← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/1781/2023allowed

Kaushalya Devi Alias Kushaliya Devi v. State Of Punjab And Another

2023-04-11Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri28 pages

      

 

 

!"# $% #&'('$)

**  

   

      

  

    + , - +* . . .  

   !

"  #



 



   $  %%%% . . 

/

*

0-1  &

 '( 

 ''

' 

 

"

)





* ( + (  " ''



*"

)

 '(    "   # " (

,--

# + '(

   









.(

 ' "



  



/) "

/0



# !&"2!3 +!"4'5  1 &

(

(





 )  $) " '*"

2 (

 "

3(

  " #



(    4 5"

"

(

 (

6+ 57 

1 -1-81--9 ( ,-:

,18 ,17 ,1, 7;

< 7= +# "

" ) /

(

 ( (  =-,1-7 ( " ) ) 

 ,

 &

  3(

  " #



(  (

) ' "

( (

/  3(



  1;-,1-7 '( ( 

3(

 " #



(   #"  ,-,1-7 /'



  

'( 



 '(

(

"





  

 

)

  :11-,  ' ("

 (

()

(

" " )

)

'

 

)



("

 

 ( (  (

( (  *

(

 =-,1-7

, 3

  

,-,1-7 



()





 .

1 ># ?

'(

  ( 

 

  &   -7-91-9



 )

(  "

  

3(

(( $    (

) /

  "

 

  

( ' 



()



  ) (

' (   )  "

( 

)





 '  -9-=1-9 



  $) "

"  @

  ((

 "

''



)



  '( '

, ( 

' )



     '(  ((



 '

"



)

 "

 "

''

  $) "

7 & 



 1-8  '

 

 # "

#A8;:1-8

*"

" )

 

  '( ((



 '(

 '

 "

 '' &

  '

    #

"

 



 .

1  19-11-= & #  (

 ( 

11

 #  ( 

(

)

 

")  #     B     C (  =11-;

 





  ") 

( '(    )

 @,



( (



(

' 

 (  (





 

"

  *

"

 '



11 &







  

(  B

                                    

          

    

       

  !               

                

7

                      

         9 & 

)

3(

 " #



(    (  ( " )

 





" 

)

'





 "

(

  (

()

( (



 '  ( ( 3



( 

(

" "

 " )

(  '(   (



) 

  -=-,1-1D   8 +

(

   (   #



 .

1

 " #



(  



) "   1=-:1-= > .

,?

  "



   (

() ( ( 

)

   )  ( ( '

)  ( +

  ) "    

( () 

((



D

"

"

'

( 

 '



) " 

( 

11>?

 #  (  (

(



' 

( ( () # +

  

 " #



(   

 ()

((  () 



 

)

) 

")

 " )  (( "

9 (

*

)

  (  ( (

(( ) ( ( (   (

'



 '

"

)(( ""

(







 

 

  

"

'  

11>?

 #  (   & 

'

 

 ) ""

  



 " #



(   A (

)  ( "

) )

 ( 



3( ' 



    ) 



(

'     

"

'







 .278'(('$)( 3#!4)#:

&$2)(#3 %$4 ";# <#"'"'$)#4  :

 

  ( 

  )

!

"  # (

 ''

 (  ( 



   # /

 )



 

 1-9  ) ;



 

 "



"

)





* (

(  "   /

 ) 

)

'

  ( 

  ( )  ' "

(  )

(

   &

 ( ( "







 1-7 " '(



 

 

 # ) '



 

 1-9

 D 

 ( ()

(

"

8

"

"



 (

   (

   





( ,=7

#

#) ( 



)











)"  " )

 ''

'

  /

 ) ) "  '( 



 " #



(    

 



 " )(( " ""

'(  D  " )  '#

5(

 )  ( * 

 " ) 6 )

) "  



 1-= '( 





  "



 " "

)(( 

) "  

 " 

 '( *' (

  ( /

 )



)" 

( )





  ' /

 )  #



 .

1 

((  (

 " #



(  

 

 '



11

 #  (  '

) "  

 ' 

 

11 

 



 ( )



 @

( )



 "

' 

  '( ((



 "

'   .278'(('$)( ";# 3#!4)#:

::'"'$)!3 :=$&!"# #)#4!3/ 2)>!7  ; 3

 



   

: (

$   '

 "

 



  5, ) 

)

'



 

( (

'

 (

) (( 

()  ( ( 

" )(( 

'

)   ( * "

 ( ' " )((   ( * "



 ' "

)



 )

   

 ) 



 )

) ' "

() ( (

  

" 

) ) (

( D 

'  



    ' 

   )!39('( $% (278'(('$)(  = + 



 ( 

  " - 

 "

  ( 

 (  



) "   1=-:1-= D

 ( 



  '( 

)

'   3  

)

' " (( ) (





 ()) "

)(( ""

(

'



  

 "

 1-9 

" 

" 

 1 (

" 

" 



 D  ""

"

 '"

 "

#  



) " 

;  (  (  D 

 "



  , $    

)

( () 

((



D

"

"

'

(   /'

6+ '(



 ("

'(

) ( (

"



  "  "

#

"

( 

 7 + 

 (

) " 

 



 

'  

11>?

  ( " 

 ' 

 

11>? 9 A"

  

  )

 )

(

 '

(

()

(

" 

 

() '



 





  &

   

   '"

 '(



 ) )

(



       & #



  .

1 

 

((  (





 

 '



11

 #  (  ) ++ &

  

( 



#

>?

#

>?

#

>(? 



# 

=

(  $    % &

                    

      '          

           

   

  

             

      

 

            

 '       

  

       

  % ( )       

                     *       

   *    

      

      



 

   +  ( )        

          

      ,

 ( )

-        

 

        *,       

  

                                  

                

  

         .

  

-

 

       

( )              '    

   !  

          

  '  .

      

        

      

   % 

*  $

/  

      0    !   1  234  (23    234)+     *    $

   /      

     

      ,       

  

         50  ! 1234(23234)(         ' )        

  

!

!  %1

'  

   .

 

   



6% ( )      



    

  +

()      



  

      6% (2)      

   



'          

                     

()  '             

                  , 



 7 



    

   

    

 

(4) ,'  

     ( )   

   (2)   (4)  

    

       *   

 6% ( )0 

( )-   .



        



   .

 

            

         '               

  

    

   *  

                             *

  

   

      () 

   

(2)(4)

                   *  .

  *   

8

 ( ) 9



                    

            

          

   

     

 

  

            

        

 

   

'  

   

  

1 

       

     

  



    '   



  2( )

     

:      

               '       '  !   

 

                

*

              (     

 

1  ,'



  '

$1/ '

$;/  )          1  ,'

 

        

     

  

        

              

      

                               

  1  ,'



                       .

 *         

    

!  2 %1               

 *,

      

                       <        '      

  1  

        



  ( 

,

       )              

   



!  %!         

 

          

    

 

' 

   

    

       

    

                          

   '                 

 , 

 

              ,     6,

  % (2)!

                     



  ,                   

            

             

      

          + ()!

                      

  ,  % ( )         ' + ( )         

       +

 ( )   

      ' 

   

          

      

7                  

       

   

(4)"                        

  ,          

          

       + 

 

   !    

               

   %& 

 

% ( )                                       +  ()                       % ( )   

                    =  

  >  

+  ( )             

! 6%1   

 

     

         

               

 1  ,'



     

()     *  ,                     

              

    

  

         .

  

 

9



"

-                 

  ()   

                   

( )           

             

 

                                      

            *    

*

           .

                      

           + 

  ,

,

   

                                         

  

          

      

                    

 6

         <           

2?

   !    (

      1 )     23@?  

       

( )( )

 ( ) 

 5     

      

  ,

,  

  

  

()

      

 

,

  (2)               

                             

                   

8    

    

!  % 

    

       

    

  A B                             / 1  

  

( '

D 

 

.)"

  )

 " #



( 



 



 

' 

 '



11

 #  (   

11>?

 



" (( )  (

"



"

)

)

" '"

 ''"

 

  

 ( (  ()



" "

)(( +

(

'

 ( (  ()

(

*

"

")

# "

( ( ( /'

(

( ( ( 7;

,17@7= ,17 ,1, < ,18@7= +# "



" 

(

'

( D

* 

   )

 ( ( +  (

( 

 

11>?



()  '  )

"

$

) '

 

 

" (( '( 

)  ( 

"

 '

(



    

 D  

" (( 6 )



) 



 " "

)(( 

 

("

 



:

"



" ((

 (

'  

(

'

 D  ( 

(

"



(

"

 "





"

 " "

)(( /'

(*"  

  

 





 )*"

 

" "

)(( '(  *' (



 , 

11>?

 '  '

$

) 

)

" '"

 ''"

 

  '

)   

(



"  "

(

)



'





(  ( $

) 

)   (

(

"

  " "

)((  ""

(

"

  (

("

(

  

 )    /'

(



) 

(

"

 (

(

"

"

"



  4

 

.

 E   C     0 

 

  

11>?

) 

(

"



 



 '(

 ("



( 

  

( 

( 

 )

 

 ( 

.

     C 



(

()

(

"





 '(

()  



(

(  '(

"

* ("F(

) /'

(



; )

"

) " 

 



( ,=7

#

#) (  &



   

 " ) 

 ( 

(

"

"





 '

 

 

 (

(

"

"



 

 D  *"

  

11>?



)

"

) " 

 1-=

 )



 (



'   (

'   )

 @,

   " "



 "

  "

"

( )

 (

#)) '

(

 



 D  " "



   "



(  ( '

(  )

 (

#))

7 

11>(?

  '

)   (

(

"

 #

>?



11  '

) 

(

"

( #

>?

  " ( '    "

"

()     '



 "

 ()) ("

)



 



 '(  (( (

(

"    



 

 

.(

"

).))

 '( ' 

)



  D "

(



  



 







)) 

( "



 '(

( 

G   "  ()

=  " 

 ) 

(( (

(

"     +

(



) 

(

"

 (

(

"

"

"



 

)

'

) " 



 1-= 

 

" (  

' 



>(?



11

9 &

" ( 



  # " '

) " 

 (

,--

# + +   # "   

 

/0



#   /) " & 

( "

(  (

'

 ''

   ;

 "  #

(

 '

   (

,-- 

 

(

1

# +  

"

'



  *

'

" !

''

8 &

D  '( D

'

'

 

 



 

  )

 '

 (



)

  '  '

'( 

 

)

(

 +

(



  (

"

 





  (

$    



'

'

  '

 '  '



   )

 

  ) 

 ( 

(

"

"





1-

 (

(

"



)

"

) " 

 1-= (



      

 )







 ' ) "   

 

 " #



( 



 " )(( '(  " 

 '( 

)

' &

")    (

$   

)

 





)  ( (

' 

) ) (

 "

(  ( ")  +

'   

  " >)?

 

((   5,



 ( (  =-,1-7

  " #



(  4 5" (

 ( (



  59-:

 1;-,1-7 '( ( 

(

 51  " #



(   ,-,1-7 &



 

"

 

)

 ,-,1-7



 .

1@&

 " #



(   &





 19-,1-7   



 (  ,-,1-7 & 

  (





  : &

'

' "

" ( 



  '( 

 





(

( A (*

 =: # ( /0



# B#   

1 $ C "%&"

''(() 

  



 6)  " (

,>?

# + /'

 



77 )

# + " 

 ()

# " (

,--

# +   6)  " &







  ")

(  B,1

 

  

      &  ;

 :

 :  

 * 

+ , -./ "%0& " 1&2 3$

:  

   

      

.

             

:  





                      ,    

      '          



           

   

    '   

       

                  

               

    

        

           .



             

  

   

 

 

  

        

    *   #     

   !       ;

          #                 

          

    



11                     

   

    

 !          .

                           

   

    

.

     

   "          

  .

        

               

                    

:*                 *     

   #   

 :  

     ;

    

       

          ,  

'          

          

 ! 4+     -"%025('62%  

.

  D 

D D  D      *   1  23(2)()  42(2)       

      D      



   D.

; &  B *  4 ! C 7."%28' (80

/0



# 

 " 

 "





$

) 



    



"



   &

  

'



1,  

/0



# B 97 :     C "%%% ',(6& '

= &  /0



#  

")

 B ;#  ;

*    C )"( " ''")" (



'

"



"

"

"

   5;

8

  ")

(  $E       

       1            ,      

      < !

"



0 9 8  +(23E4)2 ! 4?5#  < <  ;       6 $2E    

       .

       1   .

  

 F   *     !    F          

     

             F ?

-    F-     F-      

     F     

           

      F-       .

                   

17   

?

   .

               

         

  



          

  

                     ; < "

 

 ! ; 

0 G23@2H!

!

A4B    

  

             '    

 

'     

   

   

  

    C                 

   .

  

      

  

  

  

              

      

     

 ! 



1 9 . ! (A)/

       

    

$  /                             1    4??,1        

2A  

    

          

 >   $  / 1  4??,1        $())57   ++   + :

,"    

19   

   / 0        .

                    

           1              

          

   1   4??,1        

        



           

     



      

   

     / 1-

6 (  # B .      C "%%( ( /6%%  (





' " " '



) '

())



(  (  '  



 

  (

'  '  ' &





(  9:

1        

  6, ( ) '            

    !        2??                



  

      

( ) '   

 



 *     



 .



( )                       



( ) '     <  .



     

   

18         .



          *   



          

    .

 .

     

 

() .

   .

  

( )    



  .

  

( )   '   

 

  

  / 1 + ( ")



  (  # - $* $%   B<    C (  -;-11-1,  

 (

(   (

(

 ( )

  &





  ")

(  $    

 '   .

   

" 2                    

    

 11 + B,#  *  ;          :  

+1  4 .

 '

 C )"( "

''(8(

/0



# 

"



 '

(

  #   "   ) "  =

  ")

(  B=

                  

        



1:      

   :

         

   

     

   " 

    

     

      

      (9 6 / ; - ))& ")''662=7      - )") ")''6(= )") 6'' '  %-    4+      !  $  7 -

)""

&''2&8>7.)""'"%2%- 1+ 4#*- )""

")''6)6> )" (''

'  &0%>7.)"'88%  7   

/    9 - )""

%''(86> )""

6''

'  0&(>7.)"'8&(?C $)&32('$)  1, +

 '

 

( (()(

(

 (  ()  '  '

  



 )



 

'     & 

#  /) "

 



 17 # D 

 '

 &

) "  > .

,?

 1=-:1-=  &



 ( .





 



)

.

)





"

'   H8I

) )



 (( 



  '

 

) )  



   '( ((



 '(  

1;





  



 "

'   8I

) ' 

) )   + (

  ) 



 '

 , ) ) 

 

  

  =I

)   8I

) 19 # "

  (()( '

 ''



 '

 

 1-9 '( ;

 " 

 *(*

  # '(

'



( )

" "  ( (

( )

  

 

.

 ( '( 

   1 ( '(  



 '

 , ) )  

**

0. . 1 ;



  A

*"@ 

J 1 A



J