High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/7567/2016allowed

H.S.Bhatia v. H.V. Rai, And ORS

2019-03-05Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan3 pages

!" #$%$&'( ) * $

$$& + +

$ &"* % %,&" &% -' ./- 0/

% &'

-12*$3 4"5# 4!* , $$& -- *&"$

4"5# 4! %,&" & & ! %,&" &% &"( 6666666 0/47 /8 * , % & , $$& $% "$ # " $&% * " "

4, %% ":;* $5$<1"9 71&$$5$%$&84

$ < 7!%*4 * $ <184"$%=$%%$&9* , $$& .% $&!$< "1&" "

4*19*>*$#** * "%19**$%$=,< "= &$& %,&" & .%%1$ * !

#%4 $& :$ !4 >*$#* ?1$ " : &$# " !

$&91,&* , % &, $$& * !$< " %1$ % 2$&9* $&, = & &$&31&#$& % $& %,&" &% &"( != "$%#&& #$&9 * > @% > 9 #&& #$& $&% << " :; * = $& A)@A41:

B<&;4

$ < 7!%*4* %1$,, ;81#* %1$> %!$< ":; %,&" & &* 91&"* * > %>& $& ,%% %%$&!* %1$,, ; %,&" &% &"(41&" ,<$$# < , %%1 > #& =,< $&9 "$%#&& # * > @% > #&& #$&* %1$,, ; &: $&9,1&$# 4 %,&" &%

&"( ,, ": ! * $ <1 &""$%,1 " %,&" & .%#< $= :;%1:=$$&9* * > %&* >& !* %1$,, ; &"

CD * * * "9* > #&& #$&$&*$%& = :;! 1"1< &= &% ! * $ < 1 #1<" ! = * $%%1 %4 * , $$& !$< " &

$& 1&" " % 2$&9*$% $=,< "= & %

" ! &"

&$& %,&" & .%%1$,$= $<;&* 91&"* $> %* >*> %* >& !* %1$,, ; * $ <1 3 # "* , $$& .% $=,< "= & $& *19* * " >*$#* $% 1&" #* << &9 $&* , % &,# "$&9% / & "#1&% <!* , $$& % <% %,&" & * : &* "

%,&" & !$< " %1$ % 2$&9 * $& , = & & $&31&#$& % $& %,&" &% &" ( != "$%#&& #$&9 * > @% > 9 #&& #$&$&% << " * %1$,, ;!>*$#** #< $=% *$=% <!: * >& $&,%% %%$& %,&" &% &"(* 5 " &$ "

%,&" & .%>& %*$, &"* 5 !1* % "*

* "= & 9 "9 * #&& #$&$&*$%& = *19*! 1"1< &= &%

%,&" &% &"(* 5 !1* % ": ! * $ <1* * > @% > 9 #&& #$&$&% << " * %1$,, ;$%$ 91< % = #1<" &">1<": 91< $E "&<;$! %,&" & #1<","1# #"%, $&$&9*$%>& %*$,5 * %1$,, ; &5$ >!* :5 !

#%4 %>*$%* >& !* %1$ ,, ;>1<": &$=, &$%%1 : "1,& &"* ! 4 * , % &# !* , $$& 4>*4&* % &9*! 9$% "% < " "4 #< $=%*$=% <!: * >& !* %1$,, ;4>1<": ?1$ ": ! * $ < 1 !! #$5 <; " #$" %1#* #&5 %; * " #$%$& $& %,&" & .%%1$>1<" <%* 5 :

$&91,&* $9*%!*

C(D , $$& 1* 4$& %$=$< $&31&#$&%1$!$< ":; %,&" &

$&%* 1&3 : > , $&/"7!%*4* , $&8 % $&* , $&!="$%#&& #$&9* < #$#$;: $&9%1,,<$ " * %1$,, ;*19*" "

4* $ <1* % , =$ "* , $$& : $=,< " " % " ! &"

&4>*$#*" * %& : &#* << &9 ":; %,&" & &5$ >!* :5 4* $=,19& "" $%% %$"

$&!$< ":;* , $$& 1&" " $% <<> " * , % &, $$&$% <<> "$&* :5 =% , 1% <!* #"% 5 <%* !$< "*$% %1$$&1& 4 &"* % = = $&%, &"$&9 5 %$&# &* <$9*!

*$%!

#4* $ <1$%"$ # " 1,&* %1$ B, "$$1%<;

:1&< * & $9*=&*%!=* "

! # $,! # $!$ "#,;!

*$%" ( ) C 0/D %* =%* F* * %, 2$&9@ %& "

%@ F* * , :< ' %@