Mindro & ORS v. Krishan Kumar & ORS

Pooja Sharma 2017.03.18 10:34










 

 


 

 

 !"# ! $%"& '%

 %"& (%"&)& *"&$# *) #"# ! $%"& %&+ !% 


 
 
 

   '"%&% , "(#-$#.%$/#01!.2# %

 %"& 
  
 $%+"%&% "%.& +%

 $#&-%%  0%!) !%""

20%

 $% 
 &

)      !#  "  &%

 /  #&!%  +)/ %!  "!%"  !#

 %5)"%', +#&&%!-6 "22!% &
0# &"-) #01 7)!$# #$%"% #

%""% %""%! #&8 $%"-) #0819$%"%-61 $%#++02#

.%!-6

 %"& ""%0%#& /& %&$#"% $%&

 "& $%" % # 2%$#&-%% !& &&%! :"% 061 $%2#&%#"% $%20# &,+%

 %"&1 9$#"% $%"# ! 9  "2$0!"%  !%2%#&%!,#"!#"0 0%!20#

+%

 ) !%"%2  $% "(%$20%2 4;;$%"% #

%"

"% %""%! #&8 $%2 8 "/"#  #22)

!%# #"!#"0 # #22!% $%20# +%

 9#& 0%! $")/$

$%!%2%#&%!#&$&2$0!"% 9%"%  "$%20# +%

 9#&

#009%!# !20# &9%"%/"# %!2 ) % 
;1;

<,

9#"!&#00 $%$%#!&#&

%"9#&2 +" &%!9 $ $%"%&+ !% ,  &)"# 2%2 +# 6 ) #0#  120# ,

$%!%2%#&%!9#&#9#"!%!

<,# ! $%"% #  /#

 9#&"!%"%! -%+#!  "2$0!"% -69#6

&  $% #  #0&%!-# = 00 $%6#

#  $%#/% #>"

6   #++02#   9#&  .%!  -6  $%  20# , $%"   !%2%#&%!1 # %061 !"& $%"%  &$%&# 0!0#!6# !$#. / &)"2%  2 %$%&$#"!06 #  /- $  "2$0!"% 1 9$#"%&2$0/ / $#&#0&-%%   %!  $%#++02#

%" $%!%# $%"& 1&$%$#&#0&-""9%!& %# "%0# .%& % # 2% $%"&%0 # !  "/"# !2$0!"%  $%$#& +"#6%!  $%#++02# 19$2$&06 /!%+& %! & -%"%0%#&%! $%"& &$% #6-%#-0% # # !%!)2# %- $

 "2$0!"% #!#++02#  9#&!& &&%!.!%"!%"!#

 $%/") ! 2#  /-%6 ! $%#9#"!# !#009 / #++02#  9)0!# "%.%9 $%%#"0%""!%"19$2$&&)->%2

%" 2$#00% /%  $%+"%&% "%.& +%

  7%#" %!2) &%0

 %"&&)-

+)/ %!

"!%"$#&-%% +#&&%!9 # 6#++02#    !# ! %& 2 "#"6 >)!/ ? 8-0%   $%2#&% 



!

"


#$%!

!

&!#
'$
($
*!) $
#"
! *

$
 44 '7  7%#" %!2) &%0$#&#0&"%0%!)+  $%>)!/ $&
)"

 #+($*
 !
'$

,&#"

&#-*
#"
! *

$



;

!%2!%!  

  2%  9#&&&)%!  $%2#&% ;

(!%

"!%"!# 

1& 2%"%&+ !% & # ! 9%"%  &%".%!1 "%&$ 2%&9%"%"!%"%! -%&&)%! 7%#" %!2) &%0

 %"&2 % !& +)/ %!

"!%"$#&  $ / !9 $ $%"%&+ !% &# !%

%2  /&%".2%)+

&   %2%&&#"6 ?%#"!  $%  #"/) &  #!.# 2%!  -6  0%#" %!  2) &%0  "  +%

 %"&  # !  $#.%  #0&  / %  $")/$  $%  +)/ %!  "!%"  # !   $%"

!2) &#.#0#-0%  0% #2 &"%0# 0 / 20# +%

 1#009 / %-6

$%"-) #0# !&$#"%  /"#  "20# &-69#6 & # #  #0-# =#"%  !&+) %!$%+)"+&% !%+&   9#& % &)"% $%+#6 # $%"/$

22#&  9#&  %!  $%#9#"!+#&&%!-6 $%"-) #0 &-%% 2#&$%!#

#

#  /#/% #>"

6  "&  2% $%/"# !

 "& %0  %2%&& 6  %6#& $%"% 9#& &)"2%  2 % $%"   06 % # 2%  "

2$0!"% -) $%"%!)2#  #0&1&$% 0%!# #++02# ""%0%#& / & %&$#"% $%&  "& $%" % # 2% $% #++02# .%!-6 $%/"# !

$%"9#&!& &&%!9 2 &!%" /

$%/)!%0 %&&&)%!-6? 8-0%   ($
*!) $ .

$
/$(%

0

: $  "2$0!"% #"%  $%#/%/")+ , 6%#"&# !

 %6&   06"%@)"%! $%"%!)2#  -) "0.%0$!#0& $%+)"+&%# !->%2 /)!%0 %&0#!!9 -6? 8-0%

% &)"%  $%2  # #6  /  $%$# !

) &2")+)0)&+%"& &#&9%00#& .%"2 %  # 2#0!

2)0 6

06  -%"&   $%  !%2%#&%!,.2

     2#&%  $%  #  

 2  &  #009%! -%) 0A%!# $%"/$

%1 +)"+&% 9)0!-%&%".%!?9%.%"1 & -%&%%  "%#&  "9 $!"#9#0  &$)0!-%/% ) % ? 8-0%  
* "
($$ &#
'$
 * "

 

.0  $#&-&%".%! 9$%"% & "%@)"%!-6 $%+#"% $%.2

#22!% $%"%&  %2%&& 6 &&)%!"%2  & !%+&  # #  #0&%!-# = $% -&%".#  & #"%#&) !%", B7%#" %!2) &%0 $%#++%00# 0#& 06&)-

%!   +#6#-0% $%"& $%.2

&$)0!  $#.%-%% !"%2 -%=%+   5%!!%+&  #  #0&%!-# =  &# !2"2) # 2%& $%+"%&%

2#&%19%#"% $%.%9 #9#"!%!  #.)" $%"&&$)0!  -%=%+  # 5%!

!%+&  # #  #0&%!-# = 2#&%1 &$#.% 

-%% #0"%#!6 .%& %!1 %&$#00-%+#! $%"&1 -) 1  $9%.%"1   .%& %!  -6  !%+&  /  $%  &# %    5%!

!%+&  # #  #0&%!-# =1 $%"% #6-% & +"% )"% $!"#9#0 2#&% $%+#"

%&& % !C $&.%9 ? 8-0% $%)+"% %
)"

9#&#/# "% %"# 2#&% 
      
 

 !"#$$!# %'#"#  $%&#!>)!/ "%#!&#&) !%", :% "%9%+#"

9% )& -&%".% %.%  $)/$ /)!%0 %&0#!!9  )0>-$#8&2#&%$#.%-%% #++".%! # !#++0%!-6 $&
)"

  "%  %! 92#&%&1

# 6 "#22!% &
0# &"-) #0&# !%.% &

  ?/$
)"

&  $%"+#"

$%2) "6!  009 D%#"%#0& 0!  20# #"%&%

0%! ") &!%
)"

""-) #01 20)! /7=!#0# &"7=6#6#0#6#&1

$%&%/)!%0 %&#"%.%"0=%!D%9)0!0=% #=%

#-&0) %0620%#"  #00 2#&%& 9$2$2  & #9#"!%! " >)"62#)&%! # "#22!% 19$% $%"-69#6  #!>)!2#   "  #/"%%  -% 9%%  $%  +#"

%& 
)"

<"-) #0 )& #++06 $%&%/)!%0 %&D% )& #!! %

)"

$%"/)!%0 % $%%

%2 9$%  & .%&  # 5%!!%+& $%-# =&$)0! .#"#-06-%!"%2

5 #  %  $%5%!%+& %2%+  0# "

#!.# 2%&$)0!-%/"# %!  $%& "% / $%&#! $%%5+"%&&+%"

&&  <"-) #09$2$ "!%"%! $%!%+& $&900%0 % $%+"#2 2% #= / 0# &9$2$ #6-%)+ ;

E  .%& %!# !

$%"%-6!% %# $%.%"6+)"+&% $%"!%"D%!$+%

&<"-) #0  $%2) "6900  &)22) -

+     +%"

 /  $)/%  9 $!"#9#0&    $%  $+%  

!&+& / $%20# D%#"%&)"% &<"-) #0& 900"%#0&% $%"!) 6 9#"!& $%.2

$%#22!% &

#0#"/%+#"

$%2  # &  0& $%.%"6+)"+&% 0#6 /!9  $%/)!%0 %&9#& % &)"%

6 & $%20# &!  -%2 .2

) &2")+)0)&+%"& &# !) % $2#0#/"%% &"

#""# /% &D%!$+%)"# 5% 6 +" %2 $%20#

%5+0  -6&)2$%0% &900-%%@)#006&$#"%!-6



&<"-) #0&C $&.%9 $%? 8-0%)+"% %
)"

$#&-%% 2 &&

009%!# !/)!%,0 %&#&0#!!9   #&!#


2&"

!

&!#

.
.
'$
#&!#
!1
#"& 
.
.
/$(%

0
#"%-% /% "2%!.%  >)!/ ? 8-0%)+"% %
)"

 
* "
($$ &#
'$
 * "
/$(%

0
&  $%&#!2#&%# !!%&  0#6!9  0#9  %.%"62#&%# #!)0 -%"&%

0%! 9 $!"#9 $%#& 9#&&)/$ -%2 % !%! 22"! /061  $%  +"%&%  "%.&  +%

  &  #009%!  # !

+)/ %!"!%"!#

&&% #&!%# !#!"%2  &&&)%! "%0%#&%# # 
0#2&-69#6 +"% )"%"%0%#&%  2 2%" %! :# = $%:# =  #) $"

%& #"% #0&  !"%2 %!    "%0%#&% 9 $ #+%"! % !#6& $%!# "%2%+ 2%"

%!2+6 $%"!%"#

%"+"+%".%"

2#   #"2$ 1

 /
  0 +>#   D$% $%"&+%#= /<"%#& %!

F%& D$% $%""%+"

#-0% F%&