Kamla Rani v. Banwari Lal
!" #$% &' !( !
! #"$ % &"'
(
$)* +,$ - -,-,, !"
"
) % *) "+( "
"
#,-$(*) "+"(
.
"
/// ,-,, ( ! "0 11" 2$
3 ( 45+"
)(()$+ "5*!&+"452$
6 3( 45+"
" "* 4++4
+ ( " + 4 "
" " + ("
7$
%" "5 " + "++ (" 7$ + ( " 1(" +( "4 &" $45 8 1+0+" +"(
.% &" ' 9
" $ "+$4
+(" "
: +5" *.;(" + <
5& " = & +9
" $ "& $ (5+ " 5*&" +"1 4 + $>("" +" =$"+"( + 8 1+* +" +
4 "" & *.;" 9
" $ "
&" &> $ 4& +(" $"+ *&+ +& " "
2$ 1+ &"
+" ++ ( "1 &" 1&
" 5 459
" $ " +("
8 1+ <++ (
7$ &" "" 45 8 1+ $" % &"'."(
45"$" " " ?
*+4 + &
++ ( 7$
&( 459
" $ " % &"' (+" &"$ 9
" $ "
"+ (" &( $( @
& + &(
+""
< +
""5*$ "("
(" & 459
" $ "&+ +&(
14 "+ $" 9$ 1* 4+ 9
" $ "$ "$ 5
6 !" "* *(( ++ + = "
" ("$"
+"+
*A=
6$
8 @=!&"1" 1 +
+4+ + (" " & 9
" $ "
'
B&&
11 1 $1+"&" ""5
$ +A= =&
++(" "+ 1(( ++ 9
$ "& """ "
C & $1+ 1" $
""" " & "(" 4 5 +
= ++
& "" !" '&+ &
""5 1+4$ &"(
+ 2 1+ ( <+
(" &""7$" " 1+ " +
&+ +
" + " $ > 4$& =&" ++
& +"+ ( $" 137$"5"
4$+ &
$ ""$
1+4$ 1"
"5 "5 "+
) +"" ( $" 1 @7 5"
( $" 1@@7
5"
4 " + $ $" 1 7$"5"
&+ ++5 &"" 1&" 4 & 45+( =( 5
@ "" +++ ( 7$ & $4 ""$
11"
"5 ,"5 4$ 45+
B
A$"+" "*"
+
& 2 + + ( 7$ * & $ 4 >" 5
"+( "B "$ +4$ " ++ (
7$
(4 1"7$ * "$ +("
?
*+( &
!" ""(
+("
14 "+ "
" "" +(
=& +" + + (& *.;(" + =& 4 * .;(" +
'45 + (5++ $>&
= +" $( 3 6&(
'
& +
& +
" !" " 1&++"+$4
&" 4+"
+" " (" 8$ "
("
&
% 1 $(
5 ++" $45+
*+$4
+(" "
$
A= +"( "1"
= +++ ( &"7$" " +
B &+ &1 4 & " +"(" ("5& +( &("5 "
( &
A & 1$&"" 45+"
" "
;
D++"+( ""7$"+ (" "+ (" 5 " + 1 E!!
D++"+"(
""" "
F .;(" +E!!
@ D++"+
" " 45"(
+ " "
E!!
D++"+"(
4 4 " +
(" 1 E!
D++"+( 4E! C
& 454 ++(" '"
" "
" 1+
*
"
$
+ ( 45 +
0 "(
&+ 4" 1++
+ "
(" ("5&+" + $ "5&4
" "*+
* 4" * & ( @7$"5"
+(" ("5
667$" 5"
=$"+" 4" +2 & 45 +
& +" 1 +&" +$ "
("
*+"45" 1 "
" + =& + +4 (" 5 +
& 1 $
& (" " +
<++ (&+ +&1 " +" 5"4 ,+ $ +4 $ "
"$
1+4$ +
B
'"
" "$"+"
+ +
&$ 4 (" " " 4 *.;(" +
)" " + (* .;(" +*+1" $
""" "
1"$" +
'"
" "*+$*
+
B ( " ($1 2$
6 3
)(( 45+
&*+ &"* & 1" $
(" 4 5 +
* 45 + "
(()$+ "5*! 2$
3 )11" +"" *(" +4
=++"
"
"+(" 1+
+ +" $1++(+ (5 +" *&+ +&$"
+ 45"
$" 1+ $" +"
'"
"+( "+ 5"1$++ "
" "+"
" &"
1 2$ * &+ ++4 &"
15 45+"
(($+ "5 % + +1" $
" 45+( " "2 + " (" 45+
=
++( "B +$4
+ 5 $ "("
""" +
" "" 1 +(
'
+ (("
+ &" + $ = + ""1 $ * + "B+$4
$ &+ ++
+ 5 4"&"""5
$
= 545&5 "4+ +(" 2 & 45+
" " "5 1" 8 @@ +C!$ 24G"4 "
) *6 "+ ";B+) B" ( &+ <+
+
+ +++ & " 7 5"
" "*
2 + (&1 5"(" " + 1 +(
'
B &
$ 4" 5"
+4$ $
5+4 "$ + + ( A$"+" "*+
B
( +++ $4(" ("5 ""$
1+1"
"54$
"5 1" " 8 @@ +) *$"1 * "
( $ $ 45 +" 4
= $4 + +" 1" " 1
45 + "
(( $+ "5 <+" "*
3 ( 45 + "
(( )$+ "5* !4
2$ 6 3( 45+"
" "* 4+4$(+
=*+$*("5 ++( 4 &
'"
"+"(
;
"("
"$4
+(" 4 5 $5("
<+"(" ("
(
&++$ "5(" @@ +)
(
B & "" *+ 1 +" $"
(
++"
<+ 2 + (&+ +&1
5"(" " + 1 +( &4 1$ 45+"(
B &+ +4$ ( * &"(
<+ ( " 4 1$ $""5
+ 2 + (4 1$ &"( " <+" "* 5++
B&+ $ ("$
1+"
4$ 5&+&
+ $ 2$
4 +(" 4 5 +
;
> $ $"+" $4 + + "(
+ 5 4"+4 7$ + " "1" +
+( =
+ +"(
+ 5 4" &+ + 4 $42 >" +"
("$" ++
+( <+"(
B$ ""
$1+"& ""5
$
<+5+ " (" $
=*+$*("5 ++" ( 4
3 ( 45 +"
)(()$+ "5* !4$(+
= 4 "
$ " + " + + "(
+
+ (" '"
" " 45+
1 " 5 +& 1" $
" 45+
""" "
(" 4 5 +
'"
(($+ "5 ($1 2$
3* & +(( + 1" $
+ (" 4
5 +
&(" " +
A
:
+"
" ""1"
1""" " &*+ &"* $(+
)("$ +" "++"
(()$+ "5 +"1+5 "
+"1$ " 45+ ++
( + 1" 8 @@ + ) !
"8 @ +) ( 5 + +"(" ("5&+ + & 45+
=$"+" +
B&& "$
1+4$ &"(
+& " 1+ &"(
++ ( <+ +"+ ( $" 137$"5"
* & *& $ ""$
14$ 1"
"5 + & ( & 45+
"
= "5
+" ++ (" " $4 ""$
11"
"5 4$ +
B
1 1 45 + "
" "++"
45+
$ ++> " +( 7$ *+4 "1+5 = ( & + +
+ 4 2$ 1 + "7$" = "+ +" +" '"
" "+
1" 5"" , 1 4" *+
+" & 5 4 "7$" +
* + + "(
0
& 8 2 $ " + $ + 4
7$HH +( (" 5 +
+ " ("
1 )("" + ++ &"("("
1* 458 2 $ " + " > +( "
2 45+
+1" $
4 ("
5C> 3 '"
(()$+ "5+((" +
"" ("( )"1$ " 4+ +( ++
B + ++ & 5 +"
(" ("5 5 " !"$ C> !D.) !D ) $ " +
"+++( 5 + + & 5 +" $4 + ( ""$
1 1"
"54$
<+" "* 5++
( 5++ &
5$4(" ("5 +
"+ $ 4, 1" $
;$+
"5
"" 8 "5*+" " +"1$ ++(
" @ +) "4 +$ "("
45+( "B+$4
""1" A=$
8 @=! =" + 1 +$ "("
45 """ 1+
" "" 1 + ( $ $" &
44" 1 +
45
8 "5*"1" A=$
"8 @=! (" " 1 +(" (
5
" ("$ ( + "4 "+(" 4 5 +
> G + 2 + (45+
B& 7$"5("
<+" "* 5+
B &"$
1+" &"( 4$ + 2 + (&+ +&1 5"(" " + 1 +( "$ 1+ "
"1*+ + $ 41 + ""$
1+1"
"5+ (*
"5$ 2$
=" ++"(
&+5 D@+ ++ + (4 1$ " "1 &"
( " + $""5"$ 45+ + 2 1( *+ $1+ $1+ 4>( ++
" $ 1+ (" 5&+ & ,+( "B
= ++
5&+& +
+" " = +1
"
$
+ $ 4 *=
5 " 5
+ ($1 2$
3( 45+"
)(( )$+ "5*!
+""1$ +4 "
'"
"+( "$ 4 ( $ 15* " 5*(""5 """ " & + ($1 2$
3( 45+"
)(()$+ "5*!*&+ +
" ""
>"
" 2$" 45+ $"
<+ $(+
"
" 4 ( + (
1 $ (( * 5*+ (
!" *
15*
",.% &' !( !
/01 " D++"(, 1."
I.
D++""( "4
I.