← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/845/2004dismissed

Punjab Singh v. State Ofpb.

2020-08-27Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu12 pages



   



!  "

  

# $%&  

      

!!""

#



!  

  '( 

# $%&   "  $$ !!""

#



!   %)  * + %, !

- !.

-%/

 0 + %, !

-  -  -

 

% # 

$    !!""

 &'()'*'( % #!

" + "   !!""

 &','*'( % - .+ " " .  "

///  -  - / !,

   $$  1      "

+          "    

  !! "  2  ! !  $$

$    &$ "!! "3 ()'*(  " 

  &$ "!! "3 ,'*(  "    *

!! "     

$   0450  ( 

 !

67!

   & 3 0+ 

!!""

++ +  !



"   0)3   !

 04)8 93

9:         $! $ 

!;+"<  !

  0)5'   

"    $! $  !    = ; !    ""   = 

'

> !%

 >  &>  1

67!

 " + !" "+ !  3

    !!     $ 2

   ""

% + "?



 )  %  2   3  '0=.'(()+  $ $""

 % + "?

 

  ""!+"! ;!! 2  0'2 $$"!



 +    2 ;" $  

"  $$ > $ $ ! 

$! $   2$

2    + " -+     >   " 

  

+    + ! "2 +  >     

2     !+ $ @  $  "  "



  2  A!    ! $ %  .

7A+    +    $$B@ )  $ .

7A A  +"$  .

$   

 C   !

 , = $ -

2 $       

1 $"    .

7  A     C  -  "           $  @  $  "+  !  !      2+     &  $$B@ 0+ !!

++  

  +      >    A

     " 

!+  +)

!!! 2+2!  "     +   $ ""!

2">   A 

 $0) - !

+ $!"!!! 2 +   $$ 

 !!

!

" ;!

"+ "  ; $   !!! 2    

+ + B 

   =4? , $!!! 2  !

!

"

+ !!

 ;!

"+ " >   A+ "9% ;  " @ "9.

9 ;  ""!

" " + 2 + 2  ! $$B@ ++   +  &    0+ "$



    

  2+ "    & 2  ""   ""

$+ 2   ! $$B@ 0   + $ ""

  B@ +  "   

+$ 6>B@ +   3 $ "  !"

 !"

 $ + + "   !

$!"!

"+ &$ "B@ $ +!B@  "

   $!"!

" 9!!! 29 $!"      ""

  D !!""

+ !   ( ;!  @ $  +   !! ;

  $    =0=&  & + ;   ""   * !"    !!2 ""  -   C %E "+  !!$ "    & !

       ""$!"     ; !"  +!2 !$""

 ! % 2

  

 $!"   "     &   -+ "       ) ; !!""

+     

 -  !! "  , F  "   "!

   

$     F0.

$   % 2 !   = + !  C 

 ,  $+"$ $



     "   !     ""

% F     +   2 A $$ " !

 , () $ -   +   !"!



" + 23  '0=.'(() -   $"   .

7"A "   $ @  $  " !  !     2+        " "

  !   .

7A %   ; @!   

    !  ;   $$B@ 0+ !!

++ "  

$ A + 

   2 !   

 !  >  >

+   >    )

    !!! 2+ "   " 0,

$ !!+ 6$    )

!!! 2+ $!" +  $  0 $!"  ""+!

 !   $!" ;+ " 

 +    $! 9% 9 - " @ "9.

9  0 $!" !

"  )

 +$ +      =4 ,2 !!! 2 "

+

 ;

+!

2  "  !

" 

 + "9% 9 - " @ "9.

9    $ ;  

  "   +     $!"  !

"  +   2     !" !  $$B@  

 ++ 

$  

+      > &  05'  !  + "7$$B@ = ;0,

 !++ " 2  ! $$B@ ( ; 2+ " 7 $$B@    F

-A C !   = + ! >  &> 67!

 A    " + >

  >

+   !" "+!    +

    % F "?

 

 )  $  2 3  '0=.'(() $$% F "?

 A  !   2+  ""!+"

  2+ !!    0'  2 $     F    "!        !"   "  

!!    

   "  +  -+    >   " +  !  +   

$  "  2+

'

2  " "   ! .

7A %   ; @!    ! 

.

7A     $$B@ )+ !!

++     ; .

$   C +  "" +" $  ;  !  ".! ; "    C .

7A "  $ @  $  " !  !     2+        " "   !   .

7A %   ;  !    $  $$B@ 0  ;      2+")

!!! 2$  

!+80,  :    +  "+ $!" +  $80  :$ )

+ 2   B  )

 +$ +       =4 ,2!!! 2 "

+

  ;  ""0 !

" )

$   !!! 2+ " $+ 9% 9  .

$ " @ "9.

9  "" $!" )

 !!! 2 ;  !!+  2  !  $$B@  " + 27$     +   $ >    05'  !   +7$$B@ = ;     B@ !"    

+$ "6>B@ +   >.

  0,

!++ " 2  ! $$B@ (  $   &B@ 4  ""B@ 0  ""

B@ 00+ 2   ! $$B@ 0  +  $  

( $$B@ 0=++     ; !!

  !"

B@ 0(+$   $ +  A   !"  !  +""  !! 

-A?

"!  + " !!+ "9?

9  $!" "$!     -2 !!  ! $$B@ 0)  - $  >?

"!

  A  ,  

 ++ !   *

!

""

 2  45'  !   

  ! " +7$$B@ 0,  +    $$B@ 0 

 +

"$ ""@ $ !" !!"  B@ 0  A !!&$ "B@ $ B@  ""

+ "  

 -  !!%A'0%A') ; 2    +2   + "   C

  @ $    

 +   # " $   - 2 +

  "  A " >   2 +$  F "   >   $$ ""$ 

 +  

+   5 !

  +   2 

 +     2 - $2 +      

  + +  2  0 F=   >   "     &>    67!

  !     = + ! &> 67!

  A       !"!

 

 >  &>  " +!" " + !   .  % 2% +    +

 A 

  2 $$% F ++  ""!  > %

  ; 2+ !! 0'2 $   ;!" !

+  ; !!  "  $$ ++    2 - !! ! ++      2

  "   - $ 

  

+    !

 # " 2 +$ " 



  !  +    

$   2 -$     ! 

.

7A %     @!   

.

7A      $$B@ )+ !!

  ;  +"$ .

$   C + 2    .

$   ! -"    +"" .

7"A - 2  

     !   !   $$$B@ 0 ; 

     2+" )

!!! 2"  0,

!+ - !    2   $!"  +  $$ )

 +  

  2 $ !    05'   !   + 2  ! $$B@ = 0,

!++ 2  ! $$B@ ( $ &

"  ""

+ 2  ! $$B@ 0 > @ $    2 +

  "  ""



"? + 

  ""



  -

!

     ""



   ""

 -+  "

 !+

 

2 0  F(  >  ?

"!     

   67!

  !       = + ! -A C ;

 

 &>  !  $   " + !! $!"     "% .

 2 " +

;

  -        " !!+ "9?

9 

 $!" "$!  2 $ !  $$ B@ 0) ; + " !""2 ! A = = !  #>   !!  >.

 $!  " + !! & 

!!"  B@ 0 + $ B@  A    !"   >.

 !! "  + $!"$  A ) =   $!" & 

">> *    !  &$ "B@ $ 

 

  $$  = +$

 "

  ;  0 (   $!"  &'>>*     + !  $ 

2!$  "    !!$  +$  $!+ $  ""+   " $!"     +  ""

 $  0=  F)-&* "+        B@ = !   ) = + ! !"  C A   

-A"  C  $) $!"!!! 2+   $  "+   $! ?

% .

 $!" "

" +23 &)50 ) = !  $  6   E

 &   A  $    2  + $



  

   E

 &   , =   -+ "  $!"+ !

  A  =  $

2 !"   

  $!"!!! 2 2

-A?

"!  "  C  A 0 (  &$ B@ $ 

 !) $!"  !!! 2    +  $ " " " + $!" " &$ B@ $ 

    ! A $ 

2!"    ! -A   "   $!"!

" $      $!+$  ""+  "   0(  F, >.

    = = + ! 

C A    >?

"! -A C $  !!  !   $ "  >""

%    C   -  $   !!"   B@ 0      "    >""

%   !  " + !! +&  !

B@  A   !"    $ > ?

"!   $   "   !!$  +$   $!+ $  ""+  " 0)   !  !  B@       &$ "  B@ $  

    $!"+ !+!!!  %!  % + !    $!"  0,  6$

 "    = F



-A C  " + >   >

+    !" "+!    +

   %  "?



 )  $  23  '0=.'(() $$

 % F "?

 A  !  2+  ""!+" 

  2+ !! 0'2 $   F "!!" "

  !!  

 ++   2 

 ++      2  "  +  -+    >    " ;  +  !! " "      !  .

7A%   -!

  !  .

7A  .

$  +  "" ! -   !!  " "     !   .

7A %    ;  @!   

    !  &  $$ B@ 0+ !!

     )

    !!! 2+  "   " 0,

$!!+     +  "+ $!" +  $80  :

$ )

+ 2   B  )

 +$  +      =4 ,2!!! 2 "

+

 ;  ""0!

" )

$   !!! 2+ " A   !"  

 !  +""   !!  -A?

"!  + " !!+ "9?

       $!"   "  $!            A  , 

  

 ++ !   *

!

""

 2 -+     $$B@ 0  0 ;" 2 $!"  F( > ?

"!  F)-&* "+  F, >.

  ;

 !!$!" + ""! " "$ "  0   !  !  B@       &$ "  B@ $  

    $!"+ !+!!!  %!  % + !    $!"  04  ; 

  "

"  F= >   $ ! "   >  @ $     2 +

  "  ""

 

"? + 

  ""



   - !

     ""



  ""

 >

"$   

 + +  2    A $ 2 

" $     $!"   !" " "   !!2 "%E   !! !" ;   

" F+  $ "  0  ;     !   

" 

 ;    ++""    E ; "&     " !! " $ 

#!.

-%& # -  - &  !

 

!

 

3435

(/



F ! 2 5   < F!

" <53