Kuldeep Singh & ORS v. State Of Haryana






    
  



 !!



  
 ""##  $%    "  
 & 


 ""## $%   
  "   


'

 

    ""## $%   
  "       


 

   
 (

) *
+, *  ) *%+ .! /%,  ""## 

) /%#.! #,  "!! 

 & 

 +"#!

) $!

 1!, * !  ) 2* ) !,  ""## 3

)  +# )#!4, 1, 56



 

 ##  ! %0 ++

!, 6 ! ++

! !! 9:%!#, :% -!    !+"! + , , , 8+ !+"

  ""#  ! 0!

 ! -



*!
 3<

& # !! # *! 2%0, /!#, - " - ! !!

% #-!

+!  0 -

0!

 +    "% !8# % *! 

% *!

  (
5  !

!!

0!

  % 1% + 0 -

"

  "% !8# % *!



(
# 5-, %0 -

!, # !# 2%0 "  ! :%!# 0!

 % 5"

, 0- /%#- , 20!

, * + 20 1%!



:% ! !!

 0!

  ! 0 -

  "% !8# % *!



(
,    ! % 0 !0% !+"! + #! , !+"   ,

 % +"!

%+ 

9, , 8!

 %# "6+ ,    % ! % 0 % !0% !+"! + 6 ), # !# 2%0 " , %0 "   !

 -



!+"   !+"! + = !

%" 6,

! #-!


, +!

" 0 -

% *!

  (
, 8! !+"

!   +"!

%+  &

9 ,

 %# "6+ +% !+",

! !+" %   !+"# !+"! + = !

%" +  ##    %"  %

% #6  ! %", 8+ 00! -

! !! :% -!    %", !+"

+, 8+ # !% 0!

 ""# 3
 

8  !
% & * 56 -## +"#!

(%

8+ 00! ! :%!#, # !! # *! 2%0 ,  %,  # !% 0!

 ! "! ""#9!!

8  !
%  %!

"  6  ""# 8  !
%, +! 5"

/%#- 20!

% %+ 8 % ! "!  ! !, 8+ "#

 # % # ; ,

    ""# +!

!

   8  !
% 8+ 8,  !+! %

!

"#$% &'

'

0 ! "%!

 !

""# >, -! ?=(9

!0 !

+"#!

!

+ , (%



0!%#%! @

<

&

+ 0, 8


!"#  

(+.! #! (++ + % +"#!

 "6 # + 6 #  .! 

/   

*%!

2 *!4, ! !##0 )0, +" 6!

!"# 8% # + 6 - 8 0!

! " 5!

"- ("

#! * % 

;

  0 !# % +"#!

!%

  #!

!##0 )0 !##0
4% A 5 # 0-! !"#  ! " !!

B1B  8% '9'

& )

"- ("

#! * %  - +!

84 % !# 5 - +"6   5! %  % +"#!

C

("

#! * % 

 %,

%

! 8% 6 -##, 

20!

2 *!4 9 )0,  - % . %, + #!

!4, 1 !

 !

 " !

+"#!

, #-!

#! 2%0 

*%"

- #!

1 !D 1% + 

/%#- - #!

!D +! 0-  /%#- 

5"



20!

20 #! ; 

/%#- 1%!

#! ##% 

/%#- * + 

/%#- + #!

#!

!   # 20!



*%"

+

 # 0-!  ! " , #!

#!

  20!

 /%#- ! ##4 * % 8 %0 #  ! 5 %#

8 " @

!

!

!, +"#!

, 8 !"# 

"- (+.! #! (++, .!   +

 !0 8  ! 6 1%!

#! ##%  * +  %%  ("


#! * % 5"

 20 %0 # ("

#! * %  #-!

#! 2%0 ! 1 !

 ("

#! * %, -! - #!

 -! %4    1% + - - #!

!

#! +

#  + ("

#! * % - - #!

0 !

#! 0 !

8#-

#   ("

#! * %

+ !+, /%, + ("

#! * %, + %

 %  #!

("

#! * %, - - #6 -6#!

  !+

+! 0 #!

8#- /%  +"#!

, 8 !"# 

"- (+.! #! (++ # 0-! .!   + -  ("

#! * %, 0- 0 #!

8#- +"#!

(%

5-, +"#!

, #%4!#6  1%!

#! ##%, * + /%#-  20!



  +"#!

!4

!  

 4 ! !+ +"#!

 % +"#!

!0 - ! %  -!#  !

 %6, ! 0%



!

    !+# %# % ;%" % 

-6 " # 0-! ! "! -" -! 

"

 !

 ! 

!, , ,  8

  %

+ !+, + ""# !##0 0  " < % !+ " +"#!

B. % %  +!

-6 ! %

   /%#- %  8    %+!

#!:%

 +!

0 %   E6

<

& %!

+ !+, # 0-!

"- ("

#! * %


  +"#!

0!

 !!! /%#-  20!

F"

!,  -  = 0 -  8%!

# 0%0 8-

+"#!

, /%#-   ;! "! - " %"

% ?= *" , *-



* *% ! !##0 )0 /"!

0%0 0!

! ! , #-!

   !

"!6 ++

 !

 ++

8.  -!# %#6 + #6 -"  % .%! ("

#! * %   + /% 5 # 0-! % ?= *"  #!  ("

#! * % "  4 !+ 0 + "!#, 1%# + ;  ! 4 .% ("

#! * % !!# "!#, /!#

!- !!# !!

 4!

.% ("

#! * %  1 5"!#, /!#, 6 4 !+ .!

 5"!#, (!#

!- - !!

5 - 0 +!   +"#!

-
4  0!

+ 6 + 9+!!

#!

% ?= *"  !##0 )0 .% ("

#! * % @

% 84 .!

 5"!#, (!#, +"#!

- + ("

#! * % %%+8 .%! @

8!  ! ##0! , > ?G(9

- 0!  !0!

 -  +!

%!

% !0! +  -!   :% "!

0 ?= (H 0 % %0 ! "#

?=(G "# % - ""  +0!

#

 # ! "#

?= (1 - 0 "" " ++ " 0!

  ("

#! * % 

;

 %  - "%


0 !  " " ++ ", %  - %  .%6 -!  ++

%  % !! % 

!

6 %

% %!

% !0! % "   0
&()*+# +%&*   +"#!

!0!     ,  ! ""  !% " % *!

'
(
, 8  #
++!#
% %,,+ ! $% ))'+&#* #
++!#
%   !!

" @ ! " %0
++!#  -

&, ++! %  !# 8  # *!
% $+ !% $ $% ))'+&#* # !# 2%0 - 0



&

 0!

 %    "% !8# % *! 

    *!

<,



(
,   -

0 8+!

"%  %, 6 !

"# 0%!#6, #!+ !# ; , "%!

- ##

# !

%"" ! 

 "%!

=+!

+

-! ,   # (%8#! (% # "%!

!

 *%8:% #6, % =+!

% *!

 
(
, ="#!

!%+  -! "" 0!

 +

"%!

 ;6  ! "%!

##0! , "#

 , #!+ # !+"#!!

  =+!

% -! , #   !

$

% &- .)%

$$)& )$)&')$)'/0 12  13  &'

 14

& (C

- +

! !!

%!

=+!

! !

! , !

0 -! 

+"# +!6 "!% + 

-!!

0, !

!8% !+!

6 # % #-!

+% , #!!

0 !

8#-

   ("

!0

!+!

6 # % 1% + +% , #!!

8!

8#-

#  + ("

8! !8%

!+!

6 # % , +% , #!!

0 !

8#-

#   ("

), !0 +!

!+!

6 #, +% , #!!

#!

8#- ("

!0 !  # 8#- " !+ %#

 ("

##!

-

/% " !+, ##

("

 !+, ! ! !  8, 8% +! 6 #! #!

8#- /%

 !0 + ), %0 0- ! ! !+ +" #! #!

8#- (C 8% ! !  !+# %

-6 - %, 8% 6 ! ! % 1%!

* + /%#- 20!

 !+ #!, + ! %

 
 :% #6, ! ! 8%0 0%

! %, + %6, ! 

!, -! # % # ! %



%++ ! ! # 8#- %", #!

 ("

"!#6 #-!

1% + % , +! ), " /% 8+!

#! #!

8#- +!

5-, (C .%!!+ " 6 % !4!

#!

8#-

 #  %#, % #-!

!4!

 0 !

8#- !  !,

 !0 4 "!!

(C

:%! 8!

"!!

(C, - .%!!+, -

 =+!

! !

! , +"##6 8

! ,  !+  ,

 "!%#6 +

-!!

), 8 (C

+  +"#!

, (C .%!!+, 8! " %+
  8!

%# #6, -

! "!!   !

  0#6 !+"!

+8##!!

0,

! "!#6 "!% + 

-!!

0, %  8 !0 ! "!#6 "!! ; ,

  , !+!

6 # !0  ! , +! #-!

-+ ! !! 0 -

% *!



% *!

  (
, 8

% # !# 2%0 8! 

% 1% + - 8

- ! !!

  % *!



(
, 8!%#6 !0 !+!

6 #  8+ +  !!%#6 "

'

%# !0 0  "!! (C (C, - %# -!  % , , !

0 !! 8+  0!

 

" 0 8! :% -! !+"!!

   !+"! + %",

, 

+!!

  !
%


+* !%* $)* ),)&* &' %&*)- )&.)$)5+.$) %()$+)* 66)$ +&+&#%

%1

*)' !5+&')$+&#.

 %1

*)',+$+&#.

 %1

*)' $& +&#.

 %1

*)'   !'))6  +&#.  7*+& )  ') ) *)'8  &'

 %&*)- )& .)$)5+.'$ 5&$) %()$0,),%*

< %!

% %!# 0!

% 1% + !0 % !#% + -! ?=(;

!0 -!

  !

0%!#, # -!##!

 % 6 8!,  ! "# ! !!

0, 4"!

!+, 0!

# "# -

#6 !+

:%  % 6 8!

%0 6 ++ -! ?=(;9

!0 !0 % !#% + % 1% + %

 ! :%! ! !6 !0,  +! !0 % %, -! !

8#6 

"  !# ), !

:% -! !, %0 6 ++ -! ?=(;9

!0  , -

8

8# 8#6 " 6 8!

- !!!%   !

%0 0+ +"#6  ! %, "

++ "4

 # 0 -

0!

  ! 1% + 8+ 0 #6 "

%!

% %!# 0!

%  !0 % !#% + -! ?=(I !0 -!

  !

0%!#, # -!##!

 % 6 0 !,  ! "# ! !!

0, 4"!

!+, 0!

# "# -

#6 !+

:%  % 6


0 !

%0 6 ++ -! ?=(I9

!0 !0 % !#% + % , %

 ! :%! ! !6 !0,  +! !0 % %, -! !

8#6 

"  !# ), !

:% -! !, %0 6 ++ -! ?=(I9

!0   -

8

8# 8#6 " 6 0 !

- !!!%   !

%0 0+ +"#6  ! %, "

++ "4

 # 0 -

0!

  !  8+ 0 #6 "

%!

% %!# 0!

% #-!

!0 % !#% + -! ?=(E !0 -!

  !

0%!#, # -!##!

 % 6 0 !,  ! "# ! !!

0, 4"!

!+, 0!

# "# -

#6 !+

:%  % 6 0 !

%0 6 ++ -! ?=(E9

!0 !0 % !#% + % #-!

%

 ! :%! ! !6 !0,  +! !0 % %, -! !

8#6 

"  !# ), !

:% -! !, %0 6 ++ -! ?=(E9

!0  , -

8

8# 8#6 " 6 0 !

- !!!%   !

%0 0+ +"#6  ! %, "

++ "4


 # 0 -

0!

  ! #-!

8+ 0 #6 "

%!

% %!# 0!

% +! !0 % !#% + -! ?=( !0 -!

  !

0%!#, # -!##!

 % 6 #!,  ! "# ! !!

0, 4"!

!+, 0!

# "# -

#6 !+

:%  % 6 #!

%0 6 ++ -! ?=( 9

!0 !0 % !#% + % +! %

 ! :%! ! !6 !0,  +! !0 % %, -! !

8#6 

"  !# ), !

:% -! !, %0 6 ++ -! ?=( 9

!0  , -

8

8# 8#6 " 6 #!

- !!!%   !

%0 0+ +"#6  ! %, "

++ "4

 # 0 -

0!

  ! +! 8+ 0 #6 "

&9)$)& )  -! 8 -

8, , 0 #6 "

++ !+#6

!

% %",

++!!

0    )'+

!(+')& )7 %*%$), )6%$8

 86  ("

- "% %"6,

<

&,  (+!

 5" (C <  (+!

"", "" -!  8=,

=+!

!

"

" ++ " -




("

-! ?=(22 !0 5 ! !

+4!

%"6

"

 ("

8 

!!

 !

  = .%! 


   


  
 
 
  
    



 








  

 
  

 



   
  




   "

#



  



 


$ 
 
  
 

  

  

%  

 

 


 

&
  


 


 
 



%  

  

     


' 

 
 

 




  

"

(
 )  )

     
 





 

'  #



   
  

% 



 

 


 

)

'
 

# 

)

    


  

 

 *



    +


'   

   

-


 
 .

 )

      

  

 



/
 

     




 "!

!

! !

+!  ("

,! +! :%# ++  .%!, 8+ !#, "

5 " = ++ .%! -! %#!+#6 % +! ("

%8# %0 % !+!

6 -"   , 8+ , %0 ++,   %  !

& ; , "4!

0 (C <

=+!

!  ! ,  !+#6 8#! ! %+, !! %# %   (C (C !+ !  :%!!


8!

"!!

%", "!##6 -



!  !6 -!

0 6 ++ 8

## 0,

-

#! =%#"6 "# 8

8#!, %!

% (C < %8. =+!

!



%## "
 8!

"! "%!

 "

!! %# % 8! "

+!# %

'

%# #6, !
% 8+ !

 !+ !

0 !! :% -!    %", 8+ !+"

% -! - -!##

4    ! ! %!

"  6  ""#, %# #6  !

""! ""# 8+ 8 !+

 )6%$

< ;%0, %!

% !0! ""# >  !  %0 6 ++, % ! 8# !

!+!

6 !+, 8!,  " "4 +

# # "#, -    +! # "#, *#0! -4!

 >*A 5-, *#0!

+4!

=+!

! 8# !

-"   , 8+  !+, 

#%! "!

!

8# !

, , 8+ !  ,  8# 0!

8# 0%"

, 9, 8# 0%"

.%!!+ /% 5-, 6, #%! "!

!

8# !

!

-" J

8# 0!

8# 0%"

, 9, 8# 0%"

!!+!

.% /%, -%#

-##  0%+ ! !

! :%!# " %  +



) *%&9%$'$ 5+&#.) /%()+&9)$)& ) 

+!

#%! % %+ , #%!!6 "!

! ! #6  !! !0!  ! +% , !#!

## >;) , "!#6 .%, , ! "! +!#6 ++8,  %!

,   +4!

0 ""! 8
 +!

0
 >;)  8# !

J %!

-" J     *#0! +4!

"!

!

!# "%!

%8# "%!

5-, !

>;)  ""!

, .%!!+ /%, 8+

 ##  ! "! +!#6 ++8 %# #6, +!! -

!

8#6 !#! *#0! +4 8
 +!

09+"!
 8# !

J !

-" J    >;)  ; , #%!!6 "!

! " 8# 0%"!

0 8# !

J !

-"    

#8# 8# 0%"

 8# 0%"

!!+ 

0  ,  ! 8+ !# ! :%!#  ! -%#  !

!#6 8+ !# ! :%!# 8+!

+, 8% #6  , ""! ##! +!#6 ++8 , 9, +!#6 ++8 .%, *#0!   +4!

+"! 8
 +"! 9 +!

0, +4!

"!

!

8# !

J !

-" J   , 

8# 0!


8# 0%"

!  8# 0%"

!!+ .%, -!

; ,    !

* (% .8,  !

4"

#! %# > %!

""! +"#! , 0!6 !
% ! -!  +! "6 ! ! ! 1 # (#! (% .8, # !+! %0 **(J  +!  !
+"#! !! %", 8 -! !+, 0!6 !
% )'+

!(+')& )+&$)*6) %9+&: $)'15+&)**+&')$ $ 

"%% %#,

(C , % #-!

% +!  8+ %8. +!# =+!

!

(C

- %!

% +4!

=+!

! !

! "

)A ?=(A, !# !

  = .%!, 8+

! 8 %!

"

/% 

(
 )  )


 
1   


2


   


 



 



 



    3) 


 


% 

4  



"


 
 


  )


 
1   


  


    #

 

 
 

 

% 

4 



)


 



 )  "

 



  

  
   +
 



 


 

%  

 

 
  


 

   +


% 

4 




 
 


 ) 

    

  


   






' 




 




 
   




 

  

% 

4 



#


 


 
1 
 

  




  

 3) 


 



 



          2 

+ 

% 

4 

 

#   % #

8

8# 8#!, .%! + !"%# !!+!

.%,  -

"!#6 !#% +  % #-!

 % , % +! 6  ! 0%!#

#!!

.%!,

"

/% 8! -

6 % #! ! # !+!

6 -"     ! ; , %0  0!8# +!# ! %", "%!

8

8# 8#! !+!

6 "!!"!

% ! +4!

%#

"

.%!!+ /%, 8! +!# ! %", 8 0"! %# %   0 ! "%!

  /,+**+%&*  %9  !) $&)'   )  % &*)!

 &'

 %9  .)  !) $&)'  % &*)!  9%$ 6)++%&)$+&.) 66) !;$)(+*+%&+&5.+ . .

!!)&#)+*, ')%.)()$'+ %9

- + !  , ')  +&  $)*6)   %9  6)$*%&*  & ,)!0   $'))6  +&#.  7*+& ) ') ) *)'8  .

#5 &  +&#.

  !5 &  +&#.  7*+& )  ') ) *)'8  %#+&')$ +&#.7*+& )') ) *)'8  & ,+&#.

 # $+&#.

 &'

 $(+&')$+&#.



# * % # + %8+!!

8  !
% ! :%!#,

% +"##6 !+, ! ! 0 +!""!!

! #6 ! !! (C (C, -!

 !%# ! !+!

6 "!!"!

# 0   

+4!


%8+!!  +,

 %!!

%, "!#6 +4!

!0 % !#% + , , 8+ "!#6 +"!

?=(*,

?=(F,

?=($,

?=(

5 % %8+!, !

 

"%% , %0 "!#6 -

6 ++, "!#6 +"!

=!8! ! ?=(*9

?=(F9

?=($9

?=(

9  ## # ! 8+  ,  ! "!  ,  ! ; ,    - 8 + 8, ! :%!#, + %0 !+"%0 ! :%! ! 8+!

:%,  !

) *%&*9%$$):) +&#.)* /,+**+%&  5-,  8 !0 !

 , !
% 

" %8+!!

# * % # ?

%0 "%!

! (C

%# -!  % , %0 "", %, -!  8= ), %0,

=+!

! !

! !8% %

!+!

6 # -! +"##6 ! ! !! 8+   (C (C, 8% "!

%# -!  % , 

+ 8!

! !!

(C (C, #6 %", = !0

!+!

6 #,

" ,

+#6 /%#-

1%!

20 #-!

20!

, 5"

, , 0- +! 8% 6 +!

- %

+#6 * + 1% + 

+ !+ +09""  !+ ! ; ,  "4, #6 !#8#,  !+ !, +!

- %



!#8#,  !+ !,  !+ 6, ! 

8 ! !! (C (C ),

!

! ! !! , , (C (C,  +! !8 ## %, !+!

6 # ! !!

##4, !#!


 :% #6, -

6-! , ! !!

- :%! 8 "%6!

+"# 8!

! !! (C (C,

#6, " ## % !#8#  !+ !, 8%

" ## !!

##4,   !#!

 , =#% - + 0 % 6 "!!" 

# %# 8!

!8%, 

 :%! %, - "%"#6 !#8#,  !+ !, !+!

6 #  !!

##4,   ! !#!

 ; , +0!

 !!

(C J ! !!
   "!! (C (C,  %#

#%! !0

!+!

6 # :%! %, :%#   ! "!!   (C (C  ; ,

"%% % !#% +   %, !  ! "!   #!, 8+ %  ! 8% !0 % !#% +  :%! %, :% -! !  8% :% !# 

, # !,  #!, 6 8+  % % 8%, 6 -

6  !#6 !#8# ! + + %# #6,  + "

%


% " , ! !, 

8% 8 #% 8

# ! 8+!

 ! %

# %# * 0   -

  8+ 0  %+,
 !!

 ! !!

(C

! !! (C (C  +4!

" "!%% +0 , 8! -

8%  +"##6  " :%! " ,  !+ !, %# #6 :%    , , 

# !0 % !#% + , :% -! !  8+ + 8# 8 #% 8 :%# 

!

 !    ! %& ! *+%& &

 8, !
% 

+!

## 0 ! :%!#, ,

" :%! %
 :% #6, ! :%!#, :%! % +!

!

 !+, ""#9!!

## 0!

! :%!#   !+! 

!- !%! !+!

# ""# ## 0!

! !! 8! :% -!  !+"!!

   !+"! + %", 8! , !+!, %# #6, ! !! 8! :% -!    !+"! + , 8! , ,

 +!

!

 !+ '

5-, !

! ="! %!

"  6 ""# 8!

3
 

8  !
%, %, ""! ""# # 8+!

8 !+, !+! % %# #6, -

! !! 8!%#6 :% -!    

8 =%


!+ %!!

! 

8!# %"

  !+"! + !+"

 ! 8 -! =% # !# 2%0 %0 -!

++!# -  <
 ""6 8 6   ="!6 "! #!+!!

 8  -

-! 7

 

  <=<>3<33 78
.!)*.

  
.).)$*6) "+&#;$) *%&)'1 )*;%