Gurbax Singh And ORS. v. State Of Haryana


 

      

     

       !        

 
     

      "#$%#$&%#$'()*$+$,%-#.(/)0$&$1.&%$)2,%#$)2*$-%3 .

     !



    

!      4"!





     !


  

 

 

 



       

      



  !"#   

  !"#    $ 

       !"#   %&  

  

    ' (  

     

 &

#  )$5&,$)  6.(,-$/  511$5&2,*  7.&  %#$  511$//5,%-  5,)  /$5&,$) 6.(,-$/  511$5&2,*  7.&  %#$  6.+1/52,5,%  -(0+2%%$)  &$7$&&2,*  %.  %#$ 6.+1&.+2-$)$$)8,,$9(&$
:%#5%0.%#%#$15&%2$-#5;$5+2650/<-$%%/$) %#$2&)2-1(%$5,)-%5&%$)/2;2,*1$56$7(//<#$<#5;$5/-.1&.1.-$),.%%. 2,)(/*$2,5,<6&2+2,5/56%2;2%<2,7(%(&$ ,%#$05-2-.7%#$6.+1&.+2-$ )$$)%#$<5/-.-(0+2%%$)%#5%%#$6.,;26%2.,&$6.&)$)0<%#$%&25/ .(&%+5< 0$-(-%52,$)5,)%#$511$//5,%-+5<0$-$,%$,6$)%.%#$1$&2.)5/&$5)< (,)$&*.,$0<%#$+


= ,5-+(6#5-%#$511$//5,%-#5;$,.%65,;5--$)7.&56>(2%%5/5,) %#$<#5;$1/$5)$)7.&.,/<&$)(6%2.,2,-$,%$,6$2,%#$57%$&+5%#.7%#$ 6.+1&.+2-$-%&(6?0$%@$$,%#$566(-$)5,)%#$6.+1/52,5,%%#$ .(&% ).$-,.%2,%$,)%.$,%$&2,%.5,$/50.&5%$))2-6(--2.,.7%#$$;2)$,6$ 5))(6$)0<%#$15&%2$- , 

       

  !"#$  %&'( )  %$(%&'#2%@5-#$/)5-7.//.@-
B


                 

  



  

               

                   

  

          

 

!"  

      

    #     $ 

 

    

 $

                

      C ,%#$/2*#%.7%#$50.;$&5%2.2%2--(0+2%%$)0</$5&,$)6.(,-$/ 511$5&2,*7.&%#$%5%$%#5%%#$>($-%2.,.7566$1%2,*6.+1&.+2-$5,) &$6.&)2,*56>(2%%5/.7%#$566(-$)7.&%#$6#5&*$(,)$&$6%2.,=D

).$-,.%5&2-$ #$50.;$)$62-2.,.7%#$.,F0/$(1&$+$ .(&%2,)265%$-%#5% 6.+1&.+2-$$,%$&$)2,%.0$%@$$,%#$566(-$)5,)%#$511$//5,%5-&$*5&)-5 -$&2.(-6#5&*$(,)$&$6%2.,=D 65,,.%0$566$1%$)7.&56>(2%%2,*%#$

=
566(-$)(%2,%#$2,-%5,%65-$%#$566(-$)
511$//5,%-#5;$,.%-.(*#%7.& 56>(2%%5/.7%#$6#5&*$;$,.%#$&@2-$2%2-,.%565-$@#$&$%#$566(-$)
511$//5,%-@$&$6.,;26%$)(,)$&$6%2.,=D %5,<&5%$%#$ .(&% #5-1&.1.-$)%.6.,-2)$&2,%#$2,%$&$-%.7'(-%26$@#$%#$&%#$-$,%$,6$65, 0$&$)(6$)%.%#$1$&2.)5/&$5)<(,)$&*.,$2,%#$/2*#%.7%#$6.+1&.+2-$ -%&(6?0$%@$$,%#$15&%2$-0<0(&<2,*%#$#5%6#$%#$&$7.&$2,%#$50.;$ 756%-5,)62&6(+-%5,6$-%#$50.;$&5%2./52)).@,0<%#$.,F0/$(1&$+$

.(&%).$-,.%511/<%.%#$65-$2,#5,) #$$<$@2%,$--566.(,%5,)%#$+$)265/%$-%2+.,<@.(/)*.%. -#.@$-%50/2-#%#5%566(-$) (&0592,*#@#.@5-5&+$)@2%# *5,)5-5 65(-$)5*&2$;.(-2,'(&<.,%#$7.&$5&+.75#2,)$&2,*#5,)566(-$) #(12,)$&2,*#@#.@5-5&+$)@2%#)5%5&)$/2;$&$)50/.@.,%#$&2*#% ?,$$.75#2,)$&2,*#5,)65(-$)*&2$;.(-2,'(&<

.,-2)$&2,*  %#$  ,5%(&$  .7  2,'(&2$-  -(-%52,$)  0<  5#2,)$& 2,*#2%2--(0+2%%$)%#5%%#$-$,%$,6$+5<0$&$)(6$)%.%#$1$&2.)5/&$5)< (,)$&*.,$0<%#$+  72,)%#5%%#$&$2-+(6#7.&6$2,%#$-(0+2--2.,+5)$0< /$5&,$)6.(,-$/511$5&2,*7.&%#$511$//5,%-#$511$//5,%-#5;$+5)$.(% 565-$7.&-(0-%5,%25/&$)(6%2.,2,-$,%$,6$.,566.(,%.7%@.756%.&- 2&-%/<%#$2,'(&<#5)0$$,65(-$).,,.,
;2%5/15&%-$6.,)/<5/.,* -%5,)2,* )2-1(%$#5) 0$$, &$-./;$)0$%@$$, %#$15&%2$- 5,) %#$<#5;$ -%5&%$)/2;2,*1$56$7(//<  66(-$) (&0592,*##5-(,)$&*.,$+.,%#-5,))5<- 5,)566(-$)#(12,)$&2,*##5-(,)$&*.,$ +.,%#-5,)G)5<-.7

A
-$,%$,6$ ,;2$@.7%#$50.;$%#$6.,;26%2.,&$6.&)$)5-5*52,-%%#$ 566(-$)
511$//5,%-(,)$&$6%2.,==&$5)@2%#$6%2.,=A $6%2., = &$5)@2%#$6%2.,=A 5,)$6%2.,=E&$5)@2%#$6%2.,=A

-%5,)-6.,72&+$) (%%#$-$,%$,6$2+1.-$)7.&%#$57.&$-52).77$,6$2- &$)(6$)%.%#$1$&2.)5/&$5)<(,)$&*.,$0<%#$566(-$)
511$//5,%-#$72,$ 5+.(,%5,)%#$)$75(/%-$,%$,6$2+1.-$)0<%#$%&25/ .(&%-%5,)-(-%52,$)

,$+.,%#1$&2.)2-*2;$,%.%#$511$//5,%-%.15<%#$72,$2+1.-$)0<%#$ %&25/ .(&%,)$75(/%.715<+$,%.772,$%#$&$.7%#$<-#5//(,)$&*.%#$ )$75(/%-$,%$,6$  66.&)2,*/<%#$511$5/-%5,)-)2-1.-$).7  $6$+0$&

   

(/5%2  "#