Punjab State Civil Supplies Corp Ltd And ANR v. M/S Khalsa Rice Mills









 


 



 

 





 





 

  


 

 



 
  

    !"#$%&$'(
##) (''

"      !"

 #$%% &'

 (&$

 !"

 #$  ***** #) (''

"+% )# $ $%% %" "# **+ + %     , -

.&/-$  01# %% *
%!%*2& +% 3%!%%  (& $& 4#01 %*  01 # $%% &  #0%  
"%*% %" %#6#"7  %8% 
&* #$%%# &08% # $ /9 :# *  %" %** %*   &%  8  1 %;&"% %"%+ #  &08%& +&%  *+ * ""& #**%+ &%+# "$ 1  

/

  

/    *  # "   &"# %" 4%# "<&% **% $8 %;&"% %%+#   8 % %+ % 1  1 0&%   # $*

/ %8  )# $%%9   %*  # 4%  8  %%+ $*%8% 1 0;"%# %#*%+# %"* &%# +8 #&% *%0 #
%!%*
&  *% 0*0 %8% = 

 %   %8% * #&% 4  ;&% %"%%# *%+# 0 "  & "%, #"4  %* 0&# 8#  0 %8% 01#% *
&>% +& 4%#!#8"# %!%4 %"* &" % %"* & +804# $ % %* 01#$%%%*% 0*0 **4   # &%8 10 %8% >&$$ #%"% ## *% &$ ;& +8 ?70*#&$8
&
 

!"#
$ #
% &
#


"&%'(
)**+
,

,+-  .
%

/ "
0#
$ #
###
/%

0%
!

/ "%

"&%'

(
)*--
,

,+)
&* $%+ # $  #  &$$  # %8$&+  4%##&08%%# # %& "%, #"4  %*  * 1  $*+ "%% #&%>% &#

+& #  #$%% %* #4% 8 4%+"* %8 # $ 9$*

  8%  % 8&  # $%% # !%+ &08%   ;&% %"%   #
%!%*
&  #  % &  #"# %+#*10 %8% 01#% *
&@#% $&$ ##   ;& +8 #%
&$ 1
2/'
& $ #
&%
3 '
4%'"

5%
 '
6 
!"#
3 '(
)*-)-+

 
-7+ ># !#  "&* #$ % $& #$ $/0' $ %"&* *1#!

%& .& !

%* 0*"  > %$& 0*1  # $%% %*  # 4%  8 .&/4#%#$%%"! # **+ % %  % # $* %  ?4!  $*%8% 1 0;"% %"*& %+ %&   / % % 0%*%1   # &% % # *%+#  % "* & 4  %  )#<&%# 

** "%  %% 4###$%%"

0

- #   1# %"% %  %&4%#+   %%# 4%  8  % "

 "

$ ! "<&"   # !%+ %* # 4% 8)#%
&%$ 1
2/'
&
"

&$ #  #*    **4/ A,B)#   % 8! 1 %& "%,  
"%*% %" %# #"0  %*%+ 4% 8"%, #"%$&* # &"#  # 08! 0  %*%+ 4% 80;"%+  %+

% "* &  ' % # 4%  8   8 # <&%8   "% ,   # "  # " 1 "" %+  "% ,   # "  #   0  &08%%+ #% 4%  8#&* # ! %*  %& "%, # "   %+ # %$&  # 0%  ?4!  % 4    
<&*1 #$*

"

0/&% #%+& C )#"!1%#$$%%%<& *1"! 01 # ;& +8   #%
& % $ 1
2/'
&
"

 &$ 
&* #$%%# 

%* "% 1" 1* 4* %  401 #%
&8&"#*?70*#&$8
& > % >#%!%4 #8  > % 8%%"% #$ #  #$%%

%* #4% 8 % 8&&08%%#;&% %"% #
%!%*
&  #   # $%% "

 $ % "* %8 &  #" ) 0

%  # $%%  "&* #  *%  &$ 0!

%   ?70* # &$8
& "   % $       # ;& +8%.
%

/ "
0
0 %
&$  *!

. " 4# 8   **4/ A *1 %*%+   # 4%  8 %  &%  0& %*%+  1  8 %

% !% %* 01   $%# %*%+ #4% 84%**0"&  D&08%%  8 # &0 " # %$&E % 01

%*%+ &"#  89 %9

% !%  #   #4 #% %% 

 &08%#%8* #;&% %"% #"&  4 %!#%%+#'  "  % & %*%+   $*1 01      

 8$ 1 %;&"%9  "#8 0  ;& +89 $$%8 "%! "

0"%   &08%%  8#&0 " # %$& # %  !%   %%8 0%+8  + %#%8C & *   #

 %  . " % 81 "%   $%% &$$"

& #$%% + % %8$&+ >#% !%4   # 8   >   %  1  8&"# * %**+ *%1 % # %8$&+  4  %+%!% #$%# 0 %  @# +%+  #$%%

%*  % "" %+*1 %8% * !%+#$ %0 #%4"  $6
-7(
)*-7

2
6!
63(&* %7













 
F##$ '%+9    19 F##$ 0*  19