High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/5494/2021dismissed

Parvinder Singh v. State Of Ut Chd

2021-02-05Mr. Justice B.S. Walia6 pages

!"#"$%

&'"$( &)"$*+ , ""$ & - &#.# + &+ , #/$( $

& # $% #"#+ 0('!

&+ / ""$ & &.$!++"0.12"!&# !.&0 0 + &+3"+ &$./ 4 $# 20('!

555

# "# 1 "$* 6 $ ./ & + &"$* +&.*+ -"( $ & $!"$*(. '"(/ $( 4"!

& 7 &"$+ # !$(/ ""$.$( &) !"$89 & :"&# / ""$3 #("#4"## ( #3"+(& 3$3"+2"1 &7"2 & #+/ ""$ 3"+1 &/ &"!.2 &#;"#&*& $ &71 "2"$!

(

& *"# & ( .$( & ) !"$

2"! ) "$0 ) !&0 + &+ 8 &" !# + !

& + + & 4 $"$ ( 3 & *"# & ($+ !4/2 "$$( &<")"$*+$+ 22 * "$#+ + / ""$ & + ( "$(.! ( +"4 $( +"# & 2 "' #0 +./"$( & )"$*+ $ )"$*+ / 7 +"4 # 9 2 !# $ + $! # !.&"$* *' &$4 $ <1 & +./"$( & )"$*+ $( $ )"$*+ 1. ( #/" & ! "/ # 9 2 !#0 + / ""$ & $ "+ & && $* ( 4/274 $ $& & .&$ (+ # "( 4.$

= > ?

&$ ( !.$# 2 !$ $(# + + / ""$ & + # 1 $ "4/2"!

("$+ "$# $!

# 17+ !4/2 $"$!$#/"& !73"+$ -"#+$. $() 7/& ' $+"4&4/.&#."$* !"$ * "$#+ 4 & !' & # @A && !+ ( 17 + 4 &4 + / ""$ & ?

&$ ( .$# 2!$ $(#+ + / ""$ &+ (4 ( !4/2 "$0$$ B.& 8 + ) $"&)./ &"$ $( $2"! 0 + * "$#$ -"#+$.0 B!"# $#/ !&0 0 + &+0 ) 70 $# 12

"23 7 2"!

&! ( 7/ 2&!44""$*& .(+ .$ # &@A2 !# $+ /& B# !.&"$**' &$4 $ 4/274 $& #/"& $#"$+ &7 $ $($& .&$"$*# "(4$ 7+ / ""$ & $ 12 +"4& .&$+ # 4 # "( #/"& $#$+ "&$# !.&"$**' &$4 $ <1#&# "( #/"& $# / &.# 2 + !4/2 "$0 $$ B.& 8 4 ( 17 + / ""$ && '

2#+ + 3+"2 3&6"$* # !+ &"$' &$4 $ ( 2 ) $"& ) !$( &7 )!+20 ) !& 0 + &+ "$ + 7 &

@0!

4 "$!$ !3"+$ ) 70 $# 12 "$+

"23 72"!

&! 0 41 $ 3+ ("#!2# ( +"4 + +"# !.#"$ $ 4 27 -"#+$.0 3&6"$* $ B!"# $#/ !& 3 # + '"$* 2"$6# 3"+ +"*+ "!"

2#0"$!2.("$*"$"# &#"$+ ) #.$< 10 &7 $ $( 2+"0 + + 22"$+ & / $(4 -"#+$.3+2(+"4+ + !.2(* / &#$# & !&." ( "$ *' &$4 $ # &'"! "$ + ) &7 $ $

!!.$ +"# +"*+ 2"$6# + & ./$0 + / ""$ & "$ &( & 4 6 4$ 7 !

4 "$ !$ ! 3"+ '

&".# / &#$# ( #"&.# # !.&"$* *' &$4 $# &'"! 0$ 4 #3+4 & 4 $"$ ("$/ & *& /+ + !4/2 "$0$$ B.& 8 $(!22 ! ('

&".# 4.$#"$!

#+0 #

=8> 3 22 #( /#"#"$+"#1 $6 !!.$"$.$< 1 "$ 2 $60) !&880 + &+0 &" $ 2 $6 44 &! 0 ) !& 0 + $6 $("

0 ) !&

0 + &+ # / & # $( + / ""$ &"$+ !4/2 "$0"$""

227+ & ! "' (!

#+ $(+ $( (' &+ # 4 " # 2 6+# "$ ) / 41 &0

@0 #8 2 6+# & 3 6# + & & #@ 2 6+# "$ !1 &

@ -"#+$. (. + !$$"'

$! ) 7 ( 7/ 2 #"( #03+ $ ' & $7 4.$3 ( /#" ( "$ +"# !!.$0 + 3"+(& 3 + # 4 $( + $( ( " ' &

!!.# (-"#+$. " # A 2 6+# &4 .$< 1 "$ 2 $60 # 6+#&4 &" $ 2 $6 44 &! # 82 6+#&4) $6 $("

+ !4/2 "$ .&+ & & !&(# + + & &0 + / ""$ & + $( ( ' & !

22 2 &# 1.

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

=> "$ +"# $ 4 1. "$ #/" 22 +"#0 3+ $ + 3 # $ 12 / 7 + 4$ 7+ / &#$#&43+4+ + (& ! "' (+ 4$ 7&* "$* + 4 //"$ ($*' &$4 $<1#0+ //& !+ (+ +" -"*"2 $!

"! & $( $ && ( + $"& "$!"( $ $( ' $ !$ ## ( +"# *."2 1 & + & ## & #.23+"!+0+ 3 ##.#/ $( (&4# &'"! -"#+$.3 #6$3$+ "& !&)!+2(.!

"$ A / &.# 2 + & 4 $"$ ( ( "2# & '

2# +

(4"##"$ 17 + / ""$ & +"# "$'2' 4 $ "$ & !6 3"+ $ -"#+$. $(+ &#&# !.&"$**' &$4 $<1# #/"& $#&4$ &7 !$#"( & "$ 9 $ + "$# $ !

# 0 + / ""$ & 6 $ 4.$ # 6+# "$ !

#+ $+ & # 2 6+ +&.*+ $2"$ 1 $6"$* &4 +./"$( &)"$*+ $( $)"$*+0& 2 "' #!4/2 $$( &< )"$*+$+ $! * "$*+ 4 //"$ ($*' &$4 $<1#$

!!.$ +"# !2# !$$ !"$# 3"+ +"*+./# 1 #"( # /2""!" $# ).14"##"$+ .$# 2&+ / ""$ &+ "3 #+ !4/2 3+"$&(.! (+"4) 7 $(-"#+$. 4.$ #2 !#3 ( /#" ("$+ !!.$+ / ""$ &17+ !4/2 $+&.*++"# & 2 "' #0" $)"$*+ $(3" +./"$( &)"$*+4 6 . 2# !

* "$#+"4"# // & $27$!&& ! ## "(# $("#!$& &7 + # $("$!4/2 "$0$$ B.& D8 #"( #0 2 &$ ( ) $("$* .$# 20 0 + &+0 + 1&.*+ " + $"! + .& + & $#!&"/# 2 /+$"! !$' &# "$03+"!+6/2 ! 1 3 $+ / ""$ & $(+./"$( & $0& 2 "' #+ !4/2 $$( &< )"$*+0 & 12 0

=> 3+"!+ /&' + !4/2"!"7 + / ""$ & "$ + & !6 +2("$* .

$! + 4 & # !.&"$* *' &$4 $ <1# & 4$ &7 !$#"( & "$ & 3+"!+ !.#("

2 "$ &&* "$ "# $ ! ## &7 &

#! & "$"$* + 4(.# / & $(" + / ""$ & "$ (./"$* + !4/2 $0+"#& 2 "' #0 / &&4 2 &* $.41 &+ &/ &#$#0

2#& !"$*& !' &7+ 4.$ 6 $17+ / ""$ &&4+ !4/2 $D+"#& 2 "' # #3 22 #2 &* $.41 &+ &/ &#$# '"$* !$#"( & ( + #.14"##"$# !.$# 2 & + / &" #0 4 + !$#"( & ( '" 3 + + "$# $/ ""$"# 3+227 4"#!$! "' ( .#("

2 "$ &&* "$ + / ""$ & "# ## $"

#! & "$+ 4(.#/ & $("+ / ""$ &"$(./"$*+ !4/2 $D +"# & 2 "' #0 1 #"( # 2 &* $.41 & / &#$# 4$ 7 $ +

$! * "$*#.!+/ &#$#*' &$4 $<1#+ B !&2 + / ""$ &0"#1 #! & "$ (01 #"( #& !' &7+ 4$ 7 6 $&4 + !4/2 $D #3 22 #+./"$( &"#1 4 ( &3+"!+ !.#("

2"$ &&* "$"# 4.# & $! "$+"#!$ B!

$1 4 ( + ( !"#"$ $E12 + )./& 4 .& "$ F

+ !"' "$ &&* "$"$ !

2"6 +"#3.2($1 /##"12 "+ /& !"' .41& 22 &7 "2"# 12 + !!.# (0 #"$# "( ' $.

2"70"$ &&* "$+

!!.# (3.2(1 !4 $ 4/7&4 2"7$# $!

# !

$17$#& !+ "4 *"$ "$1 # "(1 $ 2# "4/2"!

"$ ""$ &0 #/ &+"# 3$ (4"##"$0 "$(.2* ( "$ "22 * 2 !# !22 !"$* +.* 4.$# 4$ 7&4 2 &* $.41 &/ &#$#"$!2.("$*+ !4/2 $(+"# & 2 "' #17*"'"$*+ 4 $! # !.&"$*+ 4*' &$4 $<1#$

=@>

!!.$ +"# !2# !$$ !"$# 3"+ +"*+ ./# "$!2.("$* /2""!" $# ""$ &( #$( $7& ! "/4$ 7&4+ !4/2 $"$+ "$# $ !

# + /2 + + 4$ 7 3 # * ( /#" ( 17 + !4/2 $+&.*++"#& 2 "' #& 4 +"4"$ 2# !

# "#$ * &4 + # $( + ) $("$* .$# 2 + # / & 3+4 2 /+$"!!$' &# "$#1 3 $+ / ""$ & #3 22 # +./"$( & & 12 "$3+"!++ / ""$ & ##.& (+ 4* "$* *' &$4 $ <1# & 4$ &7 !$#"( & "$# $ !!.$ +"# !$$ !"$# + & "# $ & 1.

2 17 + / ""$ & !.$# 2 +

& 4 $"$ ( # $( 2 &$ ( ) $("$* .$# 20 + &+ !!&("$*270$*&.$(3+ # ' &"#4 ( .&*& $ &7 "2 + / ""$ 1 "$* ( '"( 4 &"0 "# !!&("$*27 3 ' &0$+"$*# (+ & "$ 1' 3.2(1 6 $ $ B/& ##"$ /"$"$$+ 4 &"#+ !

!"#"$

#$ % "