
$
)
$
$
/
)
$ $
L <=
) @ <=
D9 @ 6 "
)
C 1 $
$
& &
&
$
&1
& < = =
$ 6F3(<
B6F3(=;
$
>B% % ;$ & &1
&1$
6
1")&0() 0"60"#(570$
; 8 .
G "
$
'
) )
'
9
;
% 2
)
M
M
%% M
)
"
$
"
$
E 6B "
I, # G, %
) :
0
*
1 $
>63
B> ?>
"
6FFF >6( ($
$
1 8
;
>6F F $ 466?
>B%;$&1 1
6? 1
$
.
"
$
$ I E
I
E
$
"
!
9
$
$
"
/
.
)
1
/
I E
6( "
A
1 $
+ 8 .
&.
$ <>>>=? 11>4$
% ;
% 6?N E
9
.
)
/ % %
$
/
&/
) )
9
9
"
$
$
$
E
)
1 8 .
&.
.
$<>6?=( 11B44 64 "
$1
I I E'
$
I/
)E
9
63 '
O
.
$
$
M
66%;
!
"
$
66;$!
G I66%;&
%'
9
.
$
$ $
1
!/
% 7
$ I
E@
>B%;
& 1 <B?6 63(>E@ 6F "
1 $
;
;
C
# $ <>6 6=66 11?F$
A
66%;
!
>B;&1
G I6F
I
E
$ )
.
"
$
$
66%;
>B%;
; &1$
/
>"
$
$
E > "
$
$
66%;$!
"
6 "
$
66%;$ !
$
$ "
"
/
>B%;$&1
$
$
$
$" 1
6$1&16F4
$
9
/
6$1&1$6F F4
$
"
I
E$
/
"
$
1 9
$
"
1
)
$
$
$)
>B%;$ &1
66%;$!
/ / / / / / B "
"
>B%; &1
)
A
$
"
A
I I
E $ $
# $
>B%;$ &1
9
?"
"
$
>B%;&1
$
.
$
$
I
E
M
I
E@
"
J -
# $<>6?=64 11 1 B>?$
# $<6FF F6=6 1146H P P P P P 3
$
>B%;$&1
66%;$!
A G 36
>B%;$&1
)
3 "
/
>B% % ;$ &1 *
$
$
66;$ !
3 "
G E
>B%;$&1 1
O
E"
/
I/
)E
3B
>B%;$&1
)
A
"
A
I
E $
$
3?
>B%;$&1
66% ;$ !
$ $
3(
$
$" 1
6$1 &1$6F4 $
9
/
6$ 1&1$ 6F4
$
"
. I
E@
/
"
$
9
$
34 "
1
)
"
$ )
>B%;$&1
66%;$!
$K 5I$
"!#& " ,# ! &# ,# # 7#!, ",#"8 :# * *!" ! 1 6 C # 1 " !,!"$ ,
#" !#"
&!#!.( (*!. 1!!#,#
" $ #& # * &H $ H*!!1)$ '#
!"
(> #
&H$ )( G &H$
( , #" !#"
,# *&!& &!#!$,1*,*& ".
. &!#,!,!"#$ :# # #: !. "
"1" ",#":
!,
!"!, &##!1! !"
"
#.
!$
!# *' : # " #!" " ",#"$ !# !"!, ",#" :# ,!1 "*!!#" &!#$ #*# @ @< *" ,*& !( (
@;1"
!
!( @2 !:! . !:
1 ( "
" 1 ! ", ,#"+ " :#" *"":" !# "!#,&,!
,##H*!! 1+ :!###$
# "*"": !#&+"! &#,#$
# 7#!,",#"8 8 "!" :! ! ; # *!. !$ :! ! 6 C # "
"*!!#! &!#$ 63$ & # :
,""+ +!",(!$", *#: # # :
&#, ! # 1 1 &+ !# ,# 1"
" #1 " 1 .!#
#1" ", #"* ! $ 6/$ ,, "!. ( +"!,,> ! > #&"$/A
!!#9
:+$ +"
"!,,> ! > #&" #$ 5 " 6 * * 9 " '
$ ,#> ,( ( ,, #"?#&" $/A !!# ".
! ,**!!. , & !# 1 " ,!634A "! "(/2<3"!#,+!,"
" ,,"!. $ 65$ +!
!: 1+( !# !"# #*!! &#&& "
" #*!#& :"$ 66$ ,, #"?#&"$/A !!#"!,"1&"
,"
" ! , #" 1 !# 63$3I$5354 !. > * #,$
64$
&"!.&& !,!#(!( ##""!#&#"$ %' " &*1/2(53 (& % & " 354 @ #&'!.?#"
@ &1 %#? %#?