Kartar Singh Etc. v. State Of Pb.Etc.


 

       

   

  

     

      

  

    

     

    

     

 
    

     !"#$"#%$"#&'()#*#+$,"-'.(/#%#0-%$#(1+$"#(1)#,$2 -



  3

  

 

3



 

 



 4


567





 

 4

8


 







567



  



8


  

 



3


567





! 

 

   
 

         



 

     

 !

"

 #$$
 %  

 &       

#'#


#$$#       

 ( 

        )

  &  ( 

     # *+# ,-



  *+.

") "

   

   *+/ 0-



  

  

  

  )  

  



 

  #.!
''.



 

.$$  ) *+# *+/    )     

  ( 

 2 







  " 

 )  

   ) 

  



    *+#



- 

 )  

  

  



*+#     

  



  



   

  



  ) )  )      - 

-

  



 



  )  

     )     

  





  )     

 -



%   )      *+# *+.

 *+/    3 2

    *+#  *+/ ) - 

 ( 

           

)  

 

  

2



 *+
562   

7 *+# *+.

 *+/       *+
   

7  2 

     

     0,

375


+$"#,1(#-9$"#(#9#+:#!+(#%1+)";1+1-:'*#+$ !%1$#%<;,#=;*1+#($-0%->#$"##=#:'$1-+-9;)%##*#+$9-%,;.#(;$#(

5
 884/? -*; ;* !;+&1> '*;%<;,#=;*1+#($-0%->#$"# .#;,#(##((;$#(5 884#=#:'$#(/? -*; ;* !5;)(#>1+)"

<;,$"#;$$#,$1+)<1$+#,,$-$"#;)%##*#+$9-%,;.##=#:'$#(/? -*; ;*

!4 ;.; ;*<;,$"#;$$#,$1+)<1$+#,,$-$"#.#;,#(##(#=#:'$#(/? -*; ;* !<;,$"#".*;(-9$"# 1>1. -'%$<"-,0-@#;/-'$$"#

1>1.  '1$  - 8
  -9  88A88  '%/;:";+  1+)" >,  -*; ;* (#:1(#(-+4  /?$"# 1>1.'()#B% 1>1,1-+C;D1.@;

  !7 ;./1% ;*<;,;.;/-'%#%<"-,0-@#;/-'$$"#;$$;:@.;'+:"#(/?$"# :-*0.;1+;+$0;%$?

"#$%1;. -'%$";>1+);(>#%$#($-$"##>1(#+:#-+%#:-%( %#$'%+#(;91+(1+)$";$$"#;::',#(:-**1$$#($"#-99#+:#,;,,$;$#(,'0%;

"##+$1%##>1(#+:#<;,$"-%-')".?0#%',#(/?*# #;%+#( :-'+,#.;00#;%1+)9-%$"#;00#..;+$,,'/*1$$#($";$$"#$%1;. -'%$";(#%%#( 1+"-.(1+)$";$$"#;::',#(0;%$?<#%#;))%#,,-%,<"#%#;,$"#(-:'*#+$;%? #>1(#+:#<-'.()-$-#,$;/.1,"$";$1$<;,-+.?$"#:-*0.;1+;+$0;%$?<"- <#%#$"#;))%#,,-%, #;%+#(:-'+,#.;00#;%1+)9-%$"#:-*0.;1+;+$;,<#.. ;,.#;%+#(((.



'+&;/,'/*1$$#($";$$"#,'/&#:$0%-0#%$?<;,1+9;:$ 1+0-,,#,,1-+-9$"#:-*0.;1+;+$0;%$?;+($"#%#9-%#$"#;::',#(0;%$?";( $-91.#;,'1$+-$-+.?9-%,0#:191:0#%9-%*;+:#/'$;.,-9-%0-,,#,,1-+

"#?  ;.,-  %#9#%%#(  $-  $"#  %#>#+'#  (-:'*#+$,  ;+(  ,'/*1$$#(  $";$  $"# :-*0.;1+;+$0;%$?<;,;:$';..?1+0-,,#,,1-+-9$"#0%-0#%$?<"1:"<;,1+ (1,0'$#

"#.;%)#%E'#,$1-+<"1:"";,;%1,#+9-%(#$#%*1+;$1-+1+$"# :%1*1+;.  ;00#;.  ;+(  $"#  :%1*1+;.  %#>1,1-+  1,  <"-  ;:$';..?  <;,  $"#

4
;))%#,,-%29$"# -'%$91+(,$";$$"#;::',#(<#%#$"#;))%#,,-%,$"#%#1, +-#,:;0#9%-*:-+91%*1+)$"#&'()#*#+$-9:-+>1:$1-+;+(,#+$#+:#0;,,#( /?$"#$%1;. -'%$  9$"#;::',#(:-'.(#,$;/.1,"$";$1$<;,-+.?$"# :-*0.;1+;+$0;%$?<"-<#%#$"#;))%#,,-%,$"#+$"#;::',#(;%##+$1$.#($- ;:E'1$$;.



1%,$.?91+($";$$"#0%-,#:'$1-+9;1.#($-#=0.;1+$"#)%1#>-', 1+&'%?,',$;1+#(/?;::',#( '%/;:";+1+)"

 !% 

;%)";($- ,0#;@;/-'$$"#)%1#>-',1+&'%?,',$;1+#(/?;::',#( '%/;:";+1+)"-+.? ('%1+)$"#:-'%,#-9:%-,,
#=;*1+;$1-+(-+#/?$"#;::',#( +9;:$$"# :-+:#%+1+);::',#( '%/;:";+1+)"<;,#="1/1$#(/?$"#;::',#( $"%-')"  !  %  

;%)   -+
#=0.;+;$1-+  -9  $"#  )%1#>-',  1+&'%? ,',$;1+#(/?$"#;::',#(/?$"#0%-,#:'$1-+:%#;$#,;(-'/$1+$"#:;,#-9 $"#0%-,#:'$1-+

"#0%-,#:'$1-+<1$+#,,#,";>#'+;*/1)'-',.?;(*1$$#($";$ .#;,#(##((;$#(5 884;,,0-@#+$-/?!;+(!4<;,#=#:'$#( /? -*; ;*1+9;>-'%-9;::',#( '%/;:";+1+)"

,0#%$"#$#%*,-9 .#;,#(##(;::',#( '%/;:";+1+)"";(,$;%$#(#+&-?1+);/-'$;:%#,-9 .;+(  -<+#(  /?  -*;  ;*  -+  ;+(  9%-*  5 884   "#%#;9$#%  ;+ ;)%##*#+$9-%,;.#(;$#( 884;,,0-@#+$-/?!;+(!5<;, #=#:'$#(/? -*; ;*1+9;>-'%-9;::',#( '%/;:";+1+)"

)%##*#+$ 9-%,;.#,0#;@,-9(#.1>#%?-90-,,#,,1-+-9;/-'$@;+;.*;%.;,-9.;+( 1+9;>-'%-9;::',#( '%/;:";+1+)"0'%,';+$$-$"#;/->#;)%##*#+$9-% ,;.#



%'#1$1,$";$:#%$;1+%#>#+'#(-:'*#+$,";(/##+0%-(':#(/?


$"#:-*0.;1+;+$0;%$?$-,"-<$";$$"#?:-+$1+'#$-/#1+0-,,#,,1-+-9$"# 0%-0#%$?

 +#1*0-%$;+$;,0#:$<1..";>#$-/#+-$#((-<+/?$"# -'%$-9 ;< !1$"1+;,0;+-9*-+$",9%-*$"#(;$#-9.#;,#(##($"#-::'%%#+:# ";($;@#+0.;:# "#%#9-%#$"#%#>#+'#(-:'*#+$,:%#;$#(9-%$"#0'%0-,# -9$"#:;,#:;++-$/#,#%1-',.?.--@#(1+$-/?$"# -'%$-9;< ;,#(-+ ,':"%#>#+'#(-:'*#+$,$"# -'%$:;++-$&'*0$-;:-+:.',1-+$";$$"# 0;%$?<"-<;,,"-<+$-/#1+0-,,#,,1-+1+$"#%#>#+'#(-:'*#+$,<;, %#;..?1+-::'0;$1-+-9$"#0%-0#%$?



$1,;.,-$%'#$";$;::',#( '%/;:";+1+)"";(91.#(;,'1$+-$ -+.?9-%,0#:191:0#%9-%*;+:#-9;)%##*#+$9-%,;.#/'$;.,-9-%0-,,#,,1-+

$1,;+-%*;.0%;:$1:#9-%$"#;)%##*#+$"-.(#%$-91.#,':";,'1$#>#+19 0-,,#,,1-+  <;,  (#.1>#%#(  $-  "1*  '$  1+  $"#  1+,$;+$  :;,#  (#.1>#%? -9 0-,,#,,1-+  <;,  ;:$';..? '+(#% :";..#+)#  /? $"# :-*0.;1+;+$  0;%$?  - <-+(#%;::',#( '%/;:";+1+)":"-,#$-91.#;,'1$9-%0-,,#,,1-+;,<#.. <"1.#:;+>;,,1+)9-%$"#%#.1#9-9,0#:191:0#%9-%*;+:#-9;)%##*#+$9-%,;.# 1+-%(#%$-;>-1(;+?9'$'%#.1$1);$1-+;$$"#1+,$;+:#-9 -*; ;* "# 9;:$%#*;1+,$";$$"#,'1$91.#(/?;::',#( '%/;:";+1+)"9-%,0#:191: 0#%9-%*;+:#9-%;)%##*#+$9-%,;.#";,;$$;1+#(91+;.1$?



-%;..$"#,#%#;,-+,;*-9$"#:-+,1(#%#(>1#<$";$$"# ;::',#(0;%$?<#%#1+9;:$1+0-,,#,,1-+-9$"#,;1(0%-0#%$?+-$-+.?/;,#( -+  $"#  .#;,#  ;)%##*#+$  /'$  ;.,-  /;,#(  -+  $"#  ;)%##*#+$  9-%  ,;.# ,'/,#E'#+$.?#=#:'$#( "#:%1*1+;.:;,#.;'+:"#(/? -*; ;*$";$"# <;,@1(+;00#(;+(;)%##*#+$9-%,;.#<;,9-%)#(#+(#(1+91;,:-  "# :-*0.;1+;+$0;%$?1,9-'+($-/#$"#;))%#,,-%<"-*;(#;+;$$#*0$$-/'..?

7
$"#;::',#(  0;%$?<"-  <#%# $%;+,0.;+$1+)  0;((? 1+ $"#  91#.(,  1+ $"#1% 0-,,#,,1-+;,;*;$$#%-9%1)"$ "#;::',#(0;%$?";>##=#%:1,#($"#1%%1)"$ -90%1>;$#(#9#+:#$-0%-$#:$$"#1%0%-0#%$?<"#+$"#%#<;,;+-+,.;')"$ 9%-*-'$,1(#%,

5

+*?:-+,1(#%#(>1#<$"#$%1;. -'%$";,<%-+).?"#.($";$$"# ;::',#(0;%$?<;,1+0-,,#,,1-+-9$"#,'/&#:$0%-0#%$?(#,01$#>-.'*1+-', #>1(#+:#$-,"-<$";$$"#?<#%#$"#;))%#,,-%, "#%#9-%#$"#;::',#(;%# #+$1$.#($-;:E'1$$;.

4

+$"#%#,'.$$"#&'()*#+$-9:-+>1:$1-+;+(,#+$#+:#0;,,#( /?$"#$%1;. -'%$E';'@"(#>1+)" '%/;:";+1+)" ;$$;+1+)";+( "'01+(#%1+)",$;+(,,#$;,1(# "#?;%#9-'+(+-$)'1.$?-9$"#:";%)#, 9%;*#(;);1+,$$"#*   -+,#E'#+$.?$"#;00#;.E';;00#..;+$,'@"(#> 1+)" '%/;:";+1+)" ;$$;+1+)";+("'01+(#%1+)"1,;..-<#(

"#1%/;1./-+(,,$;+((1,:";%)#(  

+>1#<-9$"#(#:1,1-+;%%1>#(;$/?$"1, -'%$1+



567
-9

- 8-99;1.,;+(1$,$;+(,(1,*1,,#(

:$-/#% !  "

'.;$1 #$