High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1050/2004allowed

Nirbhai Singh v. State Of Punjab

2018-09-18Mr Justice Jaswant Singh5 pages

!"# $# %%&& '!( )( *"

% ,,,, )!

! #-.&/+0!#%%&& ! 1#&2#%!/++ &-)( *" ,,,,

".3.+4 ++!"! $

#" %+ #% !+. (!

. # 44 !+!

#&&"+%+% ( 0&0+ "## %%&!4&! 6!"!0./!" $7!+!4

8 # %%&/%%&& #:( +#*(+$4

++ 8

%+ 4%& ; 5< 4%&

= ++8

". %&>(+$/?#!%(! @!

+( &!#%%&& ("4+#%%&& 3 %% + # )!+( ! 3# A ( 1 #4& @4+ 9 3 ("4+ # %%&& B %% 4 # )!+( !3 %%!0+".#4% (#!.C#(/# (&+ "+$ +#)!+( !@!

+( &!

#%%&& (!#!("4+#!% %!4 #0&&+ 4%& !& $ $& (%! )#%# !4 A '*. C!+ $ 4% .C#!+434 ((!+".A( 1#4& @4+/ # + C#!% %!4 ( +# )#%#%!+( 3 !+ 3##%!!"+ +!+ +3(" +!+ :( &./4%& 3!$!+( +!

#$ +&(" #+(&;9)!!+3#&( #6!&!

(+( +! 8 #< &44+/)( #"&( +! 5# <

%%&& #" +( +!$ 4%! 4 ! %!+ .! + %. /

+( &!#%%&& ("4+#4!(&&.

0!+".+ #(!%+

!%!+

!@!

+( &!#%%&& ("4+#%%&& B%% 4 !+ 3#&33## 0+ !4*(+&%! ( 4 "#$$% %$&$% +++ 8 5 &+ '(

" )*

)

93(!#!("4+##! 4%& (& + #+(&;99#6!&! !&!+!/

/(#!# &.&#4!%!# " 74 + +!

# ! 4 3!+ B!&!B 3 !%!+ ( +! # < & 44+ #.!

=".4 #< &44+ 4 +4 /

= +3&("4+#4 ((!!# $& (%!)#%#/ 4&./A( 1#4&@4+# " 4%&++!1 $ !& $%!+( (" +!+ $& (%!)#%#

/&!

+( &!# !% 3#& ! $#%%&& B ("4+##!4%& (& + #+(&99#6!&!

# 7 1 $#4%& $& (%!)#%# +1% #1 $($+%&.# "$3## !+ 3##!+%!0 93(!#!("4+#(#! &.&#4!%!# "

74 + #4!"(&#+%!4 3!74 +9 3&("4+#+ 3!+B!&!B3 !%!+".

++ 8 53#&7! $%3!( +!("&(D9 &( #<

93(!#! ++#( +! 8#< & 44+ /

/ # 6!&! !& !+!/

3 !+(+ #+(&#!+!/

4 5!& )#%#3##3 !+(+ 8

4(#%!!#+ " $4%&!& $ $& (%!)#%# 5 5 !%0C#!!/#%%&& B # B!&!B3 !%!+!#!4 #.!

=4. #&+ $+ +%! 4!+ $(#"&3#!! ++ = ?!+#&!

+( &!#%!

5 )!(&#!!+/0+ ##!4%& (& + #+(&99#6!&!

! !$4%& #1$($+%&.# "$E6!&!4F3 &(++ 3. "1 8 5 ". 4 3#& 7! $%3!( +!("&(D9&( # <

!+3##6!&! !&!+!/

!+ 3# # ++ 8

4 53## (.#B!&!B3 &(++".4 !+! !4#< &44+%!0 6!#! 4 B!&!B !%!+ ". 4 < & 44+ 4 +4 /

= G#! &( B!&!B3 0$( !4 8 5&&

=3 !".4 +!+!

3## ! !+ 3# # < & 44+ /

C#!!/%%&& B #B!&!B#" &(++!# !4 #.!

=".4 4 +4 + #&+$+ C##! #%%&& 3## +%(+".#&!

+ ( & ! # / 4&./ 74 (#! &.& #4!%!H &!%! &.&#474 + +! 74 +/ .!& # &.&#4!%!3(&+0(!#! %!+ $9 #!$!+/ (%!4(! # "

-")) *

& .-"/& .

!%!+ 00122 %"" %! #&+#(#!#+(4 !:(!+" 74 + +!74 +& $3##0&(#+(4

"1 +! &. #!# 74 (#! &.&#4!%! $#%%&& 3(&+"&"& "+C##! #%%&& !& $(

#%%&& &1%% $#4#)!+( !3### " %!0+".#4% (#!. +:( 1 $ .

$ #%%&& !(" +!+%!+( )#%#3#A( 1#4&@4+4. " !.!

++ $#%! %%&#0 $!$!+## + #!# 74 &.&#4%%&& :(+##!$ &" + +(!." +(!

#+".# %%&& ++#!$+

%%& +&&3+

!"#$%&'$% ( )* G##!%1 $A! + IA G##!%!"& IA