← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1654/2007dismissed

Jai Lal v. Rajender And ORS.

2022-11-24Mr. Justice N.S. Shekhawat12 pages

      

  ! "# $%&'((

)* %+ ,-!-%&' ((

  

 

     

%"). '%&/01 "( 2!*-, ((3 43)5)*       

 !   

" 

 #  

"  

$   

 % &

   '#(  

"  

) *** ((3 43)5)* ( +  



  "

  





 ",



%-$$%../   

 '

  01 +(2 45 5   

$ &5   ,

" 

)./6)&"

 8

2 0 "

 "

 97829"

3 + 17

5 

 

 '6  

"  !5 

5 

" 

  5   :





  ! 5  

5   '  !

 2 5      

 5   

  

5

  '  ;

 %..% 55

     '   '6    '    

 "  8 5  



  1

' ' 5

 

2  2

" " "% /.

...6<+  5   '   '     

$&$.%..%+ "

 

5"  .=$$%..%  

: ;"" 2    , 5   

     ' '6'  

'   

'

' '6' '  

' '6 ' '  1

' ' 5

 

&%.

&/> &/- &/?

&-$ )>&

$%.<4 )&"782  "

 '  "  



      ;

   $-$$%.%%   (



 

5 

 



5  +  

5 "  '6  '     ' 5  " 



  :

  "  '  

 

  " +  



 



5

  5  

5 (   ( 

    "   

  5   :

 

"         @  

  "  ' 5

(

 "  5   "

 

  "

5

     

  ;

"

 

AB82 17

)./ )& $.?"7825 

  

6 

6 "

 

"



"  

$-)2825 

  2 " 

  



5   2 "   5    



  

 +  5

 <



)./ )&782 #   

  

  

    '

  01 + 2 45         "     5"    

    5   ,

2   

2    

"% /.

...6<5  "  

     " 

 

 " (  

" 7 5   

 ""

   5    (

 

5"    5 5 " 

 5   ""

 

7 5  

   (

         " 

  "       

  +  5



 " 5

(";

 %..%    

 

$-6$>$$%.%% "



"



"  

2 "  

5

B

"  ' 

 



  " 

  

 

         '             

 

  "  

  

 + 

      ( 

 (

"

  "

     

    +  ' 



"  

"  

  "  5

   ("  "



 + 

2 "   5



" 5 

 5 "

5      

 A



  

 "



" 

"

"  

 

5



 5  

"

A

5 (82

 "   (

"  " 

 55 "    



  A

   

  5 (825 "   (

" 

" 

  5 5 " 5

 

   " , 

":  "    " 2



 

",

  

2  

  "









",

  "  +  

  "



 " 2

)->0&3"282

  5"  

)->0&32825   

  5 

  

  "           

B     

%-$.%..?

 

5     

7  , 

 '   

% '  

&

B  

"  " 2 

 7   

 "    5  



C7 



 "   



   "  

 $ )      

" 2 17

5 

 $>$$%..%  



"

,

    

        

    2    %-$$%../C ,

   

        "       



",

  

 '

  01

+ 2 45 

)->0&3282 

 "

 

 

   '

)-%282 5 

 



 "  ,

5

5 ")$$%%..?   

 + 

5   



%..>

  " " 

 2

D

   "

""DE

 

 

5"B  )$$%%..?  DE

" 2 ,

   

 "  2  

 "  

   

5 5 "4

" 2 

   

  !"# F 

"

: G ' 

2 H$% & "'($)*+ , " #  (#(, "$- ' "%"# ./ 0)1+ ) $ $"+0 +      

 "  



   

 " 

 

5"    

)->0&3282 5



 " 2 2

II7I"2 "2  8 

$?-)  5  '

)-%    )$$%%..? "5<      5    <  

"  

 "  2

   "  2   5"  " F '

"

)->282

  5<  ,,$"! !2 $        

            !

"

 #  $% &'"  '

"    () (     )   *   &     +)  '  $%      %,)   ))   -

   .& &'"  '

"    ()

(     )   /% * &  %)  ))    +)  ' ' *    /% *  %    *)

0      +)  '  *    0 1       +)    '

         % '  #)  ) ()  2)&    #)  ) ()  2)& 3 "

!  "  ' '

 % ' &  & %       ' *) 3     *"

 *) .& &'"       

   " )    () (     )



  *  " &     +)  '  $%      %,)  

))   -

   /% * &  %)  ))     +)  ' ' *    /% *

 %    ) 0     +)  '  *    0

 7 )   /% *    

 

 

))   8    )   /% *

1       +)    '

   &)   /% *"   )  &   '  &)   ) " %  ) )  ) &     +)"  &) &'

    )   /% *

!

7 )        %   ) )  ) &     +) ))   '  /% *    8'  8 &"   &)   ) "  8' '  '  "

& &       +)

1 "  '

"  )        %   ) )  ) &     +)   "  ) &     +) )) )    

    

9 8 

"'

)-%282 $?-)  

    "  7  '

 + 5

 

5

  "

 A   ""

5

 ""





  5 



  

 7

7 

 

  (  

"

    2 

$=/"

282 $?-) "  

%.."282



"'

$=/282  

 

 

    2

II7I"2 "2  8 

$?-) 5 

  +       

  "  ,

    

   

  "'

)->"282 

0$3")->282 

   



   

 

88   " '

0%3"'

)->"282 5  





'

8 A 



$?&/  2

D

 

     "  '

0)3"'

)->282  :2  '

0$3'

0%3

5  " 2 '

0&3 5 

"  

 ",

    

   

:2

      

 "



   " 

 ",

 '

" '

0=3   "   " "

"

"   

 "'

0&3 '

0/3      "    "  



0&3 "

 " 

 ",

 '

0$3 '

0%3 7

 5 282

  

   



'

"  ,

 





8 5

 "  55   " 17 + 

 5  

5

 

" 

)->0&3"282"



(      :2   

 6 

'

  "  

",

+   5

" " J  G    '

)-%"

2

2 "2  8  0

 3%..> '

$03" 

  

H 

"



 2

D

   " "" DE

 

C ""



   

"""

   "  F'

"

%?" 



%..>

"'

)-%" 2

 H

)-%"

8  

"5   

<8 

     "

    

2 ,

 

"  ""

    ,





  2 5

    "

"2 F + 2

D

 " ';))$)0A3 

).$%%..?

 

)$$%%..?

 

"  ="%..? 

"

55  DE

"7    8 %03 '

)03 

).$%%..? :



"  B  

"   

      "

  "

 

 "    '

)-% 282   03"  5 5

     2 ,

 

 "   ""

    ,





"

)$$%%..? +

   "'

)-%282

 5"  "

<   7 )  ) )   7 ) )) ) & ' %&     *&) * 8     '  * ' '  )   & %   :

(    & ))   %     ) % '   '  *  +% 

   %   )     &% +

&"    ) )) )   *     ) )' ) %        *0 +    



"

     

B     7

"

5   

  

  '

)-%" 2  

 

 

"  5 ")$$%%..?     "

 

" 

 "   "

    %'

)-%282 "

 

   "

)$$%%..?  5   

   )$$%%..? 2 ,



 

5

 "



   "'

)->0&3282+ : G ' 

2 "7 

    

"H$% & "''($)*+ , "#  (# (, "$- ' "%"# . 0)1+ ) $ $"+0"5< 5 ;  %     ) /% *              &        %  )          *(*"

4 <        ) )%%    =   & &   ) /% *  )         ))%      )    %  ) 1   )"          "   %            +)  '  <) * 1  "            &      )'      +)           # &"

>>4   &   % 

))%   +)" %  ) 1"  %  )' 8  ))%%     +)  )

))%%      

   )     &% + & < )%%     + 8) "   )        8   9 5"   2 "  

5   

       '

 )->0&3  282  "    

 

 

 ",

  

 '

  01 +(2 45 17 $.= 

$>$$%.%%

)./ $.? )&"782   



" 2  

     + 

6 

"     2

%?>/)"%.%%      

)?$282 

 5 '

&>%" 2 "2  8  5    

  

'

   "

 

  



      

  

"    ""

  2    "    5   "

B  " "  +  

(  ((9:

((



   K

 ( 6 

 L K

  

 L