← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/7450/2015dismissed

Kirpal Singh v. Sumit Sharma And Other

2015-11-16Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih3 pages



     

     

     

    

 " #$%&!'(

 " #$%&!'(

 " #$%&!'(

 " #$%&!'(

)&*+",- )&*+",- )&*+",- )&*+",-     ."/    ."/    ."/    ."/ 0 "

"

0 "

"

0 "

"

0 "

"

"1$2"-+&$+3& "1$2"-+&$+3& "1$2"-+&$+3& "1$2"-+&$+3&  "

."/  "

."/  "

."/  "

."/  4#  4#  4#  4#  564  "  564  "  564  "  564  "

 66 

 66 

 66 

 66

&2# 4&"++2-(78+2(&2-*22&  !9-2-&  *&2&    8+  :*+*&  $+;  % +:722-<17,$2="> %&&&722- *&2&&2="

?9-2-&  2-  <17,$2 -17  %  &*&27   2- 7,2=">   

 66(. &+/ 

 66(. &+/ 

 66(. &+/ 

 66(. &+/ 07&7&%,++7(7+27?!  (&7&7 %;17,.1&/(1&7+*1&(++**8+2$7 %;2-*22&17&&7&! 1!

(7 &871&( 2%+&&+;7+*+&2;77+2-+78%7$77 2-881&8&772-&,+&7&+7(+2-1#@ A&,1$2  -+&7  +    *&17  - A&,1$2  -+&7  +    *&17  - A&,1$2  -+&7  +    *&17  - A&,1$2  -+&7  +    *&17  - +**8+2   *&   - :&-* -+ %&1,-2   +**8+2   *&   - :&-* -+ %&1,-2   +**8+2   *&   - :&-* -+ %&1,-2   +**8+2   *&   - :&-* -+ %&1,-2  

 &8&78*;+$+%+7:-&2-22++&+ &8&78*;+$+%+7:-&2-22++&+ &8&78*;+$+%+7:-&2-22++&+ &8&78*;+$+%+7:-&2-22++&+ 2-*&*&2;-:+ B++ 4+&++72- 2-*&*&2;-:+ B++ 4+&++72- 2-*&*&2;-:+ B++ 4+&++72- 2-*&*&2;-:+ B++ 4+&++72- +7-:+A+&4+C&1+D:-8-812+% +7-:+A+&4+C&1+D:-8-812+% +7-:+A+&4+C&1+D:-8-812+% +7-:+A+&4+C&1+D:-8-812+% -&2-,2-&1&8&7:-8--: -&2-,2-&1&8&7:-8--: -&2-,2-&1&8&7:-8--: -&2-,2-&1&8&7:-8--: 2-+2+;-1E2,2-+7-:2- 2-+2+;-1E2,2-+7-:2- 2-+2+;-1E2,2-+7-:2- 2-+2+;-1E2,2-+7-:2- +$+%+7*&7187%;2-+**8+2 2-2-& +$+%+7*&7187%;2-+**8+2 2-2-& +$+%+7*&7187%;2-+**8+2 2-2-& +$+%+7*&7187%;2-+**8+2 2-2-& -+7(2-*+2-128272-+2-1+ -+7(2-*+2-128272-+2-1+ -+7(2-*+2-128272-+2-1+ -+7(2-*+2-128272-+2-1+   2-  +7  :-8-      A6+  6+B&D  +7  -+     2-  +7  :-8-      A6+  6+B&D  +7  -+     2-  +7  :-8-      A6+  6+B&D  +7  -+     2-  +7  :-8-      A6+  6+B&D  +7  -+   )-+&+&7+:+&+71&2-&2+272-+222++&+ )-+&+&7+:+&+71&2-&2+272-+222++&+ )-+&+&7+:+&+71&2-&2+272-+222++&+ )-+&+&7+:+&+71&2-&2+272-+222++&+ 2-  -1    @!

>  4+&+  -  7$    2- 2-  -1    @!>  4+&+  -  7$    2- 2-  -1    @!>  4+&+  -  7$    2- 2-  -1    @!>  4+&+  -  7$    2- -1,2-*+2+7$227%;9@!- -1,2-*+2+7$227%;9@!- -1,2-*+2+7$227%;9@!- -1,2-*+2+7$227%;9@!- 8&@E+$+2  +  :  +  *88  F12 8&@E+$+2  +  :  +  *88  F12 8&@E+$+2  +  :  +  *88  F12 8&@E+$+2  +  :  +  *88  F12 &,+&7,2-7$:&*122 9@!71&, &,+&7,2-7$:&*122 9@!71&, &,+&7,2-7$:&*122 9@!

71&, &,+&7,2-7$:&*122 9@!

71&, -  8&@E+$+2  +7  -  2+27  &%+2$  + -  8&@E+$+2  +7  -  2+27  &%+2$  + -  8&@E+$+2  +7  -  2+27  &%+2$  + -  8&@E+$+2  +7  -  2+27  &%+2$  + $272-*+2-&&(+**8+2-+2 $272-*+2-&&(+**8+2-+2 $272-*+2-&&(+**8+2-+2 $272-*+2-&&(+**8+2-+2 %+%2-:2-+2*&*&2;F122- %+%2-:2-+2*&*&2;F122- %+%2-:2-+2*&*&2;F122- %+%2-:2-+2*&*&2;F122- +$2:&7:-8--%+,-8+$4&&( +$2:&7:-8--%+,-8+$4&&( +$2:&7:-8--%+,-8+$4&&( +$2:&7:-8--%+,-8+$4&&( 2-+**8+2$2%727+;2-2&+ 2-+**8+2$2%727+;2-2&+ 2-+**8+2$2%727+;2-2&+ 2-+**8+2$2%727+;2-2&+ 2-8++72-+222-+,72-2&+- 2-8++72-+222-+,72-2&+- 2-8++72-+222-+,72-2&+- 2-8++72-+222-+,72-2&+- +**8+2&7,2-+$+,+7- +**8+2&7,2-+$+,+7- +**8+2&7,2-+$+,+7- +**8+2&7,2-+$+,+7- ,&+7+2-&77+2!

+777+2 ,&+7+2-&77+2!+777+2 ,&+7+2-&77+2!+777+2 ,&+7+2-&77+2!

+777+2 -&7+1,-2&@@+:+72-122*%2-+2 -&7+1,-2&@@+:+72-122*%2-+2 -&7+1,-2&@@+:+72-122*%2-+2 -&7+1,-2&@@+:+72-122*%2-+2 -  :+  2  +:+&  +%12  ,,  2,+2  +7 -  :+  2  +:+&  +%12  ,,  2,+2  +7 -  :+  2  +:+&  +%12  ,,  2,+2  +7 -  :+  2  +:+&  +%12  ,,  2,+2  +7 2-&&+**8+27%&+2;7728+$&:+&7 2-&&+**8+27%&+2;7728+$&:+&7 2-&&+**8+27%&+2;7728+$&:+&7 2-&&+**8+27%&+2;7728+$&:+&7 2  *1&1  -  8+$  +&&  -&&(    2- 2  *1&1  -  8+$  +&&  -&&(    2- 2  *1&1  -  8+$  +&&  -&&(    2- 2  *1&1  -  8+$  +&&  -&&(    2- 8&81$2+8*&2+**8+22+77$7D 8&81$2+8*&2+**8+22+77$7D 8&81$2+8*&2+**8+22+77$7D 8&81$2+8*&2+**8+22+77$7D 877;(*+2-+1,-2*88*&&$+8   2-  +,&$2  2    7+27  !

E8127%;77+2!+7  &(2-*22&2+ *+&2;22-82&+82(2-&+;&%,8+$7&2- +,7  +,&$2    &8+%  +,+2  -$  2-,  :+ %&1,-2&8&72-:2-+22-*22&:+* 2-12+72-&+;8+(&,-22-*22&+&

 2B;2%+827%;+;782-+2-+%&7&7   2-  *&2  12  -&&(  +**8+2  $7  %;  2- *22&:+&,-2;787+-:+2-&+8+&; &+*&*&*+&2; -+2  %,  (    2&&8    :+&&+27   E&8    &+  <1&782  17&  &28      2- 2212    7+   22  %,  77    $&2  ( +88&7,;(7$7$  04 !'(   04 !'(   04 !'(   04 !'(      .

 66/ .

 66/ .

 66/ .

 66/ )+, )+, )+, )+,