High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/7627/2016dismissed

Inam Ali v. Harbhajan Kaur

2023-01-27Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan9 pages

#"$ %"&'()$"

* !"

"+,' )'*"-. "'*" +"'"* //// 0" 1-'"'*"2 1 %"&'()$"-+ '"""""+

- "345'"$3''""15'.')$ "'&"$3' *$"5 0'6!$(&4"&" -787 '"""""' 3"*2

-,3( ' "" ''*+ '.3"

$"39:9 '"""""' '* $ '*"'*"*"1+;-<= +3"- >$-< '" '''*'=" $"' * ''"=' *"'."'*"-''&"3 45=''" 1"' 11"?''*$"'*"*"1 ;-<= +3" >$-< '"=''' '*

'*"-'1"7@?"'*$"''*"*"1- ' *" "$ '" '* ." ' " ' " 3"$ ">$"&""$"'*$"* " 1'*"?' '*="$ "*2."3" 77 ' 1" ₹ @2? '$3''&$"' '*="." 1 ="3 1 '3" &$'&"" 1"& '''*= '* ''"=' A' *"2 1 $3' ( ' "*2 ."$3"$-"&3''"""" "'?

1 ' *" &3 3 1 " B $"3" ."$-= = *"

1 ' .3 '" ' " "$"'"" *$"*'*"*"1&1 '3' '*"3'*"-','"* .' '*"'"''">$""'"= $$*&$'"$-$'-' *" ' **"' ' " "- < '" ,3 ( ' "*2 &1 =1 3 ' * >$

-'"***" =""* 1 3'*"3."$ 3 &(-='* & ?'* '=''*="3

"-'"*"$'*"+ -"'"' '*"

B A'"3" * &1'

*"$&&"$ "$&" ' 1"3" ="&='*"?'1 &" A'"*''*"">$"' '* " '" = $ $* 3 ' ' *"&"33"3$ "" " 45'" " ' '" "$"3 $3 ' " 3 ."

-'"**"1" '* 8

' * 3 ' *"- =3 $ =" " C''"'*" & &(" $*"*"1 *"1"&1'*"D !! C''"'*"* & D !

C''"'* '="3D ! 8 ; 0''*" ."*'" $"3'$".'*"-5'.' )$ "- "1 *" 3 ' "" !C $& 3'.6:!C2='''"*'' '*"3.'*%*"."" *1 *=""1 6:!-"*1 7@6:!-"3" 776:!

-* 6:!8-"6:!;***"6:!6:! A'=: &1'*"'**&!C -%0"'- -< '"-='&"$3''"3 ""='"3""3" 7;7@-

8 *".3"*16:!C2A'* $"'": !C 5(.)$ "5'"

-"$3' -+=$"-< '"-=' *". * 6:!8 3 ' ' ' *"*" ' ".3'* C'''.'*"3 $

"&$ -<. '"***"C ".'.6:C2='''$**" ''"* " ** 3' = ""C$& 3'.6:C2 ='''"*''3.'=""* 1 *"."""*6:6:@ -&,.$'"6:@8 6:@A'""-'.'"* $ "'*"". " *1( "" 9%"&'()$"#E$"*53'96:!F '"&$ .'*" "'"3"3$ - "" "-< '"

.($3 2""87$+ .$"

'*"3'"*-='"$+= .$"'*"$ 1-'*=* '"*=""&(" ' '* "3' '."'.*'"'*" ='*"= '" '""- 3=''-' *"=$ & ,*='' $"

; A'"" '"*233".'' **"''$"&1=1 3'*"".*- *"13'' &*-'( ""*3'

&1'" "-< '"&'*>$ & @ +'".*=3.'"*- =''*$**"'"$3'$ " "&$$&>$ 1$' $ ***$3**"5'".*'** &>$ " 3'1"- *""

'"3$ "'*"33'"$3''"" 7

''" '* "&= '*" '$3''"*2 '= " 1"3" =:$&='*"- &$'*"'$$ 1 *".' $' 3" 77',* &=' A'*"2 1 '&"$3''( *=3"$-"&3"* &3""""= "'-=" 1 ='"3"'*" 13''="$"

" 45='"'*$3$**" 1 =

1 A' '"$'*"='3"$ G" ' !C -%0"'- -< '"- ='&"$3''"3 "" +7;7@ *".3"*16:!C2- $''*"

'*$"''*"*"1-=''' '*"

*".

'$ &$

1"&" 3'( *A *".'"$+ -!C"1'*"'* ""***"6:!6:!'=3'*" + ."&1'5 'A'"* **"3C33"=''"*"+ " +."&$ '"3"'& '$3'&( '&"&' '"*'' '*' & *"*" 1 "& &$ ' " "- < '" " "3'* 3'*".&"$3'"" '"3' 1 $''* *".""&1'*" 6:!

8*'""&$"'$ * C'"3"'3"$*" 1* &1 ' *"- '" "1 .' )$ " **"3 !C ' "*'''*"'* '$3''"*2' **"3C'" <. **"3C'.$'3"$&3. & '*"&$'" "$ ,31' '*"='"3"$'3"$&3. & ' *"2 1 A' " "- < '" . $*"+'""" 13$*'($3 * &1'$"= &1'*:$"'"3' 1&".'$' 3"$*".&.

H" $ " ' ". *"2 ' ''" "'**"''' *"2 1 = '" 3""$"

1 .?$"'"

"''3'$3.* ' '"'$&(3''*-=''$ "$'$."'"G$"'"

"-''3&3'$' . 3"03 %=."- '&. "A' " "-< '""" ' ' $'' ">$" *"2 1& '&' ." *"& 33 -='' 3""3$" '"1$3" 3'." ""$"'"

'" *'"" 3 '"A'""-$ &$='$'"*"2 1"$" ' "*3*'"" 3 '"&1"$3'$' *"*"1& 33'"G$"'"

"-"'*"2 1 '"">$" ='"'="$'$ "'"""*2&1.'"' "3"A''''$&'*"=(3 * ='"'$&"$*"'3&3'$ . 3"03 , "A''$&'*" 1& = 3"$'$'* & 33' *"

&,">$'"'$&""$'* & 33' 3'"=*"*"1 "' *"=''"'"'"'$ >$

@ .31'$. 3"03 3&1' ".*" 8 '"'&*$"="&1 "$ "'".*"''" "'"' '*>$

" *"*"1" '$ &"$

" *"*"1='$33'3 $" =" "$'"A'&( ='$

"+$'&('='.&"&"' " ". '"3"A'""-'"3$ &* ; H"$ "'".*"'"""

&1 53 <$3'$"='"=&".'='"*" " &$ 3."'* $-' = ='" &$ 3.* "*" $"5 & %=."-"

' " &.- ' ($3 ' * ' ".*"1 " C'"3"':($3 ! "

#"$

$&'

(&1 53 <$3'$"-'($3 ' *'". *"1 "$'""$ '':=''$'&".'& *"''$'"1' "=="=" *"*" - ='" '" $' 3 " '" " '

7 .'& &1"**".'G$"'" "-*"

($3 >$-$'3"$=$&$"3"3 .='"3" & 1'".*" C'"'-'" ""'* '*

"$& &1'$ "'". =''*" 1'3( ""3'"

-='''&,"&1 " " " 1& '&,"'' 1""$' " '*A'""- '"33.3'"'*" '" '"1>$' '* @ A'""*&1'" "-< '" = "='$'"&31 "&""A' $&$"3" 1 3 1""

1 $'

**"'A'". ($"'$" >$ "3'"$ '- '" " "" =' ' *$3 "" &1 =1 :"3'". ($" 7 A'".* "3 1 5 ' ". * - '

$** -1-*"3 1

0"(

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#