← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/5673/2024dismissed

Nepal v. State Of Haryana

2024-08-28Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger5 pages



      

 

!

"  !

!#$% (%)*+*&, 

------ %$*$*&,%0

1%0+2+ 3$#$% #04#,#

------ %+.&,(%,$   5 6 -

3 3

 0%+%,$  +- 7*0#, 1%08#9 (:&)#$% .%$*$*&,%0-

0- #,(;*0 3*,<;9 ((*$*&,#/ -- #04#,#-

- - 3

9

- ;*+ +%)&,( '*/%( 2,(%0 3%)$*&,

 &(% 0*8*,#/ 0&)%(20% =%;#/'

%.#/ <0#,$

 &-9 - 9 0%<*+$%0%( 2,(%0 3%)$*&,+ 

,(*#, %,#/ &(%9 &/*)% 3$#$*&, #$;*,9 !*+$0*)$ #/>#/- ;% '*0+$

   (*+8*++%( &20$9 - 

,,%?20% - - 2+$&(4 )%0$*'*)#$% -

'*/%( /%#0,%( 3$#$% &20$ $&(#49 $#@%, 0%)&0(9 +2=A%)$ #// A2+$ %?)%.$*&,+-

32))*,)$/49

 0%<*+$%0%( )&8./#*,$ 3;*:

;#0#, +& &+;#, 6#/9 >;%0%*, ;*+ 4&2,<%+$ +&, 8#00*%( (& #, 3*,<;-

, ,*<;$ - 9

(#2<;$%0

 

*,/#> )&8./#*,#,$ $&/( )&8./#*,#,$

>%,$ &2$ ;&2+%



-- (*( ,&$ )&8% =#)@- , - 9



--9 :*//#<%0+9 ,#8%/49 A#49 >;& <&%+ A&<<*,<B )#8% ;&2+% )&8./#*,#,$ $&/( ;*8 +#>

/4*,< 2,)&,+)*&2+ ,%#0 $#.

)/&+% 8#,( '*%/(+ #(A&*,*,<

0&#( <&*,< '0&8 1*//#<%

#*,.20- A#4

:*//#<%0 +./#+;%( >#$%0 '#)%

+&, )&8./#*,#,$ =2$ (*( ,&$ 0%+.&,(- ;%0%#'$%09 )&8./#*,#,$ #/&,<

,%.;%> )&8./#*,#,$ >%,$ +.&$ '&2,(

/4*,< (%#( 8#,(- 8#0@+ +$0#,<2/#$*&, ,%)@ &$;%0 *,A204 8#0@+ =&(4

6%#0,%( +2=8*$+ ,&$ ,#8%(

 '#/+%/4 *8./*)#$%( =#+*+ )#// (%$#*/+ %?);#,<%( =%$>%%, )&#))2+%(*,@*

>*'% (%)%#+%( #//%<*,< *//*)*$ 0%/#$*&,+;*.

=%$>%%, $;%86%#0,%( +2=8*$+ ;#( ,& #''#*0 )&#))2+%(*,@*

>*'% (%)%#+%(- ,& +.%)*'*) *,A204 #$$0*=2$%( ,&$;*,< 0%)&:%0%( '0&8 ;*8-

+2=8*$$%( ;#:% ,&$ +2..&0$%(

*,@* #/0%#(4 <0#,$%( )&,)%++*&, - .#++%( &&0(*,#$% %,);

&20$- ,%?$ +2=8*$$%( )2+$&(4 - B *,:%+$*<#$*&, )&8./%$%B );#//#, .0%+%,$%( - -  );#0<%+ ;#:% '0#8%(

- $#@% /&,< $*8% ,& 2+%'2/ .20.&+%



>&2/( =% +%0:%( @%%.*,< ;*8 =%;*,( =#0+ #,4 '20$;%0- ))&0(*,</49 .0#4%0 8#(% <0#,$ .%$*$*&,%0- - %0 )&,$0#9 6%#0,%( 3$#$% &..&+%+ ./%# <0#,$ <0&2,( +%0*&2+,%++ <0#:*$4 &''%,)%- +2=8*$$%( (20*,< *,:%+$*<#$*&, )#+%9 8&=*/% .;&,%

*,@* .2$ *,$%0)%.$*&, +;% '&2,( =% )&,:%0+*,<

.%$*$*&,%0 820(%0

$;%86%#0,%( 3$#$% +2=8*$$%( 0%)&0(*,< )&,:%0+#$*&, &=$#*,%( )#// (%$#*/ 0%)&0(+ 8&=*/% 8&=*/% .%$*$*&,%09 &=$#*,%( +)02$*,*C%( '&2,( =&$;

$;%8 )&,$*,2&2+/4 $#/@*,< %#);

&$;%09 (20*,< $*8% )0*8% .&+$ )0*8% #/+&- +2=8*$$%( ;#( +2''%0%( (*+)/&+20% +$#$%8%,$ #(8*$$*,< ;#:% )&88*$$%( 820(%0

;%/.

*,@*- )&,$%,(%( .20+2#,)% +#*( (*+)/&+20%9 <&$ 0%)&:%0%( +)#0'

(2.#$$# >;*);

2+%( +$0#,<2/#$% (%)%#+%( +2=8*$$%( %,/#0<%( $;%, 8#4 *,'/2%,)% &0 8#4 %:%, #=+)&,( +& #+ (%/#4 )&,)/2+*&, $0*#/- +2=8*$$%( .0&<0%++*,< =% )&,)/2(%( +;&0$/4- ))&0(*,</49 .0#4%0 (*+8*++#/ 8#(%- - , *,+$#,$ )#+%9 #, #))2+%( +%0*&2+9 <0#:% ;%*,&2+ &''%,)% 820(%0

+&, )&8./#*,#,$- + .%0 .0&+%)2$*&,9

;#:% 820(%0%( )&,+.*0#)4

>*'%

#<=*0- /$;&2<;9 ,& %4% >*$,%++ #//%<%( )0*8%B ;&>%:%09 .0*8# '#)*%9 +2''*)*%,$ 8#$%0*#/%:*(%,)% +;&> )&8./*)*$4 )0*8% '&08 )#// (%$#*/

0%)&0(+ 8&=*/% .;&,% *,@*-

20$;%0 0%)&0(*,< )&,:%0+#$*&, =%$>%%, *,@*9 >;*);

*,$%0)%.$%( ,:%+$*<#$*,< <%,)4B >;%0%*, #0% =% $#/@*,< 820(%0

- %0%/4 =%)#2+% 0%+$+ )*0)28+$#,$*#/ %:*(%,)%9 +#8% )#,,&$ =% +&/% <0&2,( 0%/%#+% *'

(20*,< )&20+% *,:%+$*<#$*&,9 +2''*)*%,$ %:*(%,)%8#$%0*#/ )&//%)$%( .0*8# '#)*% )&8./%$% );#*, %:%,$+ %+$#=/*+;%(-

- &,D=/% .%?

&20$       

    9

  3  &=+%0:%( >;*/% (%)*(*,< #../*)#$*&, 2,(%0 3%)$*&,

 &(% 0*8*,#/ 0&)%(20%9 *<;

&20$ &0 8#$$%09 3%++*&,+ &20$B >&2/( ,&$ /#2,);

2.&, (%$#*/%( %:#/2#$*&, '#)$+ 8%0*$+ )0*8*,#/ +$*// $#@% ./#)%- &=+%0:%( &2$)&8% #../*)#$*&, +*<,*'*)#,$ =%#0*,< /*=%0$4 #))2+%( ;#,( #+ >%// #+ .2=/*) *,$%0%+$ (2% %,'&0)%8%,$ )0*8*,#/ A2+$*)% &$;%0 0*<;$+ :*)$*8+ $;%*0 '#8*/*%+ #0% +$#@% #+ >%//-

-

20$;%09   

         

 

 !  "

 

0*8*,#/  &,5=/% .%?

&20$ ;%/( 8%0% '#)$ #))2+%( 2,(%0<&,% )%0$#*, .%0*&( *,)#0)%0#$*&,9 *$+%/'

>&2/( ,&$ %,$*$/% #))2+%( =% %,/#0<%( =#*/9 ,&0 '#)$ ,&$ =% )&,)/2(%(9 ,%#0 '2$20% %*$;%0 *$+%/'

&0 )&2./%( .%0*&( *,)#0)%0#$*&, >&2/( =% +2''*)*%,$ %,/#0<*,< #..%//#,$ >;%, <0#:*$4 &''%,)% #//%<%( +%:%0% #0% #//%<#$*&,+ $#8.%0*,< #))2+%( (20*,< .%0*&( =#*/-



7%%.*,< :*%> #'&0%8%,$*&,%( '#)$+ )*0)28+$#,)%+9 (*+8*++%(B ;&>%:%09 )&,+*(%0*,< '#)$ )2+$&(4 -  >;*/% (*+8*++*,< '*0+$ #../*)#$*&, *-%-  

- 9 (*0%)$*&, #/0%#(4 *++2%( )&20$ %?.%(*$% $0*#/B $;%0%'&0%9  (%%8 #..0&.0*#$% (*0%)$ )&20$ )&,)/2(% >*$;*, .%0*&(  8&,$;+ '0&8 ,%?$ (#$% '*?%( =%'&0% )&20$- - %,(*,< #../*)#$*&,+9 *'

#,49 +;#// +$#,( (*+.&+%( &'- %<*+$04 (*0%)$%( +%,( )&.4 )&20$9 )&8./*#,)%-

3



!

+A@+ E;%$;%0 +.%#@*,<0%#+&,%(

 "%+



& E;%$;%0 0%.&0$#=/%  "%+ 

&