High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/7588/2015dismissed

Ram Lubhaya v. Sita Ram Through Lrs

2015-11-16Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih5 pages

& '()*!+, !

-(./)0-1-20- -3

-(./)0-1-20- -3 "&% "&% "&% "&% 4 & & 4 & & 4 & & 4 & & &5- -("67-6%50*/80.

&5- -("67-6%50*/80.

& "&% & "&% & "&% & "&% $' $' $' $' 9.$ & 9.$ & 9.$ & 9.$ &

*5'

$*0/:-/0;,67-5, *50<55* !=050* <*5* 7- ><-<* (-1 ) ->65503/68(5?&@ )* **6550 <*5**5?& A=050* 50 3/68(5 0/6 ) *<*56 50 685?&@

..," *-%

..," *-% 75<55<* **6 )150<55*B-6*6 >- 6(6 )1 50 5 5**, 0-*</*, 6 *6* 6-56!! !!--<<-<* **6-8-550-6*6* >-)-**6)1 5(,<<-5/50*51,65*6*6-56 ! A !

,6(650-<<7-5(6)150<55* /6* 75 50 6- .(5-5 75, !C , -6,

7D/51,50-<<-077/-**6-5)150 -<<-5-/50*51/<<*5 5*6*,*-6-50/'B !A !A !A !

755670-*850)/*6<*/- 50 /

755670-*850)/*6<*/- 50 5-5(5 50>5>/6850>50-5 5-5(5 50>5>/6850>50-5 5-5(5 50>5>/6850>50-5 5-5(5 50>5>/6850>50-5 50* 50((67-E<*5, 50( 50* 50((67-E<*5, 50( 50* 50((67-E<*5, 50( 50* 50((67-E<*5, 50( -/5 *7;0-> 6** -6 50* <* 3/5 -/5 *7;0-> 6** -6 50* <* 3/5 -/5 *7;0-> 6** -6 50* <* 3/5 -/5 *7;0-> 6** -6 50* <* 3/5 80)/** -6 50 7* E-(-5 50 80)/** -6 50 7* E-(-5 50 80)/** -6 50 7* E-(-5 50 80)/** -6 50 7* E-(-5 50 >5850>50-5501-*5->-* -1 >5850>50-5501-*5->-* -1 >5850>50-5501-*5->-* -1 >5850>50-5501-*5->-* -1

-75-65055(1 50>565

-75-65055(1 50>565 <*507- -<<7-5-1(-* <*507- -<<7-5-1(-* <*507- -<<7-5-1(-* <*507- -<<7-5-1(-* !F !F !F !F 5 1, -<<7-5 7/6 5 )*8 785 5 1, -<<7-5 7/6 5 )*8 785 5 1, -<<7-5 7/6 5 )*8 785 5 1, -<<7-5 7/6 5 )*8 785 6750 -7-* /<*/- 50 6750 -7-* /<*/- 50 6750 -7-* /<*/- 50 6750 -7-* /<*/- 50 -<<7-5/6*75 50.(5-5758 -<<7-5/6*75 50.(5-5758 -<<7-5/6*75 50.

(5-5758 -<<7-5/6*75 50.

(5-5758 50>50-5-8/-<<7-50-) 65 50>50-5-8/-<<7-50-) 65 50>50-5-8/-<<7-50-) 65 50>50-5-8/-<<7-50-) 65 5(56-50>(/706-1>07050 5(56-50>(/706-1>07050 5(56-50>(/706-1>07050 5(56-50>(/706-1>07050 -<<7-5>-5585766-650<*6 -<<7-5>-5585766-650<*6 -<<7-5>-5585766-650<*6 -<<7-5>-5585766-650<*6 >07050-<<7-5*(-67;6-50-5 >07050-<<7-5*(-67;6-50-5 >07050-<<7-5*(-67;6-50-5 >07050-<<7-5*(-67;6-50-5 )(56-5>0075-75607/ )(56-5>0075-75607/ )(56-5>0075-75607/ )(56-5>0075-75607/ -67-(5;>*8-*68<-8 3/68(5 -67-(5;>*8-*68<-8 3/68(5 -67-(5;>*8-*68<-8 3/68(5 -67-(5;>*8-*68<-8 3/68(5 0-8/-*50-)(-650-5- >6-1 0-8/-*50-)(-650-5- >6-1 0-8/-*50-)(-650-5- >6-1 0-8/-*50-)(-650-5- >6-1 -8, 0 (5 0 7/ =0 8 -<<7-5 -8, 0 (5 0 7/ =0 8 -<<7-5 -8, 0 (5 0 7/ =0 8 -<<7-5 -8, 0 (5 0 7/ =0 8 -<<7-5 /6* 75 .

(5-5 75, -<<7-5 /6* 75 .(5-5 75, -<<7-5 /6* 75 .(5-5 75, -<<7-5 /6* 75 .

<*6 -65 0-5) 650/80 ->

76-5D/5)*--6507/*5//-1 76-5D/5)*--6507/*5//-1 76-5D/5)*--6507/*5//-1 76-5D/5)*--6507/*5//-1 7666-150-5(-55*7/6)6766 7666-150-5(-55*7/6)6766 7666-150-5(-55*7/6)6766 7666-150-5(-55*7/6)6766 (*5)/5507/*57-5-)*8-550-> -6 (*5)/5507/*57-5-)*8-550-> -6 (*5)/5507/*57-5-)*8-550-> -6 (*5)/5507/*57-5-)*8-550-> -6 >070 <5/-5 50-5 50* 0- 5 ) (5-5 >070 <5/-5 50-5 50* 0- 5 ) (5-5 >070 <5/-5 50-5 50* 0- 5 ) (5-5 >070 <5/-5 50-5 50* 0- 5 ) (5-5

85050-550*65506</5-6

85050-550*65506</5-6 50*67585 -510->*D/*/

75 50*67585 -510->*D/*/

75 7-/5)<*650 7-556- 7-/5)<*650 7-556- 7-/5)<*650 7-556- 7-/5)<*650 7-556-0- 0- 0- 0- 0-55-70-3 4 $--88 ((55* *<*56 0-55-70-3 4 $--88 ((55* *<*56 0-55-70-3 4 $--88 ((55* *<*56 0-55-70-3 4 $--88 ((55* *<*56 6 !A"!%&/<*(/*5 -+FC, 6 !A"!%&/<*(/*5 -+FC, 6 !A"!%&/<*(/*5 -+FC, 6 !A"!

%&/<*(/*5 -+FC,9) 9) 9) 9) &/<*(/*5 6-0--)*-516-5>5050 &/<*(/*5 6-0--)*-516-5>5050 &/<*(/*5 6-0--)*-516-5>5050 &/<*(/*5 6-0--)*-516-5>5050 /)375 768506-1/6*50<* /)375 768506-1/6*50<* /)375 768506-1/6*50<* /)375 768506-1/6*50<* 75 50 .(5-5 75 5*-58 50 75 50 .(5-5 75 5*-58 50 75 50 .(5-5 75 5*-58 50 75 50 .

(56 50-5 50 -<<7-5

6-10/6)6*- 56>507-* /77*-65 6-10/6)6*- 56>507-* /77*-65 6-10/6)6*- 56>507-* /77*-65 6-10/6)6*- 56>507-* /77*-65 -0- 0-G-*6(-*>50550-57/*5-* -0- 0-G-*6(-*>50550-57/*5-* -0- 0-G-*6(-*>50550-57/*5-* -0- 0-G-*6(-*>50550-57/*5-* *D/*6576506-150-)0650-5 *D/*6576506-150-)0650-5 *D/*6576506-150-)0650-5 *D/*6576506-150-)0650-5 -<<7-5 *76-5 6-10/65) -<<7-5 *76-5 6-10/65) -<<7-5 *76-5 6-10/65) -<<7-5 *76-5 6-10/65) 6-5 >50 - */5 (-* -6 50 (5 6-5 >50 - */5 (-* -6 50 (5 6-5 >50 - */5 (-* -6 50 (5 6-5 >50 - */5 (-* -6 50 (5 (<*5-5 8/6 50-5 7*-8 5671 5 (<*5-5 8/6 50-5 7*-8 5671 5 (<*5-5 8/6 50-5 7*-8 5671 5 (<*5-5 8/6 50-5 7*-8 5671 5 <*76-1--*/(-55**D/*5) <*76-1--*/(-55**D/*5) <*76-1--*/(-55**D/*5) <*76-1--*/(-55**D/*5) 7/*)6 >50 8- <-*-(5* 50 -55 7/*)6 >50 8- <-*-(5* 50 -55 7/*)6 >50 8- <-*-(5* 50 -55 7/*)6 >50 8- <-*-(5* 50 -55 <*/7(5 50 9) &/<*( /*5

<*/7(5 50 9) &/<*( /*5

6- 7- 556 - 6- 7- 556 - 6- 7- 556 - 6- 7- 556 - *30 :/(-* 4 &5-5

*30 :/(-* 4 &5-5

-*1-- *<*56 6 !F"A% /*5 - -*1-- *<*56 6 !F"A% /*5 - -*1-- *<*56 6 !F"A% /*5 - -*1-- *<*56 6 !F"A% /*5 - F ,&/<*(/*5 6-0-0650-57/*50- F ,&/<*(/*5 6-0-0650-57/*50- F ,&/<*(/*5 6-0-0650-57/*50- F ,&/<*(/*5 6-0-0650-57/*50- 56*->-6575)5>6-1-6*6-5 56*->-6575)5>6-1-6*6-5 56*->-6575)5>6-1-6*6-5 56*->-6575)5>6-1-6*6-5 6-1&/

757-/-765<*765 * 6-1&/

757-/-765<*765 * E*7 67*5 507/*5 *768,50 E*7 67*5 507/*5 *768,50 E*7 67*5 507/*5 *768,50 E*7 67*5 507/*5 *768,50 6-1 -6 (5 (<*5-51 5 0- ) 06 50-5 6-1 -6 (5 (<*5-51 5 0- ) 06 50-5 6-1 -6 (5 (<*5-51 5 0- ) 06 50-5 6-1 -6 (5 (<*5-51 5 0- ) 06 50-5 >0 (-6-5*1 <* 5 7(<6 >50, >0 (-6-5*1 <* 5 7(<6 >50, >0 (-6-5*1 <* 5 7(<6 >50, >0 (-6-5*1 <* 5 7(<6 >50, 6-15<*<*1,-5 -75*1-67781 6-15<*<*1,-5 -75*1-67781 6-15<*<*1,-5 -75*1-67781 6-15<*<*1,-5 -75*1-67781 E<-6, 50 7/*5 7-5 76 50 6-1 E<-6, 50 7/*5 7-5 76 50 6-1 E<-6, 50 7/*5 7-5 76 50 6-1 E<-6, 50 7/*5 7-5 76 50 6-1 1(<-50578*/61 1(<-50578*/61 1(<-50578*/61 1(<-50578*/61 !

:<8>-)-68/6-66> :<8>-)-68/6-66> :<8>-)-68/6-66> :<8>-)-68/6-66>

-6 ;8 5 50 -75 50 <*5 7-, 50 -6 ;8 5 50 -75 50 <*5 7-, 50 -6 ;8 5 50 -75 50 <*5 7-, 50 -6 ;8 5 50 -75 50 <*5 7-, 50 7/*5 5076*6<50-5-<<7-50- 7/*5 5076*6<50-5-<<7-50- 7/*5 5076*6<50-5-<<7-50- 7/*5 5076*6<50-5-<<7-50- 5)-)5E<--5>016-1 -)/5 5)-)5E<--5>016-1 -)/5 5)-)5E<--5>016-1 -)/5 5)-)5E<--5>016-1 -)/5 1-*0-5-;<-7 850<*5-<<- 1-*0-5-;<-7 850<*5-<<- 1-*0-5-;<-7 850<*5-<<- 1-*0-5-;<-7 850<*5-<<- 7/<6 >50 50 -75* 50-5 67/(5 0>8 7/<6 >50 50 -75* 50-5 67/(5 0>8 7/<6 >50 50 -75* 50-5 67/(5 0>8 7/<6 >50 50 -75* 50-5 67/(5 0>8 50-500-6)</*/850*58-56/*850-5 50-500-6)</*/850*58-56/*850-5 50-500-6)</*/850*58-56/*850-5 50-500-6)</*/850*58-56/*850-5 <*6 /*50*>-;507- -<<7-5> <*6 /*50*>-;507- -<<7-5> <*6 /*50*>-;507- -<<7-5> <*6 /*50*>-;507- -<<7-5> 50-(50/8-8-550-<<7-5-6 50-(50/8-8-550-<<7-5-6 50-(50/8-8-550-<<7-5-6 50-(50/8-8-550-<<7-5-6 -/* -/* -/* -/* *<65H *<65H *<65H *<65H 7661, 50 75 <55 <* **6 )1 50 <55* >- 6(6 !!

!! E0)5 B! - 7*5 67<1 50-<<7-56-56 A !,(6)1 &/(*0-6,- 5 55 ,556- -(./)0-1-&/(*0-69E0)5 B50*<1 6)1 50<55*550-6-<<7-5 A !,50*/80 &03-10--,67-5,>0-0-<<65)07/ ) *50 55** 55*776607*B E-(-5 50-5 50 *<1 6-56 A ! >- 86 )1 0( E0)5 BF - 7*5 6 7<1 4-;--5-(-, 15 -50*(-55*, -/* &0 /<5--6&0*4-*6* /<5-,67-5,>0700>50-550-(>-86)1 50 <55* !! ! $-8 50*)1, <5 <-8 *6* 6-56 !! !!

- 0 -<<7-5 6-1 8 50

-<<--8-550*6*<-6)150 55**6-56 !! !! >- (6 !F ! !A - 5* - 6-1

-(51-* /*50*,50-<<7-5(6)150<55*

6-1 >- >01 -8/, /7*5- -6 -7;6(-5*-<-*57/-*-50>-567-56-5 0>(/70 >-506-1 50-77(<-18 -<<-/

*( .;>, 50 <*6 6/*8 >070 50 <55* *(-6</*<*561>-567-5650*6-5>- (56-5>0075-75607/-6-7D/*6 ;>68 D/- 50 *6* 6-56 !! !! <<-*51, <55*0-6)E5*(1885-6*(</*/8 07-/-6077/1665705 --<<- ((6-51- 5*<-8 50*6*)150 55** 6-56!! !! &/)D/555/5 50-<<-,>- 50/-- 5*50/805 .-*67/ *50<55*7/65<5/5 -50>5077/-**6-5)150<<-5/50*51 >-50*75*-*1550<5*7*6*>-**/ -> 0-5 )8 , 5* *7 >-**-56 E*7 *-3/*675/6*&75!

% 50-5

/3-) *)- 5 5*7575,!CFC 55)866 (*5,-77*681,6(6( 4$ !+, !

4$ !+, !

..% "

..% :-8 :-8 :-8 :-8