Barinder Singh And ANR v. Avtar Singh And ANR
! "
# !"#$%&'" #
%'(
$ % & '()"
* + # % !#)"
* + #
,,, -./ " # 0 #+ 01 # 23 23.5 # 01 ( "( ! 6 " 7) 8) * #!) " '* (
8 * 9*
2:
23.: + 0!
( !; .3 23.5# 01 ("(! 6 " 7) 8) * #)"'* ##(* +(+ *(( 23 23.5' ( ; -2/
! (
* '
!(
#( +( ! + #; =!* ) + + ; ;
( * 1
!* ! + ! # # 1 ' #(
++ ( ! >! # #( ++
+ ; #*+!(# + ;* !
( ! ' +( .?
3@ 23.?
'* '
; ' +( 01 + 2.
3.
23.:
+ +( '
; ) ##(* ' +( 3A 23.? + ## ; + B 01 +
#1' (( '" 2:
23.: ! ' ( +; ; 1 ## B ' ";#(; + # + ; (" ;'() #( * *(! "* *( ; 3C 3?
+ ( *( "* .4 3A -?/ + ) + " +( ##(* + ( ("* .5 3C 23.5'*' (( '01
( " 2:
0 +
0=* 01 #( #(* * (01; + ("* ++
0!
+* !; + ("*(01 + ) * ' +D+ 0!
("*6+17 + !;
-:/ ( " 23 23.5* 0!
("* ' # = ;
# ) B '* ' ## 2:
23.: ' 8
* * B *(
"
+( # ) 1
*' !
!0; ) + )
*' !
! ()"
*
"
!0; #
-A/ 23 23.5 # 01 ( "( ! 6 " 7) 8) #( +(##(* + *(( #; + * *(! +"*01
) * ' +D + !;
" !; ' 01 #* "(* # * 1 #( ; #
2 ? ##(*
+ (( '++* $E
!
"
# $
# % &
' &
' &
# % &
(
' &
&
)
' &
' &
+ -@/ #(1
+ # ##(* + *(( 23 23.5)+ +( + (( ' #(1$E ,-
!.
-! $ ' &
& ( ( (
($ $
/ 0 $ #
1 !
2
34
&,& $
5
6 &$
' &
+ -C/
! ( + #(101 + '
!( * + #
2 " 0 ;
; >! ' + * *(! "*
) * ' +D+ "*"!; ' 01(* + +* "0;
01 + #
2 #(1 #(1
#
?) 0 * 01 + B ' ## 2:
23.:!
" * )+ * !(
0#01 +
-5/ ##(* ' =* 01 ( " ;#! .3 23.5 * ' = !
23.5+ ' # -4/ ' ((
" !
*
"(
2?
23.5+ + "
2C #1 + #(* * 01 ( * ! ( + #( '
!(
! (
' ! 2?
23.5) 0!
; ' # * 2A +#
.
; ' *" 3A ..
23.5 # ( #
++*## #
* B ((
" #* #
2C 23.5 " 24 +( 0=*
+ # +B 01(( *( !0;
( ;1 # ' !
"
#1' ;
#
-.3/ " * !0; ; 01 ( -../
* ## 01
*(
'# * #( ' ** + #(
" 1 + ; " B
*' (1 "!# ; 3A ..
; (
* '
!( + * *(!"* +0
# *(! ("*+(01 + ) * ' ( + !; +* ) ;' ! 01(* 0
' ;
01 + #(1
##(* + *(( 23.5) + ) ' ** + (
;#(; 2:
23.:+ # +;
:1 + *
!0; #
+ D* ;1* # '
!(;
!
((* "*+ # 1
'0
# (1 * *(! "* ;
' " ! # 0+ (
! "*'* 0(( '01 ( + ; + B ' "
; 0( "* #*#( + !(=!
* B (((1 ! (
2?
#( + "
#
2C 23.5) 0!
(
' # * (1 2A 23.5' *" 01 #( (1 3A ..
23.5 + (( " 2C -.2/ "' + # +* * ) ' * 1+ (
8
"
" # '0
(1 *(! "* " ! * #
" D#( # ' =
; ' (((1 * 23 23.5 01 (
8* 9* 2:
23.: + # + ;
: 1 ' * 1
*
"
!0; # !* ' (1 !;
0 01 ( * '
0# !*
0 +"*(01 -.?/
* 0 ") " # (( ' ;#! 23 23.5 23.5 # 01 ( "( ! 6 " 7) 8) * #!01 ( *
# *' * ** *' (' !; * * ' !
8
*( #
%'( #$(" ..
.2
* F <#8 < F # 0( <