High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/7922/2011allowed

Gurmail Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2017-02-16Mr. Justice T.H.B. Chalapathi12 pages

!" #"$%&%'( )

*+, %-.%'/0 "!%!%'"+ 1& *'2 3.! !" '#!0"+& "&4'#"'!&

*4.%'/0 "!%!%'"+ 1& *'2 3.! !" '#!0"+& "&4'#"'!& 565

7+ .%'/0 '#!0"+& "!%!%'"+& 1& *'2 3.! !" '#!0"+& "&4'#"'!& 8658

*+#"9.%'/0 '# '!0"+ "!%!%'"+& 1& *'2 3.! !" '#!0"+& "&4'#"'!&

( :

;. .< . ;=

! !

" # $ % &&&&&&& .< . ;=> ; '

(

" )*## #+,, - .

0 (

" )*#* #+,, -

0 (

" )1%, #+,, -2

0 (

" )1%3 #+,, -

(

" )*## #+,, - .

0 5

- 7 8 0 .

9 . 9 4 ##) ( :

. " . '

; 4 < .

,%# +, / 7 7

; = .4

5 ( :9 " # #) +> ,*)1 < < ; (

,1 < ; ,1*3 -? ?

0 ( #1 +, ,*1,

>>>@9 .

A,BC <9 ( 4

5 " 31% ,*1, . . . ; ' . ,% +% ,**+

. . .

>>>@9

)3B@9 '

4 .

#%-#0

9 +B +> ,**+ 7 8

' 4 7. 5 ( : -?5(:?

,> +1 ,**+ .

,1 +* ,**+ ' .9 @ . .

,, +B ,**, .

! "

! # " $

%&'(

" )*' !

! "

! , ! +

$ -! .%/.0 1 2!3 2! 4

( $( %&' !!

!( ! ,

! ! # "

" " %56)

%56) - 7 8 (

( - ))*6)9 5 .9 @ . " ,3)>9(:

,**,

,B# ,B%

,B, ( (

5 " 31% ,*1, D

.@ ,% +% ,**+ ,, +B ,**,

( .9

(

" ##,, +* +) ,**,

-6 9#0 / +% +% ,**# ( " ,3)>9(:

,**,

5 " 31% ,*1, 4

4 D +% +% ,**# ( #1 +% ,**# .:%)66.

! $ " " +

$ %%6.

.6;6. , - 7 29

+% +1 ,**>

4 .

' +% +1 ,**>

< -

! , !

.)* =(

- 7 2 %:659 : . #1 +% ,**#

+% +1 ,**> ( " ,33)>9(:

,**,

5 " 31% ,*1, . . +% ,, #++) -6 9%0 $

! $,

! $ + -

? " 8 - /

0( , !

) !

, ,"

! ,

, -! )*.

2! !(

$ !

$ #

! !

! ! #

! ! $ # !

$ ( ,! ,

! !(

$ @

(

$ ! !

! , $

( !

$" ,

! ,

%( )66) !

=! )%( )66& 2 = .*7 )66& A2 < )5.) )6:& 8 -

B - ! " !

! !

! ( ,

! , "

( ,$(

! , ,

! !(

! " !

" 7

! ( "

" "

! $(

+% ,, #++) -6 9%0 ( 9@ 6 93 #> +3 #++1 : -6 930 9 D

. * $

! "

C( ! ,

2 ! +

( >!

$ +

! - = -( 2 -

( >!

! ! < , $ " +

( >!

9 .9 @5(:

4 .

,, +B ,**, 4 .9 @5(:

. :

( 9@ . +B +B #+,+ -6 9B0 ..

,B +B #+,+

6 ..

.:;)& - 7 2 )**)&9 4

#1 +) #+,+

-( !$ ! 2 $ !

)):)& - 7 2 .:;)&9 (

4 6 .9 ..

,, +1 #+,+

! = 1 B

.&&& /)0 1A .;6 >!

! # !

). "

! >!

, , ! " /" !

"0 , # $ ,

" " "

$ $ , !D ! # "

! A

" >!

%&:)& - 7 2 )):)&9

,, +1 #+,+ .

. +) +* #+,, -6 9,0

E . .9 @5(:

. : 4 4

. ; :

4 .

4 4 :

4 . .

.4 . .

+% ,, #++) -6 9%0 .

. .9 @5(: ( " ,3)>9(:

,**,

5 " 31% ,*1, #> +3 #++1 -6 930 9 @ . : ,%> <.

. .4

,, +B ,**, 4 . 4 .9 5(:@ .9 . #1 +% ,**#

4 +% +% ,**# ( +% +1 ,**>

,B +B #+,+ #1 +) #+,+

4 ,, +1 #+,+

. +) +* #+,,

4 4 . . 4

4 . .4

+% ,, #++) . D -6 930

. : . 7 8 .4 D .

. ' . 4 9

. 4 . . 4 ,B 4 .

+% +% ,**# +% ,, #++) : 9 . E .9 @5(:

4 .

,, +B ,**, .9 . . F .9 @5(:

. ( " ,3)>9(:

,**,

5 " 31% ,*1, . +% ,, #++) -6 9%0

. 4 < .9 @5(:

. 4 .

4 . 8 .9 @5(:

9 .

@ ' 4 .95(:@ .9 . 4

. . @ " .

(

. . .

4 4 ' 9 4 . 4

(;4

. 9 ; 4 D 4 ,*)1

.D 64

4 . @ .< . ;=A ,> +# #+,) $

E D @ G@" E G@"