High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/777/2004allowed

Satyavir Singh v. State Of Haryana

2020-08-14Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu28 pages

!" #$% $&'( &) *!(+%,

---..+// &!, 0+%,1, ! !+ *2 %" &

---+,.*&)+&!

3 45 -

0 6 75 -

!"# $"

% &"

'"(())

&# !* +++ 6

- ,"(() "'

- ./ "# 0 1 ) # 213 $" " (()) $ " $" ( " ) # $"# "4 ) 5""6"4 267,"" $) -( - ( 89" ) "4$- """ # 4 ,"") 4($ ( :89" ) 4 - ""

# 4 ,"$ "- 1")# "

1 - ))#( :*"" $ ) ,"$" "*$")1; "-$ <"

(# " $2" # " ,"$)) - $) (),"( :"

"2" # ""-& ""$)) # "

""()"-))

" "<"( # ") &" -"-" "2" # " " $ $ # - - "$=-& # ( "" "2" # "" - "$ "$)) $ % -" -"() " " " " <"

( # " ) % - <) # "

#( "

9$)) $ % --"

9$)) # "$ ,"()= ""9 " " 2" # "$ "$)) $ % - %"( ,"9 $ " '(5>7 )"5 ))7 $""")( )% - " # " ""()," 9 $)$" '

,"" "" $"( = "- 1")# " 8$"

# 4 2 $ ," $ -() " -)( # /"2 2- ) $

-"2 :

,"( ;- - $ (( ,"- " # 2 2$

8 ## "? ")) ))) "-* ""$ ( "( " ))-() @ =-& 9 )())-() #" """" "9 9)$%," ( "$ "

9$))," "((" 2" # " "" ,"$ "-$"$ (

"- "-) $-""-"$-)) )") #""" & $$""(( "#" % " '

2" # "

/ %9 )())-() #"" " :"$-)& "

9$)) ( "-)& "$9 &"$

-)"4 "- -2" # "-- " "")" -----)#" *9 9)$=-& $## "$( "

9 $))$"" -"=-& -"," "

((" 2" # " "" A" "$ "-$ ("- "-)* $-" "-"$-)) )")#" & $$""(( "#"=-& '

2" # " .

*$ ;( ( 4 B;2 B;B )B; " ) ,"(()) $ * "(()

A"") )"( " " ""'

A- $(""$ "( (("() B; "( "() 1")# "

A" -2 )&")() - *2 # ) # > "

A-2" *2(""-) 4 "* "(" "-() $ - % $ # 4 1 : $ :4 " ("

- 4 ;- "" 41:"""- =-& $ """ " 41:" ((

*2'"% -(" :"$ " #4> ;- " C ( "$ $"#4> ;- "() $" "$)) ) ""()"$ $))1"$))"$&")5$7 : ("$( """ )

& )$) " "&& 0 $) (-"($" "

= "$"(()$ ) "

"" "" " ""(()$ 4$) ($ #4> ;- ))" & ( )( "-

9 -(-" ; &"- ( ,""(()$) & ( ,"$ ) 2" # "

*("-B; *)(" & ( ) & -"-" ;B; :

4 ;- """$)) $"""

2" # "$ $ " ) )),"$ "$)) " "$)),"$)) "$""" "(() & )$$/$-" $))$"" $1( $ "$)) $ <$ "$)) $ "$)) # "

-$"""(() & )$"$ ( *"$ ) ))"( $ ( - ( *) ) "( $ "( $) """$( $"$ ,"$) $ "$$))" ( " $""$$ ,"#*= )"( (( " - ) ," ""("(""""( "-" ( $ ("(" @

A:<"(# "(" :"" ")"(,"$ )- " (4$..(-"-A" """)" "--- -"$)) # "*$ " *$" "2" # "$"" " $"( *" ( " )*$# =-& %( " # $-$")" =-& $

: -$"(" %$-$")" ))""$ ) " "2" # "$""($( *$ ))) C "- " " " # " ""$ )) ) "-- "- )*"$$ "= "# ""-$"" $( * $*- $( "$*)"- " ," "-"")))):( -")) "-"(*$ "-*$ -" "1") # " "

"$ "," " " " ))"- $")" "1")# ")" ,""$ "$)) # "

"," "$ "$))# ,")" ," "-)" # " ")),"" # *$& 2" # "*"$;( " 2" # "," " "- )) "" "- -""-)(" )) ()*$"() ," "- #) ,""" - ,""-" *2$""-$"#*=,"#*= -" : *&"" ) ( " ) "" ) &* )" " $ & C @-"#*=$""-" )),"$ ""$)) # "# $ "," "$ "$))# ,") $

#"$)-"$))<) %"-

$ " ," ""&"$)) $ % - %"( ," " 2" # " "$))," $ " ")# ,""# ) -" ) " " " ,"

<""" $ "("$))$"& "("(" / * "("# " " ) #( " *$(( !" "5 A:67 - 5-"67<""" ) $"# # &"-"-!" "- $) ") " # " # $ "-* "("(()B; " "2" # ","$ "() -"$)) # "

4 ;- "-"# $<"( # "5 A:7" #) " " 2" # " # :

4 2* "" "() ","" ," $ " " 1 ) 2 " :*"" "2" # "$ " ) &* ) & )&-*" & )C " :," "$)) # "

-" "))$ D&- (< $ " "")$"*)$"$$

; $""" $ $&))-"$)) # "

,"# -&"( $ "$)) # " $ % - *5 A:7) "( ","$)) $ % -- :(4- $ C <""$2" # "" $"((),"" $) "$" & 3 *""")"() "( %-$")" ""$ )$2" # "

*$ $""- B;<$"$ - * $ ) $" "- B; < $" $ - " " " " $" ( * $ ) $""- B;<$"$ - "" ") " ) " " "" )$""- )&- "-)*$ ) $""- B;<$"$ - " "$ "" ))(()*" " " "- : ,"" $ ) )$* ) ))"$- )$$

=-& $""(" *"' &"$$""

"4" ( <- ) - " $ ) (())

A@1")# "("<"(# "" "" ( * = :"" )), -* -"-(-

< :( $( "" ,"<"(# ")"-" "" "

$))$"" )*"- -"

$)) # "*$ "*$"2" # " " &"

5(7 "" $"(# =-& %$$ ) "-*))"-"$" " " "# )"-," "))$ "

$)) # "," -- # =-& %$ 2" # ""," "$ "

$))# ,")" # "" "

$))* ") $) ",""$ "" # " "))# $ "

"- A" & 2" # "";(" ," "$ "" "- -""- )(" ))"() (- ))"- $),"$"() (-," "$ () )#*=$ ","$&$ "#*=#*=-" :-,"#*=)"- " " )( " ) & ) <"( # "" )"""

$)) # " @- $ "

$)) $ "

$))# <) # ")," "$

$)) $ % -# # )"," $ " -"$)) ," $)$" '

-& <"" $$"( "("$&

) " - $"" B; 2 4 $ )

*-( " ! )*()1 )4 $ ( -- !4 # "& -- $ !4 #"& :* 0# " " " )" "- "-*"$(( " ""- "; ","()" " @4 2 "" (() B;

0"() * (( "4!),"()) (()- "))

4 4 ") "( "" # "$" " ) 2" # " "- 4 ;- "" :# $ #( ""))*- $ #4> ;- 3-*")#4> ;- "( ) % " *-" B; 2 $ * ")#4> ;- "$" "- &-, " 9 : ( " " *$ " ) $ $ #4 > ;- *"))#4> ;- "" "2" # "$%"

*$ $""- B; $"")$ $ *"))#4> ;- "

$))# <) "

$))

$ ,")$ "- *" " ""- " ( " ""- " -& -() #4

> ;- <""" 2" # "$()," ( ""$" $ ,"$ ( # 2" # "-"

$)) # " : ,"( $ "$"

$)) $ ,"(("$)) $ % -$: "))") ," "$))" " ,"

$))"

- )( -(,"$ $( "$))$""$-$,"$))$: (,"$)-( "$))")"(( ( ,"(( $ 366$-"$))"$)) $ "$))

$ % - # "$/.&))

A/*2*$# " B; % ( ) () $""- " " " - 2 )" -( " # >

A. # ' )" - (-

!4 # "& ( " : " (--;- " 2" # " 1 -3)," $-

-$- "-,") " " $/-," $- )-))," $ &,"$)("E:9@-$""$ )& ) B ))$ 1$-( ) ) $ E "$( , $( $ $)) <) ) $- - " --

($( "( (" -$ ( (" -- ) $( " 2" $)) - )$))$ ( ," ( -$$)) A)) ) ) > ; "$ * <") $ = 9 ) ) $- *$ )

F-( - #-"$ -9 $")")-))

#-)) $ -9 > $ )- > ( % $) ( <)$-(= ; ) ) * "))$ '

% !

"$ % &

% '

(

) :

4 "( " " "$" '

$""$ 9-- "

$("-) ) ,- $ " (--;- $ $ - $ '

"$ ,"))$ $" " )

+ ,-./$//( "$ , 0

0 1 23452 # ) @ *(B;

>" ("(-- ($"" " " C ((B;

5(7 $""$ ) "- / ,"()

-(() B;

= :

& "( " "*( "" " "$" '

1 :@/.3 $""

$ 9-- = ) '

1$(-- '

* ("( "B;

=8*" $-& """ "() '

1F .

= @() ((""-$"(() B;

" )$ "$))" ((($""

$D6D6-"$))"$))4"-)) " $))" '

" )$""$ ) "( = $"""( " '

1F )

"( *("( B;

8*" "( #>B;

G$"""$"" -")( -)) ) )() & (" ( "))")*$ -- ( $ ) ( 3 4 9;- "$"" " "

- -)"$ $))" -:6 (":6 - (9-- '

$ )(( " A " ) ; " $))$")" )$ $$ ) ),"$ $") (" $ )( "&)) "( 4 '

1) $ "

,""

$ " '

) ) '

1- ))" " ) '* ((-"$ "" ' "

9 B;( '

1$""" & &)))" '

"$ " ,"$ ' "" " ( '

1:$""$ ")" G )")$ ) " # > ( B;

G ( $" " -)C "(,"(( ( (

A3 &"#"- )=! )*() 1 )" :()C (-- ;- " 2" # " = "C # = < "- < !

( )&0 ," ;- " ,"" (-- ;- ;( !4 #"&,"")" "()")"" ' ( )()$"

-())

A> ;- #48#*= #)" : "$(#*= #) ()) "$% ")$""- ) &" ," ;( " ( 2" # " " &)) "$ "- $))) $""-"""$)) $ % - ))%"( ,"$))$ " ))#( *- )% -$ "$))*) " $) "$)) ," $"

" "$)),"1")# ""- B;

2*- B;

28" "-"() " "("$))$"&

: ("("4 C ( $ *(" C ((B;

"() B;

"$)) " $ ((," $" ! )*()1 ) (--;- ,"-"$ "

$)) # " ("(()2" # " ( ) 2"(() "( )$& ( --B;

!," "-! )*() 1 ),""- ;( !4 #"& ,""-)() ")" (($"""& ( --B; * ,"(" "" "*(" ( ")" " B;

: = :# "(--;- " " )()$"""& ( $ -- B;

= .: " # # " =-& %$ = 3: # # "-) - B;

H"""&( & ) """( $""

&*"- $& ( --B;

A* ("-B;

@ " "#

@4 24 2," .@")) $(( " ," 1")# "-()

- (() 4!!

= "(() # - C 4 2 $ ," (()- ")) $) "

;- """ " )" ""( "&" ;(

!4 #"&$"" "(--;- " 2" # "<""" "" " ,"$ & "( "$$" = : " "$)) $ "" " ))#( " "))-))) ("( "$)) $ <$ "

$)) $ " # ""$)" (,")$-,"$( ")- ( ,"$ "( ;(" ( ( #>(6

92 8

8 #2 9+

# # 9)

," $ " - 1") # " :*""$ ) ,"$ " "*$")1;"-$ <" (# " $ 2" # " ," $ )) - $ ) (),"( :" "2" # "

"-& ""$)) # ""-))

" "<"(# " -"-" "2" # " " $ $ # "$=-& # ( "" "2" # ""

; - "$ "$)) $ % -" -"() " "" "<"

(# " )% - "

9$)) $ % --"

9$)) # "$ :

= )" )"$- "9 " "2" # "$ "$)) $ % - %"( ,"9 $ " '(5>7 )"5 ))7$""")( )% - " # " ""() ," 9 $ ) $" '

," " " " $"( @

A: <"( # " $" ))) $ " " 2" # " " (" :" " ") ..(-"( "$ )- "( A" """ )""--- -"$)) # "* $ " $" "2" # "$"" " $"(*" ( " )*$ # =-& %( " # $-$")" =-& $-$"(" %$-$")"))" " $ ) " " 2" # " $" " ( $( *$ ))) C "- "

" " # " ""$ )) ) " -- "-) 1")"$ " = " # ""-$""$( * $* - $( "$ *)"- " ,""-"")))):(

< -")) "-"(*$ "-*$ -" "1")# " "

"$ "," " " "

&"-- $")" " 1")# ")",""$ "$)) # "

"," "$ "$))# ,") " ," "-)" # " ")),"" # *$& 2" # " # ;(" 2" # " ," " "- ))"" "- -" "-)(" ))()*$"() ," "-$ #) ," "" -,""-" *2$""- $"#*=,"#*=-" : * ) " "$ & C @-"#*= $""-")) ,"$ ""$)) # "# $ "," "$ "$))# ,") $ #"$)-"$))<) %"-

$ " ," ""&" $)) $ % -%"( ," " 2" # " "$))," $ " ")#

,""# )-"," '

<" " $ "("$))$"&"("(" /

A@1")# "") " A:<"

(# " $"-" $ A:<"(# " )( -))

A")""( "2" # "

$ " " " ) " - 2 2% =-& " " :%$-)& "

9$)) ( "-)& "$9 &"$ -)"4 "- -2" # "-- " " ")" -----)#" * 9 9)$=-& $## "$( "

9$)) $"" -" =-& -" ," "

((" 2" # " "" A" "$ "-$ ("- "-) $-" ," & $$""(( ""-"$-)) )"),"5%=-& 7 '

2" # "4 "( ( 41:: 8

4 2 -() 8(()

- % " )) 4 " -() $") " "- # 2 2"- " $")"$") "-"( " =-& 9")9 9)$,"(() $

-*2-2" : % 2"$& ) " 4 $

3 " 2" # "$-"$))

$ % -"C - $""2" # "$ " " " "$ "$)) $ % - " (' " ( "

- "-)-"% =-& 2" # "

-( "$)) $ % - )" '

("( A:<"(# ""$2" # "( " $"$-$")" ("* " "

$"$

# *" $ "- " "

) - " " A@1")$""- $") "-,"" $ "$)) # "

"," "$ "$))# ,")" ," "- )" # " ")),"" # * $& 2" # " # ;(" 2" # " ," " "- ))"" "- A@1")# "") -)

A" "

"$" " # ")" " ";( " "$" 2" # ""-&)( " ," " ) "(" ( A:<"(# ""-))$" "$"

" "2" # ""$)) # """ "2" # "( $ " ($ ) # ""-$"

")">$" A:<"(# "-( ") "

A@1")# " - "

"2" # " # "" ") ");(

"$" 2" # ""C )- &# ) " - "-( A: A@$ ) "" "$ ) # "") $"% =-& "

2" # " $"-;() $"2" # " $()) "" ( ""-" -

" ,"$ ))&"- "$" " " % =-& # ) " ( 8 "

$"$ A:<"(# "$"")) "" -( A: A@"

$)) # "# " # ") " $ # " A:<"(# "

) " " ) " " 8 "$ ) "" " "& ((" 8 '

8"- " (

4$ *2'"% -$"$ " ) $" #4 > ;- " ;- "" $ "$)) # "$"" )))&() "$)) $ % --$"" 2" # "$$ /( @1")# " $ "$)) $ % - # "

$/.&)) B ")$- A@1")# "

)" ) 4 )" " $ ) )" - 3" ())& $ ))$))" A:<"(# "" "

8 "" " 2" # """ "-

$"$ ""$ ) - $" - ( 2" # "( A:" "$)) # "-" "))$ D &- (< $ " "")$"* "-$" $""" ) $ ) ) 4 " " "$ )) "& -( ,"( - )

A *2'"% -"" "$)) # ""$&")5$7 :("$ ( """ ) & ) $) " "&& 0 $ ) (-"($" " = "$"(()$ ) "

"" ""

" " "(() $ 4 $ ) ( $ ," "(()$ ) 2" # "

" ";- ""$)) $"" " 2" # "$ $ " ) )) ,"$"$)) " "$)) 1( $ "$)) $ <$ "$)) $ "$))

# "-$"""(()2" # " &

)$"$( *"$ ) )) "( $ ( - ( *) ) "( $ "( $) "" "$( $"$ ,"$) $ "$

$))" ( " $""$$,"#*= )"( (( "- )," ""("("" ""( "-"( $ ("("

A> ;- #48#*= #) ;- )" $ "

$)) $ " # "" $)" ($""$-

@ ( A:<"(# "")$"$$ $""" $ $&))-"$)) # "

*)""# -&"( $ "$)) # " $ % -*5 A:7) " ( "

/ ( A@1")# ""$( # 2" # "-"

$)) # " : ,"( $ "$"

$)) $

" "") $ "$)) # " $ % -$$ "( )) ) $""" " -"$)) # ""$)) $ % -

"-$ 4"( " " "$ )" -( - "- ," A@1")# """"$ ( # 2" # "-"

$)) # " : ,"( $ "$"

$)) $ A:<"(# "("" " ( $ "$)) # " $ % -

"( " ) )"""

9 " 2" # ""$)) $ % - " "$ "$)) :

A> ;- #48#*= #) ;- " ") $ "

$)) $ " # "

"$ (,")$-,"$( ")-( ,"$ "( ;( " ( ,") " " $ "

$)) $ % - ( -"( % =-& : 4"- A:""$)) $ % - $:(4"((: "))") ," "$))" C " ,"

$))"

- )( -( ,"$$( "$)) $""$-$ ,"$))$:( ,"$ )-( "$))")"(( ( ,"(($ 366$ -"$))"$)) : ( A. # ' )" $" ( --;- " 2" # ""$ '

% !

"$ % &

% '

(

) : = (()

- "()& "( " ""( "" "$ '

1 :@/.3 $""$ 9-- = ) '

1$(-- '

4 ( "(() B;

$""" '

""-)) "$))-" ) "$))" ((($""$D6 D6-"$))"$))$ ) "( "( " '

1F ) "( ::

4 9;- "$"" " "

- -)"$ $))" -:6

(":6 - (9-- '

$ )(( " A " ) ; " $))$")" )$ $$ ) ),"$ $") (" $ )( "&)) "( 4 '

1) $ "

) '

1- ))" "

) ' :@ ,"

" '

" (("( """ "$ " $))"" " :/ ," " A: A@"- ""$ " ) & "" ")C : (( #>B;

G" -")(-)) ) )() & "( "))") ," $"" $" "% =-& "- # 2 2""" $-)) )") :.

,"))-"-( A:

A@""" ((!" 5" "-"67 # ") #( " "" "-) (( 4" $" ") "(#( "$")$"" # ")" "-$" C "- :3 ,"

")""( " )(

; " " )

@ )"(()))$," C ))""- "-," ") ( "( "(()," )

1'1,!

A""#(& 8 I A""( ) I81