Rupinder Pal v. Tara Chand Thr Lrs Promila And ORS

         

   




"#$%$ & ''

 

"#$%$ & ''

 

"#$%$ & ''

 

"#$%$ & ''



()$&"* 

()$&"* 

()$&"* 

()$&"*  '''' ,*%(% 

- -* (.- /*% * 0$+

*%'



- -* (.- /*% * 0$+

*%'



- -* (.- /*% * 0$+

*%'



- -* (.- /*% * 0$+

*%'

'''

%) &"&  1  1  1  1 2/ 13'

3 1   2/ 13'

3 1   2/ 13'

3 1   2/ 13'

3 1   *%&  1*'

) ..

*5 +6 "7 #

$ &*'

1*'

%-5$&"*) 3$&.-6 "7 #

1*'

+ 4 1$

+6 "7 #

%'

88888 1  6 '

1  6 '

1  6 '

1  6 '

'

()$&"* 

#$7$+ *7$%$ & * $#+

 &% &"$

$&.

%$"

*"*

 ''
 9&&:(* ;

%%"

""$ $7$+ (".

93&$ * $7$%$ &;6  <-

5-*<=

<& "$%0$%%"'

'

/

*.("



- 9"# %";

& 5 *)*%&

-* (.- +.

-$*% *"

*"$&.

> +6  *+ <$&.

?@ > %-

@

> *+ %$

 <-

$ &*'

% )*

%++6 *#$7"

%'@ #%

*&%

0 &=

""

:#( ' '
@


 7 (*

*#$7$&.

# &%$"*

$ &'

% )*

%)$*$

""

+!

%-

:#(

*.$% *"

'>'
@ 7 (*

*#$7$&.

0 (&

## *"$&.+='



- $+"

:#(

""

<! *

!$:"

4& 5

%(<A#

#-0&

% 0 +$ $.

5&

"!&"



-

 "

 *) *

&"$

-*! *6

""

# (+"

<& :#( 

-

*# 7*=

%'

#% $''

%'@ #%

## (&

)*$&#$)

0 (&

%'@ #%

.%'

# )=

&&:(* 

5*$

0&

"!&"



- &&:(* 
'

!



- &"6 +.

-$*% 5* $0)+ ""

='

$%%(% 5* !* 0"

!$:"

7$"&#'

&  ' '
 6

$&"

# )= *7&( *# *"

4& 5

*+ %"

!* 0

#-0&

!* !* 0

++ &#(0<* &#%'

-* *6 $00"$



# )=

+ &.

0&""

&&:(*% 

>'

)) %"

%'

*)+= &&:(*  '

"#+$&"

%%$&.

$0)(.&"

*"*

 ''
 &&:(* '

/

)* ) %"

. $&.

&.

 %?"!&"

5$++

%(!!*

&= )*A("$#'

$++

$&$

.

5-&

!$+"'

)* =*

)* )*

#-0&

&#6

)* )* !* !* 0

++ &#(0<* &#%

-&

7*= *$.-

%++'

)* ) %"

&#%% A(%

"#$%$ &

5$++

+% )*7&

0(+ $)+$#$ +$ $.

$ &'

5$++

&.

%"

%()) *

*.(0& *+$"

() &

- *$  &B<+ ):

$7$+ ))  '

 *$%$&.

3/9$7$+;

 '>

;

"#$""

''


.( -$+

.( -$+

.( -$+

.( -$+ ' -& ,%'

3'

)) &D ' -& ,%'

3'

)) &D ' -& ,%'

3'

)) &D ' -& ,%'

3'

)) &D

-+"

 '

(&"* C'

!

! *%

))+$"

$&%

%6

# (+"

"#+$&"'

" 0$&

)(*) %

++ 5$&.

0$&$0$%

+$ $.

$ &'

*.( <+

#$*#(0%

&#%

%6

7$"&

!* 0

)*(%

7*0&

;

9!;

5*

$&# *) *

!+

#$*#(0%

&#%

+$0$

<$&.

"$%)( # (+"

%(<A#

$%%(

++ 5$&.

)* ="

! *'

> & 7$5

+.

) %$ $ &6

-*#$& < 76

$0)(.&"

*"*

%(%

<+'

## *"$&.+=6

))

++ 5"

$&.

%$"

$0)(.&"

*"*

)*0$

$&.

))++ )+

0&"

%(<A#

=0&

# %

%'

?'

))

++ 5"'D &

*+$"

() &

- *$ $7$+ ))  '>@ >@ >
>  &B<+ $7$+ ))  '>@ >@ >
>  &B<+ $7$+ ))  '>@ >@ >
>  &B<+ $7$+ ))  '>@ >@ >
>  &B<+ ):

C &4

&*'

,%'

++ ))

9;

/*%'

):

C &4

&*'

,%'

++ ))

9;

/*%'

):

C &4

&*'

,%'

++ ))

9;

/*%'

):

C &4

&*'

,%'

++ ))

9;

/*%'

*%'D *%'D *%'D *%'D'

*+7

 '



> *(&%

(&"* C'

(

G(% # &%$"*

5- %%

"+ :

$&.($%-"

*$.-

7$* :)$*=

)*$ "

+$0$

)*%#*$<"

:*#$% "$%#*

*$.-

##*("

++ 5$&.

%(#- <+

%H >'

*"

+% G($

# &%$%

<% +(

*(+

7*=

<# (% +$0$

%- (+"

++ 5"'

$%#* %(#- %% ")&"%

#$*#(0%

&#%

%'

A(*$%"$#

++ 5

++ 5

<$&.

"$%#*

5$++

:*#$%"

A("$#$ (% +(

#$*#(0%

&#%

!

.* $&.

++= %(<%*7%

(% A(% $#

7 $"% !(* +$ $.

%- (+"

++ 5"'

-* $.-

#4

! *0(+

++ 5$&.

"$% ++ 5$&.

"$&.%'

 ")&"%

#4.* (&"

%D

  &

 '

!$& ++=

<%*7"

*.( <+ G(% 5-

+$0$

"#+

++ &

/$0$

#

& *$% >

/$0$

#

G(%

"#$""

*$ +6

-*! * 7$5

! ++ 5$&.

A(".0&

9
;

3 >

$&C

.( -$+ ' -&B%

.( -$+ ' -&B%

.( -$+ ' -&B%

.( -$+ ' -&B% 9%()* ;

9%()* ;

9%()* ;

9%()* ;D

%$"

$0)(.&"

*"*

# (* <+ 5

++ 5

)* ="

"$*#

*$

!* &#%% $%%(

*"

"#$"

$%%(

## *"

*$&.

0$&"

" 5&



@

3()*0



C/''/

 '

/ "'

&*'

9%()* ;D /''/

 '

/ "'

&*'

9%()* ;D /''/

 '

/ "'

&*'

9%()* ;D /''/

 '

/ "'

&*'

9%()* ;D

))

## *"$&.+=

##) "D'

/

*.("

0*+=

.* (&"

+$0$

$ &6

&&

"#+$&"'

-*! *6

$0)(.&"

*"*

 ''
 9&&:(* ;

4$&"+=

%$"

++ 5$&.

$ &*?)+ $!!'

'

&

&"6

*)*%& $&.



- & 5 *)*%&

-* (.- +.

-$*% * &.+= )) %"

$ &'



&7*

!$+

*# 7*=

%'

#% $''

%'@ #%

## (&

)*$&#$)

0 (&

%'@ #%

.%'

!$:"

7$"&# 5-&

!$+"'

 5

<+

.6

&&

++ 5"



0&"

$0$&.

*&

%++'

 %()) *

*.(0& %6

*+$"

() &

- *$ #$ @@9;

@@9;

@@9;

@@9;

'
@ (&A



$.-

9;

'
@ (&A



$.-

9;

'
@ (&A



$.-

9;

'
@ (&A



$.-

9;

- - ("- *$ 7%'

&A$

I(0 *$D - - ("- *$ 7%'

&A$

I(0 *$D - - ("- *$ 7%'

&A$

I(0 *$D - - ("- *$ 7%'

&A$

I(0 *$D

(*&

*&%

0 &=

+ &.

.%'

&

%6

"#$%$ &%  &B<+ 3()*0

*# *""

C / "-5

C / "-5

C / "-5

C / "-5

,'

 *$)

- 4* <* =D6 

@ @ 3()*0



,'

 *$)

- 4* <* =D6 

@ @ 3()*0



,'

 *$)

- 4* <* =D6 

@ @ 3()*0



,'

 *$)

- 4* <* =D6 

@ @ 3()*0

 *+$"

() &

%$%6

<%*7"

(*&

*&%

0 &=?

"7 .*

.% %(#-

"$%& +% -$0%+!

*&

7& $!

$0"

!

% 6 &&

++ 5"

0&"

# &

!$*%

(*&

*&%

0 &=?

"7 .%

*&

*+$!'

-$% )*$0 *$+=

*(+

(*&

*&%

0 &=?

"7

&"? * .% %"

*)(

# &

% &

# &

*)("$

"6

%- (+"

$+ <+

*&

-+"

C*0

7'

'/'''

'

97 ';

/ "'

&*'D6 

@

3()*0 *0

7'

'/'''

'

97 ';

/ "'

&*'D6 

@

3()*0 *0

7'

'/'''

'

97 ';

/ "'

&*'D6 

@

3()*0 *0

7'

'/'''

'

97 ';

/ "'

&*'D6 

@

3()*0









3()*0 & * 5 (+"

%(#-

"0$%%$<+ *"$&.

%'

 &%G(&

%6

*7$%$ &

++ 5"

0&"

"$%0$%%"'

&

+% *+$"

() &

- *$  *"$&

&#- 

 "#$""

' '


C

3$&.- ,%'

&A$

3$&.-

-*%D C

3$&.- ,%'

&A$

3$&.-

-*%D C

3$&.- ,%'

&A$

3$&.-

-*%D C

3$&.- ,%'

&A$

3$&.-

-*%D

>


"#$""

>' '


C ."7 3$&.- ,%'

(*%5 3$&.-D C ."7 3$&.- ,%'

(*%5 3$&.-D C ."7 3$&.- ,%'

(*%5 3$&.-D C ."7 3$&.- ,%'

(*%5 3$&.-D'

!(*

+% - )+%%+= +$0$

<+

.6 &&

)*0$

0&"

!

# &%$"*$&.

%6

$ &*?)+

*$.- "$%0$%%"'

>'

 # &%$"*"

*.(0&

"7 &#"

$%

. &

-* (.-

*# *"

*!(++='



*# *"

()$&"*  +6

''
 *# 7*=

%'

#% $''

%'@ #%

## (&

)*$&#$)

0 (&

%'@ #%

.%

%$%

% )*

(%

* %

-$0 5-&

*"

5&

$%'

-* *6 '>'
@ 5-&

""

:#( *"$&.

+!

!$& ++=
>'@'
 5-&

"!&"

*!(%"

*!(&"

0 (&

+ &.

.% %*7$&.

*)+=

$# %*7"

() & -$0 >'@'
'



!(* -+"

!$& ++=

54

. 6 *!(%"

=0&

!$+"'

! *% *+= $&"$#

&$

& *

*&

$7'

 0*+=

*# 7*=

*&%

0 &=

+ &.

.%'


' '


)%

< (

> *% 

0 & -%'

E-*

:#(

*.$%

""

!$*% '>'
@

!$&

' '
@'

5* &.+= $0"

)* ) %"

5$++

&.

%'

% *!**"

< 7

*# 7*=

*&%

0 &=

+ &.

.%

& 5

)* ) %"

-$0%+!

*+$&G($%-"

$&$ ++='

-*! *6 & 5

.6 &&

)*0$

0&"

%++'

! *%

-$0

# &%$"*"

4)$&.

0$&"

)* 7$%$ &% /$0$

# -*! *6  !$&"

! *#

*.(0&

"7 &#"

&

 )(

*+$

- *$ #$


9>;

$7 > 3()*0


9>;

$7 > 3()*0


9>;

$7 > 3()*0


9>;

$7 > 3()*0

C/$!

&%(*  *) *

&"$

,%'

&A7

C/$!

&%(*  *) *

&"$

,%'

&A7

C/$!

&%(*  *) *

&"$

,%'

&A7

C/$!

&%(*  *) *

&"$

,%'

&A7 ($+"*% *$7

/$0$ &*'D

($+"*% *$7

/$0$ &*'D

($+"*% *$7

/$0$ &*'D

($+"*% *$7

/$0$ &*'D

 &B<+ ):

%(00"

()

# &%$"*"

5-$+ +$&.

)* 7$%$ &%

*"$&.

"$&.%'



 '



A(".0&

*(&%

(&"* C9$;



 )*

.

$&%

%(<%G(&

$!

*G($%$

# &"$ $ &%

-* !

$%!$"

!$+"

"$&.%

@ ++% <= &"

)(*7$5'

<$&.



 $%6

-(%6 0$%# &#$7"

-&# &.

$7"'

9$$;

++

++ 5"

&#%% *0$&$&.

G(% # & * 7*%= )* 7$""

" %

(% $&A(% $# )*A("$#

%$"'

-$%

*=6

)) *&

!* 0

(%

5 *"

J%- ++J6

,

'

9$$$;

)* =*

++ 5" 9$;

$!

*G($*"

!!# $7

)* )*

"A("$#

# & * 7*%= 5&

$%6

9$$;

7 $"

0(+ $)+$#$ )* #"$&.%6 )* 7$""

;

" %

*%(+

$&A(% $#

%$"6 9<;

$%

" %

%4

-"*

&=

"0$%%$ &

# &!*%

*$.-

%$"

9#;

" %

$06 *%(+ $&.

"$7% $&.

%$"

+( <+

##*("

*$.-

9$&

%$

$ &%;'

9$7;

 )* =*

.&* ++= *G($*"

++ 5"

(&+%% 9$;

* "(#"6

5 (+"

<# 0%

*+7

# &%$"*

$ &6 9$$;

&.%

9$$$;

)* =*

!$"6 9$7;

%$"

+ %%

+$"

"!&#'

97;

& +$&.

)* =*

"$&.%6

# (*

%- (+"

7 $"

-=)* #-&$#

))* #-6

*"$& *$+= *G($*"

+$<* %)#$ ++=

)) %$

# 0)&%

# % %'

97$;

E-*

5 (+"

<+

# (*

)$&

 "+= # &%$"*

"$%)(

5 (+"

*&"*$&.

0 *

$%!

"#$%$ &6

)* =*

%- (+"

++ 5"'

97$$;

E-*

0*+=

* "(#

""$

&5

))* - (

* "(#$&.

(%

$ &6

+$ <+

++ 5"

7&

:)$*= +$0$

$ &'

97$$$;

0&"0&

A(% $!$ <+=

++ 5"

&""

*# $!=

<%&#

*$ $#(+ *%

9$:;

+

))+=$&.

+ &

.* (&"

"$% ++ 5

)* =*'

E-*

%)#

"+

*.( <+6

)* =*

# (+"

++ 5"

$%%( +$0$

!* 0"

%)

"#$%$ &'

9:;

E-*

&.%

(%

$ &6

()

$*+= &5 %6 ! *$.&

()

0(%

"$% ++ 5"'

E-*6 - 57*6

&+= *%)#

)*"$#

+* "= ""

*"$& *$+=

*G($*"

++ 5"'

9:$;

E-*

<! * # 00&#0&

*$ +6

# (*

*G($*"

+$<*

))* #-'

# (*

*G($*"

0$&"

)) %$

5 (+"

()

% %(#-6

" %

*%(+

$**) <+ )*A("$#

)) %$

=6 "$7%

)) %$

"7

.

%#(*"

*%(+

"0$%%$ &

*G($*"

++ 5"'

G( ++=6

&#%%

# (*

!!# $7+=

"A("$#

$%%(% # & * 7*%= 5&

$%6

%- (+"

++ 5"'D

 & 7$5 0=

! *% "$%#(%%$ &6

*$

*$.- "#+$&"

%%$&.

*"*

 ''


" %

*G($*

&= *!*&#'

-(%

#$7$+ *7$%$ & )*!**"

$ &*?)+

## *"$&.+= "#+$&"'

''

 91  ;

91  ;

91  ;

91  ;

3(&$+ 7$







 E- %) 4$&.?* % &"

%? E- *) *

<+

%?