← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/7211/2017disposed of

Ashok Kinger v. Pradeep Kinger And ORS.

2019-09-03Mr. Justice Sudip Ahluwalia26 pages

              

   

 !" #$ " % !&'%     

   

" (   $ )  * %+   " ((  ,  %+   %     

 - + * * %% !

 %% % .

   %  /     0%  +*  ,$%!  1  +2 

%!

+*$   . #% $!%% 0%$*3

% **3%

*  *%/ %4 % $% 5. 6% 7+%  %%$% /+%% + 8**% %9

5* %

+:$%/



 ;

% / * !1% %23 3  *

 "4"* 

- !$%3  $ % / +%3 $!

*%

+%/ 0%$ *3  **3<     

 

 

 

 

      



       

 

   

 

   !       





"    

   !     !   

  #$#!##%  &   "    

    '          !  (

 "

     

 

      



  )

     !



   &   *    

     !   



 

   #$#!##%     +       

 

 

  "

 ( "

   !,  



    &  " 

  

 

   & 

      

   

 

(

' 

  #$#!##% 

         !

     -   

  %%    .  *  /!$0

 

 

  #$#!##%       



 

#$#!##%/   

 



     !   & 

  "    (

%1 . *  /!$02  -   *   3   + */  %    

*  

"4"* 

3   ! * %

 %$% 8**   =$  3  + $ **/:$%    * % / %    %$$!

%%

% /+%3  $ **/ !% %

 %%$

 3   3 ! $ % %;

% / * !

% +*/$%   **//%%$ %

$ *%$ 3    / %

+ %3  **/ *%/ % $ *  3$*%% */! 3



**/   %  %$   $

$%  */       $  

!     %!  3         >$    " ! **/%%



%+ ! *

 %$%  8**  $  *     /     3  * %/ % 6 %% $ / 3**

%*/ %$%%$

  *%/% 3!

 $+ * $ :!  3   3** %$=$*/  % ? - 0%$*3+ *3 $ %%/  %

*  " %$* */ **3%

*   $%    5.       6%   7+%     %! **3!+ < 1/      ! &  "



   

'   

 #$#!##%  



 3  3   (  '

  (  

"     

   

'  - %% *  / " 

     "

   

  

         !

     

   

  

#$#!##%  &   "      

   

   /      



? 

2 .

!!+%3  %%0%$*  "

 % **3!$  $  %! 3%%/ 0%- *$     +     **3!     %@

* < 4'  



 "  

  & &  - %%  *  /

" 

    



  %5

%1     /  6

!    

     

  



" 

    7 "4 '   

      "   !     8       

         8          

    ##07 4 '    

  6   !      

   & "





 &  "  

" 

           6

!

   

"

     7 4 '    &    

     

      



  /

 +  

  

 

 &     6  !9  7  4 '     "

  8     

  "##0   

"



         

 

    "  

     

"

:.6

7

. 4 '   "  "   8 

 6  !    



"





  

;

4-  ;

4



"      &  7 4 '    "  " 

8   6  ! 

  8  "   "

 6  !



  

           





   " 8   



 

      

7  4' 



  

      8 



     

    

8 



 

7  4'"  



 " 



  /



       

          

  

"

 

      

"

-      

         

&   34' 



"   

      8 



 

    

 

  "     6  

 !$%

*  "

  =$  %%  /  %       +*     

!! %$/ $$$*$ / % * !

! *   3    /  %  * %  %* % /+%   5 6 %% 0%$* "

% $ %  % ;!

$ 3**  $ $$ 

5  >    %     % 

+  *  * %     

A

 !+ 

 % $  % /+% %$%8**=$$!



% 9 )     !  * 3%

* 

%  3$*%           %     %!   % *+  % * */  * 3*% $/ "@%!

**! $!% %<

 6  !"#$%&!'($ !'!%!)* +,, , *#-.*#*) /  /3  *%/ $<

 <       "  

 "  

"    "  

 =    



 

"          (  

 " 

"     

 (   

      2  6  0'.)*#'  1!0'  ($  #%!2  .)3%  !)*  4%#'$   /+5+ ,*#-.*#*) /  , $

%+% $%<

> *  6 ?    

 

    

    

"        & 

 

       %@  /



" 

"  

  (

   "  

  

  

 / 

 



 " 

"    



"

 /

 '    8

        

    "

         

  

  &     



 

 

   

 





   %1  /'

       " 

 "        / 

 (    

  



  ,   ?   %5  /  " "

  "  

 

 "   :

 

 

"    8

  " 

   2  6 !&!%!' !2($0'.)*#'.)3%'$ /67.8.2 0'4!$#$95623  *%/ $< !$  .           

          



  !%#1!BB@

 " 

 "

  .     



  &    



 ( 

     

 

 + 

  8



  " 

   

 

     !B.  "

   

  '     " 

 

     

  &    

   

 

!%#1!BB@



" 





 "'    +   

   

     

 !%#1!BB@  " 

   .

"   "    

"   + 

     2   6  '##($'.).8!$ ,6 7.8.20'4!$#$,/:

67 $$

+%< !@/     

    

9   



     

&   '   : + C      +     

 

" 

 "





       .  &      

  !"

 ! #$%&'()**(   "   

  ;4

%1  . *  / 

"     &    

  

  

 

 

" 

 

      

     

 



 " 







 

 "3   

  



 "

             %%    

 

 

 2;* 

 6  !&!;.)3%($ )*#'<.41!0'

,9  555 %%% 5 .

3  *%/ :$<  

      

  

        

  

        

           

               

                 

       

 

          

       



  

 

 

       

 

                     

 

    !"  # $  % &'() ******     

    

  

 



+),'  

   



&!,,'     -  



   

    

            *                  



)+,&,,. 

 



    

 

    



              

      

  

   

       

 

      /   0"1112- 0 

       



    3 ? '%! +   % 

*  %   $ A% 



3  % /+% %$$!

*%           % **3%  */   $   

  %$ $*  ++ *$ %3   **/$!

 %*/ $=$*/   !  *)$  $ ! *%+%  $/%!+ * +: ! *%$ **3% / =$ *$/  %$  6

3+ $ "

+  $

!% /+% %$ $$$

  / $%  * %!  */* %/ * @%   **/+ !%$%5 % 5. 7+%  %

  $$  $

% / +%  !  % **3%           =$

$%     !  * %     %!     %$  - %*%$/ "@%! * %! % /+%   3  $ %  **3!"

! < . 6  $%= 02.-%!)*  ($ !*%!82!2  0;#  !)*  !)4%#'



59 67 /:> $$%%  * 7*  "  *%  /     $$ $*   %%   !

   % ;!

$% **3!  * %!+%

"

 / %$%%$$45.1 2 7+%

/+! DD

%/      + 

    

  

 + 

   

  /

  ;4  %1  . *  /   "

    &    

  

  

 

 

"  

 

 



 " 





   

 "3   

 + 



 "

          %% 



 +

;"4 ;4

  %1    

      

   

 "  "     



  

     

  

"



.

"

       ;4  %1    C@!B05" 

 !  &  

         

  " 

 

  

   

      

 8   

"  

 !  

   "   "  

 

  "     &   

      &   '  

   

   .                    



  

  " 

"    



 ! '  

   

     

 

        

 



 !'     &

  

 

 

  

   



       6

!    " 



 

 

' 

   

 +  "  "

 .    

  +        "  "  

         

   

 "

  +  3   " +  5 - +%3    **3%/ :$   "4!$%*!($"41%;%!!).

>

67 6.8.27:/ 3  3 +%<

'   



  "

     

 " 

 



 "3       

 

 



    

"   "     



   %1   

    

 

   .

 "   

     



      

  &      &       



E

%@

" 

"   %1

   "     &    

 

 

   

    '  

   " 

" 

       "  

         

 " 



  D



" 

 

   "

  

 



  ;'     

  +

$',- ) 

  8  

 4

 . '  

        

        

   8 " 6 F  

 

"

 %1   

" 

  .  

 ;4  %1 "    '

 + 9

  







  2  6  !)3!4!"($ '!;%0!?!2 !)*4%#'$

6/7   6.8.27   +     $  %%     +  !

 % * * $45./!<

(/ 



" +C  

    

  

3        

  -  

   



 



'    + C   &   "

  

"   





     - 

      " 

.  

 (

"  

 

  

 

        

 

     

  *                "   &  2 9 * */ )##4! @!"=#$%!<A4($!'!$&!4.

@%%!4'!*%!'.0A4!

,6976.8.27:, ( % / " % ;!

$%% "$% *  $ !

B * $%5.

7+%  +!< . 

  

  "

 

       

+  " ;

 4

CG

;

 4  

   >  63 +

6 

;

 4>       

  

   



    " 

   F"    

%1   *  / "  3  " 

                " 

 

   &  

 " "   

     

  -   "   " 

                

 

 





'   

  "   " 

 

"     

 





  



 

  

 "    /*     " "



   

    







         "         

                 "

"        

" 



". 



  

  

%1   



 

 

   

  "          

   "    

 

               &&&&&& ( '  / &+     

     

   

           >   

   

+  C   H

C;  <

  4

"  1 2$-!3 -  2$-/.. '()4*4'* !

).5/..'/)4*4'4$2)5/.. ')" (54/..%"&%        

" 

  "  

?     

"         G     

   +  6//(7/.. 81 - !129  -

 $

$ ::/..

  "     





"   

%1  *  /C  6  !.'!=!$%.)3%($4!4# .%!'

697 6'.".)!27,+5 "

 ;!

$

% % % **3!

* %! % /+%/+! D &  <   +   "    "     

 

    

 

 

      3  

        '    " 



"    "      .      " 

  

 

  !"

 ! #$ '%)*4 /(5'4%&*%() .    9"



+       

" 



     "

&   

 

   

   





     

    " "

 . 

   

  

 5D$D ##1 

 

3

        

 '   

   

 

  /   "  9"  

+  "

  " 

  



      "  &

  

 

    

   



       

 " "

 . 

    

  



  



    

  "  "      

3

.

 

 



 .



"     



 

                



E

 

 .  

+ "  "  

 

 

    3

. "  

       

"   

"

    '    

     "  

   " &    

    

"      # - ;

- !<$2 2$= >-  '4%>-  /)?

6 !%.)*'!!)*!%.)*'! 4*($!'*  '0$4##$ '

4%#'4 !2-044!

,6976.8.275+  *$ ;!

$%% + % !

 - *$@'% B!      /    * %  % /  +%       %$% %$$%5.1 2 7+% /+!<

' 

      H >  F   ?

  

(   " 

"  

  

     ' 

 

      "   



     "  

   

  



  . 

  



    "

 .

=.. 6 !@+8

+

  

 

  + 

 

   

   .

 

"

  "      %1;4  / "  '     

   

(   

 

 

  

   "   

  

      '       



  

  





5 (      

      .       H  H        

    

  

 

  '                 

  



 (    %1;4  /  '   C   



     ?

 2  6 !<'.)3%!)*4%#'$($102&.)*#'1!0'!)*4%#'$

,6 576.8.27/ 9 $

%B% %*/

"

 / $!%3**/+!<

 8           !%$##5  

     &

'   

 

   "

"    



'    "

   

     "   

    '   "

H 

  " 

  "    

 "    "

H 

'        "            "      "

 



  



 H 

 $%!BBB  " "

 $# 

 '   

  "  &  3   

   

" 

 '          .     &

 

 

  "



 

 

 "   "

    H 

           "

                     "

   

    



  &  "H 

/            "     .    " 

"

" / &+   12 @ 

!128# 4

/..%'/)4*4'* !

)(. 

 

 "    "



         

    %5     *  /' / &+ 

CG

9 

;

 4    3   





  !"

 ! #$%&'()**(

    "    C         



"       

          



 



 



 

  %5  *  /

    

"   



" " 





 (' 

 



 * 

     

  " 





" 



  " "   "

H 

 " 



 

 "

 

 " 

  "   "    

2 6 !3"!.2.)3%!)4%#'($1!'!"<.4.)3%4%#'$

6 7 !&#'!2*,5  % )  $$ *% % - *$%!  / * %!

% /+%+  3  $%55

7+% 

%+%$ %%$ ! *8**3  3 * % / +!< /  



        "   

&    

    

 

 

 

" 

 



 " 





   

 "3   



9 + 



 "

 

        %% 



 /  ,

     

  C  @!B$B

          ;

4  

 

  

     " 

"  

 "

       8

<    6      8   

 

%%  /

 

  C @!B$B" 

 H

    "

  &     

 

   (      &     



D "  

  '            

   



   C @!B$B"   .



  "

 5#  #!1  

 

   

 

    "

 

      "      



2  6  1!')!.2.)3%($@$1!2'!'4%#'$>.'$!

567 6.8.27,:

> % )  $

%+%

         %    "

   /    %$ $!  ! $ /$ ! $  :

%+/%$! ;

%3!7: 

%

*%/ !*,$%! $%0'<.4!"($%'#"

10"!'1%#'!> 55967  / 67B

/. *   

    

    "  &  

 "

"

  & .  3 69    ;

 4        C        

ID .   

 " 





    

"         



" 



 

  

"

 

 2 ? 6  (#*!'=!$%($"41!'4!'1!0'

 55,67 6#)47+:

> $%! + % !

 B  / * %!% /+%

%+%<

/     + 

     .    



  .

 "  



   



  

&     & 



'   + 

      



      

 



"   '  + 

     &       

   

"  .      +  

             

   &    

 2 . 6 @$))$$2#-4').-$!2!)*%!'!)*4%#'$($"4 !';!)$1!0'!)*4%#'$

56976.8.27 ,  $ %! + % !

 - *$@'% B! % % /+%

%% D  '   +     

       &      

  

   

  

  

   

 

          '  +                "     "    



         '  

 

 " 

 



 

 %5  *  /'     +       

 

   

%%  /



" 



    

    

    

 

%5  *  /  

    

  

        "    -       +  3   %%  3     **3!

+ < /   '                 

   



   "   "

  " . 

"      

     

 

   

 

    

  

  

     

 

           6 

  "  

    

 



     "    "  



        

 

     "   

 ' 3  

"  

6 +

 

 

   

"  9"  

+   12 @  !128# 4

;

 42 5 - +%@"4!$%*!8"41%;%!!).

6$0A'!73  **3%/ $ !'"!)<.41!0'($!')!.2 .)3% /6 ,76.8.27 +,: % '% - *$ !     **     * %  % /  +%    +  * */$!%8**1   2% %.

  %3 **3!+ < &8 

      

!-%   



"

  + 

" 

 D

 !1!###!'   





  " 

'  "    

. 

    +     /

/ 

                  

 "

  

+  

        !1!###!

" 

'    

"    8      

"   "  "    

 

     





 .

CG

;

 4 "  "

"  & 

 

 "

  "   

 %5  *  /H

    

                   (       

   &       

 % '  

  

     

 + 

 " "  

 " 

    .    

  

    "  

   "  D 



6    

 2  6 0=#$%10"!'!2.!$44!($4!4# !'?!)!

6 76.8.27+9  $%% + !

 B        /  $4  5.       7+%   3    "

%$!

* % / ! *"+3

    

   

%  %/%     ! *  %$ 1"/"2 

+! %$ =$%$    %  -   $  %%     +  /  +!

 '

           

  

  " 

" 



 

  

 "      

   "     

     "

 2 9

 %*%$/ "



$ %!"!) !2($!8.)

6, 76.8.279 5 )$ % $ * "    $  % % /+%*%$45.1

% **3%3 $$! =$$455 7+% )$   %

%

$ **/ *%   * $455!%$ "* 

%$ ! *8** **!%

+  / / -  % * 3 %%

/ 0%- *$  */  % 3   $!%%3  * %1. 23 **3!+ <

&/       & 

"    

                 

'     #$#!##%  



 3  3    (    '

      (      

"          

      "

   

 

                 

!-  

 

        #$#!##%



   

   #$#!##%/  



2

- * $45. 7+% 3     */ **3%/ 0%$*3+% $!%'% 6      !$%           %  /  

  %  * $45. 7+% 3$*% =$   *$  $/    %    %  3    

$%  * %!% /+%

 %$  - *+  +  %"

  % @ * $45. $ *3<

/ '        !          

         !

    5  &  .<<  #$#!##% .         

 

  

 

.<<  



  .  

             

 

        

 

   

 

   !          



"        !     !

  .<<  #$#!##% &  "  

     '          !  (

"

   

 .<<

   

   

  )

    

! 

   &   .<<* 

        ! 

      

   

    .<<

 #$#!##%    +        

 

  "

( "     !,  



  .<< &  " 

  2 



+!  $**/%%   * + * * %*$%!"

 / **!%8**% %9

:$"<.2 %%! $ /   + $  *%$/ %  * %/% %!

 ? "

!  $ /+   !

  +*  4 /       +    +  * %!  $       !  %$=$ ! / ! * 8**  /   "4"* 

3  

%   **/%%  $

   !

+!+$ * ! / ! *%$- % $@1!')!.2.)3%

6$0A'!7   * !

*!

% % ( % / " % ;!

$"

  B$%!@)##4! @ !"=#$%!<A4 6$0A'!7 * %/%$% *3$*% *

 $% %*/ %$%8** 

*3 / */ / ! $ % %

+!     %         %$  %     $%$ "

 %$$!

*% +%$45.1 2 7+% 8 *

  /  % +  /!* %$ % / +%

% **3% %!**+3 

A%:   % $$ '## ($'.).8!$ 6$0A'!7 %$% * $ 

 %

% %   $% 

  * %!  % /  +%  /  3 /   *!    

* $455 7+% 3  3+ 3 $*% **3% "

%  **/%% !   ! * * %%%+ 



+ % /+% %$%%$

%%$45.1 2/3 / * %!! %%*+% +  :       ! *  %$  %     $ 

 . !

%!   ! % 3 ! *  **/  % 3 %

   %  2 %!  3  ! * 3  **!%*/  // "4"* 

3  *   3 "

 /$!

*%$  %%*/ ** * %/ % %     -$$    $ 

 %4 %         !  $!

      %   + **/* %+% %$%"

 /

**!%8**1 :$"<.2$BB "@% -   + *  *     =$*/  %%  



! $!%'%$3 %

"

 /

%$%%$

** +%+ **/  %!B "@% % * * %%*+%:*  + $    %$$ <!    *   %        **!%  :$     *     % $ $%3  3 !  % %3     % "

 3 ! *  * % *  %% % **!%*/ %/ % **!$ "%$ ! *  %* "$ +3$*%*% $/ $ +% $%%/ %@% 6  % *  / - *$3

%*  +%    !       +  %    % $ 3  3$*% !+  $* /!

 5   $%   !% /+%$45.

7+%  - *$ /   ! !$    %*%$$

**% $ *  ++ *$ */ %%%*/36 %!       0%  - *  $  

**       *$%  /  / +  % /3  '% 6   

7    

 8   !4 %D E4 8   *D E4