High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16232/1994dismissed

Om Parkash And ORS. v. State Of Punjab And ANR.

2024-02-05Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sukhvinder Kaur17 pages

! !"

# $

% !! !"

&'!(!"

! "# ! &'"%%"

! "#

) *+) , ,

,& -

*+) , , , -. -

$ #%&' ()*("

*+ #,-*)( # .*" +#,-* / ("

*# $(+ + 0*% *,* *+#,-*/ *(.*+#,-* / "#12!*(#* ,

,& -

/ -%(() " .*-445 /.*)+*#*.)((/*-( %$#-*.+( +( *4* %$#"#/( $(*-44 # 1 ( $((*) "+("

-.*4(

! 4*6$/*.*"$#-.* * "-/( %0-.*# 7 # *#$(4" /(*%,-.*4+% -* &8 *-("

,- " *# -91 -/ ( 0*% -"*.-+9 ( */ / ( -*..#*( : 0*%-/9;*( (*%,-.*4%-4 #( *#"

,* 8 *-#( */

# #$

$ && "#

#""

$#& (%

(&(#

" %) #'

& #$

& #

( )

#& #"

&' * (&#+

"#"

# # "&

$ &&

&") $+

( &

"*.

# "&

$ && '"

( )

-"'

") $+

( &

".* #$

) #

= < ( ;%."8

*0 #$4 # #-* .#* 0#

1 2 ( ")*

* )(-( ,. ""*. >> / 9>? %-*4 *$#+

( -##"* *$ *"(7@( /+#-.* (*#"

, % . *, ( /A#** *7@/(, #-%-4 8 *-#( */ $%& ! !

() *+,

& ( '

)%$ -,

& (.$ !

! &

0 ! !

1 2

34 5!' *+&

*+-' !

! 6

= ( $(+* *#$/(*%,8 *-#"* *$ *"(+%

/.#+(*(#-.* $( +( * . *, (*%, ,%$"

"-,*# "-, ? (.+(.* #- ./ ("

# ( ) -.*4 *+ ( $( ( 4*6$ ( ( */

- B (** 4$(*(#-.* * *+*4*#%&(

;%."8

, #- *(.#"

"-,*#

"-, //-+ % & )( ( "

, * %-4 4%##*4*#* &"( *.$&+( %&(& 5 # - -4".*- ( %-4$ 4*# %& ( "# -- #

), +( %4(*+ * )( "*&4 / *& -4"* ( " +( "#1(** 4# * ( C#" /B@D.*#/ ( "

+ ( %&+/ $$(4*#* -*

# -91 -/(E-/9; % (* - ( .,* -(4 (* % /*.C#F4".4#/ B&* +( -44-$/ 49BB..

99=( %&(*#-(4#4#(*,%-4.*"# - (*#"*4*#* &# &%-4$-* " ( "#-- #-# (%0- *#%&(.*# . -- #+&( ( "#-- #+-* $*& "" &/" *.(* $(" *.( 4*6$ * ).. -4".*# *# #- -( %0- ( +-##(*(*-5 +*4*# # ( : 0*%-/9:* #4#(*,.*"# 4/(, #-

* # (*-", ( %0-.*# 4*

* 4#..)( %&( "#-- #+( %&+( *-5 /( %0-.*##4#(*,%-4.*"#+* %&+)(% ("

* "/( %0-

% .*# .*.&+("

* .#(4*6$/* .*"$#-.* *,GHG,( %0-.*#+*#+%#5 *(4 0$1#0230$45 # 617$0 > !/ "

-#$**.&C(*%,4*# %4 %& ( .* # - . / ( " + % -* & #.*(/*- .*$(*) " 9 (*6/% ,&+(/*- .*$IG?171G 99<* *6( / #-#$(*- , & @ ( *.$)(" 1<* ,# $ #*.###*#1@@9=90) ("/> !$(*%)*/(.*#1FB(* /1>%$(*<%)* -4"

$(* *>@>F1 ..*$!*(#* */.*# )**-#@?@?9?7(" *$* #(.*# 4*

$>%$(*%)*(" 1<%-*4-G ) ( */ 4# .*# %& , / * #- #*# 1999 8

G (

# %.- - ( $( %.-* )"*" 19@=9BB+1@@<9B>*#1=@<9B>+)( %& %0- ) -*..# / 4 ( -- # " + $* #$ ( #,."4/(.*#+5 )(-()* % .*(*4 ( .

@B#*#@?9>)*/ *""

,*.%&( -"*. -.!*(#*+-.$ ( +(# *)$#*# @99>" (*""

,#-(4+() ("/(.*#)* 4*)((.*#) *#.&*"* /( .*#)*%

.C#/ #,."4"

" 1 (" /.#%0-@1@19BB 8

G1*#(*4) #-##%&(#4 * ,# # #*#

' @<@=9B>().*$ -(4)**4##6"$,) (%0-*#( */ (-(4)**#"#%&( -"*.

44!*(#*+( $(4*6$* .

%* $7@B #*#@9@B9>@(-(4*#"#)*(, 4 / *""

,*. *# ( *4 )* /# %& ( , 4 ,# /-*#*#@<@=9>7 8

G ,#3899

61720 $ # 26 :

1 ! 7 (* ( *%, 8 *-# "

,+ * -*

# ( E 0*%-/9;+84"./&(*,*-*.*# .*#--

$ % *& % .* *+( %-40#% */

#( 44+(-%&) + / "

%.-"

"-.

#$ * %.- +% ( "*&4/-4"* ( ) ( +(- ./ ( "#1 %4+(*-( -(4*-#+( 4/"

, *+)*.&/

#,."4/ *#+"* 6+%#)((*#-(4(*% 4".4#(&* 9>7( +%#)(() ("

, -(.*#+(*%*-(#/ 4("

% .&

/(.*#.4#/ (#,."4/ *#+"* 6*# < 5 .&+* $ #(*)((4".4*/ -(4*6$".*-(&* 9>7*#() "%-4$ /.#%.*#.&( / 4(&* 99< .*.&+( %&() "(%&(,-/$ #.*&*#.*-( = (**.)((-4".*--

$-.* - / -91/(E-/9;( 4*6-($+(* % . * * ,*-** *+*4*%.% */

#(44+/

(*"""

%.-"

"+% ( "*&4/-4"*

; ( ) ? ( + (-#(* )(( */ / ( %0- .*# (* *6 ".*- ( &* 9>7+ /*,

/ (

"#-- #+*#*.)(( .,**""

,#-(4 ( $(* .

@B%$4*#@?9>+( (*

.#(*#-(4%$4".4#(&* 9>7 B A5 .+( %4(*+( )(("

,)( ( .,*-.* - -(* */( */ *%..*# " 7=D/(.*#(.#$/(.*#. +%# - -

*. (*4 /"

" & */

#+( )( "*&4% "1=D+ /J

7( +( %4 (*(4" /(* &-*$/:

: ( (*(#,# *..*#(.#$ /(.*#) %$( *#& -6 +*#+(*#

5 *&4".&4( /+,GHG,+( #,##.*#/ (.*#. -- # > * .&+( %4(*-("

(* (0) ("( %0-.*#+( /7<= " - 4+*#+ /(*4 "1=D* *)**6)( ( "*&4/-4"*( +)(( *)((.4/ " - 4 */*-(/(-G) #,# *.(* +( *""0.*#+( %&+ *#.&4*6( "-,#,# *.

(* /(-G) + %$)((" 4%. -, .4/1=D+( / 9 (/

%4(*5 *9=D/.*#8-/ ( *"" -.$ .4 / 1= D+ ( -4"* (* % *#*#*.*,*.*%./ %$#%

#(.*#.

< -- #+( %&% *-(-* #("

, * *&

0 8"

*/(.*#(*%4*# 1@ ( +( *#.& %4(*)(( *%, " - 4/( % .* *+*/*..(#,# *.(* /(-G ) +% )(("

- %#* &.4/7=D( / .*.&( %4(*% *-(#(/ $4/ ("

,/ -91 -/(: 0*%-/9:+*4 -( *+( "#* 4$"/*-(/(#,# *.

-G) :(* (0.*# %&#7=D( / 1 (*./

%4(*/

% *-(# (/

.4("

, *+*4 -(*+( .*$ .& "1=D/:

:+ ( " -* % */

# ( 44+ % )( "*&4/-4"*+*)*( ) 5 #%*#+ ,G*G,+*-(#,# *.-G) 11 A5 .( %4(*"*&4/-4"* *-( / ( #,# *. -G) + "-*..& "- / (

"-,#,# *.(* +( 8-#$1=D+# .+ *-5 "

-#$ %$ /.*)# *#F ,*# ( "

* .#(4*6$/*.*"$#-.* * 17 *- ..* &( /+( %4(** -(*& */

(44/(" - 4 */( % ..*#/(-G ) -- #+)( +"* 6+ (*,% *#+( %& (*%% *-((.4/1=D+ *"".&$*-( -G) : -- # (* -4"* )* 5 # % *#,GHG,*-(#,# *.) 1< (.* #- ./ ( "#*. %4+(*

$((- *#%/ (

+%&( .* #- ./ ("

+(*"" &/(* $ %-*4*$#("

(*(%0-%-*4 #-##+ ( %4 (* .& ( "

/.# %0-+% *.*"" &/(* $%-*4$ *#(4+ %#(%0-) )..-# #*#*.%-*4 0-#+

.$(*#"/(-(4%&( -"*.44 !*(#*( $( .

7@B#*#@9@B9>@ 1= A"-/-*..&4#(*(*#%0-+) #-## %& ( #4 * + ( $( * # 4*# ( @<@=9B> 1? (*,)/(*//#*,#*#@71@11+/

(# )("

0-( (*9?D9BD#,."4/(-(4 * *(*%-4".#+*#*..("* 6(-(4* * ( (*,*.%#,."#( +-##(*)((

;%."8

(*%,8 *-#"* *$ *"(--

$( , #- *+)(&(*4*#(*#+*""#-.* *% "-, *# "-, ( + ( %4 (*

"-,&-*%*$#(#-.* $( +* . *, ,G*G,+(* &"

, *+*( %&(-4".# #,."4) 6) .#% #

"#*#) .# . -(* 4 $$ 1B , + ( *. %4 (* )( ( *%, "* *$ *"(*.*/ ( ;%."8

+ /

$*, #- 4*#%&( ;%."8

204017.,101 # =03/';>!?,

;'!+( (*#4 .##( ./4( 8$-*#- - 4*-+"-*..&)(( .,*-(4(*

%-44".4#+*(*(*""#(*-* 1> *#.&+)(% / %,*$(

"/-(* *#* G4**$*%. */ (44+( ( ;%. "8

+ ## #+( //- / ( 4".4#( -(4+*%-*44".4#"

(#-.* *( +*

. *, /"

, *( +( %4(* 4 /+)((-(4(*%4".4#(&* 9>7+* -(+*,#"

,*.-/-(**#*.*,#( -"*.

44%$"

* G4**$*%. *+( + *-,&-*%*$#(#-.* $( +* . *,

, * 02@9 617#3899

803@1720 $ # 26 17 :0190 0

6 =$19 517#3899

61720 $ # 26 17:1919

>? 19 ( * % *$# ( */ + (

*$ )(( %4/(.* #- ./ ( "#+ *##*$ +)(( %4/(.* #- ./ ( "

( +(

#4() " 7@ A*..&+ ( / #* / ( -.*4 *# %& ( "

/ 6$(4*6$/*.*"$#-.* *+,G*G, (-(4 *+

"-,/ "-,&%$*$*%. , #- *+/ ##+*#( -+("

-"./ *

*. 0 -+ %& ( "# -- #+ *4 -( *+ "" &/" *.(* $%$$ *#(%0- +( ( %0-+*#F +(%0-%$( -# #

%-4$ #-## ( $(+ * ).. *# #- ( *# - 0-#

7 ( */ 0-$(*#-/ ##+ ( ".&+*//#*,+*)..*) &"+/

(#(*# //-%&( "#-- #+)( +-.* .&". +(* (%0- ) -*..#/ (* $1>@<9B>*#@<@=9B>+ ( (//-/(#4 * +(( "

&44 + !*(#*+*#(*(*#%0-%-*4)..-# #*#*. %-*4 0-#@<@=9B> 71 -,#-#&(*%,/*- 4(*% *## -#%&("

( +(*%,* $ 4%-4 % //,$ *#**# * 0-# 77 ( %4*## #%/ (

%&(.* # - ./ ("

(*-"/( %0-.*#

4*)((.*#. -- #+( ( %&("

* .#-.*4(4*6$/*.*"$#-.* *+% *.* 4G/ ##* $ 4 7< ( */ 4*6$(*%,/ -"

+/ 4( /*- 4+(*(*#* $ 4/ ##+ "+("

-"./.*) *%.(# %& ( ;%. "8

-* .# * 2 :8 1#17 91@)0

70+020 171$/ ! !

, "'/ )(-(* *"".-*%.(*-5 "

-#$+* %-*4.* -(# # :( 0*%-/9: 7= , +/ /

*+(*4".4#*""

,# -(4*# *) 4/*"

"-,.&4*##-.* *+5 *( , *+( %$ . *, + (*# %#( ) ("/("

, ( %0-.*#+% .&(*

.# (*#$, / " ( /+ ( "#

! -- #+% / ("

"/"

%.-*4 *+%-4$ - *#( +*#+)(-(*.("

) .#%-4 .# 7? A/+%#)(/ (( */ 4*# *+( #-.* $* . *, /(*%,"

,+%*$# "-,&+,,GHG,(*

7B $/-*.&+)(% / %,*$(

"/-(* *#* G4**$*%. */ (44+( ( ;%. "8

+ ## #+( //- / ( 4".4#( -(4+*%-*44".4#"

(#-.* *( +*

. *, /"

, *( +)((-(4(*% 4".4#(&* 9>7+* -(+*,#"

,*.-/-(* *# *. *,# ( -"*. 44 %$ "

* G 4**$*%. *+( + *-,&-*%*$#( #-.* $( +* . *, ("

, * 7> , + )( * -, *#$ / ( *%, , -* .& ,*.+ (* ( *-5 + * 4*# # + 5 (*GG/* G* % .+*#,*-** ** -- #+(* -(* *+%$ */ *%.(44+/

4".&4( /*"

%.-"

"+*#% )(* # +(* -( 4*84 4 */ *%. % .F,*-* * *+ / 4".&$ ("

%.-"

"+( 8-#$7=D+*#+(*( *4 / */ *%.* *+% )( "*&4/-4"* 8-#$ 1= D & )( * /

-+ ( -*

# ( * &-*$J

7 39.

5 .&+(*)$%# 4#+)(( ( * 4/( % . ,*-** *+)( +%-*44".&#

( ( .,*"

%.-"

"+*#(*(&* 9>7+*#+( -(*..$+(*#4".4#-(4%-4$4*#(&*

99<+( 5 $(4".&4( +/(*"" # + *"" *$ ( 4*84 4 */ *%. * *+ ( -"*.

44+/ 4(.*#. + 8-#$7=D+*#F + *./ 4(*#-*"/ */ *%. % .* *+( .&1=D /%$ */ *%.+( )( "*&4/-4"* <@ (-# #4#/(

+* *+ %4*#(* &-*$/:

0($/-*/(*#* &-*$+ (*+(.$.*

)#4+(*4*#(*#-*$( + % %(+)(*4#/ .*#"

"/ .%0-+ "-,.& .*$ (4*84 4" - 4/*/ *%..*#+*#+/

(*1=D /+(*..%)( -4"*+*#+(*-*(*4 / */ *%..*#8-#1=D+("*&4/-4"*%$ 4*#(.*#. -- # < (.+ ( 4" ( %. *- / ( * & -*$+ % (* " - 4 *+ %$ *"".-*%. ( * / *-( #,# *. .*# . -- #

), +(*4%$*"".-*%.( 5 * 4/.*# (.#0) (" -G) ("/(.*#. -- # <1 A/+)((*-*+(*.5 * 4+/( .*#% $(*-5 /(.*#) -4"

#** * /7<=D( +)((*%," - 4/.*# */

# ( 44+ )( ( 4*84 4 "

- %# */ *%. " - 4/.*#+*( #("

, -91 - <7

4 +)(( * /

-G) (

" IG?171G99< 5 .&+ )( #,#$ 7<= %& <

7<=F<K>=)/ 4*4$(*##,# *." - 4/ .*#+**$*%.*-(/(-G) (0.*#+% %, .&.(*1=D/(.*#+*(*% */

#( 44+%#)((*# */ )( -4"*

), + $,($/-* *+ * 4*# (* & -*$+( ( %&+ (*# "-," - 4+#* *- + ( "*6$ ( -# "* / ( "

, *+ *4 -(*+(*-4"*%"*#+)(( */

#.*# %&#1=D+*( % .* */*..$(#,# *.(* / *-(/(.*#) .(*1=D/ 4*4$(4*84 */ *%..4/7=D << , +*"

*./ ".&+*//#*,+ ,*.# (* /(*.7<=D/*-5 #.*#+1=D( (*%*6 )( -4"*+*#+/ ( 4*$* */*% 9=D

-4"*(*%// #( +% *-((*% -* #(4*#* * <= *#.&+4*6$(*%,--.

$* "" / 4(-($/0

0 ($/-*( +(*+( (*( #,# *.(* (#,# *." - 4/((* /*-(/( -G) +(0.*#+ %-4$( *#& -6 (

.,*"* *4 / 4".&$( (*# # 4%## ("

, * <? ( * / # *)$ ( *%, --.

+ % + * *%.+/ 4*G#"( *%$4*#(-*$+* --

)(("

, *+)(-(*

*..&-*,+(*

% % 5 #%4".&#+(*..*#/(-G) -- # * .&+(*# # %4".&#(#,# *.

(* (#,# *." - 4/(* /(#,# *.-G ) <B ( */ 4*6$(*%,--.

+*.%-4 4* (*..#+/ 4(/*- 4(*,/(#G44% 4/( 0**6$".*-+( "+( (5 * 4/.*#)(-( ) .#%-4*..#*-(/(#,# *.) ) .#

.4*.& % )( ( */ *%. .*# .4+ / ( .,*

"+% )( )( -4"*+ 4/("

, -91 -/(: 0*%-/9: <> A/+(* &-*$0

0 %-4*4*%.,*(*$/(0 * 4*$#44% #+%( *$#*-*+,G*G ,+(*4*"" *$(#,# *.(* /(-G) (0.*#+*( %&(*#-*+% ) .#%*#4 )((5 * 4 " - 4/.*#+)(-(%-4 .4*.& *..#(*""$/#44% 4/(0* <9 .*.& ( %& */ *6$ ".*- / ( #,# *.(* (.*#/(-G) -- #+ ## 5 (* -4"* % *# ,GHG, ( *"" "* *#,# *.(* +* -(+#,# *.(* ##/*..

)(( -,.4/1=D/( */ .4/.*#)( -4"* =@ *.&+ *# %& ( .* # - . / ( "

(*B@D/(* * /(*.* */>%$(* %)*.*# IG?171G99<(*%*6,.*(

' 4*#* *+)( *+( "#( ".&*//#*, (*,4#(*.&7<=D* */("

.*#(*% *-5 # ( %4 ( /*- 4 (* ( *%, -*.- .* * %*# "*&#4* -* " % (*# -*. 0-# = ( */ 4*6$(*%,--.

4+/ 4 (/*- 4+(*( $(("

*#(*#%0- ( "-,%0-" % (*#%0-%-*4 )..#-##*$*(4 =1 , +)(*(4//.$/ -(%0-+ )* *. - 4% " ( "

(* ( *# %0-%-4,*.#.& # "*)..4*##4* -*/( #"

#( +/ )*/+*,*.#.&"

"* ##4* -*

" %-4$*""##)(( .,*%0-+( %&+(

*$/(*#-.*4(*) " +*#(**/

4 (*&* +-(4".4*/(-(4 *+ ( 4*6(*#-.*4%-4(%&(,-/#.*&*# .*-(+% *.)( "" $( #4* -* " %-*4 /.#%(%/ (

%#%/ (..- -- #+ %&+(*# *#-.*4"

8 *..& *# +

=7 A */ 4*(+ (

/# 4 ( ) " +*#+)((*%,% ,* +(*4* #4# =< # *- == -(4*-*./(*,%#-##+( +*..(

; "#$*"".-* +/*&+*.*# #"#/ >,

,& -

>, -. -

% !! !"

6*,$( I(( "*6$F *# '

LF I(( " *%. '