High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/457/2009dismissed

Lakhbir Singh & ANR v. State Of Haryana

2017-02-03Mr. Justice Surinder Singh Grewal,Registrar-Judicial20 pages

!" "#$%$ &' ()

)

' + ,) --)-)- + ,) ---

! "

% # "# &'()&((*!" +###

&,0

.0"

"# #

# 12)!1(&!&(- + # 1) 3

!-52(6 73 478

&5()&((*!" +# " #

." !/" &0$#!% 1- ) $&"

&2" 34!

./ 12)91)3 1 '(((9, % % % :

% 1(&91)3 % % '(((9, % % % :

% &(-91) 1 1(((9, % % % % 0

.0 12)91)3 1 '(((9, % % % :

% 1(&91)3 % % '(((9, % % % :

% &(-91) 1 1(((9, % % % % & $# "

-&(2&((5!# % ,;<6 =,-(8% % >: 1) 3?6 =,-'8

-((2&((5 -(((9-(-'%!@

#+ %

" A

+ %4

.% < "#$

3 % +!##

./ !##

&,0

# ## 0

. ! %<.

#% # % +$ % #

%+ # + % %!

#%, +

# %%%$" #

"#% /!

# ## -((9-1(% "

-(9--(2&((5B % >: ,1) % # % ,;<6 =,-(8!A3>: ,-2+

" + 1

=,-', 3?!3 "

B# # #

## #>: ,-)# ## B #"

# % !#

# ? # ,## ,0

=, -&,<+

! #

. $!

./ !0

% >: ,12!

>: ,1C

>D ,15#" 3,?6 =,-'8 # % =,-2, 3 ?"

! B!

# ! + # ## ,0

" " =,)?<%! # #B#! # 4%!B# 3 #

#! #

>: ,&( 3?"

# >:#" # #

=,-),?% !;$ !< +#% 3 # % % ##

# ,## ,0

. ! %# !+

+ $

#+ $ ! =,-),?% >:#" !

+:% !+#++

68$

+ =,--,0

+,/

$3 "

B# # @ #

@ >: -5 # $

+ " # >: ,-C $! "

B#+ %+ #

+ #

# + + % B

%# %

# ,## ,0

! %# %% >: ,)- ,)1 ) -'(2&((5! ,

. / !0

% >: ,))!>: ,)'

>: ,)2#"+# # ## # #% +

# 3 % ! ## ,

# " 7!+#+ #

+ " # "%% >: ,)C## ,0

# " # !7

6 8 $#+ " %% >: ,)5$ 7

+ #0

# " # !+#+ " %% >: '($3 "

B# %# %% >: '2 ,'5B &*(2&((5!# ,## , %<

< + $! # % % " !

# -C1 4

# !-*C16 74 478+ 4 ' $#+# %% 4 0 # " (5(*&((5 2 ##

# ,## +#

# -)5!12)!1(&!&(- + # -)* 3 4 4 " (C-(&((5 +#

#% C #! :% % : + 5 # " #!## +:%

# 1-14 4!+ ## ,

. / "

-(9--(2&((5 -(&(%!<+

. ?

# %% ,

! +

# % / " < +# #

A3 ;

--(2&((5+

# )'&!1&2!1&)!1&1!1)3 4

# %$" +

+ %!+#+

%# " % * ,0

.0 %#

" + %

# %

4 / "

# " + -( #" #!## :% ?=,-, 4 ! "# " !/# 34/

! ?=,& 3 !3 "

B# #A3;

--(2&((5!

# !+#+ <+

6 =,-&8!

. ?

% 0

!?# ?=,1" ! ?>6

8! " # >:?,C

>:?,5

*)-21,'&&&C

*)-22,)'')'

*)-21,'&&&C % ;

! #

*)-22,)'')'

% ? %!A

4 ! ?=,), !;

B#!/% !4,&',3

, ,

33!

***2(,&2&-)

% 4

% 0< ! ;

-)1&!= ;

&)! 4 !

#!49 B#!

# %

-&(2&((5-&15'C

" # %E

>:?,*##

#" # #

# -C14 4 #A3;

--(2&((5>:?,*$! #" #+# -- # " #

# ! 4 " %

% # "#

"# ,

. /

. 0 #

# 12)!1(&!&(-!1)3 4!+# ,##

<. ! %<.

. +#@ # + # %

% " %

&5()&((* -&

" +

% # "#

#! ,

.0 -1 = " #

" %# :% # # -)

% !

! "

A3!+#

: 3

+ # ## # % ,;<6 =,-(8 !+

%% % ##

E # % #

% " #

!+#

-' #

4 #@

# ,## , %<. ! <.

. + % +% " #"

% #

# " # " # ,## !

" "# %" # -2 #

% % % " ##

% ! % "

% +%

% #

# #

+ # $!#

+# " #

## $! #

" # #

# ## + # %% # -C #

+ " %

+ " $ # + @ /!

$ # % +

# # -5 #

% # #

% + A %% =,-&, <+

! +# %

# ## # %

+ # +# %

% =,-2, 3?"

! B

=,),?<%! # #B#! # 4%!3

B#!#

+ !?% !;$

$! #

# A ! ## " %# 3 ,# =,-&,<+

"# 0

! -*

A3# : $%%% "#%+%

!+ + # ## #

## ""

% >: ,12

,1C

# !

# "

>:#"

$ #

+ #

# >:#" !+##

" + #

"#" # " +# # + # % #

%# # ,## " #@ 4

+ %# &( =" " #

# &- " ! ## #

-(9--(2&((5 -((9-1(%6 8$ % # % ,; < 6 =,-(8 >: ,1)

# 3?6 =,-'8 -&(2&((5-)(%$A3 >D ,-2 -&(2&((5 11(%$! 12

% #3 A3 !% " #

"#%! #

# #

% #3# % " #

% % 0

! !#A3;

5) --(2&((5

# )'&!1&2!1&)!1&1!1)3 4+

# <+

6 # 8!/

! +

++ # #$% # % %

# %

# @ # ! % "

## && $ %

A3# +

" $!%

# #! #

!# " #

" # " ## #$

# #

# # ## % # 5 /

6 &2 !/"6%7%)-! !" ))*

* *)))

6$.$& 48 -3 #-! !" 3&9 :7%)0! 6-$&;/

* ))) 6$.$& 4 < 7:4 #

+ "# + "

A3! 4 @ !

A3 "+ ##% #% "#

# # &1 #

# #

# % +# %

% + 3# # %%

" % $ # %

" + +#$+

:# +# %

+%%##

%%!+ # "%

% %"

"!" %

# % + % =,-', 3?! =,-2, 3?"

=,-&,<+

%% #%

# #9" %

# " # # + =,-&,<+

# " !+#" %#%%

% # 4 !#

:# ## + %

# #

$ 7 :4 # -! !" = 6& ! > 7%))7) &93& !/";

?2 &2&6)

( *))) 6$.$& 4(

+ # " 3 # :#% %%" + %%## % + 3 # %%

% %% + %

#!+ + #" 3 # !

###

# #!+# % %

# " "! ++ %%! : # #

$ +

+ $ % #

# G &)

# # # +

+ # % % + 3 % =,-&,<+

!% # " +# ## %" % 0

% $! # # %

% # #$

% # #

# 7#!% # #

% # # " # +#

% " !

% %% %! % # #

## #

+ +"

+ % # # +#

% ## % # .

2 ; 6-$&;/7%)-! !" $/ 6

))) 6$.$& 4

- &' #-! !" ))7%) 6"%/ &2 !/"6%

** )))

6$.$& 4(@! 7:4

F&' #% #!

% # #

% " !

%! %% % %

# #

% ## #= % % # # !#

+ %% % "% +

# !#" ##

+"! %

# # ! # #!

%% % "% "%+#

# # #!

+# " ## # $# %

# +

+ # #G $! "+ !

# # !+# %

## + &2 3

" + #%

% # + 3# # %%

" + " # " " # #%! " % # 3+" # 3 "

%+ $!3 "

# % @ + :% #

" # "# # # + #

" " =,-),?% !;$ !

< +

&C % =,-(,; <6# % 8! =,--, 0

! =,-&,<+

# %

# " # ## % #-/A . :37%)-! !" ))

)) 6$.$& 4

@( -

- / :322$&7%)-! !" %% .<

*( * 6$.$& 4 8*) % ! =,-),?% ! ; $ !

< +!:#

+ >:#" !" :% #

, 0

.0 % % ?% !; $ !+ "

,3 #

# !

=,-),?% !; $

+ $

# =,-),?% ! ; $ %% >: ,1';

@ + +

" 3!+

!+ : =,-, / %!

?% < !; $ >" !

# ,:% ;$ +

$ + " #

# =,-),?% !; $ &5 $ ## "

% + # #

# # $ 7 %4 # >"%/ &2 & !/"6

7%)-! !" )<

**(-3B6"." 36! %"% 6$8 (

+ %

# # @

% "

% # ."%/:/ $ / &:/ $= 4$ &2 !/"6%7%)-! !" 39 6 !<

**(-3B6"."

36! # %"% 6$ *

< # + ! $ 7 %4

#" # " % % 3 "

B# % # 6.

2=3. 67%) -! !" "4/$<

*( ))) 6$.$& 4 - &* $! ##% #!+ >:#" " :% #

## !

# # 1( $

# ,## <.

! %<.

. +%

# %% #$ 4

#@ ## <. !

%<.

. # /! #@ # ,##

$ 7:4 #$C & &2 & !/"67%)-! !"

// !$%; 6/<!/6 3;/!/"/$"-"#6"! 6A< 0!) // !$%; 6/

( ))) 6$.$& 4@@

F-& + ##

,## #

" #

+ #3 # # H

8$# 0"&$. 9 6B 6!$ &

"0$2"&#"$% 3&2!

:"2"$#$"&!<$&# %"6"%$23"$%%3$#$"&!!

B6 0";3$4! & ##3%"2<& !?$!/%! &2$&; #D3$!! 4 &3.:"6

!/"6# ##3%"2B"6% &%</$%# &0$#!$ &# &:". $&! $&"2)3

4 %#=##

% ! $!?

342:" B"&!

!/" 36!!

# &0$#! & ##3%"2 & !?$!/%! &2$&; !/" #! !/ ! "0$2"&#" / % :""& 3&2 !

2"$#$"&!!

B6 0";3$4! !/"6 ##3%"2B"6% &A # %+ %+

$%:%H

% H

# 3

+ #

$%:%H

% H

#" ##

%:%# % ## +3% # % ! ##% %

% $

# % "

"@ + " #+#4 %

" ##% #!

+ % # 7 %

" #76 $% 644$0)/"-! !" !! 6 6 2"%/< * -(@@) # % ##

" #@ ! " # %! #% + !+%

# # + " "# % #@ 3 + 4 ## +

#@ % + +# "# 6 363#/ 6 &-$&;/ &2 .)0)-! !" 3&9 :< * @-@ )G 1- #//$! 6. 47%)-! !" 9 %!/ &

( * ))) 6$.$& 4 ! 7:4

" # ,## !# "# %

## + %# # # % %+ 1& "+ !#@ # ##

% 11 A %% =,-&,<+

! =,-' 3 ?! ## ,

./ % >: ,12

## ,0

.0 % >: ,1C3

" %% =,--,0

! =,-),?% !

=,-2, 3?"

!3 "

# % !

# "

## 0

=,-1,0+

+ @ A

,3!?# # >: ,1*

C #;

-'+

<+ <%

! + #

# $! % " #!# %

+# " % ,0

.0 % % !

+## #

" # #$ 7 :4 # -! !" / 6 %/!6 7%)-36"%/

*)))

6$.$& 4 *

F&2 =

# + ##

# +

% + # # +

+# # %B %+ "# # #

+ "

# #

+ "

+# # /##

# #% #

# #% + ## + % #% # # %+# # ## % $### + # B:

+#%

+ ## #%

# +#%

+ ! % +

#% # %# #% +% % #

# + #%

# &C >" # #G 1) % + ?" / #

7? 4 # $B 47%)-! !"

8)))

6$.$& 4 ( *)## "

" : +#%

A %% =,*,?0

<% 0

% % >: ,&C!# % + +

# EC:)#% " # B #

##% &

# E2:1#% " # %

, B #

##% 1

# E1:1#% "% # !%

, ) # E):1#% " + # %B #

##% ' # E--:2#% " #+B #

1!)!C!5+

# % : 2 # E2:1C#% " # + B #

!1 !5!*+

# C # E*:'#% " ##

% , B #

##% # + #

G % =,*,?0

<%0! # + # "3

% "!+# + # # # B # % % =,-(,; <! # % #

+ # !+@ : " # -(2 3

>" ##!-5C&

+##% # % /!

: #

% 1' $

% % +

% " #

+ #" "

% #

" # 3 % >: ,))

>: ,)'

#"! ,

.0 " "% +

# # #% +

# 9 " % >: ,12

>: ,1C -&(2&((5 /! % >: ,12

>: ,1C% % "

+# "

%# %# % -&(2&((5%# @ % -'(2&((5 $ @ #

% >: ,))

>: ,)'

#" + + # # # #% +

# 9 !

# % >: ,12

>: ,1C%

-&(2&((5 12

=,-', 3? # ,:% #+ %#

+#+ %# ## $ ##

% %<.

<. +

=,-2, 3?"

&*(2&((5-C # "

!# # # #%

+#+ %# +

# =,-', 3? +# : ## # + %#

+#+ %# ##

" #@ 4 +"!

# + #+ "

% % ! # #

+## + ## "# #

# %%

% 1C $ ##

% " %

3 % #+ "

" %>" ! % #

1-14 4! ## " " +# % !+#+

4 >" ! ! #+ # %

% ,/ "<3+ %

+ 3 #! %" # # ! " %+ +% " # %% # 15 $!

"+ #

% " # # !

## # #

, 0

.0 #" #%

# %% 1* $!+

% # "# # 4

# + % )( !

% %

-)-)-

A(1!&(-C

9 I9;

= I9;