High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/7200/2018allowed

Ram Asra (Deceased Thr Lrs) v. Jaspal Kaur Etc

2019-01-11Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi3 pages

$% "%&'('!) *(+ "%&% (%"$,+-.,,'(/( 0%$'$'!%+( 1%+(-( (2 34 -+ !"$,%+( 0%(2!"%!$( ) 5/ 6

67/ +%(%!$) ++', !$ '!8"9& $% +$,% 223'& !$(:2%$'$'!%+( +6,%%+;46'!.3 8"9& $% ++%(2!"%!$ <<<

+6,%++;46'!.3 8"9& $%, (2-$'! 22% + !&%!=%, 3 &!$%($'!.+%(2!"%!$ !", ( '3%",'(1 > 3 $! * '! -+$$" ; ,%( *%'($ >%!!+%&+" 223'& $'! , ( =%%! '3%" =; $,% 223'& !$(:2%$'$'!%+( + ($ ;'!.$,%2 (('!. '! 3+"%+'!$,%* '!(-'$=;$,%3% +!%" '9'3-".% +'98*3, 7'$, $,% &!(%!$ 3% +!%" &-!(%3 + $,% 2 +$'%(8 $,% * '! & (%'(2+% 2!%"$$" ; !"'($ >%!! +" ! $,% &'+&-*($ !&%(8 3% +!%" &-!(%3

+ $,% 223'& !$(:2%$'$'!%+("%(!$2+%(($,% 223'& $'!8$,%+% +%8$,%( *%'( "'(*'((%" (!$2+%((%"

?@ %9'('! 2%$'$'! , ( =%%! '3%" -!"%+ +$'&3% $,%

!($'$-$'! !"' +(%$$'!. ('"%+"%+" $%"A#2 ((%"=;$,% 3% +!%" '9'3 -".% + '98 *3, 9'"% B,'&, $,% 223'& $'! + '*23% "'!.$,%/( "% %!" !$ *(+ , (=%%!"'(*'((%" ?@ +'% &$( $,% & (% 3% "'!. $ $,% '3'!. $,% +%9'('! 2%$'$'! +% $, $ &!$%($'!. +%(2!"%!$ :23 '!$'

'3%" &'9'3 (-'$ + 2%+* !%!$'!C-!&$'! ++%($+ '!'!."% %!" !$('!&3-"'!.2%$'$'!%+( +* '!$%+ %+'!.'!,'(2% &% -32((%(('!9%+$,%(-'$3 !" ?

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

A ?A@ /% +!%" &-!(%3 + $,% 2%$'$'!%+ , ( &!$%!"%" $, $ $,% 3% +!%" '9'3 -".% + '98 *3, '3%" $ $ >% '!$ &&-!$ $, $ &-!$%+ &3 '* , " 3( =%%! '3%" !" $,% 2%$'$'!%+( ,%+%'! B%+% $,%

=%!% '&' +'%(-!"%+$,%7'33%D%&-$%"=;$,%"%&% (%":"% %!" !$E * (+ '!$,%'+ 9-+8$,%+% +%8$,%* D'*

(+%3'%"-2!=;$,%3% +!%"$+' 3 -+$B (!$ 223'& =3%'!$,%

&$( $,% & (%8 &!(%H-%!$' 33;8 $,% '*2-.!%" +"%+ B ( 3%. 33; -!(-($ '! =3% !"3' =3%$=%(%$ ('"% !"$,%2%$'$'!%+('*23% "%" ($,% /( "%&% (%":"% %!" !$E *(+ ?G@ %+ &!$+ 8 3% +!%" &-!(%3 + &!$%($'!. +%(2!"%!$ :23 '!$'

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

$E *(+ /% +!%"$+' 3 -+$(, 33 %!"% 9-+ $ "%&'"% $,% (-'$ '! &&+" !&% B'$, 3 B ( %D2%"'$'-(3; ( 2(('=3% 67 3' -".% *'$ 7,%$,%+(2% >'!.:+% (!