High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/7451/2015disposed of

Brahm Dutt v. Onkar Chaudhary

2015-11-06Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih3 pages

!"# $#%&'&() *

+!,-.""!(' /#"&"&(#+ 0#+'.' (1!+,!.$,!+2 /#'3($#(" ) 4 5 6 55 +#'#(") +'#.3"!7 $8%!"# +",#3#"&"&(#+ + (.+!9 !&(7 $8%!"# +",#+#'3($#(" :::

;,#",#+ +#3+"#+' <%!< 3!3#+' -!2 =# !<<>#$ " '##",#?.$9-#("@

=#+# #++#$"",#+#3+"#+'+("@ A ;,#",#+ ",# ?.$9-#(" ',.<$ =# +#3+"#$ &( ",# $&9#'"@ :::

55 +!< !8&(9 !+9.#$ ",# -!""#+ !" '-# <#(9",7 <#!+(#$ %.('#< +",#3#"&"&(#+ !&+<2'.=-&"'",!"",#3#"&"&(#+=# (<2!

+$#$'&B-(",'C"&-#"8!%!"#",#$#-&'#$3+#-&'#'7 !',#$#'(">&',"3+#''",#3#"&"&((-#+&"' "&%# -"&( + (.+!9 !&(7 $8%!"#7 3+#'#(" &( %.+" ( =#,!< ",#%!8#!"++#'3($#("7!%%#3"'("&%#!($'.=-&"' ",!",#$#'("33'#",#3+!2#+",!",!'=##(!$8!(%#$=2 <#!+(#$%.('#< +",#3#"&"&(#+!($<#"'&B-(",'4"&-#=# 9+!("#$"",#3#"&"&(#+"#(!(""8!%!"#",#!%%--$!"&( &(D.#'"&(

,!"=#&(9'7",#+#8&'&(3#"&"&(&'$&'3'#$ &( ",# <<>&(9"#+-') & 3#"&"&(#+"#(!("',!<<%("&(.#"%%.32",# $#-&'#$ 3+#-&'#' + ! 3#+&$ '&B -(",' +- "$!2 &# .3"

*E && ",##("&+#!++#!+' +#("7& !(27',!<<=#3!&$ =2",#3#"&"&(#+"#(!(""",#+#'3($#("<!($<+$>&",&( .+ >##1' +-"$!27 !&<&(9>,&%,+#'3($#("<!($<+$',!<<=#

+##"#B#%."#",#+$#+ #8&%"&(E &&& 3#"&"&(#+ ',!<< %("&(.# " 3!2 ",# .".+# +#("F-#'(# 3+ &"' =2 ", #8#+2 -(", " ",# +#'3($#(" <!($<+$ ( ",# #8#(" #8#( ! '&(9<# $# !.<"7 +#'3($#(" <!($<+$ ',!<< =# !" <&=#+"2 " #B#%."# ",# +$#+ #8&%"&(

+",>&",E &8 3#"&"&(#+',!<<$# +!2!<<",#>!"#+F#<#%"+&%&"2 %,!+9#' +",#3#+&$,#>.<$%%.32",#$#-&'#$3+#-&'#'E 8 3#"&"&(#+ ',!<< 8!%!"# ",# $#-&'#$ 3+#-&'#' !($,!($8#+&"'!%".!<3,2'&%!<!($8!%!("3''#''&(7 +##

+- !<< #(%.-=+!(%#' " ",# +#'3($#("<!($<+$7 ( + =# +# ",# '"&3.<!"#$ $!"# &#

*7 !&<&(9 >,&%, +#'3($#("<!($<+$ ',!<< =# +## " #B#%."# ",# +$#+ #8&%"&(!($="!&(3''#''&(E!($ 8& 3#"&"&(#+',!<< .+(&',!(.($#+"!1&(9&(",# !=8# "#+-'7 =2 >!2 !( !

&$!8&"7 >&",&( "> >##1' +- "$!27 =# +# ",# #B#%."&(9 %.+"7 !&<&(9 >,&%, !9!&(

A +#'3($#("<!($<+$',!<<=#!"<&=#+"2"#B#%."#",#+$#+ #8&%"&( 8#-=#+*7

!?!( +.(!<<& .$9#