← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/945/2004allowed

Morpal v. State Of Hy.

2024-09-10Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma17 pages



     



  

 





  



   

     

 

       "

 #$! % &' '( '

 #""''(%$()* ++++ 

 



,'

  

 

    &   '

     -  

 

(!

%



./ 

(0*'

%

1!& ( "

(2'

'!&''

 '

'& 2    !

'0 ! % '

. !& "

*'

%!0 

3'

       4'

56  #  (  '!&' 



&   / 

('





!

'

 

 &!

-  7 &!





* (

!

'

-(

  ( (

8(0

 !   *-       -!(  '

  '

     ! &   &!

-  7 &!



'

*

,'

 !

   0 -  &&

  -  '

 0  2   (( '



9!

'

'

63 6(

-

  

!*(  '

!   '

&   '

  

&. 



 

  ,'



 '(:

(

*'

 0*";:-.

2 %<2

 !

%("

  2 '  &(2'

2

- &-'

 %* &  '

&''=

*('

! 0>  2> & 

2'

'

)

2

'

 9!

&0!'

*('

2

0

* - 0 0&%('

2  ?7"?! %  & & 0

'

 -

#&

 &@   )2 (

*?7"?8 ('

 0

'

 - #&

  '(";/. % &'

A*(, '

("

2   2'

0&0



0*'

2

'

2'

'2 ! &A&  =

!-2

 *'





&- 

!-('

!

&2 ''

-

2 > 

  *- -?7"B !>>?7"$2

" % '

0

2'

'-B< ?7"$8 2  & '

!&'

'

   *?7")2

,'



''

2 ! - -?7")8 ,'

&2 ''



*'

2 

2 ! 0 ";A C%<2'

'



&  !'

'

-

2

!

 '



& & 

'



*2 ''

#)("% * "

% 2 

2   !

! 

& (

! !

&!  

& '

 !'( '&  '

2 

& '

-  !   

 !

"

#$$% &'(  =-

 

& ('2 

 !& '

='

  !( '

 2  '&  '

 '

--

  !

'0  ! % '

(2'

''

 &!

*   %!0

9!

* '

 

/2 

!0 

!

'

0! 

 '

B%C(2'

'?7"D

&  '

 !



(  '

     1!&   2  

 !   %      "( 2'

(  '

 !

 

    (  (     

  )2 ('

 *2 

'

!)* (( &( +$

&$%# !&($+ ",$# &- #".

//$ &"

 ,'

!

'

&&

 

' &!

!(''

!&    (('



9!

 

('!

9!

  )

 0

!0-

'

&!(' 

0

&

-

 ((

  - '

'& !)* (( &( +",$$

&$%"

"$# !&($ : % !

' &!

''

!&     ((

9!

'



3 6( -

!

 0*'

 1!& (

- 2'*( -



 ! -* *&

-



 



* - '

'& ,'

('

 ''

!&   0 -  (( - 0*'

! & 0( ( +",$(!)* (( &( +$

&$%# !&($+ ",$# &- #".

//$ &" &%

$ ( &(+  ##$/"

&'",$( *$ / ,'!&'?7"B  *

* 22 - -   2'

''

2 ' '

&'','

0*'

2  9!

'



& &  (0 & -

 2 -* !* 

( -0

%      &'

 *- -'!

'(<

& = 3";:6 !'

0

E.F'

-

( ('

!

(0!'

!-0 F



-0



!'

'

 - !

>

 !'

 0*";:('

*- '

%<8%)=A '- C'

2*%!>' .&!( 2'

'

! '

&2 ''



*(2 



-

 0  '

-(  2'

 '

 %)=   (  !  '

  0

  EACF(  0!  '

 !-0 F  

 

-0

  0*  %)=  ( !'

'

  - !

>

 )2 (  &'

'

B%C (



?7"D( 2'

 7 '

 ('!&''

* (''



' - 2 '

0*%"

"

('!

-

'

,'!&' 

!'

'

'

2 '

E.F(

EACF)2 ('

0 -



'

B%C (-

**2 ''

> ( - 0*'

2 

('!



 !-0 F'



( - - '

'

(

*2'

!-0



( - '

 ' 

  (   -   !

>   0*  '

  2 

 (0 -

>  *- -3 6,'

(0! 0 !

* 0 ! (''





!

'

(2'

'0 - - -'

0!>( 

- (0*'

B%C (0 &-

*  0

&-  ( '

!-0 F'



( !  *- (

!-0

> *

'

B%C (0! - !

>

0*'

";

(0

>

 *- -?7"B 

 

 

  

      

  !    "# "# "$% & ' ( )  ! ( )  & ( )  )* ()  + ( ) 

 ( )    

& )  ( , %-. / 01 (2   !      (1     )34&

( ' 15  ! !  00

  !60

0"

'7)'

0 0      7  1" "    '  +1  # 7*89: 5 6   0   !:

&!   ;

,'

! '

0

! &'



'

B%C3?7"D6(2'

(!

> 0!'

!-0 F

( - '

'





 *'

'

0 !

( !'



'

B%C(0!>3 6  *' *(2  *  ( - '

!

'

( 0* 

->

0 !

0 8'

'

0*

! 



 -

 *   '



- '

 *- -2 ''



( -

'

0 !  '

B%C

?   '!&'   

  0 -  

 0* '

  

!

''

B%C

?7"D('!

2 - 





' 3 6('!&'*

0 - 

0*'

 !

(''

-0

!-0 3 6

(0

-0

'

('!

?&

' '0 ('

 *

2 ''

!-0 3 6'



2 ''

?&

'

'0 ( - -0

'

(( -

  

 < ('

0* '!&'2' &!- 



0

!(0*'

 !

'

 

(''

( - - 0*'

B%C ('

' ('!

  '

!

-(( - !  *

 -'

0!>('



(0!

*

 7!&!- 

 <- *(  '!&'  '

 

!    '

 

 (  

7 '

0 (->

 ' &'   !( 2 

' ('!

!' 

! &(''

- 

 - 

!-

!!

*( '!&''

'

B%C ( 

'  '

!

' !(0 -  

'

(('

- 

B%C 

 ,'!&''

0  ( !

'

B%C  ( 0 

0*'

!

,'!&'('

9!



0

&

'

0  ('!&'

 *

'(  !

(

 > &2 9!

0 *

! *('!

 ! '

' 

('

!

0*'

B%C (( 

2'

 - 

2 -

: ,'!&' '

 '

0 

! *

0

& > 0

&& '

 !

(! !





 ('

2 

(

 1  !* '('

0 

! *'

2 0 0*'



!

<

9!

!'

 '

(

'('

!-  !' '0 '!&'  -

%

    '

 "(  

 '

0*  '

  1    9!

 !

* ,'

('!&' ! '



!

( -

 -'

0!>('



('

0  ! (

*   1   >(   '

!

 -'

0!>('

   *'

0(

&- '



(

G

! '



!

(2'

'

  0 -  

' 0*'

B%C  '!*$&"( +",$$

&$%"

"$# !&($ &%",$ $ ( &(+  $1$#"

&'",$ ( *$",$ $)0(", ( !

"# &#!% &'", "",$ //$  ( $2!

$%" )$

 3$%

/ .

% !

!0- '

 -  %   '

"( 

2'

0

7 '

 ('!

 0!0

!- !'0

& '



0*'

?7

 ( 

!0% %

'

"

!*('

!0- '

0* !'

  !-- * !'

( '

!0H -  '

#  (

0* 

! *

& '

'

0 *'

!  -  '

!0H  0* ?7

 ,'

('

!0- '



! *

2 0*'

('!&''

 !

- 

-> & 7'

-> '

'

B%C 

!*'

!  *  3 6( - 0*'

B%C (  '

!0H  (

-

0! 

( '  '

!'

B%C('

- - &! 

' 

(    '

 

   '

 B%C   (  0

-0

'

(0

'

- &! ! ! -

'2'

2 

  !"

# $

% &$

'

$ (  & %& )#$"<'

:

1       !               7* 1       1    5  :1 :

!1  1 1    :    :

   +51:!*    :  :5     +

-+1:5   = 511   1  :  !>"1 

$/ :  11 !:+5   !   :51:5 + :  1    :5     :    !   =      1   +5    *      : +  !

 ?                 7* 1         5 1:(<  :+1 # 1 '  +1 # 1   7* 1 8 @!+ + #  *8A B 6 ) C8 B 59= 3  5C1!:8 B @5B:B '  B A  + 6  0  !: 06  0  !:8 0 7* 1 8 @    :    7* 1              5  !: 

    5!:+ 7* 1     *"

% $( #$

%

% &$

+ &( "<  /   :

1   ! :+!:  5  *:1 !       51:!5   5  :5! 1  :    1 

- 1 ! 1! !!:

07* 1 

$/     :1    5 1 1:! *    :5 

  +   1  ! ( )* +1:5     5   !*



' -*('

* !'



 * !0- '  -  % '

"( 

2'

0

7 '

0 (



0 - ! 

2'

!

8'

!

!('

 "!0 "

! ('

2 

! *





-  *'

!



,'

(

 *'

!0- '



! * -   !

   *  2 '  '

    !

  '

-  -> & 7'

->'

 - 

% 36'

"('

'

B%C2   0

 ) !'



 * !0- ''

0** '

>-- -'

 

   *- -!

'

2 &'

 - !*

0

'

('

0* '& 2& '

 & *   (  

  

   '

 0  - *  &'

 ! '

!0 ! ( '

- 0

'2'

2 

'

    3$-$ + ",$ $ ( &(" )$ (( '&$%,$ $ & +"$ ",$(

%* %$

'!*$&"

)$+ $", ( !

")0",$$

&$%"

"$# !&($ (& " ##$/"

)$

*'

''!&'  - % 36 "('

'

 (2'



-> 



'

!0H -  ('

'





!

0

)2 ('

!

0

* !'

'

!





! 



'

,'

 -> !

0

> -'

!-(''

 &

41:!*    :  :5     +5(    &       '  '

  

(  0!  9!

 *  

!- !'('!

!

 

'

!

 ( ' '

<

9!

-> 

*



-0

% 3 6'

"(  '

9!

''

0*

 !0 2  !--

  (  2'

(  '

  

  2 -     '

    1!&

 (

0 0 '!

2 &  & 







 

#  ('!&'  - % 36'

"('

 (-*0 2 ''

 !('

-> '



  1!& (2'

0*

 1!& (-*

- '

  (

* 0*'

!''

  

0!2'

2  2 ''

 

 

 *

!0 ''

(2'

'



 )2 (* '

!

% 36'

"(0! 2'

 2'

 - 

&'!

'



>



  0

&- 



!''

  ( 0*!

! *  ( 

& ! 

 ! < ('!

2!0 2

 



!



 .

*'

0* !*

 3 6

  !

'

 1!& ('!

 !--

* !'

 '

!0H - '

('

' 0 0

    &     

   !

  '

     1!&     *(    '    0   !

    0 H! &  '

     1!&

 ( ! ''

!--

(

*2'

!  

& *

&  3 6('

* &

41:

!*    :  :5    +5( ! % '

"('

' 0*   ''

 

* H* 

!- !'< (

*2'

! ' - 0  ('!*2>  !





 ! < (

 '

!



! *       0 &  

&     '

 !

 ,'

(    

 &  '

& &'

!



! *  '

('

0*



 !''

( '

!-- (

0!

 (    *  '

  '

   0  

   0*  '

  ,'

('

'



3 6('!

2'

-    ' 

 ! < ( 0* !-- &'

 '

&*

 '

'

   *

 2 0*'

 (0! '

!0

9!

*

 



' -*('!&'% '

"( 

2'

0 7 '

0 (

->  H! !

'

 1!& (



*!- 2'

'



0*'

0*'

(  ! 2'

 !

('!

- 

*'

'

(

-  *'

& !

 * !'!- #  ( '

!

*!- '

 - &!

! ('

'

!-

-

0  * 9!

*( '



2! '

 (0!2 '! '

&!

 2'-  !  0

& ,'





! % 36 "( 2 2 !

  9!



&!



: %  3 6('

  % '

"( 

 '(  '

0*  *     0!0

!-     !'  0

& 



0*'

 

% 36'

"  ,'

0*  

 *  2'

    

! *    '

 !

    

   0!    '

 

  

(  '!&'  -> &  



 !

'

!' (

  2 ''

 - ! 

 ! < ('



 0

&- 0*'

!

'

  ! '

 '

B%C0*'

"!0 "

! (0!2!

 1!& (



!*0 &  

%

"<- *(2'

!*0 &

  -*  (0

2'



& & -

'



 

    %     "(  0

 2   &     '

-*  !*   &  4  !        1      :      1 5(

 % "

/ ,'!&'('

% !

'  &!

*&!

'

'

B%C ( 

?7"D('!

->

  *

! 



(2'

 '

' !'

!0-  '



2   0*'

"!0 "

!  ,'

'

& 2 

! *'

!

-  *'

!



(2'

! * - &!

('

2'

2 - %

36'

"('

B%C

'

 - !

! ( !' 2  0

 <! '

'

&!

''

-   



 

(  2 '!  '

!    0

&  !     !(  '

 

!

 '

( 

'

 *

! 2 & '

(

*2'

 '

 &'

0*'

"!0 "

! ('

'

2  3 6' & 

! * *'

!   - 

 ? !0-

3 6(

!

('!

'

&! ' '

!&-'

 1!& ( - &!2>

*



 ! 3 6

& '

0

7 

 %  3 6('

 !0  & 

% "(

 ! !'

   



& ! 

 ! < ( 

'

'&

2& '

#  ( '

2!* '

* '



'

2 

07('!

 0 



'

-(9!'



F && 0*'

--> 

! 

'

0* -  &'

0*'

"!0 "

 (0!2!  

'& 2& '

< ( ' &

!

(  ! ->  7'

->'

(0!* '

0H

&'!- '

!('

!  2  '!

(

2   '

     1!&   (    -     0 *  '

!* 0 &      !

  '

-(  '!

     2   '

 -     '

& 

& (



-* !* &

4!  1  :    1 5,'

!* &

 

* >!

'

! 

  ! 0

&- 



'

0*'

!

(* '

!

'

 

-  *'

& !

!-   <'

2 2  -!* !

'

! #  ('

!*!0 0 2 

*2'

!

2

 * !

-  *'

!



!- #  ('

 &'

'

((

0

0' ! 0 

 0 2 

*0*'

-(!

 !

!

->

  ''

' ! 

- -> & 7'

-> 

  % '

  

'

B%C(2'

'?7"D

& ('

 !

( ->

 (''

' ! -'



-> &  7'

->!

'

'

B%C ('

0*  1!& (

' & -'

-* !* 0 &  !

'

-'

 ! '



&0 '

-( '!

-  & * !



,'

  

- !*0*'

 1!& ('

!

0 &

'

!



! *-  *  

(  (       !0

9!

*   >  '  '

   (  0

!-- ( ''

'



 '

-(0!'

 





 



&& 0*'

-'

-> &  '

!

'  #  (% 36'

"( 

'2'

& !

*!- 



! ('

'

!- 0

0 0!2 '! '

&!

2'-

!  0

& (0!2 ' 

''

!-*(

 ( 9!

!'

&! 0    < -'('

!* &'-

 

2

% '

"('!&'  1   

*'

-

8  !

&!

!''

!-  (2'

'-*0 

-  - %

% 36'

"(0! 

* 

 1!&

 (*   - % 3 6'

"('!&''

 &

(  *&!& (0!!'

! ! &  



,'

2!!* '

 ( !-- ( 0*

2!0

-  



 (2'

0* &'  2!0

!*

 



('

-

& !  &'  ?- ' * '

  2'

'' &'*

> ''

 

'

- ! '

B%C (0 !

*9!'

  ' 

 0 -  

    '

 ->'    #  ('

'

 0 - ! !(

'2'

2 

('!

 ! -> 

> 0*'

-(



'

&

->' !0

9!

* !('!

 !-

!

 % 0 '

0* (

''

' 2 ''

   * >-

!  !   '

 

 '

 

  2'

 (  *

-

('!

?7"D('!

2 - ,'

2 '' &'

0   >('!



> '

 *0

&- '



( 



 

 *

0

&- 0*'

B%C  : < ( 

''

'



( 2'

-  

''

 *

- '

!

'

(-*0  '

!2'

' - (0 - '

B%C ( 

!-(''

!



'

-*' 

 !

!-

 '

B%C 

!!

*(2'

 

  !   '

 

 '  '

  !

  !-

 0!2

 

9!

*( & >

->

 







0*    *

>3 60



,'

(0 !0

0 '

!



&  %$

/ ,'

!'

0

!

(

'('

! - 

((

  2 

9!

*('



2  ,'

!&   H!&-    &(  ( 

& '

 

(  (    0*'

 1!& (

9! '

((



,'



9!

 '

'& - & '

-,'

 -!( *(  

 0* '

-(  0 (     2 ' 2(  !    '

- ,'

(( ! *0

' '2 '

((

'& ,'



*0 2 '(  2 '2(0!

*'

  '



&

,'

(

!

*((  9!

*'



(0 '2 '

 * 

2

 &*  

*( *(0 2 '  2 '2(0!*  '

*'

  '



&

   

2'2 '  4

 

   6778979:

4   5 ",$(,     ,$",$ (/$ ;

&'< $ ( &$%. $(< ,--$ $# $.

/0