High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/7149/2017dismissed

Arun Kumar v. Des Raj Tandon Since Deceased Through His Lrs

2018-09-07Mrs. Justice Anita Chaudhry11 pages

"!# $ % ! &' ( !)((* +

,( !$ +- )(./ (+ &!0-!./ ( +

'( + ( / + ) ( +23(0 00 .

# ++023( ++00!( 3 '( + 0 0 0 + 0# )2

3 (+ # ( !

# 4(45 3 0 (# 0 ) ( + 64+0((4(+

2!7! ) # ( + #'(0 0 4(0 0 )(+ (+0!

'( (+ +0 (( ( (+ + 0 ((!64 ! ( +0(+ /!03 44 8 )'( .( .( !

#+03 ,((! 9# )(/ (/ !

( ( 7! # 0 2 * !

0 (+ 4(0 0 )( /

( ( 90 004 )

# . (# #0 + ) ! " #$ # % &

" '()*(+

!" , %

" './/+*(0

!"1 , %

" '2((**(0 ! 3 , % ,

" '0*/*(2 (# )!# .0 !

0 (+ ( 0!+ (

+ :

23 ( , ( 4( 4(0 # ) / + . (

004 )7! 4 # 4

) )! !

!5 * 6 7

5 ) 4 $

5 + 4 7 6

) )! !

! 5 0 4 "' 2.(/*( 3

5 (# ( )!# .0 !

0 (+ (!2#((0 0 ( 0(# 0 #( ! ;(!2#( 9# . 4(#( / (2 !)(.(#((4 8 )+ # '( 0 3 <

=+ # (.( . (( !

#+03 !003 ; ! ( !2#((0 0 ( 0( (( + 3( 2!0 )( ( (+.4 %80 ,> & )( ; ! ( !2#(( ) - 55 (? $!

&2@ 2 .

( 2 A(

B(/ 2 +04( ) ( 4(

3/ + (2 0 6#32 ((4 ! ( (( 0 0 0/ C (4 !+ C; C20( -!+ #! 4(0)/ )# ) !09+ (4 C(4

!+ C((0(4 C4 !+ C4!0 0! 03(

+ 0 7! # ( 0 0 (#0 2! 0 ( #0 A# B 0 '(9+ (2 9+0 23; C20 (-!+ #! (

.4(00 )4(( ) #(

( 7! (+ 0.( 0!!

8 6 7 9 9:

9 9

: 8 ;

6 6

(2 ( + .+ 2 )

0 (! 7! # #03##2 6 (+ .

(+ 4(0 0 )(+ (+ 0032!( 7! # ( -/' (+ 003# ( ( ++0 ( / ) / 3 (+ + 0 ! !+ ( ( ++0 4 3 ( ## 0 2!0 ) (! 2 $ (++0 (2

9 2/ 4(( 2 03 2/!03.( 7! # .( .(+0 ) 4( (

< 40!04(( )!# (0 !

0 (+ '(#+03# ( 03+ #(0 3

=+ # ( 036( 4( # / ( (3( 4 0.(4 #+03# 6 4( ( )( 0 .((+ 003#!+4(+

0# ( #+ 3#+03# 22 =0 3+ # !03

29+0 4

/ 4((#32+ !#2 3 08 + .(+ / 4 0 :

00.

(0 0 ( 2 20)(+ ( ; .( ! 3!2 ( )!# (0 !

0 (+ - ) !

0# ( /0203 ( (+ * !

0 ( + (+ !(4 (+ !+ ( 0 0 * -( & ' 4

3'((+ /020 ( '( 7! # (2 ( 9 +0 ( #03##2 '( 7! # (

2 #

4((4!0 (/ 3+! + + / )0# )(/020(0 0 8 / ) (/0203 5 (+4((& )( (!.(2 9+0 23(0 0 400( .4((/ ++ (4 29.(( #+ (

: 2 ) ! )4 ) ( 0 3 ) / ( 2 0 23 ( + / ( ( ## !20 !

)2!7!6 2 ( .( ! (( 3 0# # 0 4(( (!02 0( 0 9!2# (0 !

04( ) ( 2 +0 ) ) . 7! ($ ( 2 9 2/ '( 03 004 ) ( 7! # ( 7! (+ # 4 !+

!+3 ) 3( 2!0 ) 5 ; / 3!(2!0 )4(!!

! ( ## # ( '( ) (/2 ( 9 7! # +02!; C20(-!+ #! ((0(( 7! # 4 !2 0! 03(0 0 2!0

#0# 6 !(! .( ) + /(/ 2 ( 9 -/' 4( 7! # ( / 4!)( * !

0 ( + 4(0 03 ) !+ ( &!)# +23; C20(-!+ #!

"#$ $ $ % & $. ( +0 ( ( 7! # ((/2+0 034( +( 0 0 2!04( +( #03##2 4(#(/

2 )!)(6#32 ( ( .4+ (

0+ / . 4 ( 4 64( +/ 0 ( #030# :

+ + 3( 00 (( 6 ( 9.; C20(-!+ # ! (0(( ) 7! !

- 5 (

(/2+04( +( 2!(4(0 0 / 42 )!)(23(0 0 (+ 0!6 + .( 03

'(! 4!02 0 ) !3 (7! 4(( (/2 # 0!+ 23(0 !

0 (+ 4 0(!)(. (7! 04.(4 + (2

!23(; C20 , (.(4/ .( ( + / ( (&!)# +23; C20(-!+ #! '( 4 ! (D) $0C -!+ . 0 ( #0 A# B 0 '(A# B

2 + # ( 03 +

) )! !

!5<6 + ( + / (

. ( 0 0 7! !0 00( 004 ) 7! # ; 7! (4 !

; !+3 ) (! 2 3( 2!0 )

5 ;( /!(2!0 )4(!!

! ( ## # (. (! 2 - 55 (

.9 !

()$ * $ $+, !888888 *!888888 )! !3

6 ! 7

: =

3 : = !

: :

3 :

# $

; & 3 :/+2:

6#32 (+ (

. # (2 + 2;4/ .; C20E!00, ( (!

( - % & $ . "/% '

01 ' .((0( 3 (0 0 +0(( ) 60400

0( (&!)# +23(; C20E!00, (./ ! &!)# (/2 + !

8 )/4( ( ) 7! (/2 + / 0.(+ 4!0 2# # 03 () !

(( ) (/ 2 +0 +0 ) ( 0 + (&!)# .(9+ A (4 !+ B(2 + # 0! #0 # 0 '(7! 4(( 7! 2 4 4(( !#2 !+ 0 #8 2!( 2 3 (+ # - 55

'( +!(( 7! # - 55 (

(/2+04( 7! +(0 0 ( /4 (! .!( 7! #

22+0 34( +( 0 4(#( / 2 )!)(23(0 0 4( 004( ( 4 A# B + 23; C20(-!+ #! ;4/ .

( 4!0202 32 )( (! (( + 4( 3(/ 2 )!)(( !+3 ) ( 2!0 ) (/ 3!(2!0 )4(!!

! '(+

2# 03 !

( (( +0 )4( +( 0/ 0 # - 5 (

'(! 4!02 7! 9# ( 4(( (0 0 (+ 4(2 7! # /

+0 !0 00( 7! # ( '( .2 + + (04.

2(0(# 3+0 00(( 7! # - 55 (

!( + 8 .4!0/ )) (400 0 + 4((2 ) 00423(! / 4( ) (0 0 '(22&!

((2 7! # 0 ( #0# + !0 #

+0 )( ( 2 /) ( 3+ !0 # (2 + / )03.7! 4 * 6 7

5<6 F( ) 7! .#32 ( + /230 )) / ( #0# 0 (/2 7! # .(+

2#6 .

(7! 03 ) 4 $

5<6 F( +7! 5.#32 ( (.

( 7! # ((0 0 8/ 2 7! # (+ 03; C20(-!+ #! D) $0C!+ .((0(( 7! # 03 0 (#0 2!0 ( #0C# C 0 0! ( #0# 4!02/!03# ((+ 4( ##2 ( #03 #0! 0 0 !

# 0.

0 0)0 + 2008 ( ;4/ .

2(0( (0 0 7! + /(( 0/ + 0 )03.7! 5 4 + 4 7

) )! !

! 5 F( ) 7! .#32 (( 7! ( 2& ( # 0 ) 4

# = +03. ( ( 0 0 ) ++ !

3 !0 00 ( 7! # ( 6 ( + 003 ( 2& .4!02#(((4/(2& '(! (0 3(0((+0 )4( +(+ + / (! )03.7! 4 0 4 "'2.(/*( 3

5<6 G! < !003(7! 4(( +!0 ( '(7! ( ++0203

(+ ; .(7! 2 ) 4 /4 4((2 2 /2/.(+ /

# 00(+ )#00 !++0 . 3. + . /4 (2/&!)# !"!#$!%&

'()'(*+,(-./012*(-+30(4 (+23

'()'(**(,3*)-56( (+23