High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/7276/2018allowed

Nitin Jain v. Anita Jain And ORS

2018-12-18Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul4 pages

!"#!$%&%'(

% %'%'

! % %'! ) '% %''# *!& !&+'#!' & ,( -., /.

!&!' ( ,/%'#01#2$ !1" *!+! % %'! '!"!&+'#!' , *% /+1#2$ !1"!&+'#!' ,'3% 44501#2$ !1"!&+'#!' 6666666 /.17 .8 *! +!&!' +! % %' %& #%!$ !# 4%'& *! #! # !#

1+&&!#9: *!%2%0;#4!7;'%%2%&%'81;;4<7" &* 1 *! %0 ; 8 *;4* 5*%$* *! +! % %'!=+0%' %"" *& 9!!' 4' !#0& ++ ;'% : +#;$!*%&5% '!&&!& *%&5'!&+'&%9%0% : *! "$ &1 %' 9%!"1 5*%$* ! !>;%!# 9! ' %$!# " #?;#%$ %'4;+' *!+!&!' +! % %'! * *!+! % %'!"%0!#&;% &!!3%'4 *!!%'&+!$%"%$+!"<'$!"4!!<!' &!00# !# @

00!4!#0:!A!$; !#9! 5!!'*%<'#!&+'#!' '% %'& 5! " '!: *0#! " !&+'#!' '#!?% /; ,'# : %'?;'$ %' #%!$ !&+'#!' /!'#%:)%*+ <!' B!0"! &&$% %'1C@1!$ D 1;;4<7"&* 1 *!-&&$% %'-8 !A!$; ! *!$'2!:'$!#!!#" *!++! :5*%$*5& *!&;9?!$ < !" *!"!&%#4!!<!' &!007"&* 1 *!&;% ++! :85&0&&;4* *! %0 ; +; *! !&+'#!' & ' %$! 9; %' &+% ! " &!2%$!1 !&+'#!' '#!?% /;"%0!# +; %'++!'$!'# *!!"!1 5&+$!!#!#4%'& !A+ ! !&+'#!' &'#++!!#9!"!

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

";9 !4%& 1/&*<%% !1 !0*%E $'$!'!# ""%$%0=0!3 "<'#%' 2!&!& '3*F%9#'#$'$!'!#""%$%0=0!3"<)%?:'31)%4:' )%*1!0*%*!%0; %&&;!#&;<<'& *!"!&%#5% '!&&!&9; !2!'" !&!2%$! *!:"%0!# ++!*!!"!1 *!%0; 1 *;4* #!# !# 1#%!$ !# *!"!&%#5% '!&&!& 9!&;<<'!# *;4*9%090!5' & 5!2!1' *!#?;'!## ! *!"!&%# 5% '!&&!&#%#' ++!$$&%'%'4 *!&;% 9!#?;'!

'5*%$*# ! *!%0; 5*%0!#?;'%'4 *!< !

#%!$ !# *!+! % %'!=+0%' %"" !A+0%' *!!0!2'$:"!A<%' %'" !&+'#!' &*%&5% '!&& '

" ! *!%'4 *!%'4 $;'&!0 " *! + %!& *! %0 ; 9&!2!# * *!! 5& ' !>;%!<!' &;<<' !&+'#!' & 5% '!&& '# +! % %'!=+0%' %"" 5& 4' !# 0& ++ ;'% : +#;$! *%& *! 5% '!&&!&=!2%#!'$! *%&5'!&+'&%9%0% :

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

0" *!+! % %'!&;9<% & * '$! , *% /+1#2$ !*&+; %'++!'$!9!"! *%&; ' 9!*0""!&+'#!' '#*&0&"%0!#*! %'*%&"2; % $'&"!0:9!+!&;<!# * !&+'#!' %&0%2!'# * 9!%'4&1*! #!& ' +!&& *%& +:!>;&;<<'%'4 "!&+'#!' 1& *%& 5% '!&& ' 2%!5 " *! 92!1 *! %<+;4'!# #! !4#%'4 9&!2 %'&<#!>;!&+'#!' '!!#&'%' !"!!'$! " & *! *! *!! 5% '!&&!& ! $'$!'!#1 0!'!# $;'&!0" *!+! % %'!&;9<% & * '$! *!%0; *#&;<<'!# *!< *;4*9%090!5' & *!%0; &*;0#*2! 0!& !$#!# "%'#%'45% *!4# !A!$; %'"&;$*5' &;+' *!<'# *!' +$!!#!#5% * *!< !%'$$#'$!5% *05 *! *'9&!2%'4%' *!

%<+;4'!##! * +#;$ %'" *!"!&%#5% '!&&!&5;0#'59!

C *!!&+'&%9%0% :" *!+! % %'!=+0%' %"" '$!" !*2%'49!!'#;0:&!2!# *!&;<<'!#5% '!&&!& #%#' ++!'# *!%0; *#&;4* *!%++!'$! *;4* 9%090!5' &1 *!%0; &*;0#*2!&!!' % 5*! *! *!9%090! 5' &>; *!<*#9!!'!A!$; !#' '# *!'+$!!#!#5% * *! < !%'$$#'$!5% *05*!!%&' *%'4'!$# !2!'&;44!& * &;$*+$!#;!5&#+ !#9: *!%0; '2%!5" *!92!1 *!%<+;4'!##!1 *!!A !' " 4' %'4 *!+! % %'!=+0%' %""0& ++ ;'% : +#;$!*%&5% '!&&!& *%&5'!&+'&%9%0% :%&&! &%#!'# *!%0; %&#%!$ !# "%& 4 %' *!%&&;!5*! *! *!9%090!5' &%&&;!#9:% &;<<' *! "!&%#5% '!&&!&5!!!A!$; !#' '# *!!" !+$!!# &!$;! *! +!&!'$!" *!

&%#5% '!&&!&1%'$$#'$!5% *05 *!+!&!' +! % %'%&005!#%' *!92! !<& G /.H &*<&*! B*! *!&+!3%'4=!&'!# ( !&= B*! *!!+ 90!

(!&=